Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Military service and Christianity  

36 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1769211' date='Feb 2 2009, 12:35 AM']We are not talking about the war in Iraq. There is more to the military than the current war in Iraq.[/quote]

It's fair to consider the war in Iraq, because I think it reveals a deeper issue that all Christians need to think about... a) Is the war in Iraq a just war? and b) Are you (individually) willing to fight in an unjust war (whatever that may be)?

Is it moral for a christian to fight in an unjust war?

Like I said earlier, I'm reserving judgment, merely throwing out some food for thought.

Posted

One thing's for sure. Anyone going into the military profession must do their research thoroughly - more than thoroughly. It's not for everyone, and that's never been truer than it is today.

Posted

Why are people making this out to be such a wrong thing?

I served in Iraq. It was the best time of life. There was nothing "unchristian" about everything I did in Iraq.

Posted

[quote name='ReinnieR' post='1769677' date='Feb 2 2009, 10:18 AM']Why are people making this out to be such a wrong thing?

I served in Iraq. It was the best time of life. There was nothing "unchristian" about everything I did in Iraq.[/quote]


I don't think most people were making it out to be wrong. Quite the opposite.

Still, I think we'd all agree that as a career it needs more than careful thought.

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='ReinnieR' post='1769677' date='Feb 2 2009, 11:18 AM']Why are people making this out to be such a wrong thing?

I served in Iraq. It was the best time of life. There was nothing "unchristian" about everything I did in Iraq.[/quote]

There is a distinction in Just War:

[i]jus in bello[/i]- The laws concerning what is acceptable and just concerning actions within the realm of a war (not targeting civilians, no torture, etc).

[i]jus ad bellum[/i]- The laws concerning the justification for an armed forces or nation to go to war (just cause, all peaceful options tried, etc).

Your time and actions in Iraq were in the category of [i]jus in bello[/i]. It's possible to adhere to [i]jus in bello[/i] but still be participating in an unjust war.

Now, I'm not saying whether the war in Iraq is justified ad bellum (though it seems that our past two Popes have not thought so). The question I'm struggling with (and again reserving judgment on) is whether a Christian [i]should[/i] participate in an unjust war ([i]ad bellum[/i]), even if they are fighting justly ([i]in bello[/i]).

Posted (edited)

I think it is very honorable and God bless those who serve.

One interesting scenario which I saw about Desert Storm. There was a Ricon unit or Seal unit or one of those U.S. special ops(I got that from the movies) team that was dropped behind enemy lines deep in Iraq. They basically dug a hole and lived out of that hole doing whatever they were supposed to do.

Anyway a 5 year old girl comes strolling by and spots them and then runs. One of the guys raised his rifle but did not shoot as his officer did not give the order. Well all of Iraq came down on them and they had to be lifted out in an emrgency evacuation. The officer later said that his soldier would have shot her if he gave the order. Who knows if that is true or not but it brings up an intersesting moral case.

What if he had shot her in order to protect themselvs from being discovered? Where would he stand, morally? Is it pretty cut and dry or is there any ambiguity in this moral dilema?

I felt he did the right thing.

Edited by socalscout
Posted

Just after 9-11, Father Corapi, who is a veteran of Vietnam, went down to the recruiters to sign up. They wouldn't have him because of his age and health, but his actions speak volumes as to whether military service is incompatible with being a good Christian.

I also believe that a person can serve honorably even in an un-just war, so long as nothing they do is un-just. Those who vote for an un-just war though are different.

As to the scenario of having to shoot an un-armed civilian, all I can say is that my father and I had many discussions on the topic. He had to kill more people than he cared to remember (at least while awake) in WWII. He always said that he didn't regret his actions, he only regretted they were necessary.

Posted

I'm pretty sure that the Archdiocese of the Military Services of the USA would agree that military service is compatible with Christianity.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1768943' date='Feb 1 2009, 09:44 PM']I said yes, because I know what you meant,
but on the other hand, joining say a Nazi era fascist military would be immoral, as would the military of a corrupt unstable country like Zimbabwe, in my opinion.[/quote]

But then the immorality stems from the various immoral governments rather than the millitary itself.

Posted

[quote name='Maximilianus' post='1769882' date='Feb 2 2009, 03:31 PM']I'm pretty sure that the Archdiocese of the Military Services of the USA would agree that military service is compatible with Christianity.[/quote]

:lol_roll:

Posted

I think that it is honorable. I live in a military town. I know lots of good Catholics who serve God and country. I just don't think that it's a job for everybody.

Posted

[url="http://www.catholicmil.org/"]CatholicMil.org[/url]
:)

Posted

The Vatican is certainly OK with it. At least two prior archbishops of the military diocese, Edwin O'Brien and John O'Connor later went on to very important sees, Baltimore and New York respectively. Cardinal O'Connor as a chaplain even held the rank of rear admiral in the Navy! :cool: The pacifist position is an option in our Church but problems arise when people try to make themselves sound like "true" Christians and other "lesser." A good rule is, don't demand from other people what the Pope wouldn't demand!

TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1770081' date='Feb 2 2009, 07:08 PM']The Vatican is certainly OK with it. At least two prior archbishops of the military diocese, Edwin O'Brien and John O'Connor later went on to very important sees, Baltimore and New York respectively. Cardinal O'Connor as a chaplain even held the rank of rear admiral in the Navy! :cool: The pacifist position is an option in our Church but problems arise when people try to make themselves sound like "true" Christians and other "lesser." A good rule is, don't demand from other people what the Pope wouldn't demand![/quote]

Not to be argumentative, but I would just like to clarify that priests do practice a type of pacifism called principal pacifism, which means as chaplains, they are not armed nor do they practice violence, because of their vocation.

I don't think that this takes away from the main point of what you were saying above, but I just thought I'd throw out the distinction between a priest serving in the military and a combatant soldier.

(Once again, just to be clear, I'm not supporting one side or the other, but I do find the issue interesting. I think that it requires a lot of thought. Early Christians, up until around the time of St. Augustine, practiced absolute pacifism. In the Eastern Church, Christians were allowed to go to war, but when they returned they had to do extreme penance and fast from Holy Communion for three years.... I think the issue is deeper than we often give it credit for and that there are legitimate reasons as to why a Christian may consider any facet of pacifism.)

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1769935' date='Feb 2 2009, 02:36 PM']But then the immorality stems from the various immoral governments rather than the millitary itself.[/quote]
Wouldn't joining that military be considered formal cooperation in the corrupt government's actions?

Posted

[quote name='Mari Therese' post='1769994' date='Feb 2 2009, 06:13 PM']I think that it is honorable. I live in a military town. I know lots of good Catholics who serve God and country. I just don't think that it's a job for everybody.[/quote]

My son's school has the motto;

[i][b]Deus et Patria[/b][/i]

:smokey:

I actually explained to my son what that really met.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1770686' date='Feb 3 2009, 01:21 AM']Wouldn't joining that military be considered formal cooperation in the corrupt government's actions?[/quote]

I think intent would play a role in this scenario. What if the soldier's intent was to fight the evils 'from within'?


Paying taxes to such a government would be cooperation as well correct?

Posted

There are chaplains(Priests) who are soldiers as well. They don't think the two jobs conflict or else they wouldn't do it.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1770686' date='Feb 3 2009, 01:21 AM']Wouldn't joining that military be considered formal cooperation in the corrupt government's actions?[/quote]
What about places where military service is compulsory?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

The love and service of one’s country follow from the duty of gratitude and belong to the order of charity. CCC ¶2239
Those who are sworn to serve their country in the armed forces are servants of the security and freedom of nations. If they carry out their duty honorably, they truly contribute to the common good of the nation and the maintenance of peace.” CCC ¶2310

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...