Selah Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 (edited) I was thinking about this today. We are all born with the stain of original sin, correct? It's in human nature to sin, right? If this is so, why would God punish us for something that we are born with? Why didn't he have all of humankind born without the stain, just like the Blessed Virgin? Does that make any sense? I'm not quite sure how to word it Pax! Selah Edited February 4, 2009 by Selah
Veridicus Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 (edited) I've read something somewhere about how we are all kind of "one flesh with Adam" or something like that. As in Adam's sin "IS" our sin in terms of guilt by our natural generation from Adam. There is no disconnect between Adam and us in terms of guilt because of this shared reality. My understanding is that there is no 'separate guilt' that we have that is different than Adam's guilt with regard to original sin (feel free to correct my phrasing or to instruct my ignorance anyone). Sharing the fallen nature of Adam is the way it works; Mary's Immaculate Conception is an exception to the rule. Could God make the exception 'the rule'? Of course, but in his providence apparently he's decided not to. That's my 2cents. Now I'll hand it off to people far more intelligent and qualified... Edited February 4, 2009 by Veridicus
Formosus Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 To sin is not in our nature, but rather is a disease that by the actions of our ancestors, we have inherited. Through Baptism, we are set free of this disease and thus enabling us (with God's help) to overcome the remaining effects of this disease. The Blessed Virgin's immaculate conception (to use a latin view) is only free of this disease in that she received a sort of baptism at conception (that still required Christ's sacrifice). So even in a latin view (IMO) the Theotokos still could have sinned and still suffered temptations to sin just as we all do, but her great faith in Christ our God helped her to overcome the temptations and to be a model for all us on earth to imitate. *BTW* I love the maronite church, I used to go to one often back in my hometown.
kafka Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 I really like a couple of Formosus' points. These are questions close to my heart, since I have often thought about them and sought answers to them throughout life. They are intellectually honest. So I'd like to give them the royal treatment, and share some of my partial answers to these questions, partial since some of them are rooted in mystery. But I dont have time right now to type it up, so maybe this weekend I will work on this.
cmotherofpirl Posted February 5, 2009 Posted February 5, 2009 [quote name='Formosus' post='1772412' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:21 PM']To sin is not in our nature, but rather is a disease that by the actions of our ancestors, we have inherited. Through Baptism, we are set free of this disease and thus enabling us (with God's help) to overcome the remaining effects of this disease. The Blessed Virgin's immaculate conception (to use a latin view) is only free of this disease in that she received a sort of baptism at conception (that still required Christ's sacrifice). So even in a latin view (IMO) the Theotokos still could have sinned and still suffered temptations to sin just as we all do, but her great faith in Christ our God helped her to overcome the temptations and to be a model for all us on earth to imitate. *BTW* I love the maronite church, I used to go to one often back in my hometown.[/quote] I always love listening to Eastern theology keep talking.
Apotheoun Posted February 6, 2009 Posted February 6, 2009 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1773064' date='Feb 5 2009, 11:10 AM']I always love listening to Eastern theology keep talking.[/quote] So do I. I agree that sin is not in our nature, and in fact sinful actions are unnatural. Ultimately, to hold that sin is in our nature, or that human nature after the fall is sinful, is problematic anthropologically and Christologically.
Selah Posted February 6, 2009 Author Posted February 6, 2009 Ah, I see. I had always thought it was part of us. But as I think about, it's actually unnatural. We were created sinless, after all.
cmotherofpirl Posted February 6, 2009 Posted February 6, 2009 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1773362' date='Feb 5 2009, 10:01 PM']So do I. I agree that sin is not in our nature, and in fact sinful actions are unnatural. Ultimately, to hold that sin is in our nature, or that human nature after the fall is sinful, is problematic anthropologically and Christologically.[/quote] Is this not a major difference between eastern and western theology?
kafka Posted February 6, 2009 Posted February 6, 2009 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1773537' date='Feb 5 2009, 11:24 PM']Is this not a major difference between eastern and western theology?[/quote] no. Or at least it shouldnt be. Are you referring to the neo-scholastics view of pure nature, or perhaps something else? Just curious, to know before I type some of my answer up.
LouisvilleFan Posted February 6, 2009 Posted February 6, 2009 (edited) I think she's referring to the Eastern Orthodox not believing in original sin. I'm not sure about Eastern Catholics... Edited February 6, 2009 by LouisvilleFan
cmotherofpirl Posted February 6, 2009 Posted February 6, 2009 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1774033' date='Feb 6 2009, 04:23 PM']I think she's referring to the Eastern Orthodox not believing in original sin. I'm not sure about Eastern Catholics...[/quote] There are major differences between eastern and western catholic theology.
kafka Posted February 7, 2009 Posted February 7, 2009 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1774134' date='Feb 6 2009, 05:19 PM']There are major differences between eastern and western catholic theology.[/quote] which is my an over-emphasis should not be placed in either.
LouisvilleFan Posted February 8, 2009 Posted February 8, 2009 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1774134' date='Feb 6 2009, 06:19 PM']There are major differences between eastern and western catholic theology.[/quote] What differences? Eastern Catholics must affirm dogmas like original sin and the Immaculate Conception to be in full communion with us.
Veridicus Posted February 8, 2009 Posted February 8, 2009 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1775969' date='Feb 8 2009, 04:07 PM']What differences? Eastern Catholics must affirm dogmas like original sin and the Immaculate Conception to be in full communion with us.[/quote] Patiently awaiting any needed clarification from Apo....
Apotheoun Posted February 8, 2009 Posted February 8, 2009 Click the link below to read about the Eastern understanding of the original sin: [url="http://www.geocities.com/apotheoun/original_sin"][u]Original Sin in the Byzantine Tradition[/u][/url] by Fr. John Meyendorff
cmotherofpirl Posted February 8, 2009 Posted February 8, 2009 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1775969' date='Feb 8 2009, 05:07 PM']What differences? Eastern Catholics must affirm dogmas like original sin and the Immaculate Conception to be in full communion with us.[/quote] You phrasing is unfortunate because you make it sound like the Eastern church are a graft on the Latin Church instead of an equal. Here is some Q & A on these topics from an excellent site: [url="http://www.east2west.org/doctrine.htm#IC"]http://www.east2west.org/doctrine.htm#IC[/url] [color="#0000FF"]Original Sin #1:[/color] I have heard that the Greek biblical texts of Rom. 5:12 do not contain the phrase "in whom all have sinned" relating to Adam's sin. Consequently, I gather that the Eastern churches' doctrine of original sin developed differently than that of the Western churches. Is this correct? The Greek biblical text of Romans 5:12 does contain the phrase "eph'ho pantes hemarton." The Western Church has traditionally translated this as "in whom all have sinned. In contrast, the Eastern Fathers understood the word "eph'ho" to modify the preceding word "thanatos," which means "death." Therefore the Eastern Church translates the phrase in question as "because of which (death) all have sinned." Both are legitimate translations of the text. However, this difference in translation changes the meaning of the entire verse. Thus, the Western Church has traditionally translated the entirety of Romans 5:12 as such: "Wherefore as by one man sin entered into this world and by sin death: and so death passed upon all men, in whom all have sinned," (Douay-Rheims Version). The Eastern Fathers translated the second part of Romans 5:12 as follows: "...and so death passed upon all men, because of which all have sinned." In part because of this difference the Eastern Christian teaching on original sin developed differently. In our tradition, the primary effect of original sin is not a "stain," passed on from generation to generation. Rather, it is death. Because "death passed upon all men," all of us now sin. It is death itself that causes us to sin. [color="#0000FF"]Original Sin #2:[/color] Do you view death itself as the "stain" or original sin, and if so, how does death cause us to sin? Yes, perhaps one could say that in a certain sense death itself is the "stain" of original sin. Because of the certainty of physical death, we try to evade the inevitable. This leads us to try and cheat death, which results in sin. We store more food than we need (gluttony), we horde wealth and resources (avarice), we use our reproductive potential wantonly (lechery), etc... In the quest to cheat death we distort natural God-given gifts. Thus, death causes us to sin. [color="#0000FF"]Original Sin #3[/color]: Can you explain the difference in the way the East views Original Sin? I'll try to briefly summarize the issue, but I can't do it justice in so little space. In the East: The primary consequence of Original Sin is death. The reality of death causes people to desire that which can distract them from the reality of their impending death. Hence, people turn to sex, money, and power as a way to forget about death. In this way, death leads to sin. In the West: The primary consequence of Original Sin is a "stain" of guilt. People are born with a guilt that needs to be washed away as soon as possible. Both the East and the West agree that original sin causes an ABSENCE of the indwelling of the Holy Spirit. Through baptism, the Holy Spirit can again dwell within man. It should be noted that the Catholic Church has adopted a much more Eastern understanding in recent years. In fact, the Catechism of the Catholic Church is very Eastern in its approach to original sin. [color="#0000FF"]Immaculate Conception #1:[/color] How do Eastern Catholics understand the dogma of the Immaculate Conception? Does it differ from the Western understanding? Concerning the Eastern Catholic understanding of the Immaculate Conception, I will offer a very brief summary of the issue. First, the theological seeds of the Immaculate Conception originated in the East, and were later spread to the West. Since the earliest centuries the Eastern Churches have celebrated "St. Anne's Conception of the Theotokos," on December 9. Only later was this feast transplanted to the West, where it is celebrated on December 8. In the Eastern Catholic Churches we have maintained much of the theological heritage of the Eastern Church Fathers. We try to be very Patristic in our theology, and generally model our theological approach after the great Eastern Fathers. In the West theology has developed somewhat differently. Beginning in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries a whole new style of theology developed, known as Scholasticism. Scholasticism utilized a great deal of philosophical terminology from the writings of Aristotle. It essentially created a whole new way to approach theological questions, and answered them with very specific philosophical terminology. Scholasticism was the dominant theological system in the Western Church until the beginning of the 20th century. In 1854 Pope Pius IX solemnly proclaimed the dogma of the Immaculate Conception. Being a good Western theologian, he used a great deal of scholastic terminology in the definition. Here it is, with the specifically scholastic terms emphasized by me: "We declare, pronounce and define that the doctrine which asserts that the Blessed Virgin Mary, from the first moment of her conception, by a singular grace and privilege of almighty God, and in view of the MERITS of Jesus Christ, Savior of the human race, was preserved free from every STAIN of original sin is a doctrine revealed by God and, for this reason, must be firmly and constantly believed by all the faithful." There are two terms used in the definition that are completely foreign to Eastern Christian theology: "merits" and "stain." Both of these terms are of very late origin, and came to mean very specific things in the scholastic system. But to us Eastern Christians, who still use only the theological expressions of the Church Fathers, these terms are completely alien. So is this a problem, or isn't it? I don't believe that this a problem at all. If something is written in a language that you can't understand, you simply TRANSLATE it! With some very basic knowledge of scholastic theological terminology, what Pope Pius IX is saying becomes very obvious: From the very first moment of her existence, Mary was miraculously preserved from all sin. We Easterns would go even a step further: she wasn't just preserved from sin, but was graced with the indwelling of the Holy Spirit. Also, the definition speaks of Mary being "free from every stain of original sin." In the East we have always spoken of Mary's perfect holiness. The language "free from every stain of original sin" is really a somewhat negative formulation in comparison. In fact, this definition speaks of Mary as being "absent of something (the stain of sin)," while we would prefer to speak of her as being "full of something (the Holy Spirit)." In this regard I think that the Eastern approach makes a marvelous contribution to the understanding of this dogma. So does Pope John Paul II: "In fact, the negative formulation of the Marian privilege, which resulted from the earlier controversies about original sin that arose in the West, must always be complemented by the positive expression of Mary's holiness more explicitly stressed in the Eastern tradition." (Pope John Paul II, General Audience June 12, 1996) So, the Holy Father agrees that the Eastern understanding of the Immaculate Conception actually helps to elucidate the meaning behind the definition.
LouisvilleFan Posted February 9, 2009 Posted February 9, 2009 Well, I wouldn't call those major differences. We couldn't enjoy full communion with major differences in our theology. We have different understandings or perspectives of the same dogmas, whereas the Eastern Orthodox reject the doctrine of original sin.
LouisvilleFan Posted February 9, 2009 Posted February 9, 2009 (edited) [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1776135' date='Feb 8 2009, 07:13 PM']You phrasing is unfortunate because you make it sound like the Eastern church are a graft on the Latin Church instead of an equal.[/quote] Like I said, we're all in full communion... I like the Eastern Churches. Edited February 9, 2009 by LouisvilleFan
cmotherofpirl Posted February 9, 2009 Posted February 9, 2009 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1776738' date='Feb 9 2009, 10:21 AM']Well, I wouldn't call those major differences. We couldn't enjoy full communion with major differences in our theology. We have different understandings or perspectives of the same dogmas, whereas the Eastern Orthodox reject the doctrine of original sin.[/quote] From what I understand their view of original sin and the Eastern Catholic Church are the same. Appy can you clarify this?
Formosus Posted February 9, 2009 Posted February 9, 2009 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1776738' date='Feb 9 2009, 10:21 AM']Well, I wouldn't call those major differences. We couldn't enjoy full communion with major differences in our theology. We have different understandings or perspectives of the same dogmas, whereas the Eastern Orthodox reject the doctrine of original sin.[/quote] Byzantine Eastern Catholics believe the same thing about Original Sin as Eastern Orthodox do. The Early Church enjoyed full communion with each other where there was a difference in theology, I don't see why you find it difficult to accept such a situation today.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now