Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

  

60 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='doe-jo' post='1794252' date='Mar 1 2009, 11:55 AM']:unsure: The liberals aren't? Well, I guess they're united in being separated from the traditions of the Church.[/quote]

The liberals are of greater number, have more power, and are more united.

Posted

Mass in Latin, of the Pre-Vatican II or post-Vatican II variety, in no holier than the English Mass. It is no more impressive than an English Mass (and the point of going to Mass is not be impressed, anyway). It is only less comprehensible than the English Mass except for the educated, and only a few of them.

When I pray, I cast my thoughts into words (or align my thoughts with the words that are spoken); if I'm spending all my mental energy trying to find the right words, or figure out what they mean, then I'm not communing with God - I'm just doing linguistics in the pews. I've done it in Italian and French when I was in those countries - I knew enough to keep up, but not really to participate. I was concerned about embarrassing myself through mispronunciation, or with throwing a monkey wrench into the group recitation. I tried praying in English to myself, but then I thought I looked like a religion-tourist among the faithful.

The Latin Mass eliminates monolinguals from worship. While learning Latin would be useful to almost everyone with the time, inclination, study habits, and tuition, the point of the Catholic Church is to make access to God universal - even to monolinguals.

latin is a dead language, dead as it can be. It killed off all the Romans, and now it's killing ME.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Luigi' post='1794802' date='Mar 1 2009, 10:05 PM']Mass in Latin, of the Pre-Vatican II or post-Vatican II variety, in no holier than the English Mass. It is no more impressive than an English Mass (and the point of going to Mass is not be impressed, anyway). It is only less comprehensible than the English Mass except for the educated, and only a few of them.

When I pray, I cast my thoughts into words (or align my thoughts with the words that are spoken); if I'm spending all my mental energy trying to find the right words, or figure out what they mean, then I'm not communing with God - I'm just doing linguistics in the pews. I've done it in Italian and French when I was in those countries - I knew enough to keep up, but not really to participate. I was concerned about embarrassing myself through mispronunciation, or with throwing a monkey wrench into the group recitation. I tried praying in English to myself, but then I thought I looked like a religion-tourist among the faithful.

The Latin Mass eliminates monolinguals from worship. While learning Latin would be useful to almost everyone with the time, inclination, study habits, and tuition, the point of the Catholic Church is to make access to God universal - even to monolinguals.

latin is a dead language, dead as it can be. It killed off all the Romans, and now it's killing ME.[/quote]

alll those Catholics for 2000 years before 1960's must've been some darn smart cookies :mellow:

Posted

No - in fact, they stood like cattle in huge churches without pews or microphones and waited for the bell to be rung so they would know the elevation was happening.

There was no participation. The priest spoke and the deacons, or the altars boys, answered on behalf of the people. People "heard" Mass in those days. The choirs provided lots of unintelligible but angelic sounding music

When the rosary came into use, lots of people took to praying that during Mass, and some few still do.

KnightofChrist
Posted

What a complete and utter disrespect you have for the Mass of our ancestors.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1776581' date='Feb 9 2009, 12:09 AM']I love the Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom too much to consider attending an SSPX chapel on a regular basis.[/quote]
That's awesome. I have a love for the St. John Chrysostom liturgy too. I just went today ^_^

Posted

[quote name='Luigi' post='1794802' date='Mar 2 2009, 12:05 AM']Mass in Latin, of the Pre-Vatican II or post-Vatican II variety, in no holier than the English Mass. It is no more impressive than an English Mass (and the point of going to Mass is not be impressed, anyway). It is only less comprehensible than the English Mass except for the educated, and only a few of them.[/quote]

It's not about Latin, Luigi, although Latin is the sacred language of the Liturgy.

And in my opinion the older rite does convey certain truths of the Faith [i]more clearly[/i].

As a layperson, although I believe Pope Paul VI's mass is legitimate and valid, I have a hard time understanding why large changes were made to the liturgy.

[quote]latin is a dead language, dead as it can be. It killed off all the Romans, and now it's killing ME.[/quote]

lol, indeed!

Posted

[quote name='Luigi' post='1794830' date='Mar 2 2009, 12:38 AM']No - in fact, they stood like cattle in huge churches without pews or microphones and waited for the bell to be rung so they would know the elevation was happening.[/quote]

One of the problems I have with the liturgical reform is that it appears to suggest liturgical development in the Roman rite was really liturgical deviation, and that therefore the Church was in error for thousands of years. This is the sense I get when I read contemporary books on liturgical development, it's full of criticisms of the ancient Liturgy. But again, this may not be what the Church herself has intended with the reform, but certainly some people have that impression.

[quote]There was no participation. The priest spoke and the deacons, or the altars boys, answered on behalf of the people. People "heard" Mass in those days. The choirs provided lots of unintelligible but angelic sounding music[/quote]

There was participation of an interior kind. People may not have understood Latin and they might not have heard what the priest was praying, but they knew what the Mass was and what was occurring. But we have to remember the mass is not about the people, it's focus is on God. The priest was always a (relative) mediator between God and the people. The only time people would chime in was during the intercessory prayer (if that existed) and singing. This idea that laypeople have to take part in every aspect of the liturgy is a modern one.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...