lilac_angel Posted February 9, 2009 Posted February 9, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1777052' date='Feb 9 2009, 06:22 PM']Evidently for some people the holocaust is a new article of the Catholic faith. Truly sad.[/quote] Are you talking about the seminary that didn't want him as a leader anymore because he in no way represented the congregation's views, or the person on this thread that wasn't aware of the numbers (doesn't seem like it, but just making sure)? I myself am terrible at remembering numbers of any kind, but I knew it was around that amount. Edited February 9, 2009 by lilac_angel
Apotheoun Posted February 9, 2009 Posted February 9, 2009 [quote name='lilac_angel' post='1777074' date='Feb 9 2009, 03:30 PM']Are you talking about the seminary that didn't want him as a leader anymore because he in no way represented the congregation's views, or the person on this thread that wasn't aware of the numbers? I myself am terrible at remembering numbers of any kind, but I knew it was around that amount.[/quote] I am talking about anyone who thinks that his views on the holocaust have any importance in connection with his being a bishop or a Catholic. Catholics can be in error on any number of events from general history and still be Catholics in good standing.
lilac_angel Posted February 9, 2009 Posted February 9, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1777080' date='Feb 9 2009, 06:32 PM']I am talking about anyone who thinks that his views on the holocaust have any importance in connection with his being a bishop or a Catholic. Catholics can be in error on any number of events from general history and still be Catholics in good standing.[/quote] The only people I've come across who were Holocaust deniers or anti-Semitics went to white supremacy websites for their religious information, were a little too heavily into conspiracy theories, or thought they themselves were the Pope. Prudence can sometimes be a good thing, and it's not as if he was ousted from his Bishop position. Edited February 9, 2009 by lilac_angel
Apotheoun Posted February 9, 2009 Posted February 9, 2009 (edited) Witch hunts are bad in general. The fact that Bishop Williamson disagrees with the estimated number of people killed in the camps is not really all that important, since different figures are given by different sources, and none of the sources are all that reliable. I've read things that say that 18 million people died in Nazi concentration camps, while other texts claim that only 11 million people died, and some put it at 9 million. Some texts state that 5.5 million Poles were killed, and that 3 million of them were Jews, which means that 2.5 million non-Jewish Poles were killed. Most of these statistics are "educated" guesses of historians, who do not agree on the actual number of people killed. The same kind of statistical guessing goes on in connection with the Turkish genocide of the Armenians (figures range from 750,000 to 3,000,000). That said, a man's views on the holocaust are irrelevant when it comes to his standing in the Catholic Church, and that is true whether one is talking about the Church in general or a particular seminary or other institution. Edited February 9, 2009 by Apotheoun
lilac_angel Posted February 9, 2009 Posted February 9, 2009 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1777096' date='Feb 9 2009, 06:48 PM']Witch hunts are bad in general. The fact that Bishop Williamson disagrees with the estimated number of people killed in the camps is not really all that important, since different figures are given by different sources, and none of the sources are all that reliable. I've read things that say that 18 million people died in Nazi concentration camps, while other texts claim that only 11 million people died, and some put it at 9 million. Some texts state that 5.5 million Poles were killed, and that 3 million of them were Jews, which means that 2.5 million non-Jewish Poles were killed. Most of these statistics are "educated" guesses of historians, who do not agree on the actual number of people killed. The same kind of statistical guessing goes on in connection with the Turkish genocide of the Armenians (figures range from 750,000 to 3,000,000). That said, a man's views on the holocaust are irrelevant when it comes to his standing in the Catholic Church, and that is true whether one is talking about the Church in general or a particular seminary or other institution.[/quote] It is likely that he will be hired somewhere else. There was obviously a clash in personalities at that seminary. Maybe it wasn't in the best interest of everyone that he stay there. We may never know. Sometimes people just aren't meant to be on a certain path while doing God's will. I will not judge and say what God's will was in this situation. And never know, they could kiss and make up.
Aloysius Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 no, he was removed solely on the basis of political correctness. +Williamson himself references the prophet Jonah as to why he is being treated thusly by the Society (and he accepts it for the Society's sake): " Take me up, and cast me forth into the sea; so shall the sea be calm unto you: for I know that for my sake this great tempest is upon you." here is the full interview he gave with Der Spiegel: [quote]SPIEGEL: The Vatican is demanding that you retract your denial of the Holocaust, and it is threatening to not allow you to resume your activities as a bishop. How will you react? Williamson: Throughout my life, I have always sought the truth. That is why I converted to Catholicism and became a priest. And now I can only say something, the truth of which I am convinced. Because I realize that there are many honest and intelligent people who think differently, I must now review the historical evidence once again. I said the same thing in my interview with Swedish television: Historical evidence is at issue, not emotions. And if I find this evidence, I will correct myself. But that will take time. SPIEGEL: How can an educated Catholic deny the Holocaust? Williamson: I addressed the subject in the 1980s. I had read various writings at the time. I cited the Leuchter report (eds. note: a debunked theory produced in the 1980s claiming erroneously that the Nazi gas chambers were technically impractical) in the interview, and it seemed plausible to me. Now I am told that it has been scientifically refuted. I plan now to look into it. SPIEGEL: You could travel to Auschwitz yourself. Williamson: No, I will not travel to Auschwitz[color="#FF0000"] [As he'd likely be arrested by the Nazi-esque thought-police policies of modern Germany -Aloysius][/color]. I've ordered the book by Jean-Claude Pressac. It's called "Auschwitz: Technique and Operation of the Gas Chambers." A printout is now being sent to me, and I will read it and study it. SPIEGEL: The Society of Saint Pius X has set an ultimatum for the end of February. Are you not risking a break with the group? Williamson: In the Old Testament, the Prophet Jonah tells the sailors when their ship is in distress: " Take me up, and cast me forth into the sea; so shall the sea be calm unto you: for I know that for my sake this great tempest is upon you." The Society has a religious mission that is suffering because of me. I will now examine the historic evidence. If I do not find it convincing, I will do everything in my power to avoid inflicting any further harm on the Church and the Society. SPIEGEL: What does the repeal of the excommunication by Pope Benedict XVI mean to you? Williamson: We just want to be Catholic, nothing else. We have not developed our own teachings, but are merely preserving the things that the Church has always taught and practiced. And in the sixties and seventies, when everything was changed in the name of this Council (eds. note: the Second Vatican Council), it was suddenly a scandal. As a result, we were forced to the margins of the church, and now that empty churches and an aging clergy make it clear that these changes were a failure, we are returning to the center. That's the way it is for us conservatives: we are proved right, as long as we wait long enough. SPIEGEL: People at the Vatican claimed that they didn't know you. Is that true? Williamson: Most contacts pass through Bishop Fellay and the General Council, of which I am not a member. But three of us four bishops attended a private dinner with Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos in 2000. It was more about getting to know each other, but we certainly talked about theological issues and even a bit of philosophy. The cardinal was very friendly. SPIEGEL: The Second Vatican Council counts as one of the great achievements of the Catholic Church. Why do you not fully recognize it? Williamson: It is absolutely unclear what we are supposed to recognize. An important document is called "Gaudium et spes," or Joy and Hope. In it, the writers rhapsodize about the ability of mass tourism to bring people together. But one can hardly expect a conservative society to embrace package tours. It discusses fears and hardships. And then a nuclear war between the superpowers is mentioned. You see, much of this is already outdated. [b]These Council documents are always ambiguous. Because no one knew what exactly this was supposed to mean, everyone started doing as he wished shortly after the Council. This has resulted in this theological chaos we have today. [/b]What are we supposed to recognize, the ambiguity or the chaos? SPIEGEL: Are you actually aware that you are dividing the Church with your extreme views? Williamson: Only violation of the dogmas, that is, the infallible principles, destroys faith. The Second Vatican Council declared that it would proclaim no new dogmas. Today the liberal bishops act as though it were some sort of all-encompassing super-dogma, and they use it as justification for a dictatorship of relativism. This contradicts the texts of the Council. SPIEGEL: Your position on Judaism is consistently anti-Semitic. Williamson: St. Paul put it this way: [b]The Jews are beloved for the sake of Our Father, but our enemies for the sake of the gospel.[/b] SPIEGEL: Do you seriously intend to use Catholic tradition and the Bible to justify your anti-Semitism? Williamson: Anti-Semitism means many things today, for instance, when one criticizes the Israeli actions in the Gaza Strip. [b]The Church has always understood the definition of anti-Semitism to be the rejection of Jews because of their Jewish roots. This is condemned by the Church. [/b]Incidentally, this is self-evident in a religion whose founders and all important individuals in its early history were Jews. But it was also clear, because of the large number of Jewish Christians in early Christianity, that all men need Christ for their salvation -- all men, including the Jews. SPIEGEL: The pope will travel to Israel soon, where he plans to visit the Holocaust Memorial. Are you also opposed to this? Williamson: Making a pilgrimage to the Holy Land is a great joy for Christians. I wish the Holy Father all the best on his journey. What troubles me about Yad Vashem is that Pope Pius XII is attacked there, even though no one saved more Jews during the Nazi period than he did. For instance, he had baptismal certificates issued for persecuted Jews to protect them against arrest. These facts have been distorted to mean exactly the opposite. Otherwise, I hope that the pope will also have an eye and a heart for the women and children who were injured in the Gaza Strip, and that he will speak out in support of the Christian population in Bethlehem, which is now walled in. SPIEGEL: Your statements have caused great injury and outrage in the Jewish world. Why don't you apologize? Williamson: [b]If I realize that I have made an error, I will apologize. I ask every human being to believe me when I say that I did not deliberately say anything untrue. I was convinced that my comments were accurate, based on my research in the 1980s. Now I must review everything again and look at the evidence.[/b] SPIEGEL: Do you at least recognize universal human rights? Williamson: When human rights were declared in France, hundreds of thousands were killed throughout France. Where human rights are considered an objective order for the state to implement, there are constantly anti-Christian policies. When it comes to preserving the individual's freedom of conscience against the democratic state, then human rights perform an important function. The individual needs these rights against a country that behaves like a Leviathan. But the Christian concept of the state is a different one, so that the Christian theories of human rights emphasize that freedom is not an end in itself. [b]The point is not freedom from something, but freedom for something. For good.[/b] SPIEGEL: Your statements and the lifting of your excommunication have triggered protests worldwide. Can you understand this? Williamson: A single interview on Swedish television has dominated the news for weeks in Germany. Yes, it does surprise me. Is this the case with all violations of the law in Germany? Hardly. No, [b]I am only the tool here, so that action can be taken against the SSPX and the pope. Apparently Germany's leftist Catholicism has not yet forgiven Ratzinger for becoming pope.[/b] Interview conducted by Peter Wensierski and Steffen Winter Interview conducted in German and translated into English by Christopher Sultan[/quote] (emphasis added) link: [url="http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,606323,00.html"]http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/...,606323,00.html[/url] Fr. Z's comments: [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2009/02/der-spiegel-sspx-bp-williamsons-interesting-points-to-a-hostile-interviewer/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2009/02/der-spiegel...le-interviewer/[/url] God bless this bishop of Our Lord.
lilac_angel Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1777147' date='Feb 9 2009, 08:01 PM']no, he was removed solely on the basis of political correctness. +Williamson himself references the prophet Jonah as to why he is being treated thusly by the Society (and he accepts it for the Society's sake): " Take me up, and cast me forth into the sea; so shall the sea be calm unto you: for I know that for my sake this great tempest is upon you." here is the full interview he gave with Der Spiegel: (emphasis added) link: [url="http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,606323,00.html"]http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/...,606323,00.html[/url] Fr. Z's comments: [url="http://wdtprs.com/blog/2009/02/der-spiegel-sspx-bp-williamsons-interesting-points-to-a-hostile-interviewer/"]http://wdtprs.com/blog/2009/02/der-spiegel...le-interviewer/[/url] God bless this bishop of Our Lord.[/quote] The SSPX being politically correct? Now that's something you don't hear every day. I think it's a little judgmental of him to say that about "leftist Catholics" not forgiving Ratzinger. He knows nothing about why certain people feel the way they do about his statements about the Holocaust (while though the estimates may vary, it's a certainty that deaths are in the millions). Our mission is to minister to Jews, not call them our enemies in public. The New Testament tells us not to provoke, and that's what he is doing by calling a whole race (some Jews are only Jews by heritage only, pretty much) our enemies. Sure he can consider Jews who have rejected Christ as enemies, but using the term so freely and publically doesn't exactly reel them in. My Jewish best friend was considering Christianity not long ago, but I haven't heard from her on that in a while, despite my efforts to help. Edited February 10, 2009 by lilac_angel
lilac_angel Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 I also think that step 1 of loving our enemies is not saying "you're my enemy" to them.
Aloysius Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 he was clearly talking about those of the religion of Rabbinic Judaism, as later in the interview he made clear anti-semitism as "the rejection of Jews because of their Jewish roots" is rightly condemned by the Church. He was using St. Paul's own words; where, may I ask you, do the gospels or epistles tell us "not to provoke"?!! the gospels and epistles tell us just the opposite of that, in fact.
Aloysius Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 [quote name='lilac_angel' post='1777218' date='Feb 9 2009, 09:03 PM']I also think that step 1 of loving our enemies is not saying "you're my enemy" to them.[/quote] NOT AT ALL!!! loving your enemy does not mean lying to them or being subversive. You must be clear and honest about who your enemies are... part of loving your enemies in the Christian context is HAVING enemies. if you don't have enemies, you're not being a good Christian, as Christ told us that the world would hate us.
lilac_angel Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1777220' date='Feb 9 2009, 09:05 PM']he was clearly talking about those of the religion of Rabbinic Judaism, as later in the interview he made clear anti-semitism as "the rejection of Jews because of their Jewish roots" is rightly condemned by the Church. He was using St. Paul's own words; where, may I ask you, do the gospels or epistles tell us "not to provoke"?!! the gospels and epistles tell us just the opposite of that, in fact.[/quote] I believe I heard it a couple of Sundays ago at Mass. I am fairly certain it was from Paul. I will try to find the exact verse later, when I have more time.
lilac_angel Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1777221' date='Feb 9 2009, 09:06 PM']NOT AT ALL!!! loving your enemy does not mean lying to them or being subversive. You must be clear and honest about who your enemies are... part of loving your enemies in the Christian context is HAVING enemies. if you don't have enemies, you're not being a good Christian, as Christ told us that the world would hate us.[/quote] One can have enemies and completely honest Christians without rubbing that word in someone's face. Other words can be used that may be much more effective. Of course I have enemies. Usually it's the minute they learn I'm a devout Catholic.
Aloysius Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 so was St. Paul wrong to call the Jews (of the religion of Judaism which rejects Christ) "enemies for the sake of the gospel" in Romans 11:28, or was it just +Williamson who was wrong to do so? to me, these are two bishops, two apostles, sperated by 2000 years but saying the same poignent thing which is perfectly acceptable; as a people they are beloved for the sake of the fathers (the Spiegel artical says 'the Father', i assume there was somethin misspoken or mistranslated by the Germans somewhere along the line, but in any event that also would make sense given the western tradition of viewing Old Testament acts of God as acts of the Father) but enemies to the Gospel.
lilac_angel Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 (edited) Oops, mistake.. tried to edit a post and ended up quoting myself instead. Edited February 10, 2009 by lilac_angel
KnightofChrist Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1777234' date='Feb 9 2009, 09:23 PM']so was St. Paul wrong to call the Jews (of the religion of Judaism which rejects Christ) "enemies for the sake of the gospel" in Romans 11:28, or was it just +Williamson who was wrong to do so? to me, these are two bishops, two apostles, sperated by 2000 years but saying the same poignent thing which is perfectly acceptable; as a people they are beloved for the sake of the fathers (the Spiegel artical says 'the Father', i assume there was somethin misspoken or mistranslated by the Germans somewhere along the line, but in any event that also would make sense given the western tradition of viewing Old Testament acts of God as acts of the Father) but enemies to the Gospel.[/quote] Not only St. Paul but God, because He is the ultimate author.
lilac_angel Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1777239' date='Feb 9 2009, 09:25 PM']Not only St. Paul but God, because He is the ultimate author.[/quote] I didn't find the provoke quote yet, but this recent reading from St. Paul says something to me: "Although I am free in regard to all, [b]I have made myself a slave to all so as to win over as many as possible.[/b] [b]To the weak I became weak, to win over the weak.[/b] [b]I have become all things to all, to save at least some.[/b] All this I do for the sake of the gospel, so that I too may have a share in it." Does that mention using the word "enemy" to win souls? To me, it almost sounds "politically correct," even though liberals annoy the croutons out of me. If we are to become all things to all, shouldn't we consider being a friend to all as well? Paul even goes so far as to say slaves.
Aloysius Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 but St. Paul himself uses the word "enemy" so your interpretation is irrelevant! in fact, it's not so much +Williamson here using the word enemy, but +Williamson quoting St. Paul using the word enemy!
jmjtina Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1777052' date='Feb 9 2009, 05:22 PM']Evidently for some people the holocaust is a new article of the Catholic faith. Truly sad.[/quote] Sad? It's almost weird coming from such an educated man. I could take liberal bishops in stride but this one is about history; it just boggles my mind. Denying history within the last 60 years? That just seems odd to me. Is this to be an article of the Catholic faith due to the Bishop or the fact that this is a widely accepted thought: the denial of the Holocaust? prayers for him. Edited February 10, 2009 by jmjtina
lilac_angel Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1777246' date='Feb 9 2009, 09:39 PM']but St. Paul himself uses the word "enemy" so your interpretation is irrelevant! in fact, it's not so much +Williamson here using the word enemy, but +Williamson quoting St. Paul using the word enemy![/quote] Um... no, it's not irrelevant. How does St. Paul's use of the word "enemy" trump the other things he said? Was St. Paul directly addressing Jews in that Epistle? Or was it a letter to the Romans?
Aloysius Posted February 10, 2009 Posted February 10, 2009 that's pretty much like saying was +Williamson adressing the Jews in that artical, or was it just the Germans? St. Paul's encyclicals were read aloud in the Christian assemblies and people went out from there and lived according to what he told them; so they lived considering the Jews of Rabinnic Judaism 'beloved for the sake of the fathers' but 'enemies for the sake of the gospel'... why? because they went around proposing a continuation of the Old Testament which was not in Christ, so they were THE ENEMIES OF THE GOSPEL, and they remain the enemies of the Gospel. becoming like all so that some might be saved does not mean what you claim it means; it's a huge stretch to say that it does; it means meeting people at their level. your interpretation of that passage has no place in the history of the Church, it's an anachronistic reading which doesn't take into account St. Paul's intent. how on earth you can take that verse to mean "don't call people your enemies" is beyond me.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now