Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Anyone a fan of The Watchmen (the graphic novel) and totally stoked about the new movie?

Anyone want to talk about how different the theory of heroes is in The Watchmen as compared to previous comics & graphic novels? Any comments on the morality of either?



"But the world is so full of ... miracles that they become commonplace and we forget... I forget. We gaze continually at the world and it grows dull in our perceptions. Yet seen from the another's vantage point. As if new, it may still take our breath away."

Posted

I thought the previews looked really good. I'm often not that into graphic novels though.
Unfortunately I can't get in to see it. Dunno what they rated it in the States, but I'm relatively sure it's 18A here.

Posted

Well, most of the Watchmen were based on Charlton Comics heroes. Originally Watchmen was meant to be an introduction of these heroes to the DC universe when DC bought the Charlton assets in 1985. They decided to make the story independent due to the reluctance to kill off certain characters. If you look up these characters on the web, you can see the similarities.

Peacemaker = The Comedian
The Question = Rorschach
Nightshade = Silk Specter
Blue Beetle = Night Owl
Mr Atom = Doctor Manhattan
Thunderbolt = Ozymandias

I was working at a comic shop when Watchmen came out. I can remember picking the new DC titles with the Charlton characters they did after Watchmen for nostalgia sake (no pun intended). I was mostly disappointed.

Posted

Who was the cool guy in the hat and trenchcoat? Hehe.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1778919' date='Feb 11 2009, 03:17 PM']Who was the cool guy in the hat and trenchcoat? Hehe.[/quote]
Cobra Commander.

  • 2 weeks later...
sarcasmguy126
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1778706' date='Feb 11 2009, 09:51 AM']I thought the previews looked really good. I'm often not that into graphic novels though.
Unfortunately I can't get in to see it. Dunno what they rated it in the States, but I'm relatively sure it's 18A here.[/quote]

Here in the States it is rated R for graphic violence, sexuality, nudity and language. What else should one expect from a movie directed by the guy who made "300" and "Sin City"?

Superhero movies usually aren't R.

Maximilianus
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1778919' date='Feb 11 2009, 03:17 PM']Who was the cool guy in the hat and trenchcoat? Hehe.[/quote]

Kelly Leak from "The Bad News Bears" ...the original.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='sarcasmguy126' post='1797199' date='Mar 4 2009, 09:15 AM']Here in the States it is rated R for graphic violence, sexuality, nudity and language. What else should one expect from a movie directed by the guy who made "300" and "Sin City"?

Superhero movies usually aren't R.[/quote]
There's a slight chance I can get into it in Canada though. I actually haven't looked if it's 14A or 18A. The Canadian censors are awful; I have a feeling that half of their job description is to drink until they can't see straight.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

14A everywhere in Canada except Ontario (18A) and Quebec (13+ because they're weird like that). I rest my case. Absolutely hammered.

Posted

[quote name='sarcasmguy126' post='1797199' date='Mar 4 2009, 11:15 AM']Here in the States it is rated R for graphic violence, sexuality, nudity and language. What else should one expect from a movie directed by the guy who made "300" and "Sin City"?

Superhero movies usually aren't R.[/quote]
Actually, director Zack Snyder directed [i]300[/i], but not [i]Sin City[/i], which was directed by Robert Rodriguez with Frank Miller (with a segment by "guest director" Quentin Tarantino). Frank Miller wrote and drew the [i]300[/i] and [i]Sin City[/i] comics on which those movies were (very closely) based.
[i]Watchmen[/i] is based on the graphic novel by Alan Moore, who also wrote [i]V for Vendetta[/i] (among other things).
I haven't watched it yet (Bubblicious wants me to watch it tomorrow at the same time she does, though we're now in different states), but apparently it for the most part follows the book very closely though, by necessity, large parts are omitted.
The adult content is found in the source novel - it's definitely not a story for kids, but a dark and complex satire/drama, despite the "superhero" theme.

The comic is quite entertaining in its geeky way. It's a brilliantly told (if extremely cynical) story, despite the fact that I don't agree with a lot of the far-left underpinnings of the tale.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1799406' date='Mar 6 2009, 11:34 PM']Actually, director Zack Snyder directed [i]300[/i], but not [i]Sin City[/i], which was directed by Robert Rodriguez with Frank Miller (with a segment by "guest director" Quentin Tarantino). Frank Miller wrote and drew the [i]300[/i] and [i]Sin City[/i] comics on which those movies were (very closely) based.
[i]Watchmen[/i] is based on the graphic novel by Alan Moore, who also wrote [i]V for Vendetta[/i] (among other things).
I haven't watched it yet (Bubblicious wants me to watch it tomorrow at the same time she does, though we're now in different states), but apparently it for the most part follows the book very closely though, by necessity, large parts are omitted.
The adult content is found in the source novel - it's definitely not a story for kids, but a dark and complex satire/drama, despite the "superhero" theme.

The comic is quite entertaining in its geeky way. It's a brilliantly told (if extremely cynical) story, despite the fact that I don't agree with a lot of the far-left underpinnings of the tale.[/quote]


Dude, you're gonna love it.

If you can swing it, you should see it on IMAX.

In the words of Kevin Smith, who reviewed it a while back after seeing a sneak preview, it is an opus that does everything you'd want it to do. I was really afraid that it was gonna smell of elderberries, despite the fact that I figured Synder would be the only director I could see coming close to pulling it off. And yeah, there's stuff that's omitted (not "large parts," though the ending is a bit different) but, for the most part, it's minor things that wouldn't have contributed much to the overall movie experience.

Dude, you're gonna love it.

Posted

[size=1]For the longest time I was SO excited to see this movie!
I havnt seen it yet, but my desire to see it has now gone so it doesnt matter.

My brother saw the midnight showing thursday night and told me the next day that yes, it was pretty darn cool, but there was alot more nudity than he expected.

I am to understand that the blue superhero guy is pretty much letting his little willy sway freely without much censorship for many scenes. There is also a 3 minute sex scene that shows more nudity and I just don’t think that any of this is necessary at all.

That just kinda turned me off to the movie.
Im sure the other elements of the movie such as action, special effects, etc are really great, but I no longer want to spend the money on it.
My friends bf saw it on friday and said it was a huge waste of his time. He thought it was pretty gross.


So I dunno.

Tis my take.
[/size]

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I heard a reviewer mention "far-left undertones". Is that a legitimate point?

Posted (edited)

Okay I just saw the movie. I decided to comment on it while it's still fresh. Basically, I went in knowing this was a graphic novel, and that there would be some sex and lots of violence, but I was like "okay, I'll just look away when appropriate". Also, I went in knowing that the Watchmen were a dark satire on the whole superhero thing. I found lots of irony in the movie here and there. Some I could really deem as cleaver. What was not cleaver was the graphic stuff with how they would emphasise the fact that Silk Spectre II had fallen into the same mistakes her mother made: ie, slept around. Well, twice with the same guy (Night Owl). Aside from that, I tried to look for some sort of redeeming qualities in this movie, like the directors subconscious leanings toward some Christian virtues. Didn't find any. I just saw lots of broken humans. Heck, Dr. Manhatten was the most broken of them all. I got the message that great power doesn't necessarily lead you to God. Despite his abilities, he was still leaning athiestic (probably because he was so rationalistic -- wanted to categorise everything). I think the real protagonist was the crazy one... Cobra/Roshak. He stuck to his principals through the whole thing. Everything about him was broken. The only thing that held him together was his hidden identity. Even that was taken away. [spoiler]The biggest injustice happened at the end with his death.[/spoiler] I suppose there's more I want to say. Maybe not. I really liked the Night Owl though. He was sort of my favourite Character going in (read about some of the characters in the promo site). I think the director could have cut the sex instead of pandering to the types that "enjoy" that sort of thing. Heck, I found it utterly distasteful. I'll conclude my review/rant with "I should really read the graphic novel, cause I was told it is much better".

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1800134' date='Mar 7 2009, 10:49 PM']I heard a reviewer mention "far-left undertones". Is that a legitimate point?[/quote]
Yeah. They made Nightshade a lesbian in the beginning. There were a few other "brave new world" type things in there too. And how the Communists and the Americans dropped their weapons so they could "fight a common good", aka try and kill the 'immortal' Dr. Manhattan.

Edited by Sacred Music Man
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1800309' date='Mar 8 2009, 04:00 AM']Okay I just saw the movie. I decided to comment on it while it's still fresh. Basically, I went in knowing this was a graphic novel, and that there would be some sex and lots of violence, but I was like "okay, I'll just look away when appropriate". Also, I went in knowing that the Watchmen were a dark satire on the whole superhero thing. I found lots of irony in the movie here and there. Some I could really deem as cleaver. What was not cleaver was the graphic stuff with how they would emphasise the fact that Silk Spectre II had fallen into the same mistakes her mother made: ie, slept around. Well, twice with the same guy (Night Owl). Aside from that, I tried to look for some sort of redeeming qualities in this movie, like the directors subconscious leanings toward some Christian virtues. Didn't find any. I just saw lots of broken humans. Heck, Dr. Manhatten was the most broken of them all. I got the message that great power doesn't necessarily lead you to God. Despite his abilities, he was still leaning athiestic (probably because he was so rationalistic -- wanted to categorise everything). I think the real protagonist was the crazy one... Cobra/Roshak. He stuck to his principals through the whole thing. Everything about him was broken. The only thing that held him together was his hidden identity. Even that was taken away. [spoiler]The biggest injustice happened at the end with his death.[/spoiler] I suppose there's more I want to say. Maybe not. I really liked the Night Owl though. He was sort of my favourite Character going in (read about some of the characters in the promo site). I think the director could have cut the sex instead of pandering to the types that "enjoy" that sort of thing. Heck, I found it utterly distasteful. I'll conclude my review/rant with "I should really read the graphic novel, cause I was told it is much better".


Yeah. They made Nightshade a lesbian in the beginning. There were a few other "brave new world" type things in there too. And how the Communists and the Americans dropped their weapons so they could "fight a common good", aka try and kill the 'immortal' Dr. Manhattan.[/quote]

[spoiler]For starters, I'd like to point out that this movie was about 95% faithful to the original material. This was, in my opinion, one of the best assets of this film, though I also feel it is it's greatest weakness. The Watchmen, for those who have read the graphic novel and/or have seen the movie, is a very subversive, sardonic, ironic, dark tale that is not supposed to be "uplifting" and is not supposed to possess "Christian undertones." It's supposed to be a satire of that exact sort of thing--how "traditional" comic book heroes are all "perfect" beings--powerful, intelligent, morally-upright, true Americans. What Alan Moore and Co. wanted to do was to turn this image (what I like to call the "Superman typology") on its head and to examine the sort of psychology (psychosis?) of a less-than-ideal masked hero. So we see that one character is shy and lacks confidence (Nite Owl), one character is constantly trying to live up to the expectations of her mother (Silk Spectre II), the "intelligence" of two characters lead them to detach from humanity, in one form or another (Ozymandias and Dr. Manhattan). The list goes on.

Now, the sex scene just cracked me up. I dunno...it was probably the contrast between what was going on on screen and that god-awful rendition of Hallelujah. I just found myself laughing hysterically. It was so awkward and weird. As far as Dr. Manhattan's penis thing, I thought it was handled discretely, but straightforward. They didn't make a big spectacle of it, nor did they shy away from it. You could see it, but, once you got past the initial shock, you could kinda just ignore it. But I guess I can see the merit behind being slightly uncomfortable with an IMAX-sized blue penis on the screen.

I thought that Dr. Manhattan and Ozymandias/Adrian Veidt characters were fascinating. Two highly intelligent, purely rational, all-knowing men who could do extraordinary things. Some would argue that they was "perfect." But they both lacked the emotional attachments brought about by normal humanity. This was manifested in Dr. Manhattan's monologue about "everything on earth could die, and the universe would never notice" and Ozy's plan to "save" humanity. Such rationale is devoid of "imperfect," irrational things like love and compassion. Is this really "perfection?" I think Alan Moore was playing with this idea a lot.

Finally, politically, everything was as over-the-top as the costumes of the heroes themselves. I felt that everyone was either far-left or far-right until Ozy's attack. This brings about an and to the ideology of separation; however, at what cost? Some would say this was "compromise in the face of armageddon" (i.e.- Rorschach) while others saw it as a necessary evil, the only way to save humanity from the brink of annihilation. There is definitely some "ends justify the means" stuff here, but the death of Rorschach kind of mitigates that stuff. As a whole, I think there was certainly enough criticism of "left" and "right" to go around. [/spoiler]

EDIT: Wow, I just realized that virtually my whole post has spoilers in it. Ugh....

Edited by kujo
Galloglasses' Alt
Posted

[spoiler]Just saw it myself and there definately is some far-leftism involved, as far as the portrayal of the far-rightism is you need only pay attention to how Nixon is portrayed in the film, who is both an American Hero and also veiwed as the Devil if you pay attention to some of the graffetti, with no wise cracks related to watergate, (this actually surprised me), Sacrificing the few for the needs of the many for a world peace that definately will not last? Thats what went through my head after Ozy nuked millions of the world's population. I thought it was odd to choose this character to do it as he is presented as the typical progressive, openly homosexual, enviromentalist, etc, etc.

One of the great tragedies of the film was Rorsach, (forgive the spelling), who as was mentioned before, was completely broken and flawed, but at the same time extremely principled. If you pay attention to his narrative of the film you will notice he is of the conservative ilk bordering on the condemnatory side. However, his open and obvious disgust for the whole of humanity who he veiws as evil is tempered by his unswerving principles to protect it and to tell the truth. Strangely enough this is what endeared him to me more then any of the other characters, he goes out to tell the truth of what is going on towards the end, and is killed for it as he threatened the 'Peace based upon a lie', yet he is vindicated for it later as his journals reach a press agency.

Its actually quite a confusing movie as there are so many ideas and philosophies thrown about, nihilism, liberalism, conservatism, 'ends justify the means', Justice>Peace in terms of telling the truth. There are also a number of 'change of hearts' going on, as with the comedian, possibly the most hateful character in the film, utterly cracks up when he hears of Ozy's plan and confides in his archenemy for solace. (Irony) Altough he is the character who most avidly swears humanity is scum incarnate and doesn't deserve to exist. The Nihilism of Dr.Manhatten is shattered by the miracle of an individual's very existence from order chaos. (This almost strikes of pro-life), possibly Rorsach is the only character to 'stick to his guns' in the entire film, his methods are disagreeable, but his reasons are almost justifiable.

Altough I did get sick of seeing a blue penis for half the film.[/spoiler]

This from the perspective of someone who hasn't read the comics.

filiusInFilio
Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1800384' date='Mar 8 2009, 10:30 AM'][spoiler]For starters, I'd like to point out that this movie was about 95% faithful to the original material. This was, in my opinion, one of the best assets of this film, though I also feel it is it's greatest weakness. The Watchmen, for those who have read the graphic novel and/or have seen the movie, is a very subversive, sardonic, ironic, dark tale that is not supposed to be "uplifting" and is not supposed to possess "Christian undertones." It's supposed to be a satire of that exact sort of thing--how "traditional" comic book heroes are all "perfect" beings--powerful, intelligent, morally-upright, true Americans. What Alan Moore and Co. wanted to do was to turn this image (what I like to call the "Superman typology") on its head and to examine the sort of psychology (psychosis?) of a less-than-ideal masked hero. So we see that one character is shy and lacks confidence (Nite Owl), one character is constantly trying to live up to the expectations of her mother (Silk Spectre II), the "intelligence" of two characters lead them to detach from humanity, in one form or another (Ozymandias and Dr. Manhattan). The list goes on.

Now, the sex scene just cracked me up. I dunno...it was probably the contrast between what was going on on screen and that god-awful rendition of Hallelujah. I just found myself laughing hysterically. It was so awkward and weird. As far as Dr. Manhattan's penis thing, I thought it was handled discretely, but straightforward. They didn't make a big spectacle of it, nor did they shy away from it. You could see it, but, once you got past the initial shock, you could kinda just ignore it. But I guess I can see the merit behind being slightly uncomfortable with an IMAX-sized blue penis on the screen.

I thought that Dr. Manhattan and Ozymandias/Adrian Veidt characters were fascinating. Two highly intelligent, purely rational, all-knowing men who could do extraordinary things. Some would argue that they was "perfect." But they both lacked the emotional attachments brought about by normal humanity. This was manifested in Dr. Manhattan's monologue about "everything on earth could die, and the universe would never notice" and Ozy's plan to "save" humanity. Such rationale is devoid of "imperfect," irrational things like love and compassion. Is this really "perfection?" I think Alan Moore was playing with this idea a lot.

Finally, politically, everything was as over-the-top as the costumes of the heroes themselves. I felt that everyone was either far-left or far-right until Ozy's attack. This brings about an and to the ideology of separation; however, at what cost? Some would say this was "compromise in the face of armageddon" (i.e.- Rorschach) while others saw it as a necessary evil, the only way to save humanity from the brink of annihilation. There is definitely some "ends justify the means" stuff here, but the death of Rorschach kind of mitigates that stuff. As a whole, I think there was certainly enough criticism of "left" and "right" to go around. [/spoiler]

EDIT: Wow, I just realized that virtually my whole post has spoilers in it. Ugh....[/quote]


good post...i basically agree with everything you said

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1800309' date='Mar 8 2009, 03:00 AM']Okay I just saw the movie. I decided to comment on it while it's still fresh. Basically, I went in knowing this was a graphic novel, and that there would be some sex and lots of violence, but I was like "okay, I'll just look away when appropriate". Also, I went in knowing that the Watchmen were a dark satire on the whole superhero thing. I found lots of irony in the movie here and there. Some I could really deem as cleaver. What was not cleaver was the graphic stuff with how they would emphasise the fact that Silk Spectre II had fallen into the same mistakes her mother made: ie, slept around. Well, twice with the same guy (Night Owl). Aside from that, I tried to look for some sort of redeeming qualities in this movie, like the directors subconscious leanings toward some Christian virtues. Didn't find any. I just saw lots of broken humans. Heck, Dr. Manhatten was the most broken of them all. I got the message that great power doesn't necessarily lead you to God. Despite his abilities, he was still leaning athiestic (probably because he was so rationalistic -- wanted to categorise everything). I think the real protagonist was the crazy one... Cobra/Roshak. He stuck to his principals through the whole thing. Everything about him was broken. The only thing that held him together was his hidden identity. Even that was taken away. [spoiler]The biggest injustice happened at the end with his death.[/spoiler] I suppose there's more I want to say. Maybe not. I really liked the Night Owl though. He was sort of my favourite Character going in (read about some of the characters in the promo site). I think the director could have cut the sex instead of pandering to the types that "enjoy" that sort of thing. Heck, I found it utterly distasteful. I'll conclude my review/rant with "I should really read the graphic novel, cause I was told it is much better".[/quote]
I thought Zack Snyder wallowed a bit too much in the sex/violence aspects of the story (present in the book, but not as graphic or glamorized). The violence (while I thought it was fun) was actually more stylized and cartoony than in the book. The movie's action sequences went for "cool" violence in a Miller/Tarantino vein, while the book kind of de-glamorized the "comic-book violence" and had a more cerebral tone (its "heroes" are presented more as regular people in silly costumes than as supermen).

Overall, the movie was almost religiously close to the source book (except for some plot changes with the climax, necessary to keep the movie within three hours without an overabundance of side-plots).
The book did not have any kind of "uplifting" theme not found in the movie, but is generally deeply cynical about the human condition and most ideologies.



[quote]Yeah. They made Nightshade a lesbian in the beginning. There were a few other "brave new world" type things in there too. And how the Communists and the Americans dropped their weapons so they could "fight a common good", aka try and kill the 'immortal' Dr. Manhattan.[/quote]
The book's author, Alan Moore, is a British self-described anarchist, who, judging by his writings, despises all things "right-wing," yet also has little use for conventional liberalism.
[i]Watchmen[/i] expresses a general cynicism towards all standard political ideologies (right and left), and as expressed by the theme "Who watches the watchmen?" shows a distrust of those (such as in government) who set themselves up as protectors or saviors over the rest of us.

Interestingly, I read that director Zack Snyder was asked by someone if the movie would be irrelevant now that Obama was elected president. He replied, "You have an extremely optimistic view of the world."
With people looking up to Obama as a kind of savior in time of need, I'd say the message if anything is more relevant now than ever.

Edited by Socrates

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...