Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Now you think he's a Saint too? :huh:

Posted

edited because as I have said, it is not for me to say whether or not he is a saint (Apotheoun's argument that he died in communion with Rome makes me think it possible, and I do not in principal reject the authority of the Eastern Churches to glorify their own saints, though I do not consider Romans bound to consider the saints they have glorified as saints)

.... if you're referring to the other person I roundaboutly mentioned, well, I'll say I certainly don't think he went anywhere where he can't pray for us, but that leaves two possible places I think he's at right now and either way, he's most poignent to my "pass down what has been recieved" shpiel

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1786259' date='Feb 20 2009, 09:45 AM']For example, it's my impression (and maybe some of our elder and wiser phatmassers can agree/disagree) that before Vatican II, when one asked a question like, "What is the Eucharist?" or "What does Jesus mean by, 'This is my body'?" that you'd be given an definitive answer. Think of how the Baltimore Catechism being a series of questions followed by defined answers that Catholic children in the Fifties memorized. Catholics learned the "right" answers. The problem is, many weren't encountering God through the mystery of the sacraments.

This is just my personal observation, but I think that problem is rooted in Western society's shift to post-modernism. At the extreme, that means there is no truth except tolerance for all beliefs. But within Catholicism, many Catholics weren't connecting with the "right" answers they memorized from the Baltimore Catechism. By instead emphasizing the mystery of Holy Communion, when someone inquires, "What does Jesus mean by, 'This is my body'?" instead of lecturing on transubstantation, we might instead encourage them to simply consider taking Jesus at his literal words and ponder the mystery of what they mean and how and why he would gives us his Body in the form of bread and wine. Through that approach, people are encouraged to have a personal encounter with Christ and the Eucharist... and that's how a convinced post-modernist becomes a convinced Catholic.[/quote]

I disagree. My generation could at least define what the Eucharist is. Many children today cannot get past " its Jesus". Ask them how its Jesus they haven't a clue. They may have some warm fuzzy feeling, but that doesn't constitute faith. It just leaves them open to the first warm fuzzy congregation that comes along - usually a non-catholic one.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1787583' date='Feb 21 2009, 09:42 PM']edited because as I have said, it is not for me to say whether or not he is a saint (Apotheoun's argument that he died in communion with Rome makes me think it possible, and I do not in principal reject the authority of the Eastern Churches to glorify their own saints, though I do not consider Romans bound to consider the saints they have glorified as saints)

.... if you're referring to the other person I roundaboutly mentioned, well, I'll say I certainly don't think he went anywhere where he can't pray for us, but that leaves two possible places I think he's at right now and either way, he's most poignent to my "pass down what has been recieved" shpiel[/quote]

I was referring to the Patriarch, not the Archbishop... I don't think anyone thinks the latter is a Saint haha

Posted

I'm not thoroughly convinced that that will still be the case in a hundred or two hundred years... but I should really shut up about all that :cyclops: :whistle:

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Resurrexi' post='1787533' date='Feb 21 2009, 09:18 PM']I would disagree that the by explaining Transubstantiation that one is minimalizing the mystery of the most holy Sacrament. And if the Magisterium thought it did minimalize the mystery, it wouldn't continue to use it in its documents... which it has continued to do since the Council.[/quote]

Obviously, the doctrine of transubstantiation is true. The problems is nobody cares, thus it fails to communicate the mystery of the Eucharist to our current society which doesn't relate to defined universal truths. People convert through a personal encounter with Christ, and I think that's the value of Eastern theology in our Western society.

Posted

Nobody cares? Hah. You do know that most devout Catholic today are the ones who [i]do[/i] care about what the Church teaches and thus [i]do[/i] care about transubstantiation?

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1787620' date='Feb 21 2009, 11:11 PM']I disagree. My generation could at least define what the Eucharist is. Many children today cannot get past " its Jesus". Ask them how its Jesus they haven't a clue. They may have some warm fuzzy feeling, but that doesn't constitute faith. It just leaves them open to the first warm fuzzy congregation that comes along - usually a non-catholic one.[/quote]

That's where the prevalence of poor discipleship in modern Catholicism has failed the last couple generations. A genuine encounter with Christ is nothing like a warm, fuzzy feeling. Why do you think most Catholics abandoned that practice of memorizing definitions? I think it's because our post-modern society doesn't identify with that approach. It doesn't mean it was wrong for its time or is any less true today, but a different approach is needed today to communicate the same Truth.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Resurrexi' post='1787850' date='Feb 22 2009, 01:46 AM']Nobody cares? Hah. You do know that most devout Catholic today are the ones who [i]do[/i] care about what the Church teaches and thus [i]do[/i] care about transubstantiation?[/quote]

Yes, and we are a minority even within our own faith, and in society at large we usually find more friends among Evangelicals than fellow Catholics. I care about these things too, but I look around me and see a lot of people who aren't connecting with it and I can't help but wonder why that is.

Posted

Most Catholics I know are perfectly aware of Transubstantiation...

Posted

Louiseville, I think you're absolutely 100% wrong about the issue of transubstantiation and even memorization. 'memorization' and other such things were thrown out because a whole bunch of MODERNISTS (who believe in the HERESY of MODERNISM) decided that we needed to throw them out because they didn't fit our modern way of approaching divine truths anymore. they were in error, and their actions have destroyed the faith of millions of peoople in the world. they will have much to answer for on judgement day.

Rome and the magisterium, on their part, have never abandoned distinctive doctrinal ideas and categories such as this and have remained much truer to the faith they recieved than the modernists.

we don't need to abandon Roman or Western theological paradigms which were extremely effective in basically converting the whole world, we need to GO BACK TO THEM. Before they were abandoned on the thesis that modern man would not respond to them, [i]modern man was responding to them![/i]

there's a catechetical crisis connected to a liturgical crisis widespread throughout the Church today; Rome has recognized both crises and her answer is not to abandon the theological patrimony of the West, but rather to return to a continuity with that patrimony because it was rupture with that patrimony which caused the crisis.

we really won't gain a stronger Church by disconnecting with the way the faith was formulated to our fathers... in fact, if we continue down such a road and this includes either modernization or even Easternization, we'll end up destroying the Church even more. the more we Easternize, the more we undermine the authority of the Roman Pontiff in the Roman Church itself... and the more we do that, the more errant liberal (and modernist) bishops will end up breaking apart western Christendom by simply no longer listening to the Pope.

much more is at stake than you think in mere theoretical formulations about doctrines such as transubstantiation.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1787866' date='Feb 22 2009, 02:06 AM']That's where the prevalence of poor discipleship in modern Catholicism has failed the last couple generations. A genuine encounter with Christ is nothing like a warm, fuzzy feeling. Why do you think most Catholics abandoned that practice of memorizing definitions? I think it's because our post-modern society doesn't identify with that approach. It doesn't mean it was wrong for its time or is any less true today, but a different approach is needed today to communicate the same Truth.[/quote]

Do you think you can manufacture a genuine encounter? If you had a genuine encounter without a frame of reference could you identify it as such?
Catholics abandoned definitions in the same manor as public schools did. Instead of teaching facts, it became all experiential and touchy- feely: self-esteem and how we feel about ourselves and not about the actual subject. Never in history has so many people felt so good about themselves being failures. The "different" aproach has been tried in all forms of education for the last forty years with disasterous results. Jesus my best buddy approach, instead of the God the Creator of the Universe.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1788084' date='Feb 22 2009, 09:22 AM']Louiseville, I think you're absolutely 100% wrong about the issue of transubstantiation and even memorization. 'memorization' and other such things were thrown out because a whole bunch of MODERNISTS (who believe in the HERESY of MODERNISM) decided that we needed to throw them out because they didn't fit our modern way of approaching divine truths anymore. they were in error, and their actions have destroyed the faith of millions of peoople in the world. they will have much to answer for on judgement day.[/quote]

Modernism faded around the time of World War II. Post-modernism is the major cultural movement we've been dealing with since the 60s. My question is, why did most Catholics feel disconnected from all these truths they were taught? If we don't address that "why," we're just chasing our own tail and will only attract the same token converts. Catholicism has so much to say in our world today and the only people who even give an ear are Catholics and a few ecumenically-minded Christians. That's a problem.

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1788084' date='Feb 22 2009, 09:22 AM']we don't need to abandon Roman or Western theological paradigms which were extremely effective in basically converting the whole world, we need to GO BACK TO THEM. Before they were abandoned on the thesis that modern man would not respond to them, [i]modern man was responding to them![/i][/quote]

I believe the thesis is post-modernist will not respond, and they obviously aren't.

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1788084' date='Feb 22 2009, 09:22 AM']it was rupture with that patrimony which caused the crisis.[/quote]

And what causes the rupture? Half of Catholics from European origin abandoned their faith in the past two generations. This isn't isolated to Catholicism. Look at Christianity overall, mainline Protestantism, and even Judaism... similar trends are seen across society since the 60s. It's easy to blame a few vocal liberal Catholics, but my question is, why did they choose to be liberal in the first place? What was it about orthodoxy that they rejected?

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1788084' date='Feb 22 2009, 09:22 AM']much more is at stake than you think in mere theoretical formulations about doctrines such as transubstantiation.[/quote]

I wasn't aware that Eastern Catholics and Orthodox thought of the Eucharist in merely theoretical formulations.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...