Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1786442' date='Feb 20 2009, 02:02 PM']I may not like what he says, but I'll defend to the death his right to say it. Mark my words, today it's "extremism" against homosexuals like the Westboro Baptist Church, tomorrow it's "extremism" against homosexuality like the Roman Catholic Church that will be banned from that country. Cling to the US Constitution and defend it even for this Phelps fellow, for there is NO nation on earth whose government we can trust to censor against error and therefore we must demand governments that tolerate even the most vile of errors so that our beliefs may also be protected.[/quote]

Very astute point. :yes: I will have to remember that.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1786375' date='Feb 20 2009, 12:50 PM']as much as I hate phelps, I love that I live in a country where EVEN his free speech is allowed. come now, you think Britain will stop at Phelps? To many people, there's no difference between what he says and a nuanced ballanced position that homosexual acts are sinful and homosexual marriage shouldn't be recognized and homosexuals couples shouldn't adopt but that homosexual persons are not to be hated...[/quote]


[quote name='Aloysius' post='1786442' date='Feb 20 2009, 03:02 PM']I may not like what he says, but I'll defend to the death his right to say it. Mark my words, today it's "extremism" against homosexuals like the Westboro Baptist Church, tomorrow it's "extremism" against homosexuality like the Roman Catholic Church that will be banned from that country. Cling to the US Constitution and defend it even for this Phelps fellow, for there is NO nation on earth whose government we can trust to censor against error and therefore we must demand governments that tolerate even the most vile of errors so that our beliefs may also be protected.[/quote]
I absolutely agree. There are plenty of private citizens who can protest these morons if they want, but there's no need for the government to do it for them.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1786442' date='Feb 20 2009, 02:02 PM']I may not like what he says, but I'll defend to the death his right to say it. Mark my words, today it's "extremism" against homosexuals like the Westboro Baptist Church, tomorrow it's "extremism" against homosexuality like the Roman Catholic Church that will be banned from that country. Cling to the US Constitution and defend it even for this Phelps fellow, for there is NO nation on earth whose government we can trust to censor against error and therefore we must demand governments that tolerate even the most vile of errors so that our beliefs may also be protected.[/quote]
Well, the UK does not have to allow anyone in-- especially if their sole purpose is to cause trouble.

Posted

so at what point does the visit of a Catholic bishop or pope become classified as being there just to cause trouble?

technically they don't have to allow anyone travel; but these grounds for not allowing them are wrong, IMO. they're not coming in to do crimes (except thought crimes), they're coming in to voice their (STUPID) opinion, and Britain is saying "we don't want that opinion expressed in this nation".

if you are willing to concede that type of power to the governments of western civilization, go ahead. As for me, I thank God almighty that the US constitution is still in force here and the government of the US cannot according to its own laws refuse entry on the grounds of people's opinions on such matters. We let the president of Iran come here, those who do not come here to commit true crimes are given fair chance at visas regardless of their opinions about things.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1786551' date='Feb 20 2009, 02:38 PM']if you are willing to concede that type of power to the governments of western civilization, go ahead. As for me, I thank God almighty that the US constitution is still in force here and the government of the US cannot according to its own laws refuse entry on the grounds of people's opinions on such matters. We let the president of Iran come here, those who do not come here to commit true crimes are given fair chance at visas regardless of their opinions about things.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
ditto. and i'd be more worried if i was Britain about the people already on their soil who spout even more hateful things.

Posted

Heh, I guess I was one of the only ones who thought "WBC" first. Heck, I never even thought of the swimmer.

Posted

They're in Ireland....

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1786551' date='Feb 20 2009, 02:38 PM']technically they don't have to allow anyone travel; but these grounds for not allowing them are wrong, IMO. they're not coming in to do crimes (except thought crimes), they're coming in to voice their (STUPID) opinion, and Britain is saying "we don't want that opinion expressed in this nation".[/quote]

unless you count libel, violating the peace, inciting riots/hatred as crimes

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1786528' date='Feb 20 2009, 08:57 PM']Well, the UK does not have to allow anyone in-- especially if their sole purpose is to cause trouble.[/quote]
That was my thought. Canada has denied them entry before as well when their sole purpose was to picket a funeral. And honestly, I would be somewhat surprised if there hasn't been a similar occurrence in the US, but of course I could be wrong.

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1786719' date='Feb 20 2009, 09:16 PM']unless you count libel, violating the peace, inciting riots/hatred as crimes[/quote]
it'd be cute if you were calling it libel because they wrote it on picket signs, but I'd think it more like slander and even that it's not LEGALLY slander, merely insulting people is not a crime. libel is when a newspaper misrepresents the facts about someone to destroy their reputation in a way that causes them damage, if I'm not mistaken. I don't see any crime of "libel" here. next thing you know elementary school kids will get charged with libel or slander for calling a classmate q.ueer or something...

I do NOT concede to the governments of western civilization the authority to define "inciting hatred", Canada has already gone over the deep end with that such that calling homosexuality immoral in Canada can be considered "inciting hatred"; now, inciting riots would make sense, except that they're not doing that... they're assembling to voice a stupid and unpopular viewpoint. I do not accept the idea that a stupid and unpopular viewpoint being expressed in a public demonstration qualifies as "inciting a riot"... again, this is not because I like what the WBC says, but because I do not like the governments using their power against unpopular opinions.

I would like to see an example from the US where this was grounds to deny travel visas... I'd consider that unconstitutional in principal. the president of Iran's comments could've sparked riots because of how angry they made people; but he came to the US where he was free to say such things.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1787320' date='Feb 21 2009, 01:20 PM']it'd be cute if you were calling it libel because they wrote it on picket signs, but I'd think it more like slander and even that it's not LEGALLY slander, merely insulting people is not a crime. libel is when a newspaper misrepresents the facts about someone to destroy their reputation in a way that causes them damage, if I'm not mistaken. I don't see any crime of "libel" here. next thing you know elementary school kids will get charged with libel or slander for calling a classmate q.ueer or something...

I do NOT concede to the governments of western civilization the authority to define "inciting hatred", Canada has already gone over the deep end with that such that calling homosexuality immoral in Canada can be considered "inciting hatred"; now, inciting riots would make sense, except that they're not doing that... they're assembling to voice a stupid and unpopular viewpoint. I do not accept the idea that a stupid and unpopular viewpoint being expressed in a public demonstration qualifies as "inciting a riot"... again, this is not because I like what the WBC says, but because I do not like the governments using their power against unpopular opinions.

I would like to see an example from the US where this was grounds to deny travel visas... I'd consider that unconstitutional in principal. the president of Iran's comments could've sparked riots because of how angry they made people; but he came to the US where he was free to say such things.[/quote]

There have been studies that suggust the Bush administration used anti terror laws to bar foreign acadamics with critical view points from entering the country.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1787366' date='Feb 21 2009, 07:07 PM']There have been studies that suggust the Bush administration used anti terror laws to bar foreign acadamics with critical view points from entering the country.[/quote]
I found an article speaking about one such academic. Now, I have no idea how accurate this website generally is, but [url="http://www.alternet.org/columnists/story/93361/respected_academic_denied_entry_into_u.s./"]here's the link[/url].

Posted

...freedom of speech is dying everywhere...

Posted

Thank God. That guy is just evil. Picketing funerals? Dispicable. I can't believe that interfering in [i]anyone's[/i] funeral is even allowed in the US. -Katie

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1787382' date='Feb 21 2009, 03:34 PM']...freedom of speech is dying everywhere...[/quote]

Phelps doesn't just [i]say[/i] ridiculous things, I think what he does is blatantly infringing upon the rights of others-failing to respect funerals is just low, imo. -Katie

Posted

what ever happened to the concept of "I may not like what you say, but I'll defend to the death you're right to say it"?

when it comes to picketing outside funerals, authorities should do their best to deny permits for public assembly in such locations, that's quite acceptable. Though in this particular case they were planning to picket outside a play I believe, and as stupid as their position is, they ought to have had the right to do so if they wish. or are plays sacrosanct?

actually, I'd think their presence there would highlight the point of that particular play, which is a play about the town where Matthew Shepherd died I believe... It'd be like having a group of Captain Hook supporters protesting outside a Peter Pan play (sorry, lol that was a silly analogy, but the first thing that popped into my head)

I am unwilling to concede to these governments which I do not trust the authority to decide which minority opinions are kosher and which are not... because you'd better believe they're coming for us eventually on the same grounds.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1787389' date='Feb 21 2009, 03:46 PM']what ever happened to the concept of "I may not like what you say, but I'll defend to the death you're right to say it"?

when it comes to picketing outside funerals, authorities should do their best to deny permits for public assembly in such locations, that's quite acceptable. Though in this particular case they were planning to picket outside a play I believe, and as stupid as their position is, they ought to have had the right to do so if they wish. or are plays sacrosanct?

actually, I'd think their presence there would highlight the point of that particular play, which is a play about the town where Matthew Shepherd died I believe... It'd be like having a group of Captain Hook supporters protesting outside a Peter Pan play (sorry, lol that was a silly analogy, but the first thing that popped into my head)

I am unwilling to concede to these governments which I do not trust the authority to decide which minority opinions are kosher and which are not... because you'd better believe they're coming for us eventually on the same grounds.[/quote]

Good point-I think the picketing of the play it self, while I consider it reprehensible, is within their rights. I think the UK does have good reason for banning them given their funeral activities in the US-I guess it might call into question what else they would do in the UK. -Katie

Posted

man, if you can get barred from entering the states for smoking pot once, 20 years ago...

its like when we canadians didnt let that domestic terrorist from the states into canada.


if they did this at one of my relatives funerals, i would almost definitely beat the croutons out of them.

Posted

lol. Someone should call them and say, "you're not going to UK, nah nah nah nah nah..." :P

Posted

America didn't let Yusuf Islam in and he did nothing wrong...he's just a singer!

These people are turning people away from Christianity, and I don't particularly want to encourage that to happen...

I have to laugh because that woman Phelps had a child outside marriage, yet she's condemning basically the whole world.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...