Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pro-life: Does Life Magically Begin At Birth?


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Simple, to the point.

Logic and truth demand an answer... the only logical and just answer to this is that all abortion must end.

People who support abortion have the wrong point of view... they look at it as the woman's body and not realize that the baby's body is alive. Although I have met on who said that he had no problem with the killing of a living unborn child... was shocked at that answer and couldn't come up with a good rebut of that one at the time.

[url="http://www.CatholicSwag.com"]http://www.CatholicSwag.com[/url]
[img]http://www.maxbrackett.com/images/magicbirth.jpg[/img]

This gives people something to mull over.

When people know you're trying to change their mind, they immediately become obstinate because that is human nature... Debates do not change people's minds but cause them to cling harder to their own thoughts... very few people are truly open minded. Debates are great for those on the sidelines, but not for those doing the debating. In a one to one conversation, the wrong party has to come to a conclusion on their own.

If someone comes to the realization on their own that life does not magically begin at birth they are more likely to become pro-life than if we try to convince them.


God Bless,
ironmonk

Edited by ironmonk
Posted (edited)

Good point.

This made me think of a line of sarcastic bumperstickers that just say "Pro Magic!" with fairys and unicorns all over them.*

*same joke for athiests and the big bang





**I apologize for this post not being nearly as humble as the opening post..

Edited by Sirklawd
Posted

once I was showing a chat pictires of aborted babies: and got ridiculed for using "Shock value tactics". I dont know what gives with pro-choice people

princessgianna
Posted

[quote name='Tony' post='1791021' date='Feb 24 2009, 11:06 PM']once I was showing a chat pictires of aborted babies: and got ridiculed for using "Shock value tactics". I dont know what gives with pro-choice people[/quote]
pro choice people are hurt people! Mostly women whowere being totally mistreated by a man. Killing their unborn child is all that they feel like they have a "choice" in. I know somebody who has seen more than once a guy literally shove his girlfriend into planned parenthood! For some -they have a say-they have power over their body (or so they think) so they make that "choice". Not making it right-it's not. they are still at fault for killing however it helps explain their actions.

princessgianna
Posted

Ironmonk-love the t-shirt!

Posted

[quote name='Tony' post='1791021' date='Feb 24 2009, 10:06 PM']once I was showing a chat pictires of aborted babies: and got ridiculed for using "Shock value tactics". I dont know what gives with pro-choice people[/quote]
Personally I'm not a fan of graphic pictures of aborted babies either.
I think it goes against the dignity of the child.

Posted

life begins at the moment of conception

Based on universally accepted scientific criteria, a new cell, the human zygote, comes into existence at the moment of sperm-egg fusion, an event that occurs in less than a second. Upon formation, the zygote immediately initiates a complex sequence of events that establish the molecular conditions required for continued embryonic development. The behavior of the zygote is radically unlike that of either sperm or egg separately and is characteristic of a human organism. Thus, the scientific evidence supports the conclusion that a zygote is a human organism and that the life of a new human being commences at a scientifically well defined "moment of conception."

TotusTuusMaria
Posted

i like it.

I saw one the other day that read, "It's a womb. Not a tomb."

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1791264' date='Feb 25 2009, 10:37 AM']Personally I'm not a fan of graphic pictures of aborted babies either.
I think it goes against the dignity of the child.[/quote]

Do movies that show the state of Jews in WWII like Schindler's List and Band of Brothers go against the dignity of those people? Rather, the dignity of these innocents have already been violated in the most horrific way possible, people need to see what they are voting in favor for. If I was brutally murdered and in the arms of Jesus I would want my mom and the homicidal pro-choice crowd to know what they did to me so they may find salvation.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1791264' date='Feb 25 2009, 10:37 AM']Personally I'm not a fan of graphic pictures of aborted babies either.
I think it goes against the dignity of the child.[/quote]

I had a coworker change her pro-choice position ever since she saw a few photos of first trimester aborted babies on my cell phone. Many do not realize what they are truely supporting until they see it with their own eyes.

Posted

From Father Pavone's blog.

[quote][size=3][b]Invite Others to View Images[/b][/size]
February 10th, 2009
Today I want to share with you the following email I received from a pro-abortion person who visited the our website at priestsforlife.org and saw the pictures of aborted babies. She wrote,

“I have been a pro abortion catholic… After seeing the pictures of what it exactly was, I nearly cried thinking I supported this awful murder. I ask Jesus my Christ to forgive my past way of thinking. I finally “get it.” This is pure murder. I pray that more people will get to know what it is they are supporting.”

The person then signed the letter with the pen name, “My Shame.” These pictures, at priestsforlife.org, have this effect on people every day. Invite others to view these images. You may email and print them. Nothing is more effective to end abortion.

–Fr. Frank[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1791276' date='Feb 25 2009, 10:03 AM']Do movies that show the state of Jews in WWII like Schindler's List and Band of Brothers go against the dignity of those people? Rather, the dignity of these innocents have already been violated in the most horrific way possible, people need to see what they are voting in favor for. If I was brutally murdered and in the arms of Jesus I would want my mom and the homicidal pro-choice crowd to know what they did to me so they may find salvation.[/quote]

I agree!

There have been far to many occurrences where women have aborted their babies and then seen their tiny little bodies and know that they have killed a person. Sometimes we must be comforted with the harsh reality and not try to soften the issue. Saying that an unborn child is a person just isn't getting the point across any more. People have become far too desensitized. Sometimes you have to just show them what they are destroying not just tell them.

virginiancatholic
Posted (edited)

Some people need to see those pictures, it's true, and for some the reality dawns on them then. Others definitely don't need to see them...personally, I hate all those pictures because I find them extremely hurtful and they cause me extreme mental anguish when I see them. Because I'm such a visually attuned person, violence and grotesque images (and movies) touch me very deeply and I will remember them for the rest of my life, so I avoid seeing such things. Everyone is different, so such pictures will not have the same effect on one person as they did on you or your friend. Another factor is that because everyone is desensitized, for many seeing more violence isn't going to affect them anyway. One of my pet peeves, though, is people showing the pictures around out in public where kids will see them. No child should have to look at aborted fetuses...ever. Period.

Many folks are just pro-choice cause they are going with the flow and don't even think about the issue, and because American society today is so adamantly godless and intentionally irrational that they are encouraged not to think things through. Because I'm involved in a heavily scientific field (medicine) most folks here don't deny that the fetus is alive...they know it is, and we know it is a separate entity. It's all legal for them...and impossible to understand why they still support it. Many will say "well, the fetus can't feel, they legally aren't a person, it isn't highly developed yet" and they know they are lying through their teeth. Prayer is what is needed.

I actually have more respect for that person who says it is perfectly logical to kill a baby after it is born. Birth is just a change in geography (inside womb vs. outside womb) and geography is not a moral influence on rights. At least they are recognizing: yes, this is cold blooded murder and it shouldn't make a difference whether or not they are born. Peter Singer of Princeton holds this view.

Honestly, this "life begins at birth" is just about as arbitrary as "the age of reason begins at 7" or "adulthood begins at 18 or 21."

Edited by virginiancatholic
cmotherofpirl
Posted

O ! O ! Can we all send this one to our politicians???????????????

What size do you think Nancy and Joe wear???

[url="http://www.cafepress.com/CatholicSwag.33640604"]http://www.cafepress.com/CatholicSwag.33640604[/url]

Posted

[quote name='virginiancatholic' post='1791485' date='Feb 25 2009, 05:42 PM']Honestly, this "life begins at birth" is just about as arbitrary as "the age of reason begins at 7" or "adulthood begins at 18 or 21."[/quote]


using that logic then it would be fair to say that life begins after (all) the kids leave home for college. the Mrs. might disagree with me, on that thought, empty nest syndrome, and all.
then there is grandchildren :bigthink: The good lord has not blessed me with grandchildren yet (that i know of) but, I'm looking forward to the day, with great expectations.

i have been very blessed with a wonderful wife and companion and three children, all are healthy and strong, so in a very big way my children's lives began long before conception. i would dare say my daughter and two sons lives began on our wedding day,

defiantly, life predates conception, at least in my personal case. i believe my offspring are God's plan

God is Great

TotusTuusMaria
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1791264' date='Feb 25 2009, 11:37 AM']Personally I'm not a fan of graphic pictures of aborted babies either.
I think it goes against the dignity of the child.[/quote]

How does it go against the dignity of the child? It is reality. That is what an aborted child looks like. That is what sin looks like. That is what murder looks like.

We look at the crucifix. We even wear it around our necks. It is just as bloody as the aborted baby. It is just as terrible... it is just as heartbreaking. Does it offend the dignity of God? That is the reality of the crucifixtion.

Edited by TotusTuusMaria
TotusTuusMaria
Posted

[quote name='Paladin D' post='1791465' date='Feb 25 2009, 05:42 PM']I had a coworker change her pro-choice position ever since she saw a few photos of first trimester aborted babies on my cell phone. Many do not realize what they are truely supporting until they see it with their own eyes.[/quote]

Agreed. I am very involved with a sidewalk counseling ministry and the one thing we do different the other ministry doing the same thing in our city (God bless them for what they are doing) is that we use these little cards of an aborted baby in our packets. We have had seven saves. All of them have seen the picture and commented that it helped them to realize what they were doing.

Posted

I don't think pro-life will ever win. The problem is it's infected with religion. People see the issue as Christian v secular, and most people consider themselves more secular than religious, and naturally, as with most things most people take one side or the other (regardless of whether or not they understand the issue).

I'm not totally against abortion, if a little girl is raped by her uncle she has right to terminate the pregnancy before that life inside her is at a stage its rights supercede the young girls. I'm not a moralist so I don't know what age that should be, but I think sometime before the 12th week and before the foetus can experience consciousness. I know you don't agree with me but please spare me your logic and reason, I've heard it all before.

I think abortions are pretty sad actually, but I think pro-lifers are doing so much damage, turning it into a spiritual war when clearly the majority rules and has determined that women have a right to make choices which impact on their lives emotionally, mentally, physically and financially. Why does the American public feel this way? Regardless, whatever the pro-life movement is doing to change the hearts and minds of the American public, it is failing miserably. No one wants to accept responsibility for this terrible PR disaster, and pro-lifers continue to employ the same old tactics such as name calling (i.e. "baby killers", "murderers") trying to bully the enemy into submission without actually realising how worthless and counter-productive these methods are. Some people try to justify this by saying the truth needs to be told, but calling overweight Jane a "fatty" isn't likely to motivate her to start doing exercise.

Ironmonk makes an interesting point, debates make people cling harder to their beliefs. This is also true for Catholics and pro-lifers. No one really wants to the see the issue from the other sides perspective, because they naturally assume they see it correctly and the other sides sees it incorrectly, so there is no possibility to empathise with the opponent. Actually, empathising with the opponent may cause a sudden change of heart, but most people are not willing to empathise with the opponent when they see him as an enemy.

Posted

I want to clarify my comment, when I said that I think it goes against the dignity of the child.
Yes, it is reality, and yes, it will change some people's minds. (As an aside, I do think it has a legitimate place in the pro life side... but that's not my point.)
What I'm talking about are instances when it seems like the picture is being exploited for shock value. In that case it's not the life of the child that's being respected, rather the death of the child is being used. Yes, it's being used for a good purpose, but as we repeat fairly often, the ends do not justify the means.
The use of these pictures should be done very sensitively, in the same way that we honour any adult dead.

I'm not saying that these pictures shouldn't be allowed, I just think that the respect for the violated life should be very clear, not only to the people who create the display, but also to the people viewing it.

Posted

[quote name='bonkers' post='1791795' date='Feb 26 2009, 07:25 AM']I'm not totally against abortion, if a little girl is raped by her uncle she has right to terminate the pregnancy before that life inside her is at a stage its rights supercede the young girls. I'm not a moralist so I don't know what age that should be, but I think sometime before the 12th week and before the foetus can experience consciousness. I know you don't agree with me but please spare me your logic and reason, I've heard it all before.[/quote]
First, very thoughtful post.

I respect the above position. It's closer to the Ubermensch position, which is where I wish our opponents would go, instead of their weak-minded emotional arguments. It is where they will go, eventually. They will then begin directly killing those who oppose them. I don't know how long it will take, but it will eventually happen. I think it will take many years.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...