Saint Therese Posted February 26, 2009 Posted February 26, 2009 [url="http://www.calcatholic.com/news/newsArticle.aspx?id=a7da8f70-9979-4796-97a0-c4e10015f19b"]Bishop tells priest not to criticize O'bama.[/url]
CatherineM Posted February 26, 2009 Posted February 26, 2009 Whether I agree with what the priest said or not, I don't like it when priests make matters of obedience with their bishops public. We jump all over priests who make it public when their bishops tell them to straighten up when we agree with the bishop, but don't when we agree with the priest. A priest owes obedience to his ordinary, and dragging parishioners or the public into an issue just gives our enemies ammunition. If this priest didn't agree with what his bishop was asking him to do, he has ways of appealing that don't involve publicity.
Apotheoun Posted February 26, 2009 Posted February 26, 2009 From Fr. Perozich's essay: "Abominations will be forced on us by the new government, such as which our founders never had intended, and certainly opposed to the Christian life: abortion on demand, homogenital sex, lust in all its forms, euthanasia, oppression of opportunity and entrepreneurs, silencing of faith and free speech among many." It is truly sad that the silencing of faith and free speech is coming in this particular case from a Catholic bishop.
Saint Therese Posted February 27, 2009 Author Posted February 27, 2009 Imagine if this were cold war Poland and it was Bishop telling a priest not to speak out against the Regime. The analogy is valid. What made the Polish resistance so sucessful ( I mean the resistance of the Church) was the correct assessment of the political situation by the Church. THat is, they understood that theh political culture was hostile to the Church. They understood that the popular culture was seperate from the Christian culture. This is something that we in this country do not understand.
Madame Vengier Posted February 27, 2009 Posted February 27, 2009 I'm not an expert on this issue, so maybe someone who is can add to this (or correct me), but I'm not so sure that "obedience" of a priest to a Bishop (or a Religious to a superior, for another example) is an across-the-board, black-and-white thing. I mean, if a Bishop is trying to silence a priest from, say, preaching against homosexuality in a community that is highly supportive of a gay lifestyle, because the Bishop doesn't want to offend or alienate people, would that priest be REQUIRED to be obedient to something that is against that which is part of the very nature of the priesthood, which is to teach and preach the Gospel? I'm wondering what the boundaries exactly are with this. If criticizing Obama is done in the context of teaching basic Catholic moral and social values, then would this apply to the above-mentioned question?
Nihil Obstat Posted February 27, 2009 Posted February 27, 2009 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1792340' date='Feb 27 2009, 06:58 AM']I'm not an expert on this issue, so maybe someone who is can add to this (or correct me), but I'm not so sure that "obedience" of a priest to a Bishop (or a Religious to a superior, for another example) is an across-the-board, black-and-white thing. I mean, if a Bishop is trying to silence a priest from, say, preaching against homosexuality in a community that is highly supportive of a gay lifestyle, because the Bishop doesn't want to offend or alienate people, would that priest be REQUIRED to be obedient to something that is against that which is part of the very nature of the priesthood, which is to teach and preach the Gospel? I'm wondering what the boundaries exactly are with this. If criticizing Obama is done in the context of teaching basic Catholic moral and social values, then would this apply to the above-mentioned question?[/quote] It's probably a matter of degrees. If a bishop were telling a priest not to preach against homosexuality, maybe it would be best to, after talking with him, go to Rome. In this though... well I don't want to judge. For all we know there could be a valid reason for this; it's quite hard to say. The priest and the bishop both know better than we do what the right thing is in this case, and we just have to trust that it will be done, in the end.
CatherineM Posted February 27, 2009 Posted February 27, 2009 Canon 273: "Clerics have a special obligation to show reverence and obedience to the Supreme Pontiff and to their own Ordinary." Priests give up a lot of personal freedom. They can't run for public office. They can't associate with local political parties or trade unions without permission. They can't join the military or leave the diocese or any length of time without permission. They can't even serve as executors on their parent's estate without permission. They can't engage in commerce or sign a promissory note without permission. Those are all from Canon Law. They are also supposed to avoid any worldliness. Purposely getting their name in the paper smacks of worldliness to me. In the military, officers are specifically not allowed to print anything publicly without permission of their commanding officers. There is a reason for that. Public dissension gives aid and comfort to the enemy. You give up personal freedoms when you put on the uniform. Again, if this priest had spoken out publicly for a pro-choice candidate, everyone here would have come down on him. When a priest speaks out publicly for something we agree with, then people want to support him. We can't have it both ways. A priest owes his ordinary obedience, and public disputes with your bishop, over whatever topic, even the color of the next M&M, does the church as a whole no good.
Winchester Posted February 27, 2009 Posted February 27, 2009 So "tone down" is a synonym for shut up? A priest owes obedience to his ordinary when the ordinary is being just in his rulings. I don't know the actual content of the order, but this priest may well be in his rights to disobey--one's authority comes from God. Those things outside of God (injustice) are thus outside of one's authority. This is true of [i]all [/i] authority. None of us has a right to give any orders by virtue of who we are. Our authority as parents, for example, comes through God's design of the human family.
Lil Red Posted February 27, 2009 Posted February 27, 2009 [quote name='Saint Therese' post='1792240' date='Feb 26 2009, 09:53 PM']Imagine if this were cold war Poland and it was Bishop telling a priest not to speak out against the Regime. The analogy is valid. What made the Polish resistance so sucessful ( I mean the resistance of the Church) was the correct assessment of the political situation by the Church. THat is, they understood that theh political culture was hostile to the Church. They understood that the popular culture was seperate from the Christian culture. This is something that we in this country do not understand.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ Can we PLEASE, FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY, get through one discussion without bringing Nazism/WWII comparisons into the discussion?
Aloysius Posted February 27, 2009 Posted February 27, 2009 the analogy was to communism, and it is a valid analogy IMHO. communism in Poland was overthrown by the efforts of the Church; as must be the socialism of the current administration. the Church must have a strong backbone against the Obama administration. a comparison to naziism would also be valid in that Abortion is infinitely worse than the holocaust was.
lost_in_this_world Posted February 27, 2009 Posted February 27, 2009 i dont necessarily think priests should be criticizing the president in a public manner. i think it is already implied what the priests think and i dont think they should be criticizing but instead fighting for what they want out of this new administration.
Winchester Posted February 27, 2009 Posted February 27, 2009 If you are not specific, many people will not understand.
Saint Therese Posted February 28, 2009 Author Posted February 28, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Lil Red' post='1792532' date='Feb 27 2009, 02:05 PM']+J.M.J.+ Can we PLEASE, FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY, get through one discussion without bringing Nazism/WWII comparisons into the discussion? [/quote] I'm sorry. Perhaps if you expressed more specific guidelines about I what can say or not say. I'm sure someone here will soon anyways. Edited February 28, 2009 by Saint Therese
Hassan Posted February 28, 2009 Posted February 28, 2009 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1792532' date='Feb 27 2009, 03:05 PM']+J.M.J.+ Can we PLEASE, FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY, get through one discussion without bringing Nazism/WWII comparisons into the discussion? [/quote] Shutting down free speech Just like Stalin/Hitler
Winchester Posted February 28, 2009 Posted February 28, 2009 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1792532' date='Feb 27 2009, 02:05 PM']+J.M.J.+ Can we PLEASE, FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY, get through one discussion without bringing Nazism/WWII comparisons into the discussion? [/quote] [img]http://dissonanced.files.wordpress.com/2008/04/the_soup_nazi017.jpg[/img]
Lil Red Posted February 28, 2009 Posted February 28, 2009 [quote name='Saint Therese' post='1792776' date='Feb 27 2009, 06:15 PM']I'm sorry. Perhaps if you expressed more specific guidelines about I what can say or not say. I'm sure someone here will soon anyways.[/quote] +J.M.J.+ nice way of getting around my point.
Saint Therese Posted February 28, 2009 Author Posted February 28, 2009 Thank you. It does take skill you know.
Fidei Defensor Posted February 28, 2009 Posted February 28, 2009 [quote name='Lil Red' post='1792532' date='Feb 27 2009, 01:05 PM']+J.M.J.+ Can we PLEASE, FOR THE LOVE OF ALL THAT IS HOLY, get through one discussion without bringing Nazism/WWII comparisons into the discussion? [/quote] lol.
T-Bone _ Posted February 28, 2009 Posted February 28, 2009 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1792884' date='Feb 27 2009, 07:21 PM']lol.[/quote] Godwin's Law is no laughing manner. Except for the case of furry Nazis. Those are pretty funny. [img]http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/furry/images/5/50/GermanWolf.jpg[/img]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now