Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Mahoney Says Williamson Not A Catholic? -updated


Recommended Posts

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Cardinal Mahony bans Holocaust-denier from L.A. archdiocese

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Cardinal Roger Mahony on Tuesday took the unusual step of banning Holocaust-denying British Bishop Richard Williamson from any Roman Catholic church, school or other facility in the Archdiocese of Los Angeles.
"Holocaust deniers like Williamson will find no sympathetic ear or place of refuge in the Catholic Church, of which he is not — and may never become — a member," said a commentary signed jointly by Mahony, head of the nation's largest archdiocese, and two officials of the American Jewish Committee.


FAITH & REASON: Did pope's staff fail to warn him of anti-Semitic bishops?
"The cardinal wishes to send a clear signal to the Jewish community that Williamson is not a member or even welcome in the Catholic Church until he renounces his views," said Tod Tamberg, spokesman for the archdiocese.

"The cardinal also wanted to signal that he is in full agreement with the Vatican that Williamson must apologize for and distance himself from his views," he added.

Mahony's measure is the latest repudiation of Williamson since January, when the Vatican announced that his excommunication was being lifted. That same day, Swedish television aired a previously taped interview in which Williamson denied that gas chambers existed and said that 200,000 to 300,000 Jews, not 6 million, perished in Nazi concentration camps.

The ensuing outrage caused Pope Benedict XVI to suspend lifting the excommunication, saying Williamson could only be reconciled with the church if he publicly retracts and apologizes for his Holocaust denial.

The government of Argentina, where Williamson had headed a seminary since 2003, ordered him expelled and prosecutors in Germany, where the interview was taped and where Holocaust denial is a crime, launched a criminal investigation.

Williamson, who is one of four excommunicated members of an ultra-traditionalist Catholic group, the Society of St. Pius X, apologized for offending people, but did not indicate that he had changed his views.

Mahony's ban was contained in a commentary published in the online edition of The Tidings, the archdiocese's newspaper. The cardinal stated that the ban would remain "until he and his group comply fully and unequivocally with the Vatican's directives regarding the Holocaust."

The commentary was also signed by Rabbi Gary Greenebaum, U.S. director of interreligious affairs of the American Jewish Committee, and Seth Brysk, the committee's Los Angeles executive director.

There is no indication that Williamson, who is currently living in Britain, is planning to visit Los Angeles, but the commentary noted that "many religious and civic leaders have used his situation to acknowledge the Holocaust and to affirm its unique and terrible place in history."

The ban resulted from Mahony's meeting two weeks ago with Greenebaum and Brysk.

Greenebaum said he requested the meeting to discuss the Vatican's flip-flopping position on Williamson.

The cardinal took him aback by suggesting the ban, Greenebaum said.

"It took me by surprise a little bit," he said. "It's a very strong, very welcome statement."

Religion experts said Mahony's ban is largely symbolic, but believed to be unprecedented.

"I don't know how it would be enforced," said Philip A. Cunningham, director of the Jewish-Catholic Institute at St. Joseph's University in Philadelphia. "But having positive relations with the Jewish community is important to the cardinal."

Mahony said he plans to visit the Yad Vashem Memorial in Jerusalem this year.

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

May never become a member? Isn't he already a member via his baptism?

I would like to take this charitably, but really, saying that he might NEVER become a member? How dare the Cardinal. He has no such authority.

The article seems wrong as well. The excommunications WERE lifted. Their lifting was not suspended, were they?

Edited by CatholicCid
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1797475' date='Mar 4 2009, 06:09 PM']"Holocaust deniers like Williamson will find no sympathetic ear or place of refuge in the Catholic Church, of which he is not — and may never become — a member,"[/quote]

Strong language from a Cardinal known for his liberalism and dissent.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Williamson is a baptised catholic. Even if you are excommunicated you are still catholic, so I don't see how C. Mahoney can say this?

KnightofChrist
Posted

This while Mahoney is under federal investigation? [url="http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-mahony29-2009jan29,0,6232753.story"]http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-ma...0,6232753.story[/url]

almost funny...

filiusInFilio
Posted

maybe if Bp. Williamson gives Mahoney a hug everything will be better

Posted

A few things here - lifting the excommunications was a [i]step[/i] in reconciling with the Church. Williamson is [i]not[/i] currently a member of the Catholic Church. Yes, he was baptized. I'm not denying that. But can he currently represent himself as a Roman Catholic bishop? No. So, the cardinal is trying to put this in terms that people can understand.

Because most of the rest of everyone is thoroughly confused when they hear this story, don't know what the bishops did to get excommunicated in the first place, and just assume that the bishop is a Catholic like everyone else - it is good for the Cardinal to clarify.

There are some mistakes in the article, but the quotations from the cardinal were correct.

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1797506' date='Mar 4 2009, 07:06 PM']A few things here - lifting the excommunications was a [i]step[/i] in reconciling with the Church. Williamson is [i]not[/i] currently a member of the Catholic Church. Yes, he was baptized. I'm not denying that. But can he currently represent himself as a Roman Catholic bishop? No. So, the cardinal is trying to put this in terms that people can understand.

Because most of the rest of everyone is thoroughly confused when they hear this story, don't know what the bishops did to get excommunicated in the first place, and just assume that the bishop is a Catholic like everyone else - it is good for the Cardinal to clarify.

There are some mistakes in the article, but the quotations from the cardinal were correct.[/quote]

What evidence is there that Williamson is [i]not[/i] currently a member of the Catholic Church? His excommunication put him outside the Church, the lifting of the excommunication would not resolve that, and place him back in the Church?

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

Bishop Williamson is not only a member of the Catholic Church, he is an ordained Catholic Bishop. His is suspended juridically from exercising the office of bishop, but his status is that of a bishop. His brother bishop, Mahoney, a man I must admit reluctantly is a Cardinal Prince of the Church, has disgraced his office by this outlandish slander against a fellow bishop who is fully united to the Roman Catholic Church. He is fully admitted to the sacraments of confession and the eucharist since his excommunication was lifted; he currently illicitly celebrates mass (though he does not ordain for the society anymore, I believe he does nothing else for the society right now as +Fellay has tried to get him out of the public spotlight)... but honestly, Mahoney himself celebrates illicit masses all the time with the amount of abuses he allows.

[quote]The ensuing outrage caused Pope Benedict XVI to suspend lifting the excommunication, saying Williamson could only be reconciled with the church if he publicly retracts and apologizes for his Holocaust denial.[/quote]
NO such thing was done. This is outrageous. Bishop Williamson is being treated with the most unChristian, unjust, and uncharitable persecutions by people who claim to be Catholics as a result of a mistaken historical opinion which he admits was the opinion of someone who was not an historian but of someone who simply believed evidence presented to him in the '80s and never did more academic research on the subject. the man's guilty of nothing but imprudence; the people slandering him are guilty of FAR WORSE than he is. Do you remember when Our Lord said in the gospels "whoever says to his brother, "you fool", will be liable to the fires of Gehenna"?? guess where it is the criticizers of this bishop are in danger of going? +Williamson's Excommunication was lifted, he was asked to recant his views before possibly having his suspension lifted.

this is unbelievable and outrageous, and many people will have to answer to Our Lord on judgement day for the ordeal they put this bishop of His through.

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='filiusInFilio' post='1797503' date='Mar 4 2009, 06:55 PM']maybe if Bp. Williamson gives Mahoney a hug everything will be better[/quote]
There're a couple of things [i]I'd[/i] like to give Roger Cardinal Baloney - i.e., a piece of my mind, a knuckle sandwich, etc., however, a hug is not amongst those.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1797532' date='Mar 4 2009, 07:51 PM']Bishop Williamson is not only a member of the Catholic Church, he is an ordained Catholic Bishop. His is suspended juridically from exercising the office of bishop, but his status is that of a bishop. His brother bishop, Mahoney, a man I reluctantly must admit is a Cardinal Prince of the Church, has disgraced his office by this outlandish slander against a fellow bishop who is fully united to the Roman Catholic Church. He is fully admitted to the sacraments of confession and the eucharist since his excommunication was lifted; he currently illicitly celebrates mass (though he does not ordain for the society anymore, I believe he does nothing else for the society right now as +Fellay has tried to get him out of the public spotlight)... but honestly, Mahoney himself celebrates illicit masses all the time with the amount of abuses he allows.[/quote]
Thats what I thought, hs is still a catholic!

Posted

Wow, these questions are definitely above my pay grade. Is he a Catholic, is he a bishop, is he a Catholic bishop, can a Cardinal say someone isn't a Catholic? I have no idea. I'm pretty sure he's still a Catholic. Whether he is in good standing or not is another question.

Posted

The cardinal is not my favorite but I have a hard time believing he would say "he may never become a member." Could it be the intrepid staff of the AP messing things up again?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I wonder if any of this article was poorly interpreted and reported on by the American media that has proven time again that they sure know everything about the Catholic Church?

Posted

As you are well aware, this news item was originally reported as 'Excommunication lifted on Catholic bishop and Holocaust denier'

The Cardinal was trying to clarify.

The majority of American Catholics have never heard of the SSPX (seriously - they haven't). They [i]really[/i] don't know what this is all about. Whether or not you like the cardinal, he has every right to point out that Williamson is a fringe element, not your average Catholic bishop. He's doing damage control (or attempting to, anyway).

He could be more charitable about it, but this is [i]not[/i] about some historical detail, like the number of casualties at the battle of Agincourt. This is about the relationship between Christians and Jews. The SSPX can say that none of their members are anti-Semites, but the proof is in the pudding. If it smells like a rat....chances are there's a rat, rapid cleaning up of the website aside. And yes, I realize people will level that charge without knowing anything. But saying 'it didn't happen' is kinda like the people who say 9-11 was an inside job, planned by Bush to create an excuse to go to war. In other words...there is an underlying motivation to making such an outrageous claim. I wonder what that might be?

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1797749' date='Mar 4 2009, 11:27 PM']As you are well aware, this news item was originally reported as 'Excommunication lifted on Catholic bishop and Holocaust denier'

The Cardinal was trying to clarify.

The majority of American Catholics have never heard of the SSPX (seriously - they haven't). They [i]really[/i] don't know what this is all about. Whether or not you like the cardinal, he has every right to point out that Williamson is a fringe element, not your average Catholic bishop. He's doing damage control (or attempting to, anyway).

He could be more charitable about it, but this is [i]not[/i] about some historical detail, like the number of casualties at the battle of Agincourt. This is about the relationship between Christians and Jews. The SSPX can say that none of their members are anti-Semites, but the proof is in the pudding. If it smells like a rat....chances are there's a rat, rapid cleaning up of the website aside. And yes, I realize people will level that charge without knowing anything. But saying 'it didn't happen' is kinda like the people who say 9-11 was an inside job, planned by Bush to create an excuse to go to war. In other words...there is an underlying motivation to making such an outrageous claim. I wonder what that might be?[/quote]

Something I've noticed, tell me I'm crazy, you love to demonize the SSPX. Williamson is Catholic, you where incorrect, if the Cardinal is really telling people Williamson is not Catholic, well thats just not true.

Edited by KnightofChrist
CatholicCid
Posted

My main concern is with just the following bolded part:

"Holocaust deniers like Williamson will find no sympathetic ear or place of refuge in the Catholic Church, of which he is not —[b] and may never become[/b] — a member,"

As the Church is the fullness of faith, we must work in bringing about the salvation of souls. We cannot make such statements. If this is a correct statement, ignoring the rest of the article, it is very hard to take in a charitable light toward the Cardinal.

Posted

+J.M.J.+
i'm not accusing anyone of this, but i'd like to remind everyone of one of the guidelines:
[quote]Catholic vs Catholic Debate
A post or comment that results in doctrinal debates that might cause scandal among the faithful. *Effective immediately, any negative criticism of religious or the current Magisterium will result in deletion, and a warning from the moderators. This includes but is not limited to criticism of the Novus Ordo mass and/or our Holy Father.[/quote]

that includes 'liberal' bishops/cardinals, no matter how distasteful we may find them.

Posted

that would be a correct statement about any non-Catholic (+Williamson is not a non-Catholic); I think you're reading that wrong, he is saying "may not ever become" as in "might not ever become" not "cannot ever become"... "may not" can mean either, and the "might not" interpretation seems to fit here.

there is NEVER ANY EXCUSE for uncharity and slander, even if you're trying to do damage control. this is an absolutely sinful act, to call someone who is a Catholic in communion with the Church (and a Bishop, though not allowed to excercise that office) a non-Catholic. that's is uncharity; he is saying to his brother bishop in anger and out of fear of public relations "Racca" "you fool!"; and therefore, he is liable to the fires of gehenna.

his underlying influence is not anti-semitism; it's anti-Zionism mostly, and that's a GOOD motivation for anything, because Zionism is a bad bad bad thing for the world. he's wrong about the holocaust, but he's right to say that the victims of the holocaust do not amount to a replacement-Messiah for the Jewish people (who still must accept Jesus Christ as their Messiah to fulfill the covenant promised to their ancestors), and they do not amount to an excuse to take land from the Palestinean people. that's the type of motivation he has, which is not anti-semitism. he is reactionary against the concept that the Jews have a parallel seperate covenant and are not bound by the new covenant of Jesus Christ, their true Messiah whose sacrifice is the one and only sacrifice which takes away the sins of the world.

one thing that struck me about this article is how the holocaust is labelled "unique" in history. that's an insult to the Armenians, to the Rwandans, to the dissidents in the Soviet Union, to the dissidents in Communist Russia; actually, it's even disprespectful to Christ himself. THIS is why, in Williamson's heartfelt and honest apology, he echoed the sentiment of Pope Benedict XVI:

"As the Holy Father has said, every act of injust violence against one man hurts all mankind." -+Williamson

the holocaust is not better or worse than the other atrocities of history; it is not better or worse than those atrocities which have had less people killed (Armenians, Rwandans) or those which have had more people killed (Soviets, Chinese). the holocaust is ANOTHER terrible evil, not the end-all-be-all of terrible evils. what +Williamson said in his last statement is "yes, I came to believe this, I am not an historian so I could be wrong, but whether it was 300,000, 6 million, or 6 trillion, it was a terrible evil"

here's his last statement: [url="http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2009/02/declaration-holy-father-and-my-superior.html"]http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2009/02/d...y-superior.html[/url]

anyway, Cardinal Mahoney is incorrect and being slanderous by accusing the bishop of being a non-Catholic. you cannot sacrifice truth to try to calm public outrage, you are always and everywhere required to do service to the truth because your God is Truth itself; every untrue statement (especially one which incorrectly calls someone outside of the body of Christ who is within it) harms Christ himself.

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1797891' date='Mar 5 2009, 01:46 AM']+J.M.J.+
i'm not accusing anyone of this, but i'd like to remind everyone of one of the guidelines:


that includes 'liberal' bishops/cardinals, no matter how distasteful we may find them.[/quote]
what happens when one bishop criticizes another? can we defend the bishop if he's being unjustly criticized?

I'm trying to hold back, and Cardinal Mahoney is truly a Cardinal Prince of the Church and I respect his office, but he may not say that a bishop whose excommunication has been lifted by the Pope himself is not a Catholic.

I think that when Cardinals attack other Cardinals or other Bishops unjustly, we may come to the defense of the bishop being unjustly criticized; whether it be Cardinal Kaspar's criticism of Cardinal Hoyos or Cardinal Mahoney's criticism of Bishop Williamson.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...