homeschoolmom Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 In an ideal world: 1. Mexico, Central America and other places would have governments that cared for their people so that they would not feel the need to flee to the US in droves (legally or otherwise). 2. The US would have better knowledge of who comes here and why. 3. Immigration laws would be more just. More people would be allowed to come here legally. Only those who come here with bad motives would be coming illegally. 4. There would be private charities with volunteers willing to offer English language classes, job training and teach skills of every day living (how to use a laundromat, for example). But that's in an ideal world...
goldbug16 Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 I don't approve of illegal immigration. My uncle works as a border patrol agent in the California/Mexico border, and 98% of the people that come across are gang members and drug dealers. He get's beaten up by these guys just about every week. And because of the "no gun firing" rules, he can't even protect himself.
Hassan Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1804646' date='Mar 12 2009, 06:19 AM']We DON'T need their labor. I'm sick of this leftist, PC rhetoric that is standard fare for liberals and socialists. We are in a recession with millions of Americans out of work and you're telling me we NEED foreigners to come here and do our jobs for us? Nonsense! American companies and business owners need to pay fare wages for Americans to do these jobs and stop leaning on cheap Mexican labor. If Obama and his team really wanted to make jobs for Americans, he would stop the millions of jobs that are outsourced to foreign labor and give those jobs back to Americans who were doing them in the first place. This is an issue of basic justice. But you, with your 20 years of life and 2 years of college, thinking you know EVERYTHING, would make a swipe about "Christian charity" while supporting Americans being robbed of jobs.[/quote] I'm sorry, is that too me? I mean you've quoted me but obviously that's not enough to tell. btw, apparently the Michael Jackson thread got moved. Yes, Madam V, I know about the phrase "denial ain't just a river" I was indeed "joking". Edited March 12, 2009 by Hassan
HisChildForever Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 I agree with what Madame V and Catherine said regarding "lower class" jobs - a lot of Americans who have been out of work for some time are desperate for at [i]least[/i] something temporary, like a part-time retail position or cleaning crew (for hotels). I believe that when summer comes around, it is going to be super hard for college students (undergrad [u]and[/u] grad) to find a summer job because overqualified individuals will be competing again them. And the high school students, forget about them. If lucky they would get [i]half[/i] a part-time position, like weekend help. [quote name='Hassan' post='1804805' date='Mar 12 2009, 01:12 PM']btw, apparently the Michael Jackson thread got moved. Yes, Madam V, I know about the phrase "denial ain't just a river" I was indeed "joking".[/quote] Oh, okay. So you had every right to throw a fit when I made a crack about an old thread, but yet you can go around tossing flashbacks whenever you please.
Hassan Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1804827' date='Mar 12 2009, 12:25 PM']Oh, okay. So you had every right to throw a fit when I made a crack about an old thread, but yet you can go around tossing flashbacks whenever you please. [/quote] I didn't mind you bringing up an old issue, as I said (what I did mind) I did not want that to turn into your forever cop put everytime I think you advocate something morally wrong. If you had a problem with my position I wanted to get it cleared up, as you apparently continually did not understand what I was trying to say (probably my fauly), so it did not become a regular thing of "excuse me? What about your claim x" everytime we argued. Apparently Madam V did not, how I do not know, understand that I was joking about being confused between "denial" and "The Nile". The thread where I made it clear that saying "really? Because I honestly don't know how to lay it on any thicker" was my way of saying "for the love of god, yes, I am joking" got deleted and I'm not sure she saw it. Now I have let her know, if she wants it will never be brought up again.
Hassan Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1804827' date='Mar 12 2009, 12:25 PM']I agree with what Madame V and Catherine said regarding "lower class" jobs - a lot of Americans who have been out of work for some time are desperate for at [i]least[/i] something temporary, like a part-time retail position or cleaning crew (for hotels). I believe that when summer comes around, it is going to be super hard for college students (undergrad [u]and[/u] grad) to find a summer job because overqualified individuals will be competing again them. And the high school students, forget about them. If lucky they would get [i]half[/i] a part-time position, like weekend help[/quote] I can understand that. Before the exonomy collapsed we did, for a long time, implicitly send the signal that we wanted their labor. Yes often this was because the money wanted cheep labor. Now, after they have come, settled down, and made a life some say they would uproot them and send them packing, no exceptions and no questions, and not feel the least bit of guilt, I find that disturbing. I understand this position, but there is no reason to divorce mercy from the discussion.
VoTeckam Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 [quote name='goldbug16' post='1804775' date='Mar 12 2009, 01:48 PM']I don't approve of illegal immigration. My uncle works as a border patrol agent in the California/Mexico border, and 98% of the people that come across are gang members and drug dealers. He get's beaten up by these guys just about every week. And because of the "no gun firing" rules, he can't even protect himself.[/quote] I must know the entire 2% that have come here to make a better life for themselves.
Hassan Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1804866' date='Mar 12 2009, 01:59 PM']I must know the entire 2% that have come here to make a better life for themselves.[/quote] yeah.... I'm sorry but that figure is absurd. If 98% of 12 million people were drung dealers or gang bangers we would have a serious problem, much bigger than the one we actually do have.
VoTeckam Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1804771' date='Mar 12 2009, 01:44 PM']In an ideal world: 1. Mexico, Central America and other places would have governments that cared for their people so that they would not feel the need to flee to the US in droves (legally or otherwise). 2. The US would have better knowledge of who comes here and why. 3. Immigration laws would be more just. More people would be allowed to come here legally. Only those who come here with bad motives would be coming illegally. 4. There would be private charities with volunteers willing to offer English language classes, job training and teach skills of every day living (how to use a laundromat, for example). But that's in an ideal world...[/quote] Yes! My parish is actually working towards all of these goals.
homeschoolmom Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1804827' date='Mar 12 2009, 01:25 PM']Oh, okay. So you had every right to throw a fit when I made a crack about an old thread, but yet you can go around tossing flashbacks whenever you please. [/quote] [quote name='Hassan' post='1804836' date='Mar 12 2009, 01:34 PM']I didn't mind you bringing up an old issue, as I said (what I did mind) I did not want that to turn into your forever cop put everytime I think you advocate something morally wrong. If you had a problem with my position I wanted to get it cleared up, as you apparently continually did not understand what I was trying to say (probably my fauly), so it did not become a regular thing of "excuse me? What about your claim x" everytime we argued. Apparently Madam V did not, how I do not know, understand that I was joking about being confused between "denial" and "The Nile". The thread where I made it clear that saying "really? Because I honestly don't know how to lay it on any thicker" was my way of saying "for the love of god, yes, I am joking" got deleted and I'm not sure she saw it. Now I have let her know, if she wants it will never be brought up again.[/quote] Taking off my mod hat here for a moment to address you two as a "regular" poster... Could you two please take your never-ending arguments to private messages? Please?
Hassan Posted March 12, 2009 Posted March 12, 2009 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1804903' date='Mar 12 2009, 01:48 PM']Could you two please take your never-ending arguments to private messages? Please?[/quote] I can't PM But yes, I think we can let it go
Madame Vengier Posted March 13, 2009 Posted March 13, 2009 [quote name='Hassan' post='1804840' date='Mar 12 2009, 12:37 PM']I understand this position, but there is no reason to divorce mercy from the discussion.[/quote] There is no reason to divorce mercy from laws either. Our laws are clear on residency in the U.S. And America has shown enormous mercy in the welcoming of those immigrants (as well as refugees) from all over the world who have come here legally. This is evident in the fact that, illegal immigrants aside, America is the single most ethnically, culturally, racially and religiously diverse nation on the planet Earth. And we manage to achieve this without killing each other. I would say that Americans show a great deal of mercy towards the downtrodden and the needy.
Madame Vengier Posted March 13, 2009 Posted March 13, 2009 [quote name='FiereMargriet' post='1804728' date='Mar 12 2009, 10:48 AM']I agree. I work with a good number of wonderful people who are immigrants, and there is a huge immigrant population around my town. No, I'm not well-versed on immigration laws, nor do I have a solution to offer. But the resurgent racism I've heard people espousing because of the influx of immigrants disgusts me. I know racism is a different thing from wanting to expel illegal immigrants, but as a Catholic I believe we should be merciful and understanding of our brothers and sisters who wanted to come to America as a result of less-than-ideal circumstances in their home countries.[/quote] Demanding that non-nationals follow our laws doesn't mean we love them any less. Love doesn't mean "do whatever you want".
Seven77 Posted March 13, 2009 Posted March 13, 2009 [quote name='Era Might' post='1804230' date='Mar 11 2009, 10:33 PM']The first Europeans who came to America generally didn't ask the Indians for permission. Yet people give them a pass. I believe people should follow the law. But I also believe that illegal immigration is a complex social problem, and should not be dealt with by merciless deportation. How should it be dealt with? That's a complex question, and I don't think there is an easy answer.[/quote] I heartily agree. Deportation is not a blanket solution. The way i look at the problem: no use crying over spilled milk. If illegal immigrants, in otherwise good standing, have been in this country for more than 5-10 years and wish to contribute to American society, why can't we come up with some ways for them to make some kind of amends so they can be permitted to become legal citizens? That's called Mercy. I hope we all understand what Jesus did for us on the Cross.
Maggyie Posted March 13, 2009 Posted March 13, 2009 This is such a complex issue and the simplistic solutions just. Won't. Work. Obviously we do not want people to be breaking the law. Breaking the law is wrong. But the vast majority of these people come to the U.S. and the only law they break is the one that is supposed to keep them from coming. These are decent human beings who want the same things we all want. I know if things were the other way around, and my dad was going to have to raise his family in dire poverty in the U.S. but fifty miles away was a wealthy country where he could get honest work, give us a chance at an education and a decent life we would be living in Mexico now, immigration laws be darned. And I say this even though in my heart of hearts I am pretty hostile to undocumented immigrants, especially undocumented Latinos. This was revealed to me when I watched a movie on all the undocumented immigrants from Ireland living in New York (there are more illegal Irish immigrants in NYC now than ever before I believe). And these white people really didn't provoke the visceral emotional reaction in me that the "south of the border" kind of illegal immigration does. It was quite an unexpected examination of conscience I am deeply ashamed of this of course and I hope Jesus Christ will heal this sin in me. Meanwhile I have really had to re-think my position which was much more anti-illegal alien. I am intellectually convinced that our bishops have taken EXACTLY the right stand on this issue; they always support the right of sovereign nation to control its borders but at the same time it's OBVIOUS our laws need to change. We are in a recession right now, true, but ten years ago we were in boom time and we had millions of undocumented workers then and a VERY low "official" unemployment rate. I agree that the current situation allows businesses to exploit undocumented workers. I am totally in favor of the feds coming down like a bag of bricks on all the companies knowingly breaking the law. ICE raids on workers? They rip families apart. And the workers themselves are not the problem. The companies that attract them by looking the other way and hiring them are. "Mass deportation" is a stance accepted only by the fringe. No public official from any party in any responsible position has ever seriously suggested such a thing. Talk about a humanitarian nightmare (and a practical impossibility BTW).
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now