Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pro-choicers Deny Doctors Right To Choose Life


Recommended Posts

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[url="http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/choicers+deny+doctors+right+choose+life/1385274/story.html"]http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/choicers...5274/story.html[/url]

Posted

How would you feel about a Jehova's Whitness doctor being allowed to refuse to give you an emergency blood transfusion because it violated his or her moral principals?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1807815' date='Mar 15 2009, 07:02 PM']How would you feel about a Jehova's Whitness doctor being allowed to refuse to give you an emergency blood transfusion because it violated his or her moral principals?[/quote]
JWs aren't MDs.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1807818' date='Mar 15 2009, 06:07 PM']JWs aren't MDs.[/quote]

ok, a doctor who, for whatever reason, believes blood transfusions are gravely immoral.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1807815' date='Mar 15 2009, 06:02 PM']How would you feel about a Jehova's Whitness doctor being allowed to refuse to give you an emergency blood transfusion because it violated his or her moral principals?[/quote]
Well that's an emergent matter, isn't it? Bad analogy. A better one:

How would we feel about a convenience store not carrying our brand of soft drink? Procured abortion is a matter of convenience, not life or death.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1807821' date='Mar 15 2009, 05:09 PM']Well that's an emergent matter, isn't it? Bad analogy. A better one:

How would we feel about a convenience store not carrying our brand of soft drink? Procured abortion is a matter of convenience, not life or death.[/quote]


Yeap.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1807821' date='Mar 15 2009, 06:09 PM']Well that's an emergent matter, isn't it? Bad analogy. A better one:[/quote]


I wasn't trying to craft an analogy. I wanted to get some idea of what she considered appropiate with regards to doctors dispensing medical treatment in accords with their personal moral beliefs. If she would force a doctor to give a blood transfusion to save a life then she does not consider a doctors personal morals sacrosanct with regards to molding their professional activities. From there we could do a dialectic until we arrive at a close understanding of what her position actually is and then see how it relates to this case.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1807824' date='Mar 15 2009, 06:14 PM']I wasn't trying to craft an analogy. I wanted to get some idea of what she considered appropiate with regards to doctors dispensing medical treatment in accords with their personal moral beliefs. If she would force a doctor to give a blood transfusion to save a life then she does not consider a doctors personal morals sacrosanct with regards to molding their professional activities. From there we could do a dialectic until we arrive at a close understanding of what her position actually is and then see how it relates to this case.[/quote]
I accept your surrender.

Posted

Unless she just told me. But people (myself included) rarely give an truely accurate picture that way.

Posted

Honestly, I'm a little confused by your tactics, so I'm going to act tough until I figure it out.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1807835' date='Mar 15 2009, 06:26 PM']Honestly, I'm a little confused by your tactics, so I'm going to act tough until I figure it out.[/quote]

His tactic is to drum up a ridiculous analogy that does not even [i]compare[/i] to the actual point of discussion in order to make the Catholic opinion look absurd. Refusing to administer a blood transfusion is not even [i]close[/i] to refusing to abort a child.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1807841' date='Mar 15 2009, 05:39 PM']His tactic is to drum up a ridiculous analogy that does not even [i]compare[/i] to the actual point of discussion in order to make the Catholic opinion look absurd. Refusing to administer a blood transfusion is not even [i]close[/i] to refusing to abort a child.[/quote]

With all due respect you and Madam V may wish to stop explaining my motives, beliefs, and tactics to other as neither of you are, let us say, very gifted at discerning them.


[i]
I wasn't trying to craft an analogy. I wanted to get some idea of what she considered appropiate with regards to doctors dispensing medical treatment in accords with their personal moral beliefs. If she would force a doctor to give a blood transfusion to save a life then she does not consider a doctors personal morals sacrosanct with regards to molding their professional activities. From there we could do a dialectic until we arrive at a close understanding of what her position actually is and then see how it relates to this case.[/i]

That is my tactic.

Nothing more and nothing less.

Now you say refusing to administer a blood transfusion is not even close to refusing to abort a baby. I guess with regards to a doctors personal moral beliefs I'd have to ask your methodology at determining that.

Edited by Hassan
Posted

He's got a point. The wording was provocative, but his claim is plausible.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1807824' date='Mar 15 2009, 07:14 PM']I wasn't trying to craft an analogy. I wanted to get some idea of what she considered appropiate with regards to doctors dispensing medical treatment in accords with their personal moral beliefs. If she would force a doctor to give a blood transfusion to save a life then she does not consider a doctors personal morals sacrosanct with regards to molding their professional activities. From there we could do a dialectic until we arrive at a close understanding of what her position actually is and then see how it relates to this case.[/quote]
Doctors already dispense medical treatment according to their personal belief. You don't leave your personal beliefs at the door unless you are a politician.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1807854' date='Mar 15 2009, 06:09 PM']Doctors already dispense medical treatment according to their personal belief. You don't leave your personal beliefs at the door unless you are a politician.[/quote]


Sure, but I would like to know what you consider an accecptable range of behavior in this regard. Would you support a doctor not giving an emergency blood transfusion because it was contrary to his moral beliefs?

I don't care so much about that question as figuring out what the range is for you.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1807857' date='Mar 15 2009, 08:15 PM']Sure, but I would like to know what you consider an accecptable range of behavior in this regard. Would you support a doctor not giving an emergency blood transfusion because it was contrary to his moral beliefs?

I don't care so much about that question as figuring out what the range is for you.[/quote]
Your question is an oxymoron.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1807846' date='Mar 15 2009, 07:02 PM']With all due respect you and Madam V may wish to stop explaining my motives, beliefs, and tactics to other as neither of you are, let us say, very gifted at discerning them.[/quote]

Madame V is not participating in this thread so there is no reason for you to even mention her. Furthermore, I based my statement off of my observations. For someone who has run into your "tactics" on numerous occasions I can certainly tell you that they are straightforward. No "discerning" necessary.

If you were only curious about "Where do you [Catholics] think we should 'draw the line' when it comes to doctors and their personal moral beliefs" then you would have simply asked that question. No analogy needed. Frankly I believe that question is irrelevant anyway. The discussion here is about ONE moral belief. Doctors should NOT be forced to perform abortions. The article sums it up nicely:

[quote]Doctors who believe that the fetus is also a patient in their care knows that advances in understanding brain development and neo-natal science have shown that the unborn respond to pain by 16 weeks and perhaps as early as 11 or 13 weeks of gestation. [b]Such doctors would obviously be reluctant to refer their tiny patients for a procedure that would cause them indescribable pain[/b] and would rightly reject any policy that requires them to shut their eyes to such realities and write a referral that facilitates abortion.[/quote]

There are [b]two[/b] people here - the mother and the child.

By the way, your reaction to Winchester was completely inappropriate. This is not the Lame Board, this is a serious discussion on an important issue.

goldenchild17
Posted

I think Hassan's asking a reasonable question. No, the scale of gravity does not compare whatsoever (murder vs. blood transfusion) but if either of them violates ones moral principles then I think its a viable question. In America, whether I agree with it or not, freedom to practice one's religion uninhibited is "supposed" to be one's right, whether that's refusing to perform an abortion or refusing to give a blood transfusion. Typically I tend to think the right to freedom of religion extends as far as it needs to, until it begins to affect another person. In most cases, probably, someone who wants to procure an abortion or a blood transfusion will be able to go to another doctor if one refuses to do so. I'm not so sure how this applies in a smaller locale where only one doctor is available and he refuses to give the service. But in general, if it doesn't affect someone else, a person should be permitted to refuse something that goes against their beliefs.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1807903' date='Mar 15 2009, 07:38 PM']Your question is an oxymoron.[/quote]


How exactly?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1807905' date='Mar 15 2009, 07:39 PM']Madame V is not participating in this thread so there is no reason for you to even mention her.[/quote]

You and her are "tight" and you both have an unfortunate habit of explaining to other my motivations, beliefs etc. I only say unfortunate because neither of you were at all good at it. If it were accurate I would not care but when you sound off about what you believe to be my point or motive and incorrectly explain it to someone else I have to go back and correct it. Or get stuck in another inane argument :unsure:

[quote]Furthermore, I based my statement off of my observations.[/quote]

I have no doubt it was, unfortunatly your ability to shift through the data you observe and from that draw a correct conclusion, in this regard, is not of the highest caliber.

[quote]For someone who has run into your "tactics" on numerous occasions I can certainly tell you that they are straightforward. No "discerning" necessary.[/quote]


I also feel they are straight foreward, in fact I very straight forewardly explained my tactic on the other page. There should be no reason to have this absurd argument other than your somewhat arrogant, and quite unfounded, assertion that I am a liar whose true motives and tactics are contrary to what I have claimed, but which you are able to correctly discern.

[quote]If you were only curious about "Where do you [Catholics] think we should 'draw the line' when it comes to doctors and their personal moral beliefs" then you would have simply asked that question. No analogy needed.[/quote]

[i]Unless she just told me. But people (myself included) rarely give an truely accurate picture that way. [/i]

secondly, once again, it was not an analogy.

[quote]Frankly I believe that question is irrelevant anyway. The discussion here is about ONE moral belief.[/quote]

Why do you feel able to dictate what the appropiate range of relevancy of a given topic is?


[quote]Doctors should NOT be forced to perform abortions. The article sums it up nicely:



There are [b]two[/b] people here - the mother and the child.[/quote]

So you believe.

[quote]By the way, your reaction to Winchester was completely inappropriate. This is not the Lame Board, this is a serious discussion on an important issue.[/quote]

And some people can discuss a serious topic while at the same time trying to throw in a bit of fun or light humor. Otherwise unfortunate thing like, I ono, tedious and inane arguments over some absurd side issue ight pop up. You are not a mod, Church Militant etc. There are individuals who are posting on this thread. If any of them feel like I am inappropiate I will imediatly stop.

Edited by Hassan

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...