InHisLove726 Posted March 22, 2009 Posted March 22, 2009 Does anyone feel as uncomfortable about Folk Masses as I do? I absolutely despise the songs that are song. One night, I had to go to one since I was unable to go in the morning and one of the choir members sang "Healing River." I felt like I was in a Protestant church! The choir members participate more in the Mass than the priest does, and I don't like that. Am I being factitious?? The offering of the Mass is always enjoyable, but I wish the Folk music and group would just be done away with.
tinytherese Posted March 23, 2009 Posted March 23, 2009 I know what you mean. A folksy song was sung at the Palm Sunday Mass at Notre Dame when my mom and I stopped by the campus. I also heard some folksy songs sung well not at a mass but a Rite of Election service for RCIA once at a cathedral. It didn't make sense. So many people were entering the catholic church and yet protestant-like songs were sung?
jeffpugh Posted March 25, 2009 Posted March 25, 2009 Is it right? Let's ask another question: which Church document upholds/encourages/prescribes "folk" masses?
cmotherofpirl Posted March 25, 2009 Posted March 25, 2009 [quote name='InHisLove726' post='1814214' date='Mar 22 2009, 08:57 PM']Does anyone feel as uncomfortable about Folk Masses as I do? I absolutely despise the songs that are song. One night, I had to go to one since I was unable to go in the morning and one of the choir members sang "Healing River." I felt like I was in a Protestant church! The choir members participate more in the Mass than the priest does, and I don't like that. Am I being factitious?? The offering of the Mass is always enjoyable, but I wish the Folk music and group would just be done away with. [/quote] I think its appropriate if you are out in the woods with two hundred scouts but no where else.
Aloysius Posted March 26, 2009 Posted March 26, 2009 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1816196' date='Mar 25 2009, 01:14 PM']I think its appropriate if you are out in the woods with two hundred scouts but no where else.[/quote] even then, I think it makes a more profound statement when the mass is present in such a location in as much of its majesty as possible... Karol Wvoytiwa (sp?) said a Tridentine Mass on an upside-down canoe with the oars tied together as a cross for the youth who went with him on hikes... granted, it was probably a low mass, but perhaps at least some of the kids present had been trained through Catholic schooling to sing in a schola and they might've had some majestic chanting and such... so yeah, I don't think it's appropriate even in that setting, myself.
cmotherofpirl Posted March 26, 2009 Posted March 26, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1816791' date='Mar 26 2009, 02:12 AM']even then, I think it makes a more profound statement when the mass is present in such a location in as much of its majesty as possible... Karol Wvoytiwa (sp?) said a Tridentine Mass on an upside-down canoe with the oars tied together as a cross for the youth who went with him on hikes... granted, it was probably a low mass, but perhaps at least some of the kids present had been trained through Catholic schooling to sing in a schola and they might've had some majestic chanting and such... so yeah, I don't think it's appropriate even in that setting, myself.[/quote] O I think its very appropriate to the setting of mountains and lakes in a cathedral of trees made by the Creator himself. 200 children singing Dona Nobis Pacem as a round is as good as a schola. I just dont' think its appropriate for anywhere else.
Aloysius Posted March 26, 2009 Posted March 26, 2009 well, that sounds fine; but that's not what I think of when I think "folk music"... just because it's a round doesn't mean it is folksy, in my opinion... Dona Nobis Pacem sung as a round dates back to the 16th century, composed by Bach. That would be probably be appropriate in any Church, maybe especially out in the woods, but come now, is that really what is meant by "folk mass"?
cmotherofpirl Posted March 26, 2009 Posted March 26, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1816943' date='Mar 26 2009, 01:09 PM']well, that sounds fine; but that's not what I think of when I think "folk music"... just because it's a round doesn't mean it is folksy, in my opinion... Dona Nobis Pacem sung as a round dates back to the 16th century, composed by Bach. That would be probably be appropriate in any Church, maybe especially out in the woods, but come now, is that really what is meant by "folk mass"?[/quote] Not sure. I was in the folk Mass at church ages ago and we did P & W, but the new priest put a stop to that. I wasn't comfortable doing it anyway, and and no problems stopping. Do many churches still do it?
Nihil Obstat Posted March 26, 2009 Posted March 26, 2009 What exactly defines a 'folk mass'? I'm trying to follow the thread, but I think I missed a definition.
InHisLove726 Posted March 26, 2009 Author Posted March 26, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1817160' date='Mar 26 2009, 02:53 PM']What exactly defines a 'folk mass'? I'm trying to follow the thread, but I think I missed a definition.[/quote] I said "folk Mass" but I really should have said "Catholic Mass with folk music."
Aloysius Posted March 27, 2009 Posted March 27, 2009 yeah, that's what I think it means: a mass with folk music. I personally don't have any examples I could think of off hand of what music would be used at such a mass.
Veridicus Posted March 27, 2009 Posted March 27, 2009 [quote name='tinytherese' post='1814230' date='Mar 22 2009, 07:23 PM']...It didn't make sense. So many people were entering the catholic church and yet protestant-like songs were sung? [/quote] Anymore it doesn't surprise me. Sometimes I'm afraid I'm gonna look up ecumenism in the dictionary and its gonna say "the diluting of belief and liturgical practice coupled with space age architecture and trendy music."
Lilllabettt Posted March 27, 2009 Posted March 27, 2009 If anyone does have some examples of it, I'd be really interested. I have heard "folk" in the context of "so and so plays in the folk group at church" ... but I am at a loss as to what it actually is. Is it specifically guitar music, or the more general category of "praise and worship"? I am thinking in terms of Venn Diagrams here ... or is it something else? Country? Fiddle? What?
fides quarens intellectum Posted March 27, 2009 Posted March 27, 2009 [quote name='Veridicus' post='1817353' date='Mar 26 2009, 06:27 PM']Sometimes I'm afraid I'm gonna look up ecumenism in the dictionary and its gonna say "the diluting of belief and liturgical practice coupled with space age architecture and trendy music."[/quote] [quote name='Lilllabettt' post='1817354' date='Mar 26 2009, 06:31 PM']If anyone does have some examples of it, I'd be really interested. I have heard "folk" in the context of "so and so plays in the folk group at church" ... but I am at a loss as to what it actually is. Is it specifically guitar music, or the more general category of "praise and worship"? I am thinking in terms of Venn Diagrams here ... or is it something else? Country? Fiddle? What?[/quote] did you seriously just mention Venn diagrams? i thought Masses with folk music were like some holdover from the 1970s - do they really still exist?
Nihil Obstat Posted March 27, 2009 Posted March 27, 2009 Lately I tune out most music at mass. (It's getting bad.) It's still mass with or without. (Always good.) *shrug*
goldbug16 Posted March 27, 2009 Posted March 27, 2009 [quote name='Lilllabettt' post='1817354' date='Mar 26 2009, 08:31 PM']If anyone does have some examples of it, I'd be really interested. I have heard "folk" in the context of "so and so plays in the folk group at church" ... but I am at a loss as to what it actually is. Is it specifically guitar music, or the more general category of "praise and worship"? I am thinking in terms of Venn Diagrams here ... or is it something else? Country? Fiddle? What?[/quote] It's basically music from the 70's-90's that is full of lame tunes, idiotic lyrics, and oftentimes heresy. Sorry for that. I guess I just can't understand the obsession with We Are Companions On Our Journey (I'm not sure that's exactly the title) compared to Crown Him With Many Crowns...
cmotherofpirl Posted March 27, 2009 Posted March 27, 2009 I heard one today done by a guest organist that qualifies as P & W : We Remember ? I thought the lyrics were terrible.
Noel's angel Posted March 27, 2009 Posted March 27, 2009 It's really weird hearing folky hymns with organ accompaniment. I heard a choir once in Ballymena doing it. Just wrong.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 27, 2009 Posted March 27, 2009 (edited) [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1817950' date='Mar 27 2009, 04:28 PM']I heard one today done by a guest organist that qualifies as P & W : We Remember ? I thought the lyrics were terrible.[/quote] "We remember how you loved us to your death and still we celebrate for you are with us here" Is it that one? (That's one of the most respectful ones my choir will do......... ) Edited March 27, 2009 by Nihil Obstat
cmotherofpirl Posted April 2, 2009 Posted April 2, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1817978' date='Mar 27 2009, 06:59 PM']"We remember how you loved us to your death and still we celebrate for you are with us here" Is it that one? (That's one of the most respectful ones my choir will do......... )[/quote] This is the part that bothers me : Now we recreate you love, We bring the bread and wine to share a meal; Sign of grace and mercy, the Presence of the Lord. We aren't recreating anything, we are receiving the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of our Lord Jesus Christ. The verse is way too ambigious and open to more than one interpretation, which is the problem of way too many current hymns. Hymns should teach as well as praise. I do like all the possible harmonies.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now