Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

well, like what? cheating? not really the same.

the whole marrying someone you know loves motorcycles(or whatever) and then pulling the "if you loved me, you would change this..." is pretty much idiotic. either you kill the person you fell in love with,make them miserable to be around you, or they smarten up and dump you.

its like moving next to a farm then complaining of the chickens noise.

txdinghysailor
Posted

[quote name='Lilllabettt' post='1820726' date='Mar 30 2009, 10:28 PM']Somewhere in the course of my formation in religious life, I was taught that taking extraordinary, unnecessary risks with one's life is a sin, regardless if one is married or not. It's breaking the fifth commandment. The gift of life is holy and its not okay to put it in a high risk situation just to have fun or try something new or crazy. The context was in reference to extreme sports and bungee jumping. I don't know certain kinds of skiing would fall into that ... I guess so.[/quote]

But what is an extraordinary risk? Honestly, more people die in car accidents every day than die from bungee jumping accidents every YEAR.

Posted

[quote name='txdinghysailor' post='1821388' date='Mar 31 2009, 07:22 PM']But what is an extraordinary risk? Honestly, more people die in car accidents every day than die from bungee jumping accidents every YEAR.[/quote]
An extraordinary risk is one that is something outside the bounds of ordinary risk. Driving a car is considered an ordinary risk, unless you have a condition that makes it risky for you to drive, such as poor eyesight or seizures. Bungee jumping is not an ordinary risk. People do it, yes, and it can be done safely, but it is still not so common as to be considered "ordinary."

Part of what makes a risk ordinary or extraordinary is the benefit to be gained from the risk. There are benefits from driving, such as being able to get to work or school, go to the grocery, etc. The benefits from bungee jumping are the adrenaline high you'd get from doing it. The benefits of driving typically are thought to outweigh the risks, thereby making the activity one which carries an acceptable level of risk. Bungee jumping, not so much.

Lilllabettt
Posted

[quote name='txdinghysailor' post='1821388' date='Mar 31 2009, 10:22 PM']But what is an extraordinary risk? Honestly, more people die in car accidents every day than die from bungee jumping accidents every YEAR.[/quote]


Okay ... the point is, probably most of the people who died driving were not doing it just because they got a "thrill" from it. They were probably going to work, taking kids to school, accessing health care or friends or family. Even the people who were just taking a pleasure drive were not intending to risk their lives by doing it. They were not thinking as they were driving along: "This is scary! I could get hurt doing this! Woohoo!"

People get thrills from extreme anything. The question is, where is that thrill coming from? Is it the thrill of cheating death? I think for some people, it is. The risk of getting hurt or killed is part of what makes it fun for them. And that is breaking the 5th commandment.

txdinghysailor
Posted

[quote name='Lilllabettt' post='1821447' date='Mar 31 2009, 11:04 PM']People get thrills from extreme anything. The question is, where is that thrill coming from? Is it the thrill of cheating death? I think for some people, it is. The risk of getting hurt or killed is part of what makes it fun for them. And that is breaking the 5th commandment.[/quote]

Oops... :unsure: Guess I've broken the 5th without realizing it... I'll prolly keep breaking it too. It's tons of fun...

Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1821381' date='Mar 31 2009, 08:17 PM']well, like what? cheating? not really the same.

the whole marrying someone you know loves motorcycles(or whatever) and then pulling the "if you loved me, you would change this..." is pretty much idiotic. either you kill the person you fell in love with,make them miserable to be around you, or they smarten up and dump you.

its like moving next to a farm then complaining of the chickens noise.[/quote]

My husband and I make concessions to each other out of love. Doing them or not doing them doesn't make either one of us miserable. One of my most favorite pastimes before marrying was target shooting. I could have imported my rifle when I came North, but my husband was afraid to have it in the house. He has a serious mental illness, and was afraid that if he had a psychotic episode, he might use it violently. He hasn't had a psychotic break in 17 years, so I wasn't really worried about it. I miss shooting very much, but my husband's peace of mind was more important in the scheme of things that really matter. He also asked me to grow my hair long. I don't really like long hair because I'm always in the swimming pool, but I have adjusted. And yes, he made just as many concessions to me.

Lilllabettt
Posted

[quote name='txdinghysailor' post='1821454' date='Mar 31 2009, 11:21 PM']Oops... :unsure: Guess I've broken the 5th without realizing it... I'll prolly keep breaking it too. It's tons of fun...[/quote]


Okaaayyyy

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1821460' date='Mar 31 2009, 08:24 PM']My husband and I make concessions to each other out of love. Doing them or not doing them doesn't make either one of us miserable. One of my most favorite pastimes before marrying was target shooting. I could have imported my rifle when I came North, but my husband was afraid to have it in the house. He has a serious mental illness, and was afraid that if he had a psychotic episode, he might use it violently. He hasn't had a psychotic break in 17 years, so I wasn't really worried about it. I miss shooting very much, but my husband's peace of mind was more important in the scheme of things that really matter. He also asked me to grow my hair long. I don't really like long hair because I'm always in the swimming pool, but I have adjusted. And yes, he made just as many concessions to me.[/quote]
My husband and I have made similar concessions (including the long hair one). Neither of us has asked the other to give up anything essential to our enjoyment of life; we just make accommodations so we are able to enjoy each other more fully and live more comfortably together.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1820491' date='Mar 30 2009, 03:32 PM']I don't want to cause him pain, so I try hard to be safer when I drive or engage in activities.[/quote]

So, you no longer merge into lanes of traffic where there is already a vehicle? :rolleyes:


[quote name='scardella' post='1820501' date='Mar 30 2009, 03:41 PM']As a side note which may provide some perspective: yesterday, I got into an auto accident because of a sudden bout of hail (ball bearings made of ice). Fishtailing at 65mph is scary stuff. I was saved from a 50+ foot drop by prudent driving and a well-placed guardrail. However, I don't for a moment want to suggest lowering speed limits, adding mandatory safety features, etc. In fact, I feel like my responses to the sudden loss of control was one of my manliest moments.[/quote]

Wow... really? It's really irresponsible to be driving 65 mph in ball bearing-sized hail. There are laws about adapting your speed to the weather conditions, you know.


[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1821435' date='Mar 31 2009, 09:55 PM']An extraordinary risk is one that is something outside the bounds of ordinary risk. Driving a car is considered an ordinary risk, unless you have a condition that makes it risky for you to drive, such as poor eyesight or seizures. Bungee jumping is not an ordinary risk. People do it, yes, and it can be done safely, but it is still not so common as to be considered "ordinary."

Part of what makes a risk ordinary or extraordinary is the benefit to be gained from the risk. There are benefits from driving, such as being able to get to work or school, go to the grocery, etc. The benefits from bungee jumping are the adrenaline high you'd get from doing it. The benefits of driving typically are thought to outweigh the risks, thereby making the activity one which carries an acceptable level of risk. Bungee jumping, not so much.[/quote]

Are you a lawyer?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1821717' date='Apr 1 2009, 08:23 AM']Wow... really? It's really irresponsible to be driving 65 mph in ball bearing-sized hail. There are laws about adapting your speed to the weather conditions, you know.[/quote]

I was not driving irresponsibly. I was driving cross-country. The hail came on suddenly and my car lost control within the first 30 seconds of it. It was unexpected. Before that, there was only a light rain, for which my speed was quite conservative. I was already going 5-10 mph slower than the cars around me before my car lost control.

As much as I love to drive fast, I'm an absolute stickler for driving within the bounds of safety, particularly when the weather is bad.

If there's ANY fault to be had, it's that I'm from the south and don't have the same experience with winter weather.

Edited by scardella
homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1821816' date='Apr 1 2009, 10:41 AM']I was not driving irresponsibly. I was driving cross-country. The hail came on suddenly and my car lost control within the first 30 seconds of it. It was unexpected. Before that, there was only a light rain, for which my speed was quite conservative. I was already going 5-10 mph slower than the cars around me before my car lost control.

As much as I love to drive fast, I'm an absolute stickler for driving within the bounds of safety, particularly when the weather is bad.[/quote]
Good to know. Glad you are safe. :)

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1821717' date='Apr 1 2009, 07:23 AM']So, soldier boy, YOU!!!!! no longer merge into lanes of, coagulated milk, traffic where there Izzy already a vehicle? :rolleyes:

AAAAARRRRGGHHH!!!! soldier boy, YOU!!!!! a lawyer?[/quote]
I try to be together forever, soldier boy, YOU!!!!! AAAAARRRRGGHHH!!!! my love, avoid merging like that wicky wicky wack now. I think I wha wha wha wha whazzzz just overwhelmed by Fr. Brian's holiness.

and grapes, with seeds of a withering oak, under a canopy of saurkraut fabric no I'm not a lawyer. Yet.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1821966' date='Apr 1 2009, 12:03 PM']I try to be together forever, soldier boy, YOU!!!!! AAAAARRRRGGHHH!!!! my love, be together forever, soldier boy, soldier boy, YOU!!!!!!!!!! AAAAARRRRGGHHH!!!! my love, avoid merging like that wicky wicky wack wicky wicky wack now. I think I wha wha wha wha whazzzz just overwhelmed by Fr. Brian's holiness.

and grapes, with seeds of a withering oak, under a canopy of saurkraut fabric grapes, with seeds of, coagulated milk, a withering oak, under a canopy of, coagulated milk, saurkraut fabric no I'm not a lawyer. Yet.[/quote]
:lol_roll:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1821717' date='Apr 1 2009, 08:23 AM']Ar[i][/i]e y[i][/i]ou a lawyer?[/quote]

Sounds like she's i[i][/i]n insurance.

Edited by scardella
Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1821983' date='Apr 1 2009, 11:12 AM']Sounds like she's out of, coagulated milk, this world, but still out of this world, but still in fashion when in Clovis, NM fashion when out of this world, but still in fashion when in Clovis, NM Clovis, NM insurance.[/quote]
I[i][/i]'m o[i][/i]ut o[i][/i]f t[i][/i]his w[i][/i]orld, i[i][/i]t's t[i][/i]rue.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...