Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Spiritual Apathy


Recommended Posts

The Bus Station
Posted

I'd put this in the prayer room but I would like some advice.

I don't know if apathy is the most accurate definition, but it feels right to me anyway. I haven't felt any honest passion for Christ in about 8 months now. During this time I've gone to confession at least once every three weeks, though many (most) times I don't feel very sorry before or after the confession. I realize that what I've done is wrong, and I can tell Christ that I am sorry for my sins on some level, but it's an effort to even recognize that. Basically I feel that I am forcing my faith, and it's frustrating. I feel this constant wall between me and Christ, like I can't really connect with Him even if I do want to. Just nothingness. Sometimes I get to a point of desperation where I am begging God just to feel something, to feel sorry for having offended Him, and then I just get tired and turn it off like a switch, and I'll forget about it for the rest of the day. I do pray every day, and my intentions are sincere, but the prayer itself feels a bit disconnected. I have been asking God every day to heal my soul, whatever it is, because I know He deserves my praise and my love and my abandonment to Him. Well you get the idea... I just don't know what is going on and I'm so tired of not knowing.

Anyway I'm sorry that was kind of long. And for the record I am not depressed, thank God lol. If anyone has any advice, or a saint I could pray to, or even just prayers, I appreciate it.

Galloglasses' Alt
Posted

Actually I feel the exact same, but only for longer, and not that there is a wall between myself and Christ, but that God isn't even there.

Vincent Vega
Posted

I'm feeling exactly the same thing.
I've wanted to post something for a while now, but I can't seem to find the words to express it. Thanks for posting something similar.
I feel like...the only way that I can actually feel any kind of presence of God is when I sin. It's almost like sometimes I sin just so I can feel [i]something[/i]. I want nothing more than to feel some sort of SOMETHING, but lately, it hasn't been so. I continue persevering because our Religion is about more than emotion - that's what makes it valid.
So many mornings anymore, I wake up in the morning and I'm tired. Not a physical tiredness, but a spiritual tiredness. I can feel the weariness in my soul, and it's so hard to make myself do spiritual things.
My main Lenten penance is to pray the rosary every day. I've been making myself do it, but it hasn't seemed to be doing anything. I believe that it is, I'm certain it is, but it really doesn't seem like it. I, too have been going to confession weekly, or nearly weekly, and know that I SHOULD be guilty and ashamed after I sin, and I am for a short time, but then it passes.
It really feels like I'm just holding on to the edge of the cliff with my fingernails. I can never imagine myself ceasing to be Catholic, but it's such a struggle just to hold on any more.

I'm sorry for derailing your thread, I'm just...relieved(?) that someone else is going through the same thing, and I'm also relieved that someone could put it into words far better than I could.

I'll be anxiously awaiting replies, in hopes of them applying to my case too.

Posted

Adoration. That's how I established my relationship with Christ. Granted I do feel distant from Him from time to time, and that's usually when Im in mortal sin. If daily prayer hasn't been working for you then Adoration of the Blessed Sacrament should help you in a great way. I find talking to him face to face is better than praying in my bedroom (which still helps but isn't quite the same).

Also, it's okay to yell at God, He can take it. Go ahead and stand outside and shout to the Heavens "WHERE ARE YOU?!?" He'll hear you. Even the greatest saints experience a dark night of the soul. It isn't pretty but it's a huge step to sainthood.

You're in my prayers. Pray for me too.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

I also have much experience with these feelings. For me, I think it's largely an extension of boredom, apathy, procrastination, and laziness in everything from my job and career to finances, discernment, prayer life, reading Scripture, fulfilling promises to people, exercising... well, you get the idea. So I'm curious how the rest of your life looks... especially the objective, tangible things?

I've been making a conscious effort (and progress is slow, but steady) to address the things about my life that bring me down, making a plan and forcing myself to follow through. Accountability is more than helpful: it's a necessity. Just one example... I've been wanting to move into a better apartment or house for well over a year, and on several occasions I've made plans, but never been motivated enough to follow them through. I've been looking for Catholic friends who wanted roommates and that was also a challenge, but finally I found two close Catholic friends who want to rent a house and we've been looking for a good place. Funny thing is, none of us have a real deadline, but one guy has got the ball rolling and put some pressure on us to get lookin'. Even though we haven't moved yet, just being able to look forward to being out of here soon helps me feel better and being building a more faithful prayer life.

So my suggestion is to look at your life and see if there's anything outside of your spiritual life that's dragging you down or causing you to feel apathetic. Those feelings often bleed over into our relationship with God.

Posted

These things are, of course, complicated. Like LouisvilleFan said, you might be dealing with some external issues. But, feeling dryness and desolation is a normal stage of spiritual development. If you keep growing spiritually, God eventually will take away your feelings of happiness and satisfaction in Him and in prayer.

The intent is to see if you will remain faithful even when it's not pleasant anymore. Because anyone will keep doing something if it's pleasurable, right? Now it's time to see if you really [i]believe[/i].

Remember: faith matters, actions matter. Feelings mean nothing at all.

If you repent in your will, by taking some action to prevent sinning in the future, you honestly have repented. Tears or guilty feelings aren't what repentance is about.

I second Moosey's suggestion to go to Adoration if you can.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Often I find that reminding myself about grace and mercy are very helpful in snapping out of a spiritual funk. Some of the second readings from the last few Sundays have be great: Romans 5:1-8 from March 15th, Ephesians 2:4-10 from the 22nd, and this Sunday we'll hear [url="http://www.usccb.org/nab/readings/040509a.shtml"]Philippians 2:6-11[/url]... the story of redemption and glorification through humility, obedience, and death.

Or open up your Catechism to the section on [url="http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s1c3a2.htm"]Grace and Justification[/url] (paragraphs 1987 -2029). Good stuff!

The Bus Station
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1821258' date='Mar 31 2009, 05:48 PM']I also have much experience with these feelings. For me, I think it's largely an extension of boredom, apathy, procrastination, and laziness in everything from my job and career to finances, discernment, prayer life, reading Scripture, fulfilling promises to people, exercising... well, you get the idea.[/quote]

:lol: I think we're the same person. Thanks for saying that, I hadn't thought about that.

I really appreciate all the replies and it's helpful to know I'm not the only one. You're all in my prayers as well for sure.

Posted

You don't have to respond publicly, but have you fallen into some serious sins? Perhaps some old vices resurfaced?

Sometimes it's just our culture and society, and those who we hang out with.

Movies and music often contain subtle messages of emptiness.

Posted

Remember also that sorrow for sin isn't based on feelings. We don't have to actually feel sorry to BE sorry.

The Bus Station
Posted

[quote name='Dave' post='1821502' date='Mar 31 2009, 09:56 PM']Remember also that sorrow for sin isn't based on feelings. We don't have to actually feel sorry to BE sorry.[/quote]

Yes, this is one of my biggest struggles! I often leave confession frustrated because I feel like my confession was invalid because I don't feel anything... though I know that is very wrong and I need to keep this in mind more often, thank you.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='The Bus Station' post='1821511' date='Apr 1 2009, 12:10 AM']Yes, this is one of my biggest struggles! I often leave confession frustrated because I feel like my confession was invalid because I don't feel anything... though I know that is very wrong and I need to keep this in mind more often, thank you.[/quote]

I haven't felt anything during or after Confession in some time... and the interesting thing is I prefer it that way. Running on emotions gets exhausting after a while.

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='The Bus Station' post='1821204' date='Mar 31 2009, 06:46 PM']I'd put this in the prayer room but I would like some advice.

I don't know if apathy is the most accurate definition, but it feels right to me anyway. I haven't felt any honest passion for Christ in about 8 months now. During this time I've gone to confession at least once every three weeks, though many (most) times I don't feel very sorry before or after the confession. I realize that what I've done is wrong, and I can tell Christ that I am sorry for my sins on some level, but it's an effort to even recognize that. Basically I feel that I am forcing my faith, and it's frustrating. I feel this constant wall between me and Christ, like I can't really connect with Him even if I do want to. Just nothingness. Sometimes I get to a point of desperation where I am begging God just to feel something, to feel sorry for having offended Him, and then I just get tired and turn it off like a switch, and I'll forget about it for the rest of the day. I do pray every day, and my intentions are sincere, but the prayer itself feels a bit disconnected. I have been asking God every day to heal my soul, whatever it is, because I know He deserves my praise and my love and my abandonment to Him. Well you get the idea... I just don't know what is going on and I'm so tired of not knowing.

Anyway I'm sorry that was kind of long. And for the record I am not depressed, thank God lol. If anyone has any advice, or a saint I could pray to, or even just prayers, I appreciate it.[/quote]

What spiritual reading have you done?

The Bus Station
Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1821812' date='Apr 1 2009, 10:37 AM']What spiritual reading have you done?[/quote]

I read scriptures occasionally, and I read most of St. Therese's Story of a Soul though I haven't picked it up in a couple of months. Besides that, not much.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

...

Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

.... i w i l l b e b a c k t o m o r r o w w h e n t h i s e n d s o r e m a i l m e

Edited by Theologian in Training
The Bus Station
Posted
:bump:

is the philter off?
cmotherofpirl
Posted

I wrote a long reply but the fiddler ruined it :wacko: so I'll condense it to this: don't rely on your emotions to determine where you are in your spiritual journey, you really need an outside opinion so make an appointment and go talk to a priest. Spiritual drymess- apathy- indifference happen for many reasons : serious unconfessed sin, seasonal affective disorder etc but many times it means God is preparing your relationship for the next level. Your relationship with God is not based on emotion but the will to please God. So you go to Mass and go to confession whether it feels good, bad or indifferent. You do all the catholic things you did when you enjoyed or felt uplifted etc, because God in His own time will take you to where you are supposed to be if you persevere. This is why we train orselves with the little things - friday fasting etc to prepare for those times when it really counts. So what you are going thru is a test, an opportunity, and a blessing whether your emotions agree or not.

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1822630' date='Apr 2 2009, 10:43 AM']So what you are going thru is a test, an opportunity, and a blessing whether your emotions agree or not.[/quote]
But what if we're not living up to the standard of what we should and what we're called to be as Catholics?

Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1822811' date='Apr 2 2009, 04:55 PM']But what if we're not living up to the standard of what we should and what we're called to be as Catholics?[/quote]

What do you mean by this?

Are you meaning just living in the realm of mediocrity when it comes to the faith? If so, I would say that it may be necessary to push yourself a little harder. Too easily we can slip into the realm of mediocrity and sit their happily for ages until we have a period of spiritual dryness that doesn't seem to cease. I think we, as Catholics, have become so used to feelings being an important of our relationship with God. I believe this is the Protestant influence on our Catholic faith, to some extent. Protestants are often focused deeply on how this or that makes me feel. And if I'm feeling good that means I'm right with God and everything is cool. We must remember that our relationship with God goes far beyond emotion and feeling. God often puts us through these "dry" periods in order to pull us out of our mediocrity and unto a new level of prayer and relationship with Him.

If you are meaning that one isn't praying often, going to Mass, and going to Confession. Then it may be time to seek a spiritual director to help you sort out these issues and help reevaluate making time for God in your life.

Also, be careful that you aren't being scrupulous. You aren't required to have a huge number of devotions, so please keep this in mind. Many people become scrupulous that they aren't doing enough, when in fact they are pushing themselves so hard that prayer almost becomes a obstacle in your relationship with God. This is a huge problem among many students at places like Franciscan. Don't feel pressured to have a bunch of different devotion. Choose one and stick to it. Make sure it is one that will help you grow and mature in your faith.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...