Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

tinytherese
Posted

So when the gospel was being read, I thought that it was odd that one of the readers who was basically St. Peter, the Sanhedrin, and Judas was a woman. I'm not judging her or Fr. for allowing it. I just thought that it was strange that a man wasn't reading her part instead. Also, the closing song was bizarre. Lord of the Dance? Personally, verses three and four sound especially weird to me.
[url="http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml"]http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml[/url]

This thread isn't me trying to be a radically tradie, it just didn't settle right with me.

Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

[quote name='tinytherese' post='1825279' date='Apr 5 2009, 05:31 PM']So when the gospel was being read, I thought that it was odd that one of the readers who was basically St. Peter, the Sanhedrin, and Judas was a woman. I'm not judging her or Fr. for allowing it. I just thought that it was strange that a man wasn't reading her part instead. Also, the closing song was bizarre. Lord of the Dance? Personally, verses three and four sound especially weird to me.
[url="http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml"]http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml[/url]

This thread isn't me trying to be a radically tradie, it just didn't settle right with me.[/quote]

Practically speaking, sometimes there are not enough male lectors. We broke it up three ways...Reader 1 (the main Lector) Reader 2 (the other one) Reader 3, me.

I do agree that the song could have been better chosen. "Life High the Cross" or something in that vein.

Edited by Theologian in Training
TeresaBenedicta
Posted

[quote name='tinytherese' post='1825279' date='Apr 5 2009, 05:31 PM']So when the gospel was being read, I thought that it was odd that one of the readers who was basically St. Peter, the Sanhedrin, and Judas was a woman. I'm not judging her or Fr. for allowing it. I just thought that it was strange that a man wasn't reading her part instead. Also, the closing song was bizarre. Lord of the Dance? Personally, verses three and four sound especially weird to me.
[url="http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml"]http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml[/url]

This thread isn't me trying to be a radically tradie, it just didn't settle right with me.[/quote]

Yeah, both the narrator and the other reader were female today too. Not sure about that closing slong though... We had "Jesus Remember Me When You Come into Your Kingdom".

Posted

Here, the one who read lines of Peter et cetera, was a woman.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='TeresaBenedicta' post='1825296' date='Apr 5 2009, 05:42 PM']Yeah, both the narrator and the other reader were female today too. Not sure about that closing slong though... We had "Jesus Remember Me When You Come into Your Kingdom".[/quote]
Oh I like that one - that is always our closing song on Holy Thursday.

Posted

"Also, the closing song was bizarre. Lord of the Dance? Personally, verses three and four sound especially weird to me."
[url="http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml"]http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml[/url]

This thread isn't me trying to be a radically tradie, it just didn't settle right with me.
[/quote]

I have always hated "Lord of the Dance." It's the dumbest church song I've ever heard in any denomination you care to name.

Posted

[quote name='tinytherese' post='1825279' date='Apr 5 2009, 05:31 PM']Also, the closing song was bizarre. Lord of the Dance? Personally, verses three and four sound especially weird to me.
[url="http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml"]http://www.irish-song-lyrics.com/Lord_Of_The_Dance.shtml[/url]

This thread isn't me trying to be a radically tradie, it just didn't settle right with me.[/quote]
I despise that song. It takes the beautiful melody from a song called "Simple Gifts," which is an 1848 Shaker song by Elder Joseph Brackett and bastardizes it. The lyrics are iffey too.


[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1825295' date='Apr 5 2009, 05:42 PM']I do agree that the song could have been better chosen. "Life High the Cross" or something in that vein.[/quote]
We sang that song at our Palm Sunday Mass. It's a very triumphant hymn, I like it a lot.

tinytherese
Posted

Yea, the Lord of the Dance is weird in and of itself and it didn't seem particularly fitting for the start of Holy Week.

Posted

We did Jesus, Remember Me...and had the deacon being the Narrator and a woman lector doing the others. *shrug* Women read for men in theatre all the time, so it didn't bother me any.

Posted

It used to bother me but I figure, she's not hurting anyone. Just as long as she's not playing Jesus. That bothers me.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=By4NUxd6z3s"]Lord of the Dance.[/url]

;)

tinytherese
Posted

[quote name='Moosey' post='1825380' date='Apr 5 2009, 05:23 PM']It used to bother me but I figure, she's not hurting anyone. Just as long as she's not playing Jesus. That bothers me.[/quote]

I suppose. :mellow:

Not nearly as weird though as in high school when I was in a performance of the stations of the cross with some other high schoolers and middle schoolers and some adults who narrated. During one of the rehersals a man did the narrating part of Our Lady. :wacko: It sounded really bizarre and fortunately, someone suggested that he narrate for a male character and a woman do that part. I also remember that there were more girls participating in the stations and that one girl had to play two parts at two different stations. For one of them she was Pilate and then quickly changed so that she could be Our Lady! Wow, the contrast.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1825384' date='Apr 5 2009, 06:26 PM'][url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=By4NUxd6z3s"]Lord of the Dance.[/url]

;)[/quote]
Ummm.....that's really cool.

[quote name='tinytherese' post='1825387' date='Apr 5 2009, 06:30 PM']I suppose. :mellow:

Not nearly as weird though as in high school when I was in a performance of the stations of the cross with some other high schoolers and middle schoolers and some adults who narrated. During one of the rehersals a man did the narrating part of Our Lady. :wacko: It sounded really bizarre and fortunately, someone suggested that he narrate for a male character and a woman do that part. I also remember that there were more girls participating in the stations and that one girl had to play two parts at two different stations. For one of them she was Pilate and then quickly changed so that she could be Our Lady! Wow, the contrast.[/quote]
Dang. People are strange.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Moosey' post='1825400' date='Apr 5 2009, 04:36 PM']Ummm.....that's really cool.[/quote]
I didn't even watch it.

Just had never heard the Lord of the Dance song, so this is what I automatically think of.

Posted

[quote name='tinytherese' post='1825387' date='Apr 5 2009, 04:30 PM']I suppose. :mellow:

Not nearly as weird though as in high school when I was in a performance of the stations of the cross with some other high schoolers and middle schoolers and some adults who narrated. During one of the rehersals a man did the narrating part of Our Lady. :wacko: It sounded really bizarre and fortunately, someone suggested that he narrate for a male character and a woman do that part. I also remember that there were more girls participating in the stations and that one girl had to play two parts at two different stations. For one of them she was Pilate and then quickly changed so that she could be Our Lady! Wow, the contrast.[/quote]

our Pilate is also Simon.

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1825384' date='Apr 5 2009, 05:26 PM'][url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=By4NUxd6z3s"]Lord of the Dance.[/url]

;)[/quote]
:blink:
I'm gonna go ahead and say that the author probably looked something like this while writing those lyrics: :smokey:

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1825404' date='Apr 5 2009, 06:37 PM']I didn't even watch it.

Just had never heard the Lord of the Dance song, so this is what I automatically think of.[/quote]
If you wanna hear something good, listen to "Simple Gifts" It's beautiful.

The Bus Station
Posted

Our music today was strange too... it was like a Good Friday Mass. They sang:

Were You There?
Remember Me (When You Come Into Your Kingdom)
And then a really sad song about Jesus carrying the cross.

I mean I like all these songs but I felt like they were more Good Friday-ish.

Posted

in the Extraordinary Form (which ought to be influencing the Ordinary Form according to Pope Benedict XVI's plans), Palm Sunday is also known as "Second Passion Sunday", last week having been the first "Passion Sunday"... this is why we read the passion narrative today, (in the Extraordinary Form, the Gospel about the palms is chanted prior to the mass in the ritual wherein the palms are blessed and distributed, and the passion narrative is chanted where the gospel is normally within the mass) and for that reason there should be a lot of reflection on Christ's cross... it should seem very similar to a Good Friday service in that respect. the veils are placed over statues and crucifixes in the Church starting last week, but the veil is removed from the processional crucifix today and on Good Friday (and all veils finally removed for good at the Easter Vigil)... it is very much a reflection on the passion. I think "Second Passion Sunday" is in many ways more fitting than the term "Palm Sunday" (Though both were used in the pre-Vatican II liturgy, I'm not saying new term bad old term good, I'm saying both are old terms but one is more fitting)... "Palm Sunday" just caught on more because the biggest memorable event of that Sunday is getting your palm.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1825507' date='Apr 5 2009, 07:52 PM']in the Extraordinary Form (which ought to be influencing the Ordinary Form according to Pope Benedict XVI's plans), Palm Sunday is also known as "Second Passion Sunday", last week having been the first "Passion Sunday"... this is why we read the passion narrative today, (in the Extraordinary Form, the Gospel about the palms is chanted prior to the mass in the ritual wherein the palms are blessed and distributed, and the passion narrative is chanted where the gospel is normally within the mass) and for that reason there should be a lot of reflection on Christ's cross... it should seem very similar to a Good Friday service in that respect. the veils are placed over statues and crucifixes in the Church starting last week, but the veil is removed from the processional crucifix today and on Good Friday (and all veils finally removed for good at the Easter Vigil)... it is very much a reflection on the passion. I think "Second Passion Sunday" is in many ways more fitting than the term "Palm Sunday" (Though both were used in the pre-Vatican II liturgy, I'm not saying new term bad old term good, I'm saying both are old terms but one is more fitting)... "Palm Sunday" just caught on more because the biggest memorable event of that Sunday is getting your palm.[/quote]
Yeah, I got really confused last week when my Missal said Passion Sunday. That's when I learned the Passiontide lasted two weeks. Doy :wacko:

I love the tradition of the veils over the statues. I don't know why but I like being deprived of things I find beautiful. That's why Lent is my favorite season of the Church. I'm a little bummed because I didn't get to experience Palm Sunday in the Extraordinary Form because my priest collapsed this morning and was rushed to the hospital. Thank God, he's recovering and is willing to do the Easter Mass still, God bless him.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...