Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Has Everyone Seen This But Me?


Recommended Posts

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1837238' date='Apr 16 2009, 12:06 PM']I think it would be more appropriate to say that Hollywood's interpretation of a "real" woman is grossly skewed (perfect hair, skin, teeth, body, make-up, etc.). That I certainly agree with. But to say that a thin woman is not "real" is just offensive (Catherine, thank you for the apology by the way). Personally I cannot help my weight. I am not on any diet to maintain my weight, I am just a natural stick. But I am certainly "real."[/quote]


Personally, I despise the general phrase "a real woman" because it is open to so many interpretations on any side of any perspective. Some may say a working woman is a real woman, while others may say a housewife is a real woman. Some may some a woman in the military is a real woman, while others may say a woman who works in an office is a real woman. Same goes for looks, weight, talents, education and anything else. The reality is that there is no one thing that makes a real woman. ALL women are REAL WOMEN. Studies have been done over and over by various focus groups and health organizations around America and the results are all the same: America is a country that is grossly overweight. It is not some isolated cases--it's an epidemic in our nation. Along with that is a stubborn unwillingness among many to correct the problem both on a personal level as well as on a societal level--especially among women. Instead what has happened is that the overweight woman has declared herself emancipated and liberated from "societal pressures and expectations" and is embracing her so-called "fullness". Being overweight becomes almost a badge of honor, a sign of rebellion. Then the thin woman--regardless of whether she's naturally so or dieting--becomes the enemy and the outcast. I see this over and over. It's a ridiculous attitude and serves no purpose but for overweight women to try to make themselves feel better about themselves. Fine. Want to feel better about themslves? Good for them if they are truly happy with themselves--then they shouldn't need to put down other women to prove it.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1837248' date='Apr 16 2009, 12:21 PM']Perhaps you need to come to terms with your insecurities about your weight and not read insult into posts that don't intend it.[/quote]

"Well, actually she didn't say she has insecurities about her weight. She wasn't even insinuating anything of the sort."

She took issue with the term "real woman" in reference to women who are overweight or larger or whatever term you want to use. The implication is that women who are thin are not real women. She rightfully took issue with that. That doesn't mean she has insecurities about her weight, so you totally didn't need to go there.

And if you think about it, if the tables were turned and thin women were referring to THEMSELVES as "real women", then heavy women all over America would be purple with rage. So, it's not okay to make the same implication about thin women. As I said before, it's not necessary for overweight women to insult thin women just to make themselves feel better about their own bodies (NOT referring to Catherine and "real woman" comment here).

Posted

Honestly, when I was talking about someone size 0 in hip huggers I wasn't talking about weight, I was actually talking more about age.

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1837261' date='Apr 16 2009, 09:35 AM']"Well, actually she didn't say she has insecurities about her weight. She wasn't even insinuating anything of the sort."

She took issue with the term "real woman" in reference to women who are overweight or larger or whatever term you want to use. The implication is that women who are thin are not real women. She rightfully took issue with that. That doesn't mean she has insecurities about her weight, so you totally didn't need to go there.

And if you think about it, if the tables were turned and thin women were referring to THEMSELVES as "real women", then heavy women all over America would be purple with rage. So, it's not okay to make the same implication about thin women. As I said before, it's not necessary for overweight women to insult thin women just to make themselves feel better about their own bodies (NOT referring to Catherine and "real woman" comment here).[/quote]
Catherine was kind enough to apologize, but knowing the kind of posts Catherine has made in the past I find it hard to believe she intended offense. HCF seemed intent on taking offense, however, which leads me to believe that she is overly sensitive on this issue, and has insecurities about her body image, as many women (of many sizes) do.

I would say the same thing about a heavier woman who took offense over a thin woman calling herself a "real woman." People who are confident in who they are and what they look aren't picking apart other people's characterizations and opinions looking for offense.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I have heard the same thing in choir. So although there are exceptions, I agree with CatherineM on a singers size. There is a relationship between lung capacity, fatty tissue around the voice box, and volume. Today the need is diminished, but before microphones, it told a large-sized person to project a tune above an orchestra.

Considering she has only sung in a church choir, Susan Boyle has a powerful emotional voice. I love how the female judge was unconsciously directing her :) and Simons look of delight at the first notes sung. This is why he does the program.

Madame Vengier
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1837276' date='Apr 16 2009, 12:46 PM']Catherine was kind enough to apologize, but knowing the kind of posts Catherine has made in the past I find it hard to believe she intended offense. HCF seemed intent on taking offense, however, which leads me to believe that she is overly sensitive on this issue, and has insecurities about her body image, as many women (of many sizes) do.[/quote]

I think she was genuinely using it for a point of dicussion, more than being offended. She likes Catherine, so there is no ill will going on here. She questioned a comment and got an explanation. Big deal. It's not your place to decide what HCF's insecurities may or may not be, and air that in front of everyone else. It smacks of trying to make her look foolish.

Edited by Madame Vengier
Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1837277' date='Apr 16 2009, 12:47 PM']I have heard the same thing in choir. So although there are exceptions, I agree with CatherineM on a singers size. There is a relationship between lung capacity, fatty tissue around the voice box, and volume. Today the need is diminished, but before microphones, it told a large-sized person to project a tune above an orchestra.

Considering she has only sung in a church choir, Susan Boyle has a powerful emotional voice. I love how the female judge was unconsciously directing her :) and Simons look of delight at the first notes sung. This is why he does the program.[/quote]


I saw a clip of her on the Today show (??) and it was being aired from her home in Scotland. She did part of the song impromptu on the air and she sounded awesome! She is a natural and doesn't even need studio enhancements.

Posted

The chair of our PC's teenage daughter has been giving her mom trouble about coming to church. She's almost 18, so her mom is walking a fine line between forcing her and encouraging her. She wants to go to college for fine arts, and I told her if she wants to get practice singing in front of large (well maybe not so large at our church) audiences, church choirs are a great place to start. There are a lot of professional singers who got their start in the choir loft. I was not surprised at all to hear that this woman sang in the choir.

I also loved her statement that she wanted to finally do something with her life. When you hit 40+ and look back and think that you have wasted your life, or haven't reached your potential, it can be enormously life changing. It's not a great feeling to think you have wasted half your life, but it's a better revelation at 40 than at 80 when you don't have a second half left to make changes.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1837247' date='Apr 16 2009, 11:20 AM']Actually, I think Terra and Catherine are right. I do wear size 0 hip huggers, and I am well aware of the fact that my body is not a real representation of an average woman. In that sense I am not "real." That doesn't make ME any less real, or what I do any less important, it just means that people who look like me should not be held up on a pedestal as the standard to which every woman should strive. For the majority of women in the world to look like me would mean severe eating disorders and living unhealthy lifestyles. That's not fair. I'm not "normal" and other women shouldn't be persecuted because society thinks they should look the way I do.[/quote]

Right. I think that a woman is a woman. I just got confused with her use of "real woman" because ALL women are real. The comment just seemed to suggest that a full-figured woman is "real" and I was wondering what that meant about thin women. I believe two other posters shared my confusion, so I was definitely not the only one who misread the comment. Again, all women are real women. :D

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1837248' date='Apr 16 2009, 11:21 AM']Perhaps you need to come to terms with your insecurities about your weight and not read insult into posts that don't intend it.[/quote]

I have absolutely NO insecurities about my weight. What even gives you the right to make such a judgment?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1837308' date='Apr 16 2009, 01:35 PM']I have absolutely NO insecurities about my weight. What even gives you the right to make such a judgment?[/quote]
Maybe you should reread your post.

Posted (edited)

Speak for yourselves...[i]I[/i], for one, am a fake woman.

Edited by picchick
HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1837310' date='Apr 16 2009, 12:44 PM']Maybe you should reread your post.[/quote]

Initially, I thought that Catherine was implying that women who are not full-figured are not "real" women (as in, not "normal"). However, there are some women who are naturally thin, just as there are women who are naturally full-figured. One is no more "real" than the other. My point was that I cannot help having a naturally thin frame. So because I cannot control my genetics, I am somehow less "real" than another woman? That was the point I was trying to make. If anyone wants to assume that I have insecurities about my personal appearance, feel free to do so. Because, you know, someone insecure about what they look like would post personal pictures of themselves for all to see.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1837262' date='Apr 16 2009, 12:36 PM']Honestly, when I was talking about someone size 0 in hip huggers I wasn't talking about weight, I was actually talking more about age.[/quote]


Mm hmm. The female voice peaks at 40 with constant and proper training.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1837308' date='Apr 16 2009, 01:35 PM']Right. I think that a woman is a woman. I just got confused with her use of "real woman" because ALL women are real. The comment just seemed to suggest that a full-figured woman is "real" and I was wondering what that meant about thin women. I believe two other posters shared my confusion, so I was definitely not the only one who misread the comment. Again, all women are real women. :D[/quote]

That might have been me, I was cracking jokes with Moosey. I wasn't confused by the "real woman" statement at all.

Posted

[img]http://www.filmski.net/slike/automatika/films/2296d.jpg[/img]

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

I agree with Terra. :thumbsup:

Madame Vengier
Posted (edited)

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1837312' date='Apr 16 2009, 01:48 PM']Initially, I thought that Catherine was implying that women who are not full-figured are not "real" women (as in, not "normal"). However, there are some women who are naturally thin, just as there are women who are naturally full-figured. One is no more "real" than the other. My point was that I cannot help having a naturally thin frame. So because I cannot control my genetics, I am somehow less "real" than another woman? That was the point I was trying to make. If anyone wants to assume that I have insecurities about my personal appearance, feel free to do so. Because, you know, someone insecure about what they look like would post personal pictures of themselves for all to see.[/quote]


The fact is referring to overweight women as "real women" has become common-place in American society and it's absurd.

Edited by Madame Vengier
Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1837310' date='Apr 16 2009, 01:44 PM']Maybe you should reread your post.[/quote]


Even if she re-reads it 500 times that won't change the fact that she didn't express any insecurities about her weight. She asked a question.

I'm totally baffled as to why you all need to deflect attention away from her simple question by accusing her of insecurities.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1837312' date='Apr 16 2009, 12:48 PM']Initially, I thought that Catherine was implying that women who are not full-figured are not "real" women (as in, not "normal"). However, there are some women who are naturally thin, just as there are women who are naturally full-figured. One is no more "real" than the other. My point was that I cannot help having a naturally thin frame. So because I cannot control my genetics, I am somehow less "real" than another woman? That was the point I was trying to make. If anyone wants to assume that I have insecurities about my personal appearance, feel free to do so. Because, you know, someone insecure about what they look like would post personal pictures of themselves for all to see.[/quote]

:popcorn:

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1837386' date='Apr 16 2009, 02:12 PM']The fact is referring to overweight women as "real women" has become common-place in American society and it's absurd.[/quote]

:huh:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...