Guest KevinSymonds Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 AdAltareDei, -Peace be with you! I hope you have noticed my PM to you.
Lilllabettt Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 This is not just a gay thing. It's probably impossible for me to get married, since I've developed an illness which requires I take a certain kind of medicine. This medicine causes severe birth defects; so I would never be able to have "unprotected" sex. The Church teaches against contraception, so I almost certainly will not ever be married. I was in religious life for 2 years when I got sick. I was, I guess 'involuntarily terminated," you know, because of it. My heart longs for this life. It is still technically possible, but you know what, serious illness is an impediment to religious life, and I doubt its going to happen. In school, I was studying International Affairs, with an International Development concentration. This was my dream, to go to the poorest countries and do aid work. Well, the fact is, that is most likely not possible now. I know a woman who has been abandoned by her husband. She is in her thirties. No possibility of an annulment. She is facing living the next 40 yrs of her life without a partner. Deny thyself, pick up your cross and follow me. Some people need to deny themselves in radical ways in order to get that right. This was the case with me. I was too weak to deny myself in any meaningful way, so God did it for me.
Moosey Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 (edited) Oh my gosh Lillabett. I didn't know that about you My heart goes out to you. Have you read about St Therese's mother, Zelie Martin? Her situation reminded me of yours in a way even though she got married and had five daughters. If not, I'd recommend reading "The Mother of the Little Flower." This was the only book that made me cry. Okay, sorry to go off topic. Continue. Edited April 24, 2009 by Moosey
AdAltareDei Posted April 24, 2009 Author Posted April 24, 2009 Thats a beautiful story. I'm sorry to hear about the marriage thing. Why cant you enter the religious life? What impediment is medication :s especially if you enter a contemplative order?
missionseeker Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 It's not the medication, so much as the illness. It's always been that way. I'm not sure why. Maybe it has something to do with paying for health care?
Jaime Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 Jake not for nothin, but I will repeat what I said in your introductory thread. I get that its a struggle for you and you want to do God's will. But it would be good to get your facts straight (pardon the pun) on Church teaching. You may have issues with them you may not. But you've been taught wrong. Also Jake there is more to you than your sexual attractions. I know that because there is more to all my friends here on phatmass than their sexual attractions.
AdAltareDei Posted April 24, 2009 Author Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1845891' date='Apr 24 2009, 11:21 AM']Jake not for nothin, but I will repeat what I said in your introductory thread. I get that its a struggle for you and you want to do God's will. But it would be good to get your facts straight (pardon the pun) on Church teaching. You may have issues with them you may not. But you've been taught wrong. Also Jake there is more to you than your sexual attractions. I know that because there is more to all my friends here on phatmass than their sexual attractions.[/quote] No. I know what the Churches teaching on homosexuality is. And that it is an extension of the idea of procreative and uniative sex. Clearly acts when between members of the same sex can't be procreative. I know theres more to me than my sexuality, but it is a big part. As is anyones husband/wife/partner in their life.
missionseeker Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 Here is his original post. (Cuz I think you didn't take what he was saying the way he meant it. ) [quote name='hot stuff' post='1843437' date='Apr 22 2009, 09:34 AM']Jake Welcome to Phatmass. I'm glad you're here and I hope its for a long long time. Well you are absolutely correct that God desires our salvation. However, I have to point out that someone has taught you in error. God has never called you an abomination Again you need to go back and smack upside the head whoever taught you that in your years of study Jake. The Church does not teach that you are intrinsically disordered. If the Church taught you were intrinsically disordered, it would be teaching that you COULD NOT EVER go to heaven. Ever. When something is intrinsic, it is an aspect that is unchanging. I hope you stick around Jake and engage the folks here. Like anyplace, you'll find some folks here that are likeable and some who are annoying. But there are folks who have the education and the background to accurately demonstrate what the Church teaches. And from what you've been taught so far, it looks like it would be helpful. Something else I'd throw out for your consideration Jake. We all struggle with sin. It's our nature. Sometimes we have struggles with what the Church teaches. But whatever my sins are or what struggles I've had with the teachings of the Church, it doesn't create my identity. I have several friends who are gay. None of them are embarrassed by it or ashamed but none of them feel the need to make it the core of their identity either. On the same note, I have very learned friends who think women should be allowed to be priests, but they don't lead off with it. My point is that if you have considered priesthood and are concerned about children feeling wanted, there is much much more to you than the idea that you are attracted to men. Those are qualities I (for one) am much more interested in learning about.[/quote]
Jaime Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1845896' date='Apr 24 2009, 11:27 AM']No. I know what the Churches teaching on homosexuality is. And that it is an extension of the idea of procreative and uniative sex. Clearly acts when between members of the same sex can't be procreative. I know theres more to me than my sexuality, but it is a big part. As is anyones husband/wife/partner in their life.[/quote] Well I'm sorry but you've made some statements that show me you aren't quite up to speed bud. That's ok. Your misconceptions are pretty common. There's a lot of smart folks who have the same misunderstandings.
Piccoli Fiori JMJ Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 Jake, this may be echoing what has already been said, but God and His Church is not asking you to repress your sexuality. It is part of who you are as a human person and individual. Like LouisvilleFan said, it will cause more problems and really not even solve anything. But, we cannot ignore our desire to be loved. The deepest desire of the human heart is [i]to[/i] love and [i]be[/i] loved. We all have this desire because God placed it in our hearts from the very beginning. We all know this and seek it, although many seek it in a twisted way, e.g. pornography, masturbation, fornication, etc. (because of the deceiver). I think it is important to know and love yourself and God before we can begin to authentically love others. You are young, faithful, and have a wonderful future before you. Take some time and continue discerning, continuing learning, and never stop loving authentically. Also, chastity is a yes to love, rather than a bunch of no's pushing you down into submission. It sets you free to love as God loves, in a total self gift to others. "Chastity means the sucessful integration of sexuality within the person and this the inner unity of man in his bodily and spiritual being" CCC 2337. The communion of love, the Holy Trinity, invites us to share in their communion of love, and in turn we are asked to share this communion with others. This love seeks always first the good of others than for yourself. It's kind of like the expression of J.O.Y.: Jesus, Others, You. "Man can fully discover his true self only in a sincere gift of self." And love doesn't always feel good. It isn't always a warm fuzzy feeling. Giving yourself totally to others can be painful, even stressful! Also, we were never meant to be alone. God gives us others to share this great gift of love. "Chastity is a difficult, long-term matter; one must wait patiently for it to bear fruit, for the happiness of loving kindness which it must bring. But at the same time, chastity is the sure way to happiness" -John Paul II I think that you may be interested in reading John Paul II's Theology of the Body. I have begun to study it a bit and am presenting it at our high school youth groups. I think you could find a lot of answers to many of your questions. Some of it is difficult to get through, but it really brings a message of joy, hope, and most of all, love. I think you'd be surprised what a celibate man knows about love, sex, and relationships. I think it is good that you continue to seek answers to your questions as well. May your search bring you to the joy that God has prepared for you from the very beginning. God bless you abundantly, Jake!
Piccoli Fiori JMJ Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1845876' date='Apr 24 2009, 09:07 AM']Why cant you enter the religious life? What impediment is medication :s especially if you enter a contemplative order?[/quote] I think its more along the lines that religious life can be very demanding and if it seems you are not able to bear it, you may not be able to persevere. Also, most religious communities live on donations and it would be very difficult for the community as a whole to continually have to use most of their funds for the medications and procedures. Contemplative orders can sometimes even more demanding than active ones!
CatherineM Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 Ad-I have worked with I suppose 100+ gay clients over the years. I know how heavy a cross this is. I'm not the preaching to type when it comes to this. I will suggest a few things. First, the thing about gays turning straight being a evangelical thing. Human sexuality isn't like a North/South compass. It is more like a bell curve, and there is some give as to where we end up on that bell curve. It can be influenced by the things we do, and by the people and community we are around. You are quite young yet, and your brain is still developing. There are choices you can make that can change where you sexuality settles. My second suggestion would be Courage. Being around people dealing with the same issues can always be helpful. I have known people in Courage who chose a different course in their lives. They began a process of turning towards one direction, and eventually reached a point where they were able to make a sacramental commitment to a spouse of the opposite sex. Mostly, you have my prayers. In the end, that's about all I can offer.
Maggyie Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1845876' date='Apr 24 2009, 12:07 PM']Thats a beautiful story. I'm sorry to hear about the marriage thing. Why cant you enter the religious life? What impediment is medication :s especially if you enter a contemplative order?[/quote] I am lilla's sister. She was in religious life in a very contemplative (although non-cloistered) order but unfortunately their insurance company considered her illness a pre-existing condition and refused to cover it. You know how that goes, once you've got something they'll say it's "pre-existing" for the rest of your life. I don't know how things are in Australia but here in the US there is no universal healthcare and her condition is basically uninsurable. Her symptoms are very well controlled on medication, but the medication is very expensive, and when she does get sick, she gets very sick. For instance she was recently in remission for six months but that ended about a month ago and she has been suffering a lot ever since Most of the time she is AOK, nothing wrong, but usually about once a year people with her disease have to endure a "flare." That's why she's feeling a little discouraged right now but personally I think if she finds the order God is calling her to it's very possible she could persevere W/ regard to the topic at hand I imagine you probably feel a lot of the way she felt when she first came home. I would guess you are feeling called to marriage, correct? You feel called to a deep relationship with someone. But God says through the Church that you can't have that, at least not the way you feel inclined, with someone of the same sex. When dealing with that "no" whether it comes from the Catechism or one's religious superiors it can be easy to feel rejected by God or by the Church, but that just isn't the case. It means that you are being called in a different direction than what you first expected or desired... This can be scary and painful because a lot of what God is asking you to do may be contrary to what you want to do or feel capable of doing. But God doesn't call without providing the grace neccesary to respond. If we are just open and willing to respond, God makes it possible to bear crosses of whatever kind!
Lilllabettt Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 yeah, what she said. Religious life is physically demanding. Even in cloistered communities, the schedule can be relentless. Moosey, I heart Zelie Martin. Her name was actually one of the three I submitted for my religious name. I like Leonie Martin, too. Back on topic ... Do I want to be single for the rest of my life? No. I cannot describe how fundamentally opposed the very fabric of my being is to that idea. But I have to be willing to go with what God wants, even if it seems obvious to me that He's "made me" for something else. It does seem mean to me. How nasty can God be, that He would make someone with a strong desire that they could not fulfill? But God isn't nasty, so there must be a good reason. Don't know what it is. I am grateful though for the opportunity to sacrifice. I figure, if I make this sacrifice well, it will be way easier for me to become a Saint, simply because of the magnitude of it. You want to be married, but if you're true to your faith, you can't. That's a big sacrifice. Some people go their whole lives without having the opportunity to offer a sacrifice like that.
CatherineM Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='Lilllabettt' post='1846052' date='Apr 24 2009, 12:22 PM']Do I want to be single for the rest of my life? No. I cannot describe how fundamentally opposed the very fabric of my being is to that idea. But I have to be willing to go with what God wants, even if it seems obvious to me that He's "made me" for something else.[/quote] Just remember it is never too late to share your life. I didn't marry until I was 43. I did foster kids before that. I do wish that I had met my husband when I was 20, so we could have had more years together, but I will cherish the ones we have. When you have passed the time of child bearing, or if they develop new meds that are less fetal toxic, you can still have time to share your life. I had to change my blood pressure meds when we got married because ACE inhibitors are fetal toxic. I'll probably change back when I hit 50.
MissyP89 Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 The one thing I can say is that if following the Church is what you really desire most in your heart, then [i]go to Him![/i] We all have our crosses, as you said, but the important thing is that we're never alone in our struggle. We have Christ, we have the saints, and of course, each other. One of my best friends in high school was gay. He did not want to be gay and Catholic and hated the Church. Because of this, when I reverted, he pushed me away. I'm glad that you are different, and are willing to try. My friend was not. Stick to the Sacraments--especially Confession and the Eucharist--as much as you can and as often as you can. I have a lot of skeletons in my closet, too, and sometimes it feels like I'm living from Mass to Mass trying to get by. The thing is that when I'm there with Him, none of that matters anymore. It doesn't matter how bad things are outside for that moment, and when I leave, I find the strength to keep carrying my burdens, if only for a little while. Doesn't change the fact that it s[i][/i]ucks, but with that help it's no longer as crippling. And maybe you [i]should[/i] check out Courage, even if you're not interested in finding a "nice Catholic girl." It might put you in contact with other guys who are facing your struggle. You'll have people to talk with that really get it, and that works wonders. I'll be praying for you, Jake. You can do this.
picchick Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 I do not have much to say that no one else has already eloquently said on the subject of homosexuality. But I can tell you about carrying crosses. Sometimes it is really really stinkin' hard and I want to do away with it. I don't understand why I have to carry this cross. It isn't a cross that gets laid on me and taken away after a few weeks or months. It is there for the rest of my life. Some days it feels like it is heavier than others. There were times where I struggled with this cross and trying to figure why God wasn't relieving it because I could bear it anymore. Yet I was stuck with it. And I was trying to figure it out. And I prayed. It hurt to pray even. I came to realize that this was MY cross. No one else could carry it. So if I didn't carry it, there would be no Simon coming a long to help me. I Here is a blog I found that kinda summed up how I felt: [quote]Lately I have been addicted to the cross. I was complaining to God the other day about all the suffering that I was going through. Suddeny admist all this whining on my part, a little voice said, "It is your cross." It is my cross. For some reason I took comfort in this phrase. My cross. At this moment, I realized how beautiful my suffering became. Jesus picked this cross for me. He knew what I could handle and knew what I could not do. He tested my strength of will and love. He tailored this cross perfectly for me. No one else has the same cross as me. Everyone suffers but everyone's suffering is not the same. Some seem to be greater than others. It is not the size of the cross that Jesus gives us that matters. It is how we use our suffering that does matter. Suffering can be done selfishly or selflessly. It is our choice as to how we carry the cross. Often times, I find myself throwing pity parties with my suffering. I suffer selfishly, using my suffering in a "woe is me" sort of way. I do not believe that this is how God intends for us to suffer. He wants us to suffer as He did in the carrying of the Cross. If we reflect on His Cross, we find that He carried it without reservations, without an expectation of help from anyone. He embraced it willingly and in full knowledge of what lie ahead. Although we do not know what lies ahead of our suffering, we must come to realize that suffering is not always about us. During my meditation on the Cross, I picture the Passion of the Christ where Jesus was presented His cross. He fell to His knees nd wrapped His arm around the Cross. Exhausted and beaten, Jesus picked up the cross and started His way to Calvary. Jesus definitely did not need to suffer and carry the Cross for Himself. He was God. If He wanted to, He could say, "Forget this, I am not doing this. You are all going to sin anyway. What is the point?" Instead, He knew that this was the only way that WE could be saved. He suffered totally, completely for US. We too can embrace our cross willingly and selflessly. By combining our suffering to Christ's Cross, we help each other. We offer our suffering up for to the Lord for our brother's and sisters. In this way, we are not alone in our suffering. Instead, we have a sort of suffering party with Christ and our brothers and sisters. The power of our suffering when done willingly and selflessly is so immense. We could offer it up for so many things: a friend in need, our family, our spouse, our boyfriend, our girlfriend, our friends, to end world hunger, to end abortion, in thanksgiving for a great joy in our lives...the list can go on and on. So after I came out of my thoughts of the cross I felt motivated to suffer. I felt like my suffering was not in vain but it useful. Christ is using my suffering, as He uses everyone's suffering, for some greater good here on earth. And in that, I find joy in suffering. Next time, when you feel alone in your suffering, think of Christ and what He went through. Not as a way to say, "Here I am complaining about my cross and Christ's Cross was so much heavier" but in a way that you can combine yours to His. No one is alone in their suffering for Christ is there with you.[/quote] meg
Sojourner Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1845930' date='Apr 24 2009, 09:55 AM']Ad-I have worked with I suppose 100+ gay clients over the years. I know how heavy a cross this is. I'm not the preaching to type when it comes to this. I will suggest a few things. First, the thing about gays turning straight being a evangelical thing. Human sexuality isn't like a North/South compass. It is more like a bell curve, and there is some give as to where we end up on that bell curve. It can be influenced by the things we do, and by the people and community we are around. You are quite young yet, and your brain is still developing. There are choices you can make that can change where you sexuality settles. My second suggestion would be Courage. Being around people dealing with the same issues can always be helpful. I have known people in Courage who chose a different course in their lives. They began a process of turning towards one direction, and eventually reached a point where they were able to make a sacramental commitment to a spouse of the opposite sex. Mostly, you have my prayers. In the end, that's about all I can offer.[/quote] I agree with Catherine's comments here. One thought I had in addition to her comments here is that marriage is not between you and the entire population of other-gendered people. There is no requirement that I find every man sexually attractive (thank God) but I do find my husband to be so. I was thinking about this earlier today, and one thing I realized is that physical attraction really has only a fleeting significance in our relationship, at least the initial "wham" of it. I find him attractive not because of his movie-star good looks but because of the love we share. I think he would say the reverse is true about me. I guess what I'm saying is that even though I had the initial inclination to be attracted to the opposite gender, I still see that I make choices about attraction and love based less on initial physical appeal and more on the reality of the person I choose to love on a daily basis and on the relationship we are building together. While we can't do much about our initial reactions and attractions, attraction over the long haul is a choice, because it flows out of love which is a choice. I think we get so hung up on surface-level attraction that we lose sight of the fact that marriage is a union of persons. While that union can only happen between a man and a woman, it is still important to remember it is one man and one woman, two individual persons, who come together and choose to love one another.
dauntingknight Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 To me it sounds like the devil is after you. Which must mean that if you can overcome this same sex thing your going through God has something special in store just for you in the future.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now