Guest Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Didacus' post='1845810' date='Apr 24 2009, 08:01 AM']Mother Mary Francis[/quote] Yes I understand that quote because to even hate in your heart makes you a murderer. I just dont get how someone like Hitler could end up in heaven but say someone else dies without repenting of 1 mortal sin the night before and they go to hell. Doesn't seem to make sence. Edited April 24, 2009 by Guest
Archaeology cat Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1845806' date='Apr 24 2009, 01:55 PM']Reallly ? Any of us ? Hmm I'm not convinced. He was pretty evil.[/quote] Yes, any of us. He didn't start out wanting to exterminate the Jews. He did start out in an abusive family. And he was influenced by other anti-Semitic writings of the time. He didn't become what he was in a vacuum. [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1845806' date='Apr 24 2009, 01:55 PM']And he would be forgiven just like that ? Interesting.[/quote] If it was a sincere repentance, then I would trust in God's mercy for that. Not that he wouldn't have had a lot of time in Purgatory, most likely, but the possibility remains that he remembered the faith of his childhood and sincerely turned back to God. The point is that we can't know. Think of the parable of the vineyard workers, where those who only arrived at the end of the day got paid the same as those who worked the entire day. Those that repent at the end of their lives are still given that reward by God, in His infinite mercy.
Guest Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1845826' date='Apr 24 2009, 08:34 AM']Yes, any of us. He didn't start out wanting to exterminate the Jews. He did start out in an abusive family. And he was influenced by other anti-Semitic writings of the time. He didn't become what he was in a vacuum.[/quote] I have a difficult time with the any of us but I know that is not your point. I wasn't aware he grew up in a abusive home. It's just funny to me some will have hope in Hitler ( I dont know how ?) yet they will be the first to say that a protestant isn't going to achieve salvation because their outside of the Church. So if Hitler made it to heaven how could anyone really end up in hell ? [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1845826' date='Apr 24 2009, 08:34 AM']If it was a sincere repentance, then I would trust in God's mercy for that. Not that he wouldn't have had a lot of time in Purgatory, most likely, but the possibility remains that he remembered the faith of his childhood and sincerely turned back to God. The point is that we can't know. Think of the parable of the vineyard workers, where those who only arrived at the end of the day got paid the same as those who worked the entire day. Those that repent at the end of their lives are still given that reward by God, in His infinite mercy.[/quote] The same question comes to mind. If Hitler makes it to Heaven how could anyone end up in hell ? I think it's a very fair question. Edited April 24, 2009 by Guest
Archaeology cat Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1845830' date='Apr 24 2009, 02:43 PM']The same question comes to mind. If Hitler makes it to Heaven how could anyone end up in hell ? I think it's a very fair question.[/quote] If Hitler made it, it would be because of truly repenting and making an act of perfect contrition at the end of his life. If someone rejects God all their lives, and doesn't change at the end, I would venture to say that person would not go to Heaven because of their rejection of God. This is, of course, just my opinion, as I am not a theologian and am not an expert on such matters. So just speculation on my part here.
Didacus Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 DB; If God's grace is infinite then how hard can it be to believe that He can forgive anything we do? We are finite, our evil thus is also finite, but God is infinite; He surpasses us in every way. I find it harder to believe He cannot forgive even a man of the sort of Hitler than that He cannot. With that said, I can't imagine Hitler being in heaven either, but sometimes you just have to bare ignorance and trust the AllMighty. What I appreciate for your posts is that your lack of undertanding (which again, I do believe I share in some respect) does not bring you to question God's palce and validity. That's a good thing. At least I'm pretty sure it is.
Guest Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1845838' date='Apr 24 2009, 09:54 AM']If Hitler made it, it would be because of truly repenting and making an act of perfect contrition at the end of his life. If someone rejects God all their lives, and doesn't change at the end, I would venture to say that person would not go to Heaven because of their rejection of God. This is, of course, just my opinion, as I am not a theologian and am not an expert on such matters. So just speculation on my part here. [/quote] Gotcha Gotcha. Godbless [quote name='Didacus' post='1845839' date='Apr 24 2009, 09:55 AM']DB; If God's grace is infinite then how hard can it be to believe that He can forgive anything we do? We are finite, our evil thus is also finite, but God is infinite; He surpasses us in every way. I find it harder to believe He cannot forgive even a man of the sort of Hitler than that He cannot. With that said, I can't imagine Hitler being in heaven either, but sometimes you just have to bare ignorance and trust the AllMighty. What I appreciate for your posts is that your lack of undertanding (which again, I do believe I share in some respect) does not bring you to question God's palce and validity. That's a good thing. At least I'm pretty sure it is.[/quote] Ok I love where you're going Didacus because it leads me to then question if there is an eternal hell for human souls ? Note I say question as I do believe in it since Jesus told us about it as well as other apostles. But since we are just talking it would seem that if God could forgive hitler (which i'm not against as long as hitler would be eternally good) then God could forgive everyone. Surely if Hitler is forgivable then everyone would be. That reminds me of the lost books of the Bible where one book says that it's a secret that one day God will let everyone into Heaven. Now I dont believe that or hold on to that hope but at the same time I could see how its phathomable. It would almost seem if this were the case that purgatory and hell would be somewhat of the same. I mean is it really that impossible to think God would allow suffering souls out of hell one day ? I dont think it is although I dont see how that could include satan and the fallan angels as well ? Because if that were the case it seems like everything might happen all over again when eternity finally ran its course. lol Now im thinking way to deep. It's probally unwise to think that deep. I'll stop now. Edited April 24, 2009 by Guest
Didacus Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 Eternity is not an infinite amount of time, it is the absence of time. That is a key differentiation that is necessary to properly comprehending the heavenly and damned states. Purgatory is not eternal however, it is a temporal thing.
princessgianna Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [font="Georgia"][b]Love the sinner, hate the sin! [/b] [/font] Pax~
Guest Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='Didacus' post='1845981' date='Apr 24 2009, 11:28 AM']Eternity is not an infinite amount of time, it is the absence of time. That is a key differentiation that is necessary to properly comprehending the heavenly and damned states.[/quote] I didn't think of it that way...hmmm....interesting... I assumed at some point eternity would run it's course...
Didacus Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='pat22' post='1846022' date='Apr 24 2009, 01:05 PM']I just did a presentation on him for school.[/quote] How did it go? Spill the beans here. You can't just drop a bomb like that and walk away. What are you somekind of joker?
princessgianna Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='Didacus' post='1846126' date='Apr 24 2009, 01:45 PM']How did it go? Spill the beans here. You can't just drop a bomb like that and walk away. What are you somekind of joker?[/quote] no kidding !
CoffeeCatholic Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 the fact that God suffered and died for people like Hitler and Stalin, knowing who they were and what they would do in their lifetime make's His sacrifice of Love even more amazing, and makes their deeds even more horrid. But if God can love the unlovable, then we can too. Christ, fully man, proved the impossible, possible.
dauntingknight Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 Larry: Do you know why the Russian's couldn't win World War II? Bob: I don't know why? Larry: 'Cause the kept Stalin(stall-in).
goldenchild17 Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1845814' date='Apr 24 2009, 08:04 AM']True but I don't see how he could be ?[/quote] maybe he is maybe he isn't. I don't know if the other posters are indicating he could be in heaven or not. Personally I have no reason to believe he is. I don't think there is any reason to believe he changed his ways and accepted any form of the necessary sacraments to be saved (though that's starting a whole new debate so no need to go there). If anyone is in hell, its probably him. I still try not to hate him, but now feel sorry for where he has to be and pray other people who think like him can recognize what happened to him and change their ways. Edited April 24, 2009 by goldenchild17
Aloysius Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 the most likely candidate in all of history for an eternal fate in hell is Judas, since Jesus pretty much said it would be better for him if he had never been born. Hitler ranks high up there among the very likely residents of the eternal flames.
goldenchild17 Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1846222' date='Apr 24 2009, 04:15 PM']the most likely candidate in all of history for an eternal fate in hell is Judas, since Jesus pretty much said it would be better for him if he had never been born. Hitler ranks high up there among the very likely residents of the eternal flames.[/quote] you're right, my mistake. I'm sometimes known to struggle with hyperbole in order to make a point
Winchester Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='dauntingknight' post='1846155' date='Apr 24 2009, 03:26 PM']Larry: Do you know why the Russian's couldn't win World War II?[/quote] The Russian's what?
Vincent Vega Posted April 24, 2009 Posted April 24, 2009 [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1845799' date='Apr 24 2009, 08:37 AM']Yes you're a trillion times more deserving of Gods mercy then Hitler. If Hitler wound up in Heaven somehow It would blow my mind. I dont know how he possibly could ?[/quote] Reminds me of the joke: A guys dies, and gets to the pearly gates, walks up to St. Peter and says, "So I made it?? Oh thank God! I was a little worried for a minute." St. Peter says, "Yes, brother, you did. Now come, I'll give you a tour." So they walk in, and St. Peter starts showing him around. He notices some of the others there, and expresses his shock to St. Peter (quietly, of course) at seeing them. "Mary Ann? She's here!? She cheated on her husband!", "Jack!? He was fired for embezzling from his company!", "Miss Van Stern!? She was the worst teacher who ever lived!", and so forth, seeing people he was even more surprised at seeing. All of a sudden, he realised everyone was silent, and that they were all looking at him. He asked St. Peter what was going on, and St. Peter responded,... "They're all shocked to see [i][b]YOU[/b][/i]!" A funny little joke that reminds us about the log that we have in our own eye sometimes (and this isn't directed at you, DB, but at everyone).
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now