tinytherese Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 My roommate is a pseudo catholic and I'm afraid that the culture issue plays at least some part in that. She preferred attending a Pentecostal Church last year because it "had drums."
Vincent Vega Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1850808' date='Apr 27 2009, 08:11 PM']It shouldn't even be allowed in Africa. The Mass isn't a performance, and liturgical dance clearly takes the focus away from Christ and onto the dancers.[/quote] I disagree. It's all about cultural context. In the Western Church, kneeling is a sign of deep reverence. In the Eastern Church, standing is a sign of deep revernce. In Africa, perhaps dance is a sign of reverence - I don't know, I'm not African. I don't know what is considered most reverent. Accordingly, I'm not going to judge whether or not it's appropriate, since I don't know. Now, an African cardinal might know, considering his circumstances.
saintwannabe 777 Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1850808' date='Apr 27 2009, 09:11 PM']It shouldn't even be allowed in Africa. The Mass isn't a performance, and liturgical dance clearly takes the focus away from Christ and onto the dancers. Besides, I don't think Card. Arinze heads the Congregation for Divine Worship anymore does he? Didn't the new prefect celebrate an EF Mass a few weeks ago with the Franciscans of the Immaculate?[/quote] Why are you saying it shouldn't be allowed in Africa? That's part of our culture.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='saintwannabe 777' post='1850888' date='Apr 27 2009, 11:14 PM']Why are you saying it shouldn't be allowed in Africa? That's part of our culture.[/quote] THat is exactly why it is.
picchick Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='AbsconditaInDeo' post='1849915' date='Apr 27 2009, 09:44 AM']I went to a non-English speaking parish and the Gospel was read by an altar boy[/quote] I didn't know that this was an abuse... [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1850834' date='Apr 27 2009, 09:37 PM']I disagree. It's all about cultural context. In the Western Church, kneeling is a sign of deep reverence. In the Eastern Church, standing is a sign of deep revernce. In Africa, perhaps dance is a sign of reverence - I don't know, I'm not African. I don't know what is considered most reverent. Accordingly, I'm not going to judge whether or not it's appropriate, since I don't know. Now, an African cardinal might know, considering his circumstances. [/quote] Agreed
Brother Adam Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='picchick' post='1850897' date='Apr 27 2009, 11:19 PM']I didn't know that this was an abuse...[/quote] It's actually a pretty serious abuse. Only a deacon, priest, or bishop may read the Gospel.
AdAltareDei Posted April 28, 2009 Author Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='saintwannabe 777' post='1850888' date='Apr 27 2009, 10:14 PM']Why are you saying it shouldn't be allowed in Africa? That's part of our culture.[/quote] Because the Mass isn't about showing off your culture. It's about adoring Our Lord in the Eucharist and meditating on the readings. The focus should be on Christ, not people dancing. Besides, as Catholics we have our own culture. Greogrian and polyphonic chant is our proper heritage.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1850922' date='Apr 27 2009, 11:42 PM']Because the Mass isn't about showing off your culture. It's about adoring Our Lord in the Eucharist and meditating on the readings. The focus should be on Christ, not people dancing. Besides, as Catholics we have our own culture. Greogrian and polyphonic chant is our proper heritage.[/quote] Africa has a tradition of religious dance, which is why its allowed.
picchick Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1850921' date='Apr 27 2009, 10:41 PM']It's actually a pretty serious abuse. Only a deacon, priest, or bishop may read the Gospel.[/quote] Excuse my dumb moment...I meant the readings...not the gospel. I misread it. I know that only a priest or higher can read the Gospel...I was just mixing things in my head. [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1850922' date='Apr 27 2009, 10:42 PM']Because the Mass isn't about showing off your culture. It's about adoring Our Lord in the Eucharist and meditating on the readings. The focus should be on Christ, not people dancing. Besides, as Catholics we have our own culture. Greogrian and polyphonic chant is our proper heritage.[/quote] wrong. Mass reflects our culture. Not everyone was from Rome. Thus we have the Eastern Rite. I won't get into that because I am not well versed in it. Thereofre Gregorian and polyphonic chant is not our proper heritage. And I will highly doubt that the very early Church used Greograin Chant. It wasn't until later that that form of Chant was used. Other forms of Chant existed but not Gregorian. However, the Catholic Church has adapted many cultural practices so that it becomes accepted and understood by the people. For example, St. Patrick used symbols that pagans would have used to describe God and the Trinity. St. Boniface used the evergreen tree to demonstrate the same to the pagans in Germany. Now do you celebrate Christmas with a Christmas tree? Is your Church decorated with it at Christmastime? Dancing in cultures such as Mexico and Africa is not for entertainment but for praise. We, in the Western Church kneel, beat our breast, sing, et. al. to show God praise. In those cultures, they do it as a form of respect and paise.
tinytherese Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='tinytherese' post='1850811' date='Apr 27 2009, 09:15 PM']My roommate is a pseudo catholic and I'm afraid that the culture issue plays at least some part in that. She preferred attending a Pentecostal Church last year because it "had drums."[/quote] Oops, forgot to mention that she's from Zimbabwe.
Vincent Vega Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1850922' date='Apr 27 2009, 09:42 PM']Besides, as Catholics we have our own culture. Greogrian and polyphonic chant is our proper heritage.[/quote] As [i]LATIN[/i] Catholics. There are 22 other Sui Iuris Churches, including the Syro-Malankara, Syro-Malabar, and Coptic Churches, the first two being found primarily in the Indian subcontinent, and the latter from Egypt. I bet they have some customs and traditions that would seem very alien to you, and if you went up to them and told them that Gregorian chant was their "proper heritage", you'd probably get a look like this:
AdAltareDei Posted April 28, 2009 Author Posted April 28, 2009 In respones to all: Gregorian Chant is proper to the Latin Rite. Someone said "we aren't all Roman". I'm sorry, but we are all part of the Latin rite. So in a sense, we are. You can't use the example of the Eastern Churches, because they are different Rites and have different Masses and legitimate cultures. Africans are part of the Latin rite, so Mass should be celebrated according to the norms of the Latin Rite. Inculturation shouldn't be allowed. my opinion.
AdAltareDei Posted April 28, 2009 Author Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1851009' date='Apr 27 2009, 11:29 PM']As [i]LATIN[/i] Catholics. There are 22 other Sui Iuris Churches, including the Syro-Malankara, Syro-Malabar, and Coptic Churches, the first two being found primarily in the Indian subcontinent, and the latter from Egypt. I bet they have some customs and traditions that would seem very alien to you, and if you went up to them and told them that Gregorian chant was their "proper heritage", you'd probably get a look like this: [/quote] I should have been more specific, Latin rite Catholics have a heritage of gregorian and polyphonic chant. But the African Church is Latin Rite. Yeah sure. The other rites all have their own beautiful musical and liturgical traditions. I bet you that none of them include "liturgical" dancing.
picchick Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1851014' date='Apr 27 2009, 11:36 PM']In respones to all: Gregorian Chant is proper to the Latin Rite. Someone said "we aren't all Roman". I'm sorry, but we are all part of the Latin rite. So in a sense, we are. You can't use the example of the Eastern Churches, because they are different Rites and have different Masses and legitimate cultures. Africans are part of the Latin rite, so Mass should be celebrated according to the norms of the Latin Rite. Inculturation shouldn't be allowed. my opinion.[/quote] I am not Latin Rite. I do not consider myself to be so. I grew up Latin Rite but I am going more and more towards the Eastern Rite. Exactly right...your opinion. [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1851017' date='Apr 27 2009, 11:39 PM']I should have been more specific, Latin rite Catholics have a heritage of gregorian and polyphonic chant. But the African Church is Latin Rite. Yeah sure. The other rites all have their own beautiful musical and liturgical traditions. I bet you that none of them include "liturgical" dancing.[/quote] Yet you consider African/Mexican Dance "liturgical"?
CatholicCid Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='picchick' post='1851022' date='Apr 27 2009, 10:43 PM']I am not Latin Rite. I do not consider myself to be so. I grew up Latin Rite but I am going more and more towards the Eastern Rite. Exactly right...your opinion.[/quote] Unless you've officially changed your status, you would remain canonically Latin Rite (if you were originally Latin Rite, e.g. Your father is Latin Rite) and be bound by such fasting obligations (though the Eastern Rites generally have more stricter fasts). Which Rite are you leaning toward now?
AdAltareDei Posted April 28, 2009 Author Posted April 28, 2009 If you're eastern rite thats fine. You're very lucky. But that doesn't justify dance in the Mass. I'm sure you've never seen a bunch of dancers entering the sanctuary if you attend an eastern rite Mass. Who said I consider African/Mexican dance liturgical :s I'm arguing that it doesn't belong in the liturgy. At all. Each rite has its own traditions which have grown organically and have a legitimate place in worship. Dance isn't one of these traditions.
CatholicCid Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 How does one decide which tradition organically grown in a Rite is a tradition? Practices that might seem traditional in America may be different then those seen in Africa.
AdAltareDei Posted April 28, 2009 Author Posted April 28, 2009 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='1851037' date='Apr 27 2009, 10:55 PM']How does one decide which tradition organically grown in a Rite is a tradition? Practices that might seem traditional in America may be different then those seen in Africa.[/quote] It's not about countries. America and Africa both belong to the latin right, and up until 10 or 20 years ago liturgical dance was unheard of in the Latin Rite. Not to mention it's so prone to abuse and changing the focus of the Mass. I live in Australia, does that mean that we should start introducing the didgeridoo into the Mass (which I've seen)? No.
CatholicCid Posted April 28, 2009 Posted April 28, 2009 But could not two different traditions organically grow into the liturgy in two different locations, even if the tradition might seem inappropriate in the opposite location? (I was actually asking how you think such traditions would spring up btw, not trying to make a point. The location would seem to have to play some factor.)
AdAltareDei Posted April 28, 2009 Author Posted April 28, 2009 I'm not sure how the traditions "spring up". Usually once they do, they are sanctioned or condemned by the Church. Liturgical dance is relatively new so I suppose it hasn't got to that point yet. I just believe its inappropriate and doesn't belong in the Mass. It takes the attention off of the Eucharist and turns Mass into a performance.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now