mmc4 Posted April 29, 2009 Posted April 29, 2009 I was in my history class yesterday, and we were reviewing our notes on Islam and the Muslim culture. We were talking about how the Islamic people would tax non-believers, and one girl said, "Well why didn't they just say they were Islamic so they didn't have to pay?" And my teacher explained that it would be denying their own god and lying about their faith, and she said, "Well it's like the Catholics being persecuted. Even though I'm a Catholic, I would've said I wasn't just so I wouldn't get killed. Then I'd go back to being Catholic." That just hit me really hard. I can't even imagine how people can just be (insert religion here) when it's convenient for them. That's really bad. I don't think I'm the only one this bothers though.
KnightofChrist Posted April 29, 2009 Posted April 29, 2009 Problem: She and those like her don't really believe or trust in Jesus Christ.
VoTeckam Posted April 29, 2009 Posted April 29, 2009 I'm with you. I once read and article though about a girl who denied her faith during the columbine tragedy and she was later flooded with guilt. I do not think she was catholic, but she was talking to her pastor about this and he told her it was not a sin beacuse to confess her faith at that moment would have been to essentially commit suicide. While martyrdom is something that is obviously pius and noble, is it the right thing to do if say you have small children nobody else can care for? It is not as black and white as I'd like it to be.
trustandgratitude Posted April 29, 2009 Posted April 29, 2009 hi, i'm new hear but this looks like an interesting topic.
Seven77 Posted April 29, 2009 Posted April 29, 2009 It sure bothered St. Thomas Moore. He was martyred for not going along with King Henry VIII and staying true to the Catholic Church.
mmc4 Posted April 29, 2009 Author Posted April 29, 2009 I know. It is true, I mean when you're held at gunpoint like that I'm sure it would be really hard for someone. Especially someone with young kids or someone who suffers under worse circumstances. That just struck me because that's not the only instance she's talked badly about her Faith; she aways complains about being Catholic saying that she hates it, but when it's convenient for her to be Catholic, say when a boy asks her, she admits it in a heartbeat.
puellapaschalis Posted April 29, 2009 Posted April 29, 2009 Last week I watched [i]Karol: a man who became Pope[/i] on dvd (for the upteenth time!). Learning about Catholics who were shot by Nazis for really being Catholic is very confrontational.
MIKolbe Posted April 29, 2009 Posted April 29, 2009 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1852415' date='Apr 29 2009, 03:03 PM']Problem: She and those like her don't really believe or trust in Jesus Christ.[/quote] yeah!!! and if they did it three times, they could be just like Peter, and we all know HE really didn't believe or trust in Jesus Christ. Leave the mind-reading and other omniscient skills to God. thanks
CatherineM Posted April 29, 2009 Posted April 29, 2009 There was a time in the church right after the original persecutions stopped that there was much debate on whether those who denied the faith to keep their jobs or positions, or lives, should be allowed to come back in. Some martyrs begged for forgiveness for those who couldn't stand up when it counted, sometimes right before being sent to the lions. So, they let them back in, but they had to do the whole "sack cloth and ashes" bit for a year or two.
saintwannabe 777 Posted April 29, 2009 Posted April 29, 2009 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1852514' date='Apr 29 2009, 06:55 PM']There was a time in the church right after the original persecutions stopped that there was much debate on whether those who denied the faith to keep their jobs or positions, or lives, should be allowed to come back in. Some martyrs begged for forgiveness for those who couldn't stand up when it counted, sometimes right before being sent to the lions. So, they let them back in, but they had to do the whole "sack cloth and ashes" bit for a year or two.[/quote] Now is one of those times when it counts. The persecutions will build and build and inevitably, they will return to those times.
mmc4 Posted April 29, 2009 Author Posted April 29, 2009 I just got back from Youth Group and we got letters back from the Bishop, and what his letter said was so ironic: "...Let me tell you about two teenage Chinese martyrs: One of the martyrs was a 14 year-old girl named Ann Wang who died during the Boxer Rebellion in 1900 because she refused to deny Jesus. Her executioners cut off her right arm to make her submit, but she remained firm. As she was about to be beheaded, three times she lovingly called out the name of Jesus. Augustine Zhao Rong was a Chinese priest who was martyred with his 119 companions in 1815. Among their number was an 18 year-old boy, Chi Zhuzi, who had his right arm cut off by his executioners. As they prepared to skin him alive, he cried out: 'Every piece of my flesh and every drop of my blood will tell you that I am a Christian.' That only made me wonder more about people who deny their Faith in the face of fear. Fear of rejection, death, or what have you.
tinytherese Posted April 30, 2009 Posted April 30, 2009 [quote name='MIkolbe' post='1852510' date='Apr 29 2009, 06:52 PM']yeah!!! and if they did it three times, they could be just like Peter, and we all know HE really didn't believe or trust in Jesus Christ. Leave the mind-reading and other omniscient skills to God. thanks[/quote] Oh snap!
KnightofChrist Posted May 1, 2009 Posted May 1, 2009 (edited) [quote name='MIkolbe' post='1852510' date='Apr 29 2009, 05:52 PM']yeah!!! and if they did it three times, they could be just like Peter, and we all know HE really didn't believe or trust in Jesus Christ. Leave the mind-reading and other omniscient skills to God. thanks[/quote] When Peter denied Christ did Peter trust Christ? No, if Peter trusted in Christ those three times he would not have denied Him. When Peter denied Christ he rejected Christ, during those moments he did not really believe in Christ or he would not have denied Him. When Peter denied the Holy Name of God, he denied God, I can not see how your logic works. Only that Peter later repented, believed and trusted in Christ. But at the moment of denying Christ, he did not trust or believe in the Lord. Edited May 1, 2009 by KnightofChrist
lost_in_this_world Posted May 1, 2009 Posted May 1, 2009 I used to think the same thing about Jewish people in the Holocaust. Now I know different.
Sojourner Posted May 1, 2009 Posted May 1, 2009 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1853796' date='Apr 30 2009, 08:36 PM']When Peter denied Christ did Peter trust Christ? No, if Peter trusted in Christ those three times he would not have denied Him. When Peter denied Christ he rejected Christ, during those moments he did not really believe in Christ or he would not have denied Him. When Peter denied the Holy Name of God, he denied God, I can not see how your logic works. Only that Peter later repented, believed and trusted in Christ. But at the moment of denying Christ, he did not trust or believe in the Lord.[/quote] I don't think that's a completely fair assessment of Peter's faith. Just because a person falters in their faith in a time of duress does not mean they don't have faith/trust. It just means they are human and have a ways to go before their faith is perfected. A weak faith still exists, it is just not yet ready to face life-or-death challenges (which is what Peter was facing). Development of faith is something like human development. You start out as a baby needing special care and feeding, and gradually grow into a fuller appreciation of what it means to be who you are. Peter had baby faith. It got bigger later, but I have no doubt it was still there when he denied Christ.
Old_Joe Posted May 1, 2009 Posted May 1, 2009 [quote name='mmc4' post='1852382' date='Apr 29 2009, 04:39 PM']I was in my history class yesterday, and we were reviewing our notes on Islam and the Muslim culture. We were talking about how the Islamic people would tax non-believers, and one girl said, "Well why didn't they just say they were Islamic so they didn't have to pay?" And my teacher explained that it would be denying their own god and lying about their faith, and she said, "Well it's like the Catholics being persecuted. Even though I'm a Catholic, I would've said I wasn't just so I wouldn't get killed. Then I'd go back to being Catholic." That just hit me really hard. I can't even imagine how people can just be (insert religion here) when it's convenient for them. That's really bad. I don't think I'm the only one this bothers though.[/quote] I heard something similar regarding the Jews when we were studying WWII in my high school history class. I immediately thought, "You might as well ask them not to breathe."
KnightofChrist Posted May 1, 2009 Posted May 1, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1853892' date='Apr 30 2009, 10:20 PM']I don't think that's a completely fair assessment of Peter's faith. Just because a person falters in their faith in a time of duress does not mean they don't have faith/trust. It just means they are human and have a ways to go before their faith is perfected. A weak faith still exists, it is just not yet ready to face life-or-death challenges (which is what Peter was facing). Development of faith is something like human development. You start out as a baby needing special care and feeding, and gradually grow into a fuller appreciation of what it means to be who you are. Peter had baby faith. It got bigger later, but I have no doubt it was still there when he denied Christ.[/quote] I think it is fair. When he denied Christ, he denied Christ. Not kinda sorta. But fully three different times. Simple understanding of the law of non-contradiction will tell you, that you can not truly believe and deny Christ at the same time. When Peter saw what he and done 'he wept bitterly' because he knew that he had not trusted in Christ and had rejected Him. Edited May 1, 2009 by KnightofChrist
StColette Posted May 1, 2009 Posted May 1, 2009 mmc, Yes, it's very troubling that someone would deny Christ to save themselves. As MIkolbe pointed out, even Peter, in a time of great duress, denied Christ and look he was the leader of the Apostles and the First Pope. In fact, all of the Apostles, save John, fled in order to save themselves. The other Apostles and Peter became greatly remorseful for denying the Lord and sought forgiveness for such an act. But, we are all guilty of denying or not trusting in Christ often in our lives. Each time we sin, even venial sin, we are turning our backs on Christ. We are cutting ourselves off, sometimes completely, from him. We have taken for granted the great gift of His sacrifice upon the cross. Yes, denial of the Lord hurts Christ deeply, but we all share in that hurt in some manor, some more than others, each time we sin. So, I believe this is a good thing to keep in mind when thinking about others and the judgments that they would make. Again, we are all guilty of denying and not trusting in Christ.
KnightofChrist Posted May 1, 2009 Posted May 1, 2009 [quote name='StColette' post='1854263' date='May 1 2009, 12:18 PM']mmc, Yes, it's very troubling that someone would deny Christ to save themselves. As MIkolbe pointed out, even Peter, in a time of great duress, denied Christ and look he was the leader of the Apostles and the First Pope. In fact, all of the Apostles, save John, fled in order to save themselves. The other Apostles and Peter became greatly remorseful for denying the Lord and sought forgiveness for such an act. But, we are all guilty of denying or not trusting in Christ often in our lives. Each time we sin, even venial sin, we are turning our backs on Christ. We are cutting ourselves off, sometimes completely, from him. We have taken for granted the great gift of His sacrifice upon the cross. Yes, denial of the Lord hurts Christ deeply, but we all share in that hurt in some manor, some more than others, each time we sin.[/quote] Indeed.
HisChildForever Posted May 1, 2009 Posted May 1, 2009 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1854253' date='May 1 2009, 11:48 AM']I think it is fair. When he denied Christ, he denied Christ. Not kinda sorta. But fully three different times. Simple understanding of the law of non-contradiction will tell you, that you can not truly believe and deny Christ at the same time. When Peter saw what he and done 'he wept bitterly' because he knew that he had not trusted in Christ and had rejected Him.[/quote] At one time or another, we all deny Christ. This does not mean that we completely throw away our faith, it means that we are caught up in a time of weakness and human emotion. How many people, mourning the loss of a loved one, blame God and get angry with Him? How many of those individuals rage "If God existed this would not have happened" to friends and family, in a moment of despair and grief? Being a Christian is very hard a lot of the time. If it is hard for us, how hard was it for men like Peter who went through such emotional turmoil (doubting and such) firsthand? He was afraid for his life. Who knows, maybe he had a brief crisis of faith when he saw Christ being dragged away. Maybe in that instant he wondered if this man was really the Messiah, as how could a Messiah be overpowered like that? Peter was a holy and devout man - he was our first Pope! - but he was a sinner just like the rest of us. Scripture does not go into detail about his thoughts or the countless emotions he was experiencing during Good Friday. It is wrong to say that you can not truly believe AND deny Christ at the same time, because like I said, we ALL have denied Christ at one point or another. Are you telling me that a man like Peter never truly believed in Christ all that time because he denied Christ out of fear and weakness? Peter wept bitterly because of his sin and because he had displeased God. But keeping your initial claim in mind, we all must not be true Christians, then. How about reverts to the Catholic faith? Do they not have a "true" faith in Christ because they at once fell from the Church? It is wrong to judge others in this way.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now