Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Kurall_creator Offical Thread


Recommended Posts

Kurall_Creator
Posted

Hey guys. I am so proud of myself today. 5 of 7 class marks have come in for this semester, and I'm at a 82 per cent average, which means I am probably on the dean's list.

I am so proud of myself, and the journey I had this year. But now that my first project is fully done, I have to go onto the next, which is going to be really cool. I turn back the clock on the stories, and tell the origin of Kurall, how he learned of his ability and his growth from childhood to just before the first issue web comic.

It's probably going to take 2-3 months, maybe even late August before I am done it, but that is my next goal for myself.

After that, I think I am going to do things a little differently.

So, I am starting this thread, just to talk about my journey with all of you.

I hope you all keep tuning in to the same Kurall Time and the same Kurall channel when I post something up on this.

I am so excited for the next step.

TotusTuusMaria
Posted

congrats!!!

Posted

[quote name='Kurall_Creator' post='1855194' date='May 1 2009, 09:11 PM']Hey guys. I am so proud of myself today. 5 of 7 class marks have come in for this semester, and I'm at a 82 per cent average, which means I am probably on the dean's list.[/quote]

What country or school is that? Every school I know in America requires a 3.5gpa for deans list (about an 89-90% average).

Kurall_Creator
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Slappo' post='1855418' date='May 2 2009, 09:51 AM']What country or school is that? Every school I know in America requires a 3.5gpa for deans list (about an 89-90% average).[/quote]

You must be going to university or something.

It's always been get 80 per cent it was a 4.0 GP in a course.

Then you took the GPs of all our courses multiply it by course credits, and then once you get the total GP for all courses, you divided by the GP and get the GPA.

For Example,
7 courses

Course 1 - 5 credits - 70 per cent average (or 3 GP) - total 15 Grade Points
Course 2 - 3 credits - 75 (or 3) - total 9 grade points.
Course 3 - 3 credits - 70 (or 3) - total 9 grade points.
Course 4 - 2 credits - 85 (4) - total 8 grade points.
Course 5 - 2 credits - 90(4) - total 8 grade points.
Course 6 - 1 credits - 95(1) - total 4 grade points.

15 + 9 + 9 + 8 + 8 + 4 = 53 Grade Points.
Total Possible Grade Points - 64 grade points.

53/64 = 82 per cent average and a GPA of 3.3. Added to this - they take the marks and multiply it by the credit level of the course too for your average.

so in that example it would be - 350 + 225 + 210 + 170 + 180 + 95 (This actually makes it harder - as you can see - before the two 2 credit courses had 8 gps, which is 90 per cent of the 9 gps for the 3 credit course, now they are substancially reduced)

That would mean - They would get a 76 per cent average - and not be on the deans list. Where the old system they would be close, this one there are a little farther away.

That's kinda how my marking system works at college. Not all courses are treated equally, There is one that is always weighted the most, but it is the most important in the course.

In my course, the 5 credit course is Animation (Hey, the course is a 3d-animation course, so who would figure that would be the most heavily weighed course).

Right now my marks are

Animation - 5 credits - no mark yet.
Networking - 2 credits - no mark yet.
CD/DVD production - 3 credits - 85 - 12 credits.
Web Design - 3 credits - 83 - 12 credits.
Art Direction - 2 credits - 81 - 8 credits.
Programming - 2 credits - 85 - 8 credits.
Marketing - 1 credit - 72 - 3 credits.

So right now I have a 43 credits of 44 in the old system. To get on the deans list I would only need to get a C in animation and a B in networking, which wouldn't really be fair to be on the deans list, because if someone is only getting a C is the highest graded course to be on the Deans List is ridiculous.

However, if you take it down to per centages - I have 908 weighted average (marks compared to grade points). To be on the deans list this semester I have to have 1440 weighted average, so an extra 532 weighted average. That means I have to pretty much get a A (80 or higher) in Animation to be on the deans list.

I hope that explains my marking system.

It's a lot tougher to get on the Deans list than the previous ways.

Edited by Kurall_Creator
Posted (edited)

Wierd.. an 80% is an A?
It's a 93% for an A here... 80% is a -B

System here is:
Each credit is worth up to 4.0 quality points
Here is a breakdown of the mark needed to get points.
A (93-100) = 4.0 points per credit
-A (90-92) = 3.7 points per credit
+B (88-89) = 3.3 points per credit
B (83-87) = 3.0 ...etc
-B (80-82) = 2.7
+C (78-79) = 2.3
C (73-77) = 2.0
ETC...

An A in a 3 credit course is worth 4.0points*3 credits = 12

To get deans list you have to have a 3.5gpa (3.5 quality point average per credit. Quality points/total credits)

For deans list with 16 credit (which is what I am taking) I then need 56 quality points out of a maximum of 64.

The number of credits a class is is usually determined by the number of hours a week are spent in the classroom. I have a seminar class which is only 1 hour a week so it is only 1 credit. Some math classes are 4 credit classes because they meet 4 days a week. Most classes are 3 credits.

Edited by Slappo
SaintOlaf
Posted

I totally have no idea how his grades work, I just sat there and tried to figure it out.... I'll just take his word for it :P

Posted

I kind of understand your marking system now. I had to read over it again...

The big difference is you get full grade points for an 82% where as at my school you would only get 2.7 grade points. So at my school your **/** would be:

Animation - 5 credits - no mark yet.
Networking - 2 credits - no mark yet.
CD/DVD production - 3 credits - 85 - 9 points
Web Design - 3 credits - 83 - 9 points
Art Direction - 2 credits - 81 - 5.4 points
Programming - 2 credits - 85 - 6 points
Marketing - 1 credit - 72 - 1.7 points
31.1/44 total so far
which would be a GPA of 31.1/11 (number of points/number of credits) =2.8272
If you got a 100 in animation and a 100 in networking you still couldn't make deans list at my school.

Animation 5 credits - 100 - 20 points
Networking 2 credits - 100 - 8 points
would give you 59.1/72 possible.
59.1/17 (points/credits) = 3.4764

You would be just shy of the deans list. :smokey:

I don't really see how the old system was easier :)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='SaintOlaf' post='1855489' date='May 2 2009, 10:40 AM']I totally have no idea how his grades work, I just sat there and tried to figure it out.... I'll just take his word for it :P[/quote]

What they do is:
Number of credits * grade percent

15 credit hours would have a possible 1500 points

He is saying that with 1700 possible points he needs a 1440 = an 84.7% average.

That's a really odd system.

Edited by Slappo
SaintOlaf
Posted

OK I get it now, thanks for breaking it down into non-math-wizz terms for me :P

Kurall_Creator
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Slappo' post='1855517' date='May 2 2009, 12:57 PM']I kind of understand your marking system now. I had to read over it again...

The big difference is you get full grade points for an 82% where as at my school you would only get 2.7 grade points. So at my school your **/** would be:

Animation - 5 credits - no mark yet.
Networking - 2 credits - no mark yet.
CD/DVD production - 3 credits - 85 - 9 points
Web Design - 3 credits - 83 - 9 points
Art Direction - 2 credits - 81 - 5.4 points
Programming - 2 credits - 85 - 6 points
Marketing - 1 credit - 72 - 1.7 points
31.1/44 total so far
which would be a GPA of 31.1/11 (number of points/number of credits) =2.8272
If you got a 100 in animation and a 100 in networking you still couldn't make deans list at my school.

Animation 5 credits - 100 - 20 points
Networking 2 credits - 100 - 8 points
would give you 59.1/72 possible.
59.1/17 (points/credits) = 3.4764

You would be just shy of the deans list. :smokey:

I don't really see how the old system was easier :)[/quote]


I think I can see the differences. Correct me if I am wrong, but the way your marketing system works is you are marked in comparison to the other students in the class, based on criteria. In Canada, there is a somewhat different approach.

Let me break down one of my assignments I had in Art Direction. My prof there always provides this kind of feed back when she supplies marks.

Needs much improvement Marginally under expectations Minimally met Expectations Met Expectations Met Expectations very well Outstanding job
ESSAY [15%]: research completed as requested, writing style, use of grammar and spelling, fun factor for reader

(3 points)
Did not include most areas that were requested (as included on Project sheet) and/or poor use of grammar and spelling. Did not use "own voice" in writing.

(5 points)
Did not cover enough areas as requested on Project sheet. Poor use of grammar and spelling in many spaces. Did not use "own voice" in writing.

(7.5 points)
Marginally covered areas requested; grammar and spelling incorrect in several places. Could use more opinions and commentary rather than just fact.

(11 points)
Covered most areas as requested, acceptable use of grammar, spelling. Used some of own observations and opinions interspersed with facts.

(13 points) (My mark for my essay)
Good job in covering areas requested in an entertaining fashion, good use of grammar, spelling. Fun to read!

(15 points)
Exceptional job in covering all areas requested in an entertaining fashion, excellent use of grammar, spelling. Engaging and fun to read!

CHARACTER SKETCHES [20%]: 10 preliminary sketches/written notes/research images and final drawing in colour

(5 points)
Did not research as requested; did not include number of or directions requested in development sketches

(8 points)
Did some research and character development work but not enough to provide a competent character design

(10 points)
Did marginal research and character development; minimun in final character presentation

(15 points) (My mark for my drawings)
Covered what was asked for in research and character sketches; competent character design

(18 points)
Supplied material in very good form: original character design, good visual result and good depth of research

(20 points)
All material supplied in top-notch form: original character design, good visual result for final character and excellent depth of research

So, there is a certain mark level that I get because I show competency in what I am doing. It isn't so much how do I compare to what others are doing, but how much work I put in, how much I cover what is required, how much I go over what is required, and how well I do it.

Here's the comments from my teacher on my assignment -

Comments:
Good balance of information and commentary in your essay. The visuals help tell your story too. You have included visual research and developmental sketches, as requested, to help lead up to your refined character, HyperActive kid.

I.E. - I got a 75 on my drawing requirement - because my drawings were okay, and I covered what was required for it, and then a 87 on the essay because it was way above what was required.

The way it goes for us is

Needs much improvement(do the work - F-) Marginally under expectations(okay, you did some work, but put in more next time - F) Minimally met Expectations(congrats, you pass the assignment, but you know you could do better, D) Met Expectations(Keep on getting these marks for all assignments in all classes and you pass this year C, and that's the 75 per cent for the drawing I made) Met Expectations very well (You put in more effort to do the assignment than others - B, the essay I wrote) Outstanding job (I can't expect better, A)

So, I might be marked a little differently than you, because a 75 is what they considered consider a C, but in marks and everything - I can be on the Dean's list with an 80. Trust me on this, out of the 60+ people who started this year - only 3-4 will have 80+ in their courses - so that would be top 5 per cent, and over half have dropped out.

Edited by Kurall_Creator
SaintOlaf
Posted

Just curious, what school do you attend?

Kurall_Creator
Posted

[quote name='SaintOlaf' post='1855549' date='May 2 2009, 01:27 PM']Just curious, what school do you attend?[/quote]

Loyalist College.

SaintOlaf
Posted

do most schools in Canada follow that same grading system? Or is it just yours?

I'm really curious about it, since I've never seen anything like it, and I think I like it.

Kurall_Creator
Posted (edited)

[quote name='SaintOlaf' post='1855579' date='May 2 2009, 01:53 PM']do most schools in Canada follow that same grading system? Or is it just yours?

I'm really curious about it, since I've never seen anything like it, and I think I like it.[/quote]

I haven't been to other schools, but Loyalist College is an accredited college in Ontario, so I would theorize yes.

The reason, accredited schools get government funding for each student in the class. So the marks will be a little more just. In Slappo's class, only students with a 76 per cent average could go onto the next year - which would probably eliminate 70+ per cent of the class every single year. . .

Art colleges like Sheridan, and other high end schools - there is a much higher expectation than Loyalist - and out of thousands who apply, only a 100 get in every year, and only 10 graduate every year. . .

In my college, if you have a C - 60 per cent - you considered meeting expectatiions of the professors as to how well you are doing, and all courses have at least a 50, you get to go to the next year. That usually results in about half the student's failing per year.

Therefore, if more students go onto the next year, the more funding the course will have, and therefore the better program that can be delievered.

I think it is a much better way of delivering a post-secondary education, as it keeps tuition down, and it also helps people succeed better. Think of Pavlov - A student will far more likely put in effort when they only need a 60 to pass than if they need a 76 to pass. The one goal seems far more attainable than the other, doesn't it? So they are more like to put in the work to do well, than students who need a 76 to pass.

Thinking on those lines, if some is more willing to put in effort, they are going to learn more, because they are putting in the effort. How many more people wouldn't put in effort if 76 per cent was need to go to the next year?

Not to say that I didn't have collegues who were complaining all the time, and half dropped out (to be expected), but if you only need a 60 to pass, you'll put in the effort because you have hope to meet expectations.

Edited by Kurall_Creator
Posted

[quote name='Kurall_Creator' post='1855544' date='May 2 2009, 10:23 AM']Oh, I'm in Canada too - so there's a different grading scale here than in the States. The fact you need 76 per cent to show basic competency is a little steep, and is probably why there is such a bad environment in inner city schools (after all, if you need 70+ per cent to be considered basically competent in something), there is little chance for advancement in that kind of society, unless you put 4 times more work than anybody else, so why try?[/quote]

The crappy thing about American grading is a C is considered bad by most students. Getting a C in American is no longer an "average" grade. The American grading [b]scale[/b] is fine, the problem is the work is given higher grades then it really should be.

It would make sense that you need a 75% for average. It shows competancy in the field. If you only got a 60% then it shows that you missed 40% of the information you could have learned which is a huge portion. 75% means you understood a big majority of the material but have yet to master the subject as there was still a large portion of material to be learned. In masters work you need an 86% to get a passing grade for the class You need a B in all masters courses to get credit to graduate, and the % scale for the letter grades are different. An 85% is a -B in graduate work (at most schools). If you are getting your "Masters" degree in a field then you should have a very high level of competency, 86+%. You have missed understanding very little information in the class (a [b]maximum[/b] of 14% is missed).

Graduate work is usually graded more critically. Not only are the classes harder, but the teacher is more critical of your work. I think that the teacher ought to be as critical of an undergraduate students work as he is of a graduate students work and the only difference between the two should be the complexity and amount of material being learned. A 100 class level paper should be graded as critically as a 700 level paper. The freshmen undergraduate student then learns from his mistakes. If this were done, I also think that the freshmen student ought to be able to revise his work, correct his mistakes, and then raise his mark on the work by turning it in again.

Posted

[quote name='Kurall_Creator' post='1855612' date='May 2 2009, 11:21 AM']I haven't been to other schools, but Loyalist College is an accredited college in Ontario, so I would theorize yes.

The reason, accredited schools get government funding for each student in the class. So the marks will be a little more just. In Slappo's class, only students with a 76 per cent average could go onto the next year - which would probably eliminate 70+ per cent of the class every single year. . .[/quote]

I have a feeling that it is a lot easier to get a 76% in American then it is to get even a 65% in Canada.

Students here [b]complain[/b] if they only get a 76% on their work. The top 10% of my graduating class has somewhere around a 3.7gpa (a 90-92% average).

I got 104% in one of my classes this semester since extra credit was offered. This semester my marks are all within the 90-100% range (except the one that was 104), and will probably all actually be a 93 or higher. I'm not some super genius either, that is just how much more relaxed the grading of our work is.

What I might get a 100% on here in America, might only get an 80% grade in Canada, or even less. That is what is sad about America's schools.

Some of the harder schools like Stanford, Juliard, Harvard, Notre Dame, etc have a much stricter grading scale, but many many acredited American colleges give out high grades for poor work. For instance, in my seminar class of 12 students, every single one of us is getting an A (93-100%).

Kurall_Creator
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Slappo' post='1855613' date='May 2 2009, 02:22 PM']The crappy thing about American grading is a C is considered bad by most students. Getting a C in American is no longer an "average" grade. The American grading [b]scale[/b] is fine, the problem is the work is given higher grades then it really should be.

It would make sense that you need a 75% for average. It shows competancy in the field. If you only got a 60% then it shows that you missed 40% of the information you could have learned which is a huge portion. 75% means you understood a big majority of the material but have yet to master the subject as there was still a large portion of material to be learned. In masters work you need an 86% to get a passing grade for the class You need a B in all masters courses to get credit to graduate, and the % scale for the letter grades are different. An 85% is a -B in graduate work (at most schools). If you are getting your "Masters" degree in a field then you should have a very high level of competency, 86+%. You have missed understanding very little information in the class (a [b]maximum[/b] of 14% is missed).

Graduate work is usually graded more critically. Not only are the classes harder, but the teacher is more critical of your work. I think that the teacher ought to be as critical of an undergraduate students work as he is of a graduate students work and the only difference between the two should be the complexity and amount of material being learned. A 100 class level paper should be graded as critically as a 700 level paper. The freshmen undergraduate student then learns from his mistakes. If this were done, I also think that the freshmen student ought to be able to revise his work, correct his mistakes, and then raise his mark on the work by turning it in again.[/quote]

You are in university. I'm not.

Colleges are much different in Canada than in the states.

Especially in animation - it isn't so much about how much do you understand, but what you demonstrate. The idea is if you are demonstrating competency, than you understand it.

I only had 2 final exams in my course - Networking and Programing, and networking was the only one that was a standard test - i.e. - questions you answer. Programing final was - create a program that does this from scratch - again, it's showing your knowledge through competency, not testing.

Animation isn't so much, how much knowledge do you have, but how well you do it. How do you test someone on how to animate?

That is why at the beginning of the second semester in my first year they say - You have a final animation, it has to be at least 10 seconds long, and can be on anything you choose to do, but we recommend you stick to the storyboard you created for Lisa's class last semester. You have until the end of the semester to create it. That assignment is worth 40 per cent of our final mark for a 5 credit course.

They'll know if you understand how to do something by how well you do that. Animation is something that you can't be tested doing, except through the final product.

They also have other smaller assignments for you to do.

The same thing through web design - added unto that - part of the mark in web design is a group project, and half your mark in the group project is how well you worked in with the group (again, how does that test knowledge?)

Advertising and Marketing also had a small group project, and again, half the mark for that was how well you worked with others in your group.

In September, there is a year-long group project, and again - half your mark will be on how well you worked with the group.

Edited by Kurall_Creator
Posted

[quote name='Kurall_Creator' post='1855632' date='May 2 2009, 11:38 AM']You are in university. I'm not.

Colleges are much different in Canada than in the states.[/quote]

College and university in America are pretty synonymous. Usually the difference is in the size of the school and nothing else.

What you are describing sounds more like our technical institutions for specific studies.

Kurall_Creator
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Slappo' post='1855618' date='May 2 2009, 02:27 PM']I have a feeling that it is a lot easier to get a 76% in American then it is to get even a 65% in Canada.

Students here [b]complain[/b] if they only get a 76% on their work. The top 10% of my graduating class has somewhere around a 3.7gpa (a 90-92% average).

I got 104% in one of my classes this semester since extra credit was offered. This semester my marks are all within the 90-100% range (except the one that was 104), and will probably all actually be a 93 or higher. I'm not some super genius either, that is just how much more relaxed the grading of our work is.

What I might get a 100% on here in America, might only get an 80% grade in Canada, or even less. That is what is sad about America's schools.

Some of the harder schools like Stanford, Juliard, Harvard, Notre Dame, etc have a much stricter grading scale, but many many acredited American colleges give out high grades for poor work. For instance, in my seminar class of 12 students, every single one of us is getting an A (93-100%).[/quote]

I had that thought myself.

I put in probably 30 hours of homework a week beyond classes to get that 82 so far. . .

I remember back in first semester, I got 60s for my drawings in animation class. The same prof looked at my character drawings for art direction for my final there, an art history essay about the animation of the 1930s-1960s, and I made the comment, "remember what my drawings were like last semester,". He smirked.

I am so proud of myself that I got a 75 on my drawing portion of my last assignment for art diretion. Lisa saw my drawings, and the first thing she said, Mark your drawing has improved quiet a lot. I said that it's because I'm doing lots of things in XSI, and once you learn how to do a character in XSI, than it translates well on paper, as you first draw the skeleton of the drawing first, and then conform the shape of the character around that skeleton.

Art is hard to grade, as it isn't so much knowledge, but how good it looks, and my course has some hard markers in that regards. A lot of the more technical people, and the lazy people, are always complaining. . .

Edited by Kurall_Creator

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...