Archaeology cat Posted May 3, 2009 Posted May 3, 2009 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1856427' date='May 3 2009, 03:54 PM']I went to public school my entire life and loved it. I was always excited to go to CCD (which was at the Catholic elementary/middle school a few blocks away). I never learned much in CCD but it instilled in me a desire to learn more. I actually sat right up front, as did my friend, and when we were bored we drew comic strips of Moses, LOL. Sadly this was not the same for the majority of my classmates who goofed off the entire time. I really think the question "Which schooling is the best?" depends on the town or city you are in. My town is pretty small, and I would say there were about 75 kids in my entire grade - give or take. Out of those 75, 45-50 were in CCD. We have some Christian churches in my town but I would say a good proportion here are Catholic (if not in practice then in name.) Therefore, in my public school, you NEVER ran across a Wiccan-type (for example) or a fundamentalist. The teachers fit well into the system and never discussed religion in the personal sense. We learned about Catholicism and Protestantism in History classes and I recall talking about God in Physics. If home-schooling is right for you and your children, that is fine. However, I feel that you can really become strong in faith and personality if you are challenged in a classroom setting by a teacher or peer (whether public or Catholic).[/quote] Oh I agree. My public schools were good, and I liked them for the most part. But I know that isn't the case everywhere. Just like in some places, the Catholic schools are really great, and in some they aren't as good. In any case, I do think parents need to get involved in the schools (inasmuch as this is possible) to help. I know when I was teaching I was very thankful for the couple of parents who volunteered to help, or just those parents that were available for conferences.
tinytherese Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 (edited) If I was around the Dominican Sisters of Mary or the Nashville Dominicans then heck yea I'd send my kids there. They know what they're doing. Other than that I seem to be liking the idea of sending kids to a public school as long as it isn't the type that has major crime issues going on among the students. I'd also be concerned about sexual education or "comprehensive" sexual education that would be offered at a public school and the school's academic reputation. I suppose it depends on the school. Every parent needs to investigate before enrolling their children. Edited May 4, 2009 by tinytherese
Theoketos Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 I teach at a Diocesan run School. It is quite orthodox. Our entire Religion/Philosophy department are Masters of Theology from respectable institutions. If you all want good Catholic High Schools move to Wichita Kansas. The difference between our schools and most schools in the country is that our schools are [b]tuition free[/b]! They are subsidized by the Parish and the Diocese through Stewardship. The Stewardship model takes much of the market force to conform to the world's standards out the process, because we are first accountable to the Church made up of stewards practicing their faith and not paying customers who want nominal Catholicism.
missionseeker Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 (edited) Our parish was doing that! (then the school got closed, long story, it was going under then our priest recovered it, then the bishop shut it down and father is going to be a benedictine monk.) lol. I just wanna say, that I was in public school for 7 years and homeschooled for 6. I have nothing against the public school system (private) except the system itself. I don't think kids were designed to be at school for 8 hours a day. *I* rode the bus and was the first on and the last off. It made for a day from 6:30am-4:30 pm. I just think children were meant to be children, not mini-adults. Edited May 4, 2009 by missionseeker
princessgianna Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 [quote name='Theoketos' post='1856969' date='May 3 2009, 10:26 PM']I teach at a Diocesan run School. It is quite orthodox. Our entire Religion/Philosophy department are Masters of Theology from respectable institutions. If you all want good Catholic High Schools move to Wichita Kansas. The difference between our schools and most schools in the country is that our schools are [b]tuition free[/b]! They are subsidized by the Parish and the Diocese through Stewardship. The Stewardship model takes much of the market force to conform to the world's standards out the process, because we are first accountable to the Church made up of stewards practicing their faith and not paying customers who want nominal Catholicism.[/quote] Wow see that's a [b]Catholic[/b] school!!!! That's awesome -maybe you'll venture to St. Louis MO soon.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 Sorry if this has already been mentioned: Keep in mind that in the US, Catholic schools are all private schools. I got the impression from Ad's post that he has a 'seperate' school board, like we do in Alberta, where there is a Catholic school system that is publically funded. Effectively the same as a Catholic school. Problems are probably more prevalent in this kind of system, unfortunately.
Archaeology cat Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 [quote name='missionseeker' post='1856981' date='May 4 2009, 04:30 AM']I have nothing against the public school system (private) except the system itself. I don't think kids were designed to be at school for 8 hours a day. *I* rode the bus and was the first on and the last off. It made for a day from 6:30am-4:30 pm. I just think children were meant to be children, not mini-adults.[/quote] I agree. That's one of the pulls for homeschooling, for me. I just found out there's a homeschooling group here, so I think I'll contact them and see about things.
Resurrexi Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1857120' date='May 4 2009, 12:09 AM']Sorry if this has already been mentioned: Keep in mind that in the US, Catholic schools are all private schools. I got the impression from Ad's post that he has a 'seperate' school board, like we do in Alberta, where there is a Catholic school system that is publically funded. Effectively the same as a Catholic school. Problems are probably more prevalent in this kind of system, unfortunately.[/quote] Such as system would be less centralized in regards to the relationship between the school and the local Ordinary, would it not?
missionseeker Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1857287' date='May 4 2009, 01:30 AM']I agree. That's one of the pulls for homeschooling, for me. I just found out there's a homeschooling group here, so I think I'll contact them and see about things.[/quote] it IS much easier with support. My mother actually found most of her online and that's a great resource too. Lots of blogs and phorums and lists for that kind of thing. (OH! and book swapping lists, those are helpful, too)
Archaeology cat Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 [quote name='missionseeker' post='1857326' date='May 4 2009, 09:02 AM'] it IS much easier with support. My mother actually found most of her online and that's a great resource too. Lots of blogs and phorums and lists for that kind of thing. (OH! and book swapping lists, those are helpful, too) [/quote] Our neighbour across the street is planning to homeschool, so she's giving me all the contact info for groups in the area. My aunt is still homeschooling her youngest, so I'm sure she can give some tips, too. DH isn't sold on the idea, because of the social aspect, and I admit that I can understand that. Of course, unless DH gets hired at a uni in this area, we'll move before my son is old enough for school, too. So much to think about.
AdAltareDei Posted May 4, 2009 Author Posted May 4, 2009 You could always see if there is a church play group or homeschool play group in your area A few traditionalist churches I know have them. But then again, most traditionalists are likely to homeschool their children if a trad school isn't available (which it usually isn't), so I'm not sure if lots of mainstream churches would have a group like that.
Archaeology cat Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 [quote name='AdAltareDei' post='1857340' date='May 4 2009, 10:32 AM']You could always see if there is a church play group or homeschool play group in your area A few traditionalist churches I know have them. But then again, most traditionalists are likely to homeschool their children if a trad school isn't available (which it usually isn't), so I'm not sure if lots of mainstream churches would have a group like that.[/quote] Oh, I'm already looking at that. The problem is that we're likely moving in another year or so. But I'm going to go ahead and try to make contacts.
Guest KevinSymonds Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 As a religion teacher at a Catholic high school in the South, yes, there are problems. Thankfully, however, I live close by Mother Angelica's Shrine so any nonsense I see on a daily basis with the locals is offset. There's no way I'd ever let my students hear "Purgatory does not exist" or anything of that sort. If anything, I've gotten lambasted for defending the Church's teachings! -KJS
AdAltareDei Posted May 4, 2009 Author Posted May 4, 2009 [quote name='KevinSymonds' post='1857356' date='May 4 2009, 08:28 AM']As a religion teacher at a Catholic high school in the South, yes, there are problems. Thankfully, however, I live close by Mother Angelica's Shrine so any nonsense I see on a daily basis with the locals is offset. There's no way I'd ever let my students hear "Purgatory does not exist" or anything of that sort. If anything, I've gotten lambasted for defending the Church's teachings! -KJS[/quote] Get a job with a catholic school outside the diocesan structure One run by the lay movements or a good religious order maybe? That would be a dream job for me.
Archaeology cat Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 The closest Catholic school to us is run attached to a parish run by Benedictines
FiereMargriet Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 [quote name='tinytherese' post='1856957' date='May 4 2009, 12:20 AM']If I was around the Dominican Sisters of Mary or the Nashville Dominicans then heck yea I'd send my kids there. They know what they're doing. Other than that I seem to be liking the idea of sending kids to a public school as long as it isn't the type that has major crime issues going on among the students. I'd also be concerned about sexual education or "comprehensive" sexual education that would be offered at a public school and the school's academic reputation. I suppose it depends on the school. Every parent needs to investigate before enrolling their children.[/quote] If I am called to marriage and blessed with children, I either want to homeschool them or to send them to a school such as you mention run by an order like the DSMME. (I was just reading one of their vocation handouts today and I love how they have daily Mass and religion classes and weekly Confession!) That said, I agree with HisChildForever in some aspect. I went to public school my whole life and CCD; really I didn't learn anything in CCD, although I have fond memories of watching animated Bible videos and making popsicle-stick crosses. However, our public schools were on the whole very good and I met so many wise teachers and nice friends. We did learn about religion in the context of history and I had lots of interesting English classes (which was my favorite subject). Yet I was fairly liberal when I was in high school so I found my viewpoints aligning with those of my peers. Were I in school now, I'm fairly sure I would be ostracized for espousing such conservative, Catholic opinions. Yes, it's good to hear arguments from a variety of backgrounds, but if I had kids of my own I would prefer they start out with good formation via homeschooling or an orthodox Catholic school.
Nihil Obstat Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1857293' date='May 4 2009, 01:37 AM']Such as system would be less centralized in regards to the relationship between the school and the local Ordinary, would it not?[/quote] Exactly right. Technically our bishop has zero authority over the Seperate Board, including whether or not it can even be called Catholic. They listen to his recommendations... most of the time, such as when they FINALLY stopped running casinos to raise money... For all intents and purposes though, it's the same as public schools. Only difference is that we take religion class.
Archaeology cat Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 (edited) nvm Edited May 4, 2009 by Archaeology cat
icelandic_iceskater Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 #1. a few years of catholic school. Orthodox teachings and all, but the only way Catholicism showed was through religion classes and all school masses every Friday. #2. Homeschool. #3. Orthodox catholic college. From touring the campus, it looks as if they're pretty hardcore catholic I kinda want to get certified in elementary ed, then start a mini catholic school just with a few other moms. Kinda like homeschooling with other families or something... =)
Slappo Posted May 4, 2009 Posted May 4, 2009 (edited) I did public school and dropped out because it was so bad. Got my GED february of what would have been my sophomore year of high school. I graduate from Franciscan University with (hopefully) honors in less then a week. At a minimum I'll have a 3.48 gpa. EDIT: I'll probably get ostracized even here for saying this, but because of my background, I have no problem throwing kids in to college early and letting them get a GED if they show the intellectual finesse. Otherwise I'd want to home school my kids with maybe having them take a class or two at the local high school depending on the quality. I have no problem with public school from k-5 but I'd want my kids home schooled 6-12. I'm kind of reverse from the norm Edited May 4, 2009 by Slappo
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now