Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Resurrexi
Posted

Could someone who is drunk validly administer Baptism?

Posted

if they have valid matter and valid intent, sure. it's the intent which would be questionable with anyone who is drunk... in an emergency situation if you have to baptize someone but you've been drinking that night, if you're the only one who can do it then go ahead. if you're a priest, please don't get drunk before going to a baptism! lol

Resurrexi
Posted

I guess the same would hold for a priest consecrating while drunk?

tinytherese
Posted

This thread is hilarious! :biglol:

Posted

yeah I'd say so... the only issue with being drunk is whether they really have a proper intent to confect a sacrament. to have intent is an act of the will, and being drunk might impair one's use of one's will. but I think an imperfect act of the priest's will suffices... so even if his will is partially impaired he might be able to make a proper intent.

remember, the sacrament doesn't come from the character of the man himself, but from Christ who has placed an indelible mark on his soul. he can be a terrible person, and he can be in the midst of a terrible sin (such as drunkenness) but that doesn't mean the sacrament doesn't happen through him. the only thing that would make it not happen is if he didn't intend to "do as the Church does" and/or he didn't have valid matter.

CatherineM
Posted

The assistant pastor we had for many years when I was in grade school had an alcohol problem. He'd have to go away for 2-6 months at a time. I hope that this isn't just an intellectual exercise in extreme legalism again. Many priests suffer from substance abuse because the work can be very hard, and very lonely.

Posted

Wasn't it Boris Jeltsin that almost died because the priest was drunk and he was baptized by full submersion?

Resurrexi
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1857431' date='May 4 2009, 10:35 AM']The assistant pastor we had for many years when I was in grade school had an alcohol problem. He'd have to go away for 2-6 months at a time. I hope that this isn't just an intellectual exercise in extreme legalism again. Many priests suffer from substance abuse because the work can be very hard, and very lonely.[/quote]

Yep, this is just an intellectual exercise :)

Hardly legalistsic. The validity of Sacraments does matter (no pun intended), you know.

I have no experience with being drunk, but Al, I would take it that in your opinion that a drunk man is not so impared of his reason that he cannot make an act of will? Could this sometimes depend on how drunk he is?

CatherineM
Posted

[quote name='Resurrexi' post='1857705' date='May 4 2009, 03:43 PM']I have no experience with being drunk, but Al, I would take it that in your opinion that a drunk man is not so impared of his reason that he cannot make an act of will? Could this sometimes depend on how drunk he is?[/quote]

It's also not just a matter of blood alcohol content. I've seen women who had .02 and not legally drunk, who couldn't pass a field sobriety test because they couldn't stand up, and old-time drunks who could blow .20 and you couldn't tell they were drunk because their bodies are just so used to the alcohol. Now a days, cops deal with more impaired drivers due to drugs, prescription or even over the counter, than they do alcohol.

I think as long as they are able to properly do the sacrament, such as remember Father, Son and Holy Spirit, then the sacrament is valid since it comes from God anyway. Falling down, I'm not so sure. I have received the anointing from someone who was so distraught that he had trouble finishing, and had to keep stopping. I believe that it was still valid.

Apotheoun
Posted

[quote name='tinytherese' post='1857314' date='May 4 2009, 01:54 AM']This thread is hilarious! :biglol:[/quote]
It is an interesting thread.

StColette
Posted

[quote name='Hilde' post='1857448' date='May 4 2009, 10:57 AM']Wasn't it Boris Jeltsin that almost died because the priest was drunk and he was baptized by full submersion?[/quote]

I think it's spelled Yeltsin, but I think you're correct in that yeah there's a story about his Christening. That the Priest/Pastor had been drunk.

Marie-Therese
Posted
:sign: :drunk:

This is hilarious!!!

As Aloysius said, it just pertains to the intent. I think as long as the person was coherent enough to understand that they were intending to do what the Church does in baptism, and the Trinitarian form was used, then it should be valid.

Although that scene does give one pause..."Well, me and Billy Bob were out in the truck by the creek knocking back some Pabst Blue Ribbon, and I just figured I'd get baptized."

Stranger things have happened, I suppose. LOL
Resurrexi
Posted (edited)

Yes, it would definitely have to do with the intent. I mean, the intent necessary for a valid baptism (to do what the Church does) isn't the most difficult intention to have. I guess I'm more interested in what the extent of reason one has while intoxicated is, and whether most people are intellectually capable of making an act of will while intoxicated.

Edited by Resurrexi
Posted

[quote name='StColette' post='1857735' date='May 5 2009, 12:19 AM']I think it's spelled Yeltsin, but I think you're correct in that yeah there's a story about his Christening. That the Priest/Pastor had been drunk.[/quote]
Oh, I didn't know you spelled it differently in English.
Our J's are pronounced like I's.

Anyway, I thought it was funny. I heard about it in RCIA.

Posted

unless/until one gets [i]black out[/i] drunk, I would still argue that every single act is a volitional act. it may be an impaired will, but it is still a will. one may be drunk to the point that they are not culpable for some sin of grave matter that they commit but still able to act intentionally. see, with mortal sin, FULL consent of the will is required; but it would seem to me that for a sacrament, because the priest himself is not the source of the grace but rather it's conduit, a partial consent of the will suffices.

it is only the extremely extremely drunk man who loses all aspects of his willpower (though even that is not an absolute, but if relatively all of the willpower is not present, I don't think it'd suffice to do a sacrament)... but at that point one is usually unable to speak coherently, to interpret things in his mind enough to remember them, or pretty much do anything.

I think it is probably that any priest who remained functional enough to say the words and do the actions has enough of the use of his will power to confect a sacrament.

Thomist-in-Training
Posted

In the older rules of fasting (not the oldest, where you fasted from midnight), there was a difference between how many hours you could drink alcoholic and nonalcoholic drinks before Mass.

[quote]Priests and faithful, before Holy Mass or Holy Communion respectively, must abstain for three hours from solid foods and alcoholic liquids, for one hour from non- alcoholic liquids.[/quote]

Sacram Communionem
Apostolic Constitution of Pope Pius XII on Laws of Fasting and the Evening Mass
January 6, 1953

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...