CatherineM Posted May 24, 2009 Posted May 24, 2009 [quote name='agnes88' post='1874290' date='May 24 2009, 10:26 AM']I don't think the OP's situation would be grounds for nullity, but I'm just a layman. [/quote] You'd be surprised how many different things can annul a marriage. I know I was first studying it. The most fascinating one is that if you kill someone's spouse, you can't make a valid marriage with the widow, even if she was aware of or a party to the murder. The Canon that applies to the OP would probably be #1098 "A person contracts invalidly who enters marriage inveigled by deceit, perpetrated in order to secure consent, concerning some quality of the other party, which of its very nature can seriously disrupt the partnership of conjugal life."
Resurrexi Posted May 24, 2009 Posted May 24, 2009 The whole murder impediment is pretty smart actually. You don't want people killing their spouses so that they can remarry.
CatherineM Posted May 24, 2009 Posted May 24, 2009 [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1874300' date='May 24 2009, 10:55 AM']The whole murder impediment is pretty smart actually. You don't want people killing their spouses so that they can remarry.[/quote] Worked for King David. I agree that we don't want them to kill people to marry, but that the church considers a marriage to be invalid on its face in that circumstance is interesting. I never had a case like that, but have wondered if it was a situation where a cop has to shoot a man who is beating his wife, and ends up falling in love with her later, if it would apply.
Resurrexi Posted May 24, 2009 Posted May 24, 2009 Can. 1090 §1. Anyone who with a view to entering marriage with a certain person has brought about the death of that person’s spouse or of one’s own spouse invalidly attempts this marriage. §2. Those who have brought about the death of a spouse by mutual physical or moral cooperation also invalidly attempt a marriage together. I don't think the cop situation would apply, since he didn't kill the husband for the sake of marrying the wife.
CatherineM Posted May 24, 2009 Posted May 24, 2009 [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1874321' date='May 24 2009, 11:52 AM']Can. 1090 §1. Anyone who with a view to entering marriage with a certain person has brought about the death of that person’s spouse or of one’s own spouse invalidly attempts this marriage. §2. Those who have brought about the death of a spouse by mutual physical or moral cooperation also invalidly attempt a marriage together. I don't think the cop situation would apply, since he didn't kill the husband for the sake of marrying the wife.[/quote] Yes, but suppose the cop saw her beauty immediately before pulling the trigger. Maybe he didn't need to shoot the husband to restrain him. What if years later the woman meets another man, and uses this canon to get an annulment? It might make an interesting debate thread about all the different scenarios that lead to annulment.
jwingert72 Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 Honest is always a necessity when entering a vocation. Steve must have the freedom to share the truth with his future spouse, not the sorrid details, but she should know that he is an alcoholic and past abuser. If not, then he is not ready for marriage. Any true friend and family member who truly loves will have the courage to step in an tell the young woman. That would be the truest act of love, for the truth will always set you free. Failure to do so would make anyone with prior knowledge a participant in an invalid marriage. I is imparative that this couple have more formation or it is a marriage set up for failure. He is not being a "good Catholic" if he is lying to his future spouse. Marriage is a complete self-gift to the other, withholding your past is withholding yourself, which means a marriage doesn't take place. Speak up out of the demands of love.
CatherineM Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 Canon Law #1069 says, "Before the celebration of a marriage, all the faithful are bound to reveal to the parish priest or the local Ordinary such impediments as they may know about." The question is would the family/friends be bound by this? It would depend on whether this past, or the non-disclosure of this past, is considered an impediment.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now