Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' post='1868006' date='May 15 2009, 01:43 PM']Intentionality is vastly different too. From what I know usually surrogate motherhood is agreed upon before the fertilization of the embryo. Therefore it is a preplanned unnatural fertilization whereas this has nothing to do with planning out an unnatural fertilization.

The intention is different too. One intends to carry a child to term (usually for money if I'm not mistaken) so that another couple can have it. This intends to save the life of the child which would otherwise die.[/quote]

I also included IVF. Allowing the adoption of embryos would open wide the issue of IVF. And as Catherine pointed out, the Church teaches against ivf. Good intention or not for wanting to carry these embryos to term so that they may live, it does not make IVF moral.

Posted

[quote name='StColette' post='1868043' date='May 15 2009, 11:57 AM']I also included IVF. Allowing the adoption of embryos would open wide the issue of IVF. And as Catherine pointed out, the Church teaches against ivf. Good intention or not for wanting to carry these embryos to term so that they may live, it does not make IVF moral.[/quote]

Implanting of already frozen embryo's isn't IVF though. IVF has [b]already taken place[/b] by the time that you reach the point of frozen embryo's.

in vitro |in ˈvēˌtrō|
adjective & adverb Biology
(of processes or reactions) taking place in a test tube, culture dish, or elsewhere outside a living organism : [as adj. ] in vitro fertilization.

The sin of IVF has already taken place by the time that the implanting is happening within the woman. The question now is what to do with the results of the intrinsic evil of IVF.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='StColette' post='1868059' date='May 15 2009, 12:26 PM']That's not the only problem with IVF, it's also the removal of the conjugal act from the equation if we are speaking about these already created embryos.

" The human person must be accepted in his parents' act of union and love; [b]the generation of a child must therefore be the fruit of that mutual giving (45) which is realized in the conjugal act [/b] wherein the spouses cooperate as servants and not as masters in the work of the Creator who is Love."[/quote]

Again, the generation of the child has already occurred. Therefore the stripping of the generation of the child from the conjugal act has already taken place. These sins have taken place already, now the question is what do we do with the [b]already IVF'ed generated outside of the conjugal act[/b] child.

EDIT: That is the conjugal act has already been removed from the equation. Also, with the definition of the conjugal act, any act of fornication or rape is not the conjugal act, and therefore any child generated from fornication or rape is not generated within the conjugal act.

Edited by Slappo
Posted

Forget it. I'm not in the mood today. DP makes it clear. That's enough for me.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='StColette' post='1868066' date='May 15 2009, 12:36 PM']The problem with implanting already frozen embryo's isn't just how they were created it's how they are put in there. The child doesn't get there by means of the conjugal act. Removal of the conjugal act is another problem that the Church sees with achieving pregnancy through IVF. Donum Vitae makes this apparent.[/quote]

lol I think you deleted your post after I quoted it.

The definition of the conjugal act excludes fornication. The child has already gotten there in the sense that s/he is a child. When it comes to the implanting of the child within the woman, it is a matter of physics.

Edit: Also the advancement of technology to move an embryo from the fallopian tube into the uterus due to an eggtopic pregnancy would follow the same principles. The embryo did not get into the uterus by means of the conjugal act, but rather by means of surgery.

Edited by Slappo
Posted

[quote name='StColette' post='1868066' date='May 15 2009, 12:36 PM']Forget it. I'm not in the mood today. DP makes it clear. That's enough for me.[/quote]

If anyone else could pick up where StColette left off I'd appreciate it.

I really don't think DP made it clear at all... :unsure:

Sorry if I bothered you colette!

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' post='1868070' date='May 15 2009, 03:44 PM']If anyone else could pick up where StColette left off I'd appreciate it.

I really don't think DP made it clear at all... :unsure:

Sorry if I bothered you colette![/quote]

Being pregnant, currently, and being in this debate is not a good mix. And we will leave it at that. CatherineM made a very valid point, but you have not addressed it. Her area of study is Moral Theology so she'll probably pick up where I left off.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1868017' date='May 15 2009, 11:19 AM']I think the Vatican was loath to approve adoption of embryos because it would open the doors to people wanting to push the envelop further. We recognize embryos as living humans, and would have liked to have reinforced that encouraging their adoption, but it would also unfortunately reinforce IVF as a necessary evil in the process. We are literally taking the line that saving these children's mortal lives isn't worth participating in a evil process that endangers the eternal lives of the adults involved.

The Vatican also knows that there is no legitimate reason to have so many frozen. Many European countries, which are much more liberal than the US when it comes to this stuff, don't have this large backlog of frozen embryos because they have limits on how many can be created, and they can only be implanted into the natural mother and it must be done within a reasonable amount of time.[/quote]

I definitely see the possibility of confusion of the morality of IVF with the Vatican allowing already frozen embryo's to be implanted in women, and the push to altogether ban IVF is very important as well. The question then comes to.. say all IVF stopped this very minute, what is to be done with the frozen ones? Throw them out? Murder. Let them unthaw to die naturally? Maybe. Implant them in women willing to adopt them? I don't see why not.

Although IVF is a necessary evil in the process of implanting these already frozen embryo's into a woman, it is an evil that has already occurred and is continued to be stressed as an evil. [b]The question at hand is the act of implanting frozen embryo's into a woman's body evil or not.[/b] The morality of anything that is done previous to this point is irrelevant because those evil's have already taken place and the movement of a frozen embryo into a uterus is a a separate moral act.

If we developed technology to be able to raise the embryo's from frozen embryo to postnatal child without the use of the uterus of a mother, would this be a moral evil?

CatherineM
Posted

[quote name='Slappo' post='1868076' date='May 15 2009, 02:56 PM']I definitely see the possibility of confusion of the morality of IVF with the Vatican allowing already frozen embryo's to be implanted in women, and the push to altogether ban IVF is very important as well. The question then comes to.. say all IVF stopped this very minute, what is to be done with the frozen ones? Throw them out? Murder. Let them unthaw to die naturally? Maybe. Implant them in women willing to adopt them? I don't see why not.

Although IVF is a necessary evil in the process of implanting these already frozen embryo's into a woman, it is an evil that has already occurred and is continued to be stressed as an evil. [b]The question at hand is the act of implanting frozen embryo's into a woman's body evil or not.[/b] The morality of anything that is done previous to this point is irrelevant because those evil's have already taken place and the movement of a frozen embryo into a uterus is a a separate moral act.

If we developed technology to be able to raise the embryo's from frozen embryo to postnatal child without the use of the uterus of a mother, would this be a moral evil?[/quote]

I'll take the baton. DP was eagerly awaited by folks like me. I was hoping for embryonic adoption. I have friends back in Florida who adopted two of their children this way. I've had to take a long hard look at what went into DP, and a lot of prayer as well. What we are dealing with here are humans who have been frozen. I think the stat is 50% die when thawed. I think is some regards, we have potentially murdered them already just by freezing them. We need to stop interfering with the natural process of reproduction. We use damaging chemicals to prevent conception. We butcher our bodies. We load ourselves up with hormones to produce abnormal amounts of eggs for the IVF process.

I didn't marry until I was 43, and had several miscarriages. Don't you think that we dealt with people suggesting IVF which would have been free to us? It wasn't tempting because we really aren't up to being the parents of an infant anyway. If we had been desperate to have a child though, it might have been really tempting. People also assumed I was on fertility drugs because I kept getting pregnant. We are dealing with such personal, core issues with DP.

Basically the Vatican is saying, if it isn't natural, no go, period. Most teachings dealing with morality and new science or medicine issues fall into authoritative doctrine. That means we are to follow the rules even if we don't agree with them. They are not definitive or infallible. The church recognizes with this stuff that things may change in the future, but for what we know, here and now, this is what it right. In 50 years with all the leftovers of birth control pills in the environment, maybe women will no longer be able to produce eggs on their own. If that happens, maybe the Vatican will look at defrosting the embryos to save the race, or maybe they will decide that it's just time for the end to come.

We have to draw the line somewhere.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1868280' date='May 15 2009, 04:50 PM']I'll take the baton. DP was eagerly awaited by folks like me. I was hoping for embryonic adoption. I have friends back in Florida who adopted two of their children this way. I've had to take a long hard look at what went into DP, and a lot of prayer as well. What we are dealing with here are humans who have been frozen. I think the stat is 50% die when thawed. I think is some regards, we have potentially murdered them already just by freezing them. We need to stop interfering with the natural process of reproduction. We use damaging chemicals to prevent conception. We butcher our bodies. We load ourselves up with hormones to produce abnormal amounts of eggs for the IVF process.

I didn't marry until I was 43, and had several miscarriages. Don't you think that we dealt with people suggesting IVF which would have been free to us? It wasn't tempting because we really aren't up to being the parents of an infant anyway. If we had been desperate to have a child though, it might have been really tempting. People also assumed I was on fertility drugs because I kept getting pregnant. We are dealing with such personal, core issues with DP.

Basically the Vatican is saying, if it isn't natural, no go, period. Most teachings dealing with morality and new science or medicine issues fall into authoritative doctrine. That means we are to follow the rules even if we don't agree with them. They are not definitive or infallible. The church recognizes with this stuff that things may change in the future, but for what we know, here and now, this is what it right. In 50 years with all the leftovers of birth control pills in the environment, maybe women will no longer be able to produce eggs on their own. If that happens, maybe the Vatican will look at defrosting the embryos to save the race, or maybe they will decide that it's just time for the end to come.

We have to draw the line somewhere.[/quote]

Thanks Catherine,
I should e-mail two of my old professors, one who ran my seminar and one who recently took the Bioethics chair at FUS.
My seminar professor seemed to think that DP's wording did not authoritatively prohibit adopting frozen embryo's :unsure: .

I definitely see the complications in the situation, and I most definitely see the need to stop interfering with reproduction. As someone who hopes to be getting married soon, it's really sad to see how much marriage has been attacked as well as the natural process of procreation.

I assuredly submit to the Church's teaching, but I guess my confusion came with confusion in one of my classrooms.

Posted (edited)

You are definitely on to something Slappo.

Conte has an interesting take on all of this. I'll try to find his ideas and post them tommorrow. Not in the mood tonight.

Edited by kafka
CatherineM
Posted

This is what DP says about frozen embryos:

[quote]19. With regard to the large number of frozen embryos already in existence the question becomes: what to do with them? Some of those who pose this question do not grasp its ethical nature, motivated as they are by laws in some countries that require cryopreservation centers to empty their storage tanks periodically. Others, however, are aware that a grave injustice has been perpetrated and wonder how best to respond to the duty of resolving it.

Proposals to use these embryos for research or for the treatment of disease are obviously
unacceptable because they treat the embryos as mere “biological material” and result in their
destruction. The proposal to thaw such embryos without reactivating them and use them for
research, as if they were normal cadavers, is also unacceptable.

The proposal that these embryos could be put at the disposal of infertile couples as a
treatment for infertility is not ethically acceptable for the same reasons which make artificial
heterologous procreation illicit as well as any form of surrogate motherhood; this practice
would also lead to other problems of a medical, psychological and legal nature.

[b]It has also been proposed, solely in order to allow human beings to be born who are otherwise condemned to destruction, that there could be a form of “prenatal adoption”. This proposal, Praiseworthy with regard to the intention of respecting and defending human life, presents however various problems not dissimilar to those mentioned above. [/b]

All things considered, it needs to be recognized that the thousands of abandoned embryos represent a situation of injustice which in fact cannot be resolved. Therefore John Paul II made an “appeal to the conscience of the world’s scientific authorities and in particular to doctors, that the production of human embryos be halted, taking into account that there seems to be no morally licit solution regarding the human destiny of the thousands and thousands of 'frozen’ embryos which are and remain the subjects of essential rights and should therefore be protected by law as human persons”.

The freezing of oocytes

20. In order avoid the serious ethical problems posed by the freezing of embryos, the freezing of oocytes has also been advanced in the area of techniques of in vitro fertilization. Once a sufficient number of oocytes has been obtained for a series of attempts at artificial procreation, only those which are to be transferred into the mother’s body are fertilized while the others are frozen for future fertilization and transfer should the initial attempts not succeed. In this regard it needs to be stated that cryopreservation of oocytes for the purpose of being used in artificial procreation is to be considered morally unacceptable.[/quote]

At the end of the emphasized part above, it says, "presents however various problems not dissimilar to those mentioned above." I think that refers back to the, "The proposal that these embryos could be put at the disposal of infertile couples as a treatment for infertility is not ethically acceptable for the same reasons which make artificial heterologous procreation illicit as well as any form of surrogate motherhood; this practice would also lead to other problems of a medical, psychological and legal nature." [url="http://www.usccb.org/comm/Dignitaspersonae/Dignitas_Personae.pdf"]SOURCE[/url]

I hadn't heard of anyone interpreting this to mean that prenatal adoption was okay. After reading it again, it could have been written stronger, but so could a lot of Vatican documents in my opinion. It would be very interesting to have your moral theology prof's interpretation to compare with mine.

Posted

Holy Mother the Church teaches that adoption is a great evil gravely contrary to the natural law.

Orphaned children should be left to the wolves.

Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1868295' date='May 15 2009, 08:56 PM']You are definitely on to something Slappo.

Conte has an interesting take on all of this. I'll try to find his ideas and post them tommorrow. Not in the mood tonight.[/quote]
What's his ideas on Hillary not winning that election?

Does that throw off the rest of his astonishing predictions? Will the Arabs still nuke NYC next year?

And could you get me the link to that site again? - I'm afraid I forgot it. I forget how many more times Christ was supposed to return; was it three or four times? (Seems Conte, in his wisdom said His Second Coming wouldn't leave much of a lasting impression on people.)

I wish to feast more on Conte's amazing prophecies so I won't be led astray by shams and amateurs like Scott Hahn or the Pope.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1868307' date='May 15 2009, 06:29 PM']What's his ideas on Hillary not winning that election?

Does that throw off the rest of his astonishing predictions? Will the Arabs still nuke NYC next year?

And could you get me the link to that site again? - I'm afraid I forgot it. I forget how many more times Christ was supposed to return; was it three or four times? (Seems Conte, in his wisdom said His Second Coming wouldn't leave much of a lasting impression on people.)

I wish to feast more on Conte's amazing prophecies so I won't be led astray by shams and amateurs like Scott Hahn or the Pope.[/quote]

Come on, at least use charity.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1868299' date='May 15 2009, 06:10 PM']I hadn't heard of anyone interpreting this to mean that prenatal adoption was okay. After reading it again, it could have been written stronger, but so could a lot of Vatican documents in my opinion. It would be very interesting to have your moral theology prof's interpretation to compare with mine.[/quote]

I e-mailed him asking for his take on it, or if I was mistaken in what I heard at our seminar. I agree that it definitely could have been worded stronger and an actual statement as to why it is wrong would have been lovely <_< .

My seminar teacher could have been giving the opinions of some theologians and not the interpretation of Dignitas Personae. I'm anxiously awaiting his reply!

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Socrates' post='1868307' date='May 15 2009, 09:29 PM']What's his ideas on Hillary not winning that election?

Does that throw off the rest of his astonishing predictions? Will the Arabs still nuke NYC next year?

And could you get me the link to that site again? - I'm afraid I forgot it. I forget how many more times Christ was supposed to return; was it three or four times? (Seems Conte, in his wisdom said His Second Coming wouldn't leave much of a lasting impression on people.)

I wish to feast more on Conte's amazing prophecies so I won't be led astray by shams and amateurs like Scott Hahn or the Pope.[/quote]
Oops, looks like Conte took down his remarkable prophecies for 2008 and 2009 from his website.

Looks like 2010 should still be quite an eventful year though:[quote]In the year 2010 A.D.

* April 2nd, 2010 (Good Friday), the Day of Repentance = the Warning of Garabandal = the First Secret of Medjugorje
* April 4th, 2010 (Easter Sunday), the Day of Consolation = the Second Secret of Medjugorje
* May 13th, 2010 (Ascension Thursday), the Day of Healing = the Miracle of Garabandal = the Third Secret of Medjugorje
* It is a year of great success for the prolife cause
* Pope Benedict XVI suggests building three places in Jerusalem, a Temple, a Church, and a Mosque, so that the three religions, Judaism, Christianity, Islam, can worship in peace in the City of Peace. (But it does not happen soon; instead there is war.)
* The Jews decide to build the Third Temple of Jerusalem
* There is war, insurrection, and coups among the Arab/Muslim nations of the Middle East and northern Africa. Extremist leaders fight against more moderate leaders, and the extremists win. If they cannot win by coups and insurrections, then one Arab nation attacks another in outright war.
* The war and the insurrections and coups end within the same year that they began. Then the leader of Iran and the leader of Iraq will have much power and influence over the other Arab/Muslim nations, all of which will be led by extremists.
* the holy Pope Benedict XVI dies.
* the holy Pope called 'Peter the Roman' by St. Malachy is elected. I think that he will be Cardinal Arinze and that he will take the name Pope Pius XIII.

* New York City will be struck by a nuclear bomb (not a missile; not a dirty bomb) sometime between June 1, 2010 and Dec 31, 2010, inclusive
You will make them like an oven of fire, in the time of your presence.
The Lord will stir them up with his wrath, and fire will devour them.
* World War 3 begins as a result of the nuclear attack on New York City
* World War 3 is the first horseman of the apocalypse and the first of the Seven Seals.
* World War 3 is a war in which the Arab/Muslim nations of the Middle East and northern Africa invade and conquer all of Europe, parts of Eastern Europe, parts of Scandinavia, and the northern part of Africa above the equator.
* The Arab forces will be unstoppable, except that they can be held above the equator.
* To the soldiers who will fight for the Allies in World War 3, I tell you sincerely:
The Arab forces can be stopped above the equator in Africa.[/quote]
Holy Balls of Redemption! :o

Edited by Socrates
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1868325' date='May 15 2009, 07:56 PM']Oops, looks like Conte took down his remarkable prophecies for 2008 and 2009 from his website.

Looks like 2010 should still be quite an eventful year though:
Holy Balls of Redemption! :o[/quote]

Dear Socrates,
These are all ad hominem's.
Sincerely,
Slappo


PS: Although I do agree that they are ridiculous and can be very dangerous. I also agree that certain erroneous works give reason to carefully and prayerfully scrutinize other works by the same author.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Socrates' post='1868307' date='May 15 2009, 10:29 PM']What's his ideas on Hillary not winning that election?

Does that throw off the rest of his astonishing predictions? Will the Arabs still nuke NYC next year?

And could you get me the link to that site again? - I'm afraid I forgot it. I forget how many more times Christ was supposed to return; was it three or four times? (Seems Conte, in his wisdom said His Second Coming wouldn't leave much of a lasting impression on people.)

I wish to feast more on Conte's amazing prophecies so I won't be led astray by shams and amateurs like Scott Hahn or the Pope.[/quote]
you are acting like an idiot.

His works will find their time and fruition when God desires if he does.

Edited by kafka
Posted (edited)

here is Conte's post I was referring too:

The proposal that these embryos could be put at the disposal of infertile couples as a treatment for infertility is not ethically acceptable for the same reasons which make artificial heterologous procreation illicit as well as any form of surrogate motherhood; this practice would also lead to other problems of a medical, psychological and legal nature.

The problem here is that surrogate motherhood, while generally illicit as it is most often practiced, is not intrinsically evil. Therefore, there may be some circumstances and intentions by which surrogate motherhood is moral.

Artificial procreation is intrinsically evil, but saving frozen embryos from certain death (after these embryos were illicitly created by other persons) is obviously not intrinsically evil, since it is an exercise of love of neighbor to save an innocent person from certain death.

The problems associated with saving these embryos are substantial, and there are various morally illicit acts that must be avoided (including culling, formal cooperation, and immediate material cooperation).

It has also been proposed, solely in order to allow human beings to be born who are otherwise condemned to destruction, that there could be a form of “prenatal adoption”. This proposal, praiseworthy with regard to the intention of respecting and defending human life, presents however various problems not dissimilar to those mentioned above.

The term adoption is useful because some of the reasons for generally condemning surrogate motherhood are that the prenatal child is not the genetic child of the couple, but no one thinks that adoption of a born child is immoral for that same reason. Therefore, embryo adoption is not intrinsically evil.
[url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/co...n-life_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/co...n-life_en.html[/url]

Since the CDF states that the intention (first font of morality is good), and since the act itself with its moral object is not intrinsically evil, the morality of the act depends upon the moral weight of the good and bad consequences.

All things considered, it needs to be recognized that the thousands of abandoned embryos represent a situation of injustice which in fact cannot be resolved. Therefore John Paul II made an “appeal to the conscience of the world’s scientific authorities and in particular to doctors, that the production of human embryos be halted, taking into account that there seems to be no morally licit solution regarding the human destiny of the thousands and thousands of ‘frozen’ embryos which are and remain the subjects of essential rights and should therefore be protected by law as human persons”.

Notice that the CDF states that 'there seems to be' rather than a more definitive statement. This leaves open the possibility for faithful dissent from this point.

If frozen embryos can never be morally implanted, there would be no way to save their lives and they would certainly all die. There is a limited length of time during which an frozen embryo can be stored and then successfully thawed and implanted. If left in storage indefinitely, all such embryos will die.

In the third font of morality, the good of saving an innocent human person from certain death is one of the most weighty circumstances possible. Although the difficulties in saving such embryos are substantial, and there are a number of possible negative consequences as stated by the CDF in the two above cited documents, since there is no other way to save the lives of these hundreds of thousands of frozen embryos, the moral weight of the good consequnces outweighs the bad, and so the act is moral.

Frozen embryo adoption is moral, as long as formal cooperation, immediate material cooperation, culling (implanting excess embryos and then killing some to obtain the desired number), scandal, and any other sins are avoided.

Edited by kafka

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...