IrishSalesian Posted May 28, 2009 Posted May 28, 2009 [url="http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,522637,00.html?test=latestnews"]http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,522637...test=latestnews[/url] What is your reaction?
StColette Posted May 28, 2009 Posted May 28, 2009 Ridiculous! I guess Micah and I can't pray with our parents when we have dinner at our house now lol
IrishSalesian Posted May 28, 2009 Author Posted May 28, 2009 Freedom of religion is a Constitutional Right no?
eagle_eye222001 Posted May 28, 2009 Posted May 28, 2009 Well..... My reaction depends on the definition of a "few friends" and how many cars come to this event. Also how often? The article really doesn't give any details to this. I mean if they are having a few people over every week....let's say three cars that are parked on their driveway, and the street, I would say the county has no case and is being ridiculous. However, if we are talking about 12 cars every week that block up the street....then I would agree with the county as this has nothing to do with religion, and everything to do with holding too big of functions on an area not designed for such functions. Family parties every once in a while are one thing. Weekly meetings at a home in a populated neighborhood are inappropriate whether religious or secular. If the bible study is attracting a crowd of 15 cars weekly, they need to meet at a public meeting room or something along those lines. Given the lack of details in this article, I'm inclined to think that the county has a legitimate case and the pastor is being a crybaby about it. I doubt this bible study has less than 15 people and less than 10 cars. However since there are such sparse details, I don't think any real judgment can be laid down on this. ---------------- Now playing: [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/artist/linkin+park/track/what+ive+done+(live)"]Linkin Park - What I've Done (Live)[/url] via [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/signatunes/"]FoxyTunes[/url]
StColette Posted May 28, 2009 Posted May 28, 2009 My extended family used to gather at my grandparents house every weekend. We're talking 25+ people. I don't see how weekly family gatherings are inappropriate just because there happen to be more cars parked out front. If it was bothering the neighbors that much why didn't they try talking to the people first or asking if the Bible study participants could park further away or something. And typically Bible studies are around 12-15 people. Anything larger lends itself to other difficulties.
Archaeology cat Posted May 28, 2009 Posted May 28, 2009 [url="http://www.10news.com/news/19562217/detail.html"]Here's the longer article.[/url] It says they average 15 people. I suppose they could alternate who hosts it. A Bible study group I was in, in JAX, did that (we had 10 or so in the group).
eagle_eye222001 Posted May 28, 2009 Posted May 28, 2009 (edited) [quote name='StColette' post='1877359' date='May 28 2009, 04:44 PM']My extended family used to gather at my grandparents house every weekend. We're talking 25+ people. I don't see how weekly family gatherings are inappropriate just because there happen to be more cars parked out front. If it was bothering the neighbors that much why didn't they try talking to the people first or asking if the Bible study participants could park further away or something. And typically Bible studies are around 12-15 people. Anything larger lends itself to other difficulties.[/quote] I watched the TV interview and from it, it seems that they are having way more than 15 people. Like the article though, it really didn't say anything else and didn't clearly say they are having more than 15. In the interview, there is a note made of you need a permit for an event with more than 15 people and they neither confirmed nor denied that they were exceeding this. What is funny is that they had this interview with their lawyer. If the pastor was innocent and was having very few people over, I would think that would be in the article to publicly force the county to back off, but since they did not mention the number of people they are having over, it seems they are hiding the numbers and that makes me very suspicious of this "few friends." Would someone be allowed to hold atheist meetings at a house in a subdivision on a weekly basis with 20 people or more? I don't think so. edit: Just read this had an average group of 15. I wonder if that means 15 cars? ---------------- Now playing: [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/artist/linkin+park/track/session"]Linkin Park - Session[/url] via [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/signatunes/"]FoxyTunes[/url] Edited May 28, 2009 by eagle_eye222001
StColette Posted May 28, 2009 Posted May 28, 2009 [quote name='eagle_eye222001' post='1877369' date='May 28 2009, 04:54 PM']Would someone be allowed to hold atheist meetings at a house in a subdivision on a weekly basis with 20 people or more? I don't think so.[/quote] Why not? It's their house and property. Maybe they'll just have to park on the grass in their yard lol
CatholicCid Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 I'm always confused by this. If the street has public parking, can''t anyone park their cars there?
Socrates Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 Yeah, it's hard to know all the facts of this situation from the material. The test would be if the county would have the same penalties for a weekly poker night or TV ball-game watching party involving the same number of people.
MissScripture Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 [quote name='StColette' post='1877373' date='May 28 2009, 04:56 PM']Why not? It's their house and property. Maybe they'll just have to park on the grass in their yard lol[/quote] It's illegal to park your car on the lawn where I'm from. You can't even have an RV or something parked in your backyard, or you could get a ticket. You need to have a gravel path made to be able to park your RV in your own backyard. BUT, you ALSO aren't allowed to park on the street over night (but maybe that was just in the winter). At any rate, I find it utterly ridiculous. They (the city gov't who made those ordinances) justify it by saying that it would decrease property value of the houses around you.
Brother Adam Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 Oooh that is dangerous. I have never heard of anyone receiving an order to stop gathering peacefully in any private place except when they were blocking the road with their cars parked. Unless there is something we are not being told, like there were so many people in the house it exceeded the fire safety or other ordinance, than this would set an extremely dangerous precedence.
Lounge Daddy Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 When Government starts telling you what you can and cannot do with your own property, it is tyranny. It's an infringement on the right to property. Of course, Government is interested in anything BUT your right to life liberty and property.
MithLuin Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 But the gov't can tell you where you can park your cars. Ie, they could have the meeting if people carpooled, probably, though I don't really know the situation or problem here.
Archaeology cat Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 [quote name='MithLuin' post='1877637' date='May 29 2009, 04:57 AM']But the gov't can tell you where you can park your cars. Ie, they could have the meeting if people carpooled, probably, though I don't really know the situation or problem here.[/quote] I know a few of us carpooled when we went to the home Bible studies, so yes, a definite possibility. I wish we had more facts about all this so we knew exactly what was happening.
Archaeology cat Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 OK, a little more info here: [url="http://www.10news.com/news/19585458/detail.html"]http://www.10news.com/news/19585458/detail.html [/url] Some excerpts: [quote]Jones said a visitor to a neighbor's house called the County after a Bible study member hit the visitor’s car while leaving. Shortly after, a county code enforcement officer gave him a citation that said he needed a permit to host the weekly Bible study meetings, he said.[/quote] [quote]A County spokeswoman says the County is concerned with parking and its impact on the neighborhood.[/quote] So it looks like this started because of a traffic accident. But still, if they're parked legally, then I don't think there should be a problem with having people there. And if they aren't parked legally, then ticket the person who parked there, or the person who caused the accident - not the person at whose house they were.
whatsup Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 I saw the picture of the house and it looks as if this is a walled community. It also looks like this is on a bend. Trying to cram 15 cars or more on a tiny road is STUPID. I'm guessing the road is probably narrow, too, beucase it dosn't have a curb or rain vale. If you're in the country, yes, go right ahead but in a city which more than likely has a homeowner's association. Its just silly. Options...carpool, find a venue, etc. If I had 15 people over my apt driving on my street would be a total nightmare for everyone else...especially if anyone else decided to have a party. Mind you this is weekly and not one time...its not a big weekend bash. I'm just particular about cars and saftey. Imagine if someone came careening around that neighborhood when it was dark and stormy and killed someone beucase the street was overcrowded. A minor accident was just the precurser. So, why a permit? Why would that be ok? Well, a permit would pay for the extra poliece protection and the potential widening of the road, and things necessary to facilitate. It'd also shift the liability from the city to the homeowners and clearly define the rights of others on that street.
scardella Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 (edited) I think this is a violation of the right to free assembly and a violation of freedom of religion. Edited May 29, 2009 by scardella
hoosieranna Posted May 29, 2009 Posted May 29, 2009 [quote name='whatsup' post='1877790' date='May 29 2009, 07:10 AM']I saw the picture of the house and it looks as if this is a walled community. It also looks like this is on a bend. Trying to cram 15 cars or more on a tiny road is STUPID. I'm guessing the road is probably narrow, too, beucase it dosn't have a curb or rain vale. If you're in the country, yes, go right ahead but in a city which more than likely has a homeowner's association. Its just silly. Options...carpool, find a venue, etc. If I had 15 people over my apt driving on my street would be a total nightmare for everyone else...especially if anyone else decided to have a party. Mind you this is weekly and not one time...its not a big weekend bash. I'm just particular about cars and saftey. Imagine if someone came careening around that neighborhood when it was dark and stormy and killed someone beucase the street was overcrowded. A minor accident was just the precurser. So, why a permit? Why would that be ok? Well, a permit would pay for the extra poliece protection and the potential widening of the road, and things necessary to facilitate. It'd also shift the liability from the city to the homeowners and clearly define the rights of others on that street.[/quote] Basically, yes. I work for a local transportation planning authority. Road capacity is always a concern. [quote name='scardella' post='1877837' date='May 29 2009, 10:58 AM']I think this is a violation of the right to free assembly and a violation of freedom of religion.[/quote] It's not a violation if the homeowner is in violation of HOA covenants. The homeowner agreed to abide by the convenants when the moved in. Admittedly, the article didn't say if there is an HOA. It's also a safety concern if emergency vehicles can't get through. Sometimes one trumps the other. You need to get a permit for any sort of gathering that has the potential to disrupt normal functions and conditions. That's not an unusual requirement. Fifteen people is a fairly sizeable gathering. My guess is that one of the neighbors got miffed and reported the meetings. Letting neighbors know that you plan to have regular meetings goes a long way toward forestalling this sort of problem and is common courtesy.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now