Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

+J.M.J.+
the whole Fr. Cutie thing brought up a question for me. since he is validly ordained, going over to the Episcopal/Anglican church, does that mean he truly confects the Eucharist when he celebrates Mass in the Anglican church?

Posted

well there's a few things going on that would make the answer "no".

1. They use different types of bread. There are ingredients that would invalidate it
B. I'm pretty sure the prayers are different. That would invalidate it.
iii. Part of the mystery of the mass is that it is eternal. We are celebrating one mass with all the saints and everyone on earth at the same time. He won't be celebrating that


That plus the Church says he can't celebrate mass.

Paddington
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1877873' date='May 29 2009, 01:16 PM']That plus the Church says he can't celebrate mass.[/quote]

:hehe:

dominicansoul
Posted (edited)

Will he be excommunicated?

Edited by dominicansoul
Posted

[quote name='dominicansoul' post='1877885' date='May 29 2009, 12:31 PM']Will he be excommunicated?[/quote]

No he became Episcopal

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1877859' date='May 29 2009, 11:47 AM']+J.M.J.+
the whole Fr. Cutie thing brought up a question for me. since he is validly ordained, going over to the Episcopal/Anglican church, does that mean he truly confects the Eucharist when he celebrates Mass in the Anglican church?[/quote]


As hot stuff pointed out, the matter and the form are different in the Anglican Church.

Posted

Isn't there intent as well?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='StColette' post='1877889' date='May 29 2009, 10:39 AM']As Jaim[i]e[/i] pointed out, the matter and the form are different in the Anglican Church.[/quote]
The matter used in the Episcopal / Anglican Church is normally unleavened bread, and as far as the "form" (i.e., the words) of the prayer is concerned, there are many Eucharistic prayers that have been used in the history of the Church and so the fact that the Episcopal Church uses a different anaphora than the Roman Rite does not invalidate that rite [i]per se[/i]. The traditional answer of the Roman Church would be that Fr. Cutie's celebration of the Eucharist in the Episcopal Church is illicit, but not necessarily invalid (i.e., as long as he uses the proper matter and form with the proper intention).

On the other hand, the predominant view among Eastern Orthodox theologians would be that Fr. Cutie's celebration of the Eucharist (and also the other sacraments) would be invalid because in Orthodox theology grace is closely tied to the Church, which is the living body of Christ, and he is not a member of a true Orthodox Church.

Edited by Apotheoun
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

I hate using the word "confecting" in reference to the sacraments...makes me think of powdered sugar...

CatherineM
Posted

The letter that his bishop published pretty much pulled his facilities, so I wouldn't consider his Eucharist a valid one. I know he is going to pull some people with him, so more to his shame. And a big shame on the Episcopal bishop for making all this so easy for him. He has no consequences for violating his oaths, and the Episcopal bishop is participating in something that is causing a big rift for us for his benefit. It's poaching at its worse.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1877939' date='May 29 2009, 11:34 AM']The letter that his bishop published pretty much pulled his facilities, so I wouldn't consider his Eucharist a valid one. I know he is going to pull some people with him, so more to his shame. And a big shame on the Episcopal bishop for making all this so easy for him. He has no consequences for violating his oaths, and the Episcopal bishop is participating in something that is causing a big rift for us for his benefit. It's poaching at its worse.[/quote]
Taking away his "faculties" makes his celebration of the Eucharist illicit, not invalid. The Roman Church distinguishes between liceity and validity.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1877919' date='May 29 2009, 01:20 PM']The matter used in the Episcopal / Anglican Church is normally unleavened bread, and as far as the "form" (i.e., the words) of the prayer is concerned, there are many Eucharistic prayers that have been used in the history of the Church and so the fact that the Episcopal Church uses a different anaphora than the Roman Rite does not invalidate that rite [i]per se[/i]. The traditional answer of the Roman Church would be that Fr. Cutie's celebration of the Eucharist in the Episcopal Church is illicit, but not necessarily invalid (i.e., as long as he uses the proper matter and form with the proper intention).

On the other hand, the predominant view among Eastern Orthodox theologians would be that Fr. Cutie's celebration of the Eucharist (and also the other sacraments) would be invalid because in Orthodox theology grace is closely tied to the Church, which is the living body of Christ, and he is not a member of a true Orthodox Church.[/quote]

the flaw in your logic is that priests in mortal sin can celebrate mass validly

Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1877957' date='May 29 2009, 12:08 PM']the flaw in your logic is that priests in mortal sin can celebrate mass validly[/quote]
Where have I said that a priest in mortal sin cannot celebrate the Eucharist validly?

Fr. Cutie's moving into a heretical Church, according to traditional Western sacramentology, has no impact on the validity of his celebration of the Eucharist as long as he uses the proper matter and form with the right intention.

Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1877957' date='May 29 2009, 01:08 PM']the flaw in your logic is that priests in mortal sin can celebrate mass validly[/quote]
That never stopped the Priests and Popes in the Dark Ages.

CatherineM
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1877950' date='May 29 2009, 12:53 PM']Taking away his "faculties" makes his celebration of the Eucharist illicit, not invalid. The Roman Church distinguishes between liceity and validity.[/quote]

I realize the church would consider it valid but not licit. I was speaking more to how I would feel. In my heart if something isn't licit it isn't valid either. I know that isn't theologically correct, but I don't store my theology books in my heart. Even if it was valid theologically, I certainly wouldn't attend.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1877965' date='May 29 2009, 02:35 PM']Where have I said that a priest in mortal sin cannot celebrate the Eucharist validly?[/quote]

I think the reason hot stuff said that was because of the following (emphasis mine):

[quote]On the other hand, the predominant view among Eastern Orthodox theologians would be [b]that Fr. Cutie's celebration of the Eucharist (and also the other sacraments) would be invalid because in Orthodox theology grace is closely tied to the Church, which is the living body of Christ, and he is not a member of a true Orthodox Church.[/b][/quote]

The sentence can come across as saying that those not in the state of grace cannot validly celebrate Mass or the other Sacraments.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='StColette' post='1877969' date='May 29 2009, 12:42 PM'][quote name='Apotheoun' post='1877965' date='May 29 2009, 12:35 PM']Where have I said that a priest in mortal sin cannot celebrate the Eucharist validly?[/quote]
I think the reason Jaim[i]e[/i] said that was because of the following (emphasis mine):

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1877965' date='May 29 2009, 12:35 PM']On the other hand, the predominant view among Eastern Orthodox theologians would be that Fr. Cutie's celebration of the Eucharist (and also the other sacraments) would be invalid because in Orthodox theology grace is closely tied to the Church, which is the living body of Christ, and he is not a member of a true Orthodox Church.[/quote]

The sentence can come across as saying that those not in the state of grace cannot validly celebrate Mass or the other Sacraments.
[/quote]
The Eastern Orthodox Churches follow the sacramental doctrine of St. Cyprian, and not that of St. Augustine. Nevertheless, the Orthodox do not believe that a priest must be in a "state of grace," which itself is a concept that is foreign to Orthodoxy, in order to validly celebrate the Eucharist.

The personal holiness of a priest, or the lack thereof, does not have any impact on the validity of the celebration of a sacrament in the Orthodox tradition.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1877968' date='May 29 2009, 12:41 PM']I realize the church would consider it valid but not licit. I was speaking more to how I would feel. In my heart if something isn't licit it isn't valid either. I know that isn't theologically correct, but I don't store my theology books in my heart. Even if it was valid theologically, I certainly wouldn't attend.[/quote]
I think this is a matter of doctrine, and not [i]feelings[/i].

I have been to several Catholic Churches where I did not [i]feel[/i] God's presence -- for many reasons -- during the liturgical worship of a particular congregation, but I knew as a matter of faith that He was present in the Eucharistic celebration in spite of my [i]feelings[/i] to the contrary.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...