Isidore Posted April 12, 2004 Posted April 12, 2004 [quote name='RedSnapper' date='Apr 4 2004, 05:12 PM'] I don't know if it was a technical error (probably not, since Gibson is so attentive to detail) but I noticed the eyes of Gesmus get pecked out by the crow and afterwards, when the roman soldiers are breaking his legs, he still has his eyes. I would really take a second look, if you can at those two tables. They really are very different. Another interesting thing I noticed is when Jesus and Barabbus were standing near each other, Jesus looked at Barabbus, Barabbus became subdued in his glee. The right eye of Jesus was completely swollen shut and Barabbus' right eye was completely scarred... which gave him the appearance of blindness. The spiritual blindness of Barabbus is what it made me think of. A little something more to meditate on. AMDG RS [/quote] Greetings, You know you bring up a great point in general. Did you know that historians and theolgians believe that Barrabus' name was actually Yeshua Bar Abbas, or Jesus Son of the Father? Yeshua or Jesus was a very common name at the time, and the correlary between the two is striking. Perfect good against incarnate evil. The son of the True father forgives the sins of the son of the earthly father.
RedSnapper Posted April 14, 2004 Posted April 14, 2004 I'd heard about their names having the same meaning some time ago but had forgotten. Thanks for the information. What was that look on Barrabus' face when he looked in the eyes of Jesus? Was it perhaps, a complete lack of understanding, like being baffled? I am not sure. It was a quick scene. They certainly seemed to be at direct opposite ends of a spectrum! Thanks again. AMDG RS
Homestarlover85 Posted April 14, 2004 Posted April 14, 2004 i niticed Barrabus' face to, when he looked at Jesus. My first thought was that B. knew that Jesus was innocent, but since he (Barrabus) was now free, it didnt matter
RedSnapper Posted April 14, 2004 Posted April 14, 2004 I agree. It seems he looked at Jesus with a look that portrayed that he understood our Lord's innocence. It was kind of funny how he descended the stairs with his arms outstretched to embrace his people and they pushed him away and didn't want him in their midst. I wonder if Mel was trying to relate the Jewish sense of good and bad in this part of the scene or some other reason? AMDG RS
myduwigd Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 Hey guys, I heard that the Passion was less Catholic than some people expected it to be. But I think that Mel Gibson did a good job subtly sticking Catholic ideas in the movie (besides the cloth with Jesus' face on it). For instance, it is a good guide on how to pray the Rosary. The main focus is on Christ and His suffering (in movie and Rosary), but MAry is also a very important and moving part of it too. I think the movie offers a good guide to how you can medidate while praying the Rosary and focus both on Jesus and Mary (mostly on Christ naturally, though). Also when JEsus was being accused before the pharisees someone yells out that He claims that we must eat of his body and blood. any more ideas, critiques?
God Conquers Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 [quote name='Isidore' date='Apr 12 2004, 08:04 AM'] Greetings, On the table scene.... I think the meaning of this scene is much more subtle. In the scene Jesus tells Mary that a rich benefactor ordered it. Mary tries it out, and says that it will never catch on. It was not Jesus' idea, it was just his job to build the table to the specifications of the one who ordered it. What was Jesus' mission? He was charged by God (rich benefactor) to bring forth the good news. It was different, and no one thought it would catch on. He built a church, that was different, and we sit at his table every week. When we go home, we sit at the kind of table Gibson envisioned Jesus building as well. So, they both caught on. Gibson is a grand storyteller. [/quote] Wow! That is an AWESOME observation! Thank you. oh so subtle.
Rebirth flame Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 hmmm... yeah... i too have seen the Passion again since my last post, and i must say that the tables are considerably different in the two scenes... i guess the person that told me that was just mistaken.... oh well, it matters not. sorry!
willguy Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 [quote name='Isidore' date='Apr 12 2004, 09:17 AM'] You know you bring up a great point in general. Did you know that historians and theolgians believe that Barrabus' name was actually Yeshua Bar Abbas, or Jesus Son of the Father? Yeshua or Jesus was a very common name at the time, and the correlary between the two is striking. Perfect good against incarnate evil. The son of the True father forgives the sins of the son of the earthly father. [/quote] Some ancient Bible manuscripts call Barabbas "Jesus Barabbas". It is understandable why others dropped the first name. However, you are right, Barabbas means "son of the father," so the irony of the people shouting "Give us Barabbas (the Son of the Father)" is there. Whether it is divine irony or satanic would be an interesting discussion...
willguy Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 [quote name='Rebirth flame' date='Apr 20 2004, 04:26 PM'] hmmm... yeah... i too have seen the Passion again since my last post, and i must say that the tables are considerably different in the two scenes... i guess the person that told me that was just mistaken.... oh well, it matters not. sorry! [/quote] Its a rumor that's been going around. A lot of people probably spread it without taking the time to look and see if its really true (thats how rumors are).
Lynne Posted April 22, 2004 Posted April 22, 2004 I saw the film with a group of students from a highschool out of town while we were doing a 30-hour famine and we had a discussion afterwards. When the devil holds a baby... What does the child represent? My sister told me that it represents humanity and how he holds the world in his hands or something. Any ideas?
RedSnapper Posted April 22, 2004 Posted April 22, 2004 Wow. That's pretty deep thinking there. Somewhere there is a quote of Mel Gibson saying that its the corruption of the most innocent and best (paraphrased). To see a baby being comforted, etc. then to see the baby turn and is really like, so ugly. It shows the evil of the devil perverting the good. That was a wonderful profound post on the table and then Barabbus and Jesus. Very good things to ponder. AMDG, RS
Caitlin Posted April 22, 2004 Posted April 22, 2004 Another theory on the baby is that it's the Antichrist. Also, it's an "if you had been my child you never would have suffered..." sort of deal. And, also a lot of what Redsnapper said as well.
luciana Posted April 23, 2004 Posted April 23, 2004 Also, it could be that it's like a blasphemous mocking of the Madonna w/ Jesus image, especially how the veil part of Satan's outfit kind of covers the demon baby and it looks like a touching scene till the baby turns around. notice how the movie also portays Mary and satan opposing each other, when they are walking along the Via Delarosa on opposite sides. I think the scene can have several layers of meaning I wonder if this is from the visions of Catherine Emmerich. i have to look it up in the book and see. Red SNapper, I think that quote's from an interview he had w/ Christianity today mag, or some other protestant magazine.
RedSnapper Posted April 23, 2004 Posted April 23, 2004 Oh ok. Thanks. So now I have not studied about the anti-Christ much. Is he supposed to be a real man?? My husband thinks its Michael Eisner. haaa!
luciana Posted May 4, 2004 Posted May 4, 2004 (edited) Did anybody else notice this? I mentioned it previously in this thread: [quote] One really cool thing I think I noticed is a cross in the sky. It could have been my imagination , but when it goes to one of Jesus' flashbacks of the Last Supper, a cross of light seems to be in the sky. It was right before it goes to the scene with them bringing the bread to the table at the Last Supper.[/quote] Also, I noticed 2 points when Jesus looks like he sheds tears: At the mid. of the night trial, after he says how he is the Son of God, the Messiah, the IAM, and they all shout verdict of death, He cries before they start maltreating Him. Also, when he is talking to Pilate the first time and says he is King and the Truth and all who hear Him hear truth. there are probably more, but that's what I noticed. Edited May 4, 2004 by luciana
OpusDei Posted May 16, 2004 Posted May 16, 2004 There are a few instances which just drives me to tears just thinking of them: The part where the one thief on the cross askes for forgiveness (It's also the part i the bible which won me over to Christianity!) The parts where Jesus tells the twelve of how they will be hated for his name sake & where He instituted the Eucharist. I already in tears again!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now