Resurrexi Posted June 14, 2009 Author Posted June 14, 2009 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1890015' date='Jun 13 2009, 10:35 PM']We have waited too long to apply the decrees of Vatican Council II and the Encyclicals and letters by the Popes, and notably by Pope John Paul II.[/quote] I thought you claimed that this council and those papal decrees didn't apply to you.
Apotheoun Posted June 14, 2009 Posted June 14, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1890021' date='Jun 13 2009, 08:50 PM']I thought you claimed that this council and those papal decrees didn't apply to you.[/quote] They do not, nor did the Patriarch state that they do apply to us, but they do apply to the Roman patriarchate, which still has not implemented them fully on questions related to the autonomy of the [i]sui juris[/i] Churches of the East. I would say that you are an example of a person who has been unaffected by the Roman Church's local council held at the Vatican in the 1960s, for you take a basically imperialist position that would force Latin uniformity upon the Eastern Catholic Churches. Edited June 14, 2009 by Apotheoun
Resurrexi Posted June 14, 2009 Author Posted June 14, 2009 (edited) At least I accept its claim of ecumenical status. N.B., I have never claimed that the East needs to have the same liturgy as the West, which you seem to imply by "Latin uniformity". I do, however, believe that the Eastern Churches need to be in doctrinal uniformity with the Latin Church. Edited June 14, 2009 by Resurrexi
Apotheoun Posted June 14, 2009 Posted June 14, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1890031' date='Jun 13 2009, 09:06 PM']At least I accept its claim of ecumenical status. N.B., I have never claimed that the East needs to have the same liturgy as the West, which you seem to imply by "Latin uniformity". I do, however, believe that the Eastern Churches need to be in doctrinal uniformity with the Latin Church.[/quote] The East not only has a distinctive liturgy, but also a distinctive spirituality in its mystical tradition, and a distinctive theological and doctrinal tradition as well, which is found in the writings of the Eastern Fathers and in liturgical / dogmatic texts like the [url="http://sites.google.com/site/thetaboriclight/synodikon"][u][b]Synodikon of Orthodoxy[/b][/u][/url], and in the decrees of the Seven Ecumenical Councils. Edited June 14, 2009 by Apotheoun
OraProMe Posted June 14, 2009 Posted June 14, 2009 Apotheon, You don't accept the councils of the Church or the Supremacy of the Bishop of Rome over all local Church's and rites. Why don't you just go into schism with your "eastern brothers"?
Resurrexi Posted June 14, 2009 Author Posted June 14, 2009 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1890050' date='Jun 13 2009, 11:36 PM']The East not only has a distinctive liturgy, but also a distinctive spirituality in its mystical tradition, and a distinctive theological and doctrinal tradition as well, which is found in the writings of the Eastern Fathers and in liturgical / dogmatic texts like the [url="http://sites.google.com/site/thetaboriclight/synodikon"][u][b]Synodikon of Orthodoxy[/b][/u][/url], and in the decrees of the Seven Ecumenical Councils.[/quote] The doctrines of the Universal Church, in which are the Latin Church as well as the Eastern Churches, can be found in teachings of the Supreme Pontiffs and of the twenty-one Ecumenical Councils
Apotheoun Posted June 14, 2009 Posted June 14, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1890060' date='Jun 13 2009, 09:46 PM']The doctrines of the Universal Church, in which are the Latin Church as well as the Eastern Churches, can be found in teachings of the Supreme Pontiffs and of the twenty-one Ecumenical Councils[/quote] I disagree. The Pope is first among equals in the episcopate, but as the protos he cannot teach independently of the universal episcopate. My Patriarch is also a historic successor of St. Peter, as is the Patriarch of Alexandria (cf. St. Gregory the Great, [i]Registrum Epistolarum[/i], Book 7:40 and Book 8:30), and -- of course -- all bishops are successors of St. Peter sacramentally, because by their consecration they are successors of all the Apostles, which necessarily includes St. Peter. As St. Cyprian said centuries ago, all episcopal sees are "cathedra Petri." I affirm and venerate Seven Ecumenical Councils as binding upon all Christians. Edited June 14, 2009 by Apotheoun
Apotheoun Posted June 14, 2009 Posted June 14, 2009 [i]Below is a post I wrote in response to what you said in another thread, but I think it would be helpful in this new thread also, so I am re-posting it here:[/i] Sadly, this is an issue that we will not agree upon, because we understand the nature and role of the bishop of Rome differently. The pope has no authority [i]over[/i] the other [i]sui juris[/i] Churches, because any concept of supreme authority of one bishop [i]over[/i] another bishop, or of one Church [i]over[/i] another Church, destroys the reality of communion, which is not about power [i]over[/i] others, but about reciprocity and sharing in the common divine life of the body of Christ. In fact, in an ecclesiology of communion, or what Fr. Schmemann calls, a "eucharistic" ecclesiology, it is not possible for one Church (or one bishop) to have power [i]over[/i] another Church (or bishop), because each and every particular Church is the full realization of the one Catholic and Apostolic Church. In other words, power in the Church cannot be thought of as "power [i]over[/i] others," but must be understood as "service" to others. Thus, it must not be thought of in legal or jurisdictional terms, but in terms of service and love in support of communion. As Fr. Schmemann explains, "The essential corollary of this eucharistic ecclesiology is that it excludes the idea of a supreme power, understood as power [i]over[/i] the local Church and her bishop," because as he goes on to say, "A supreme power would mean power [i]over[/i] the Church, [i]over[/i] the Body of Christ, [i]over[/i] Christ Himself," and this is simply contrary to the Orthodox faith of the Fathers ["The Primacy of Peter in the Orthodox Church," pages 38-39]. Bearing in mind what I have already said, it is clear that the "sacred power" of popes and patriarchs -- which is founded upon the unity of the sacrament of orders -- is one of service, and so it must not be thought of in monarchical, legalistic, or jurisdictional terms. Moreover, this "sacred power" is held equally by all who possess the grace of sacramental ordination to the episcopate. Ultimately, the eucharistic ecclesiology of the first millennium is opposed to the universalist ecclesiology of the Latin Church of the middle ages, which only developed due to the Scholastic isolation of the Latin Church from the great patristic tradition of the earliest centuries of the Christian era that is the common patrimony of both East and West. Finally, from an Eastern Christian perspective, following the teachings of the Holy Fathers, the pope has authority within his own patriarchal Church, but even within the Roman Church the pope himself is subject to Tradition, and so he cannot simply alter the liturgy or break with immemorial custom, and there will continue to be liturgical upheavals within the Western Church until this truth is unequivocally reaffirmed.
Resurrexi Posted June 14, 2009 Author Posted June 14, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1890063' date='Jun 13 2009, 11:49 PM']I disagree. The Pope is first among equals in the episcopate, but as the protos he cannot teach independently of the universal episcopate. My Patriarch is also a historic successor of St. Peter, as is the Patriarch of Alexandria (cf. St. Gregory the Great, [i]Registrum Epistolarum[/i], Book 7:40 and Book 8:30), and -- of course -- all bishops are successors of St. Peter sacramentally, because by their consecration they are successors of all the Apostles, which necessarily includes St. Peter. As St. Cyprian said centuries ago, all episcopal sees are "cathedra Petri."[/quote] Only the Bishop of Rome is successor of Peter in the primacy (cf. First Ecumenical Council of the Vatican, DS 3058) Edited June 14, 2009 by Resurrexi
Apotheoun Posted June 14, 2009 Posted June 14, 2009 [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1890088' date='Jun 13 2009, 10:17 PM']Only the Bishop of Rome is successor of Peter in the primacy (cf. First Ecumenical Council of the Vatican, DS 3058)[/quote] I agree with Pope St. Gregory, who said: "Wherefore though there are many apostles, yet with regard to the principality itself the See of the Prince of the apostles alone has grown strong in authority, which in three places [i.e., Rome, Alexandria, and Antioch] is the See of one."
Resurrexi Posted June 14, 2009 Author Posted June 14, 2009 Do you mean the St. Gregory who spoke of "the Apostolic See, which is the head of all Churches"?
Apotheoun Posted June 14, 2009 Posted June 14, 2009 [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1890134' date='Jun 13 2009, 11:14 PM']Do you mean the St. Gregory who spoke of "the Apostolic See, which is the head of all Churches"?[/quote] Yes, the very same man, for he spoke of Rome, Antioch, and Alexandria as one see in three places, being governed by three bishops, who together prossess primacy through historic succession. Although as I said in my earlier post all bishops are successors of St. Peter through the sacrament of episcopal consecration, which means that all the bishops are equal in authority.
Resurrexi Posted June 14, 2009 Author Posted June 14, 2009 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1890171' date='Jun 14 2009, 01:49 AM']Yes, the very same man, for he spoke of Rome, Antioch, and Alexandria as one see in three places, being governed by three bishops, who together prossess primacy through historic succession. Although as I said in my earlier post all bishops are successors of St. Peter through the sacrament of episcopal consecration, which means that all the bishops are equal in authority.[/quote] The term "the Apostolic See" refers to Rome alone, as can be clearly seen in Epistle 3.30.
Apotheoun Posted June 14, 2009 Posted June 14, 2009 [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1890173' date='Jun 13 2009, 11:57 PM']The term "the Apostolic See" refers to Rome alone, as can be clearly seen in Epistle 3.30.[/quote] You really do not know much about history! In the East there are dozens (even hundreds) of Apostolic Sees, e.g., Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem, Ephesus, just to name a few off the top of my head.
Resurrexi Posted June 14, 2009 Author Posted June 14, 2009 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1890176' date='Jun 14 2009, 02:04 AM']You really do not know much about history! In the East there are dozens (even hundreds) of Apostolic Sees, e.g., Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem, Ephesus, just to name a few off the top of my head.[/quote] I am aware that there were numerous sees founded by Apostles, but only Rome is referred to as "the Apostolic See."
Apotheoun Posted June 15, 2009 Posted June 15, 2009 [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1890189' date='Jun 14 2009, 12:26 AM']I am aware that there were numerous sees founded by Apostles, but only Rome is referred to as "the Apostolic See."[/quote] Your conclusion does not follow. I call the See of Antioch "the Apostolic See" of Antioch. Antioch, Alexandria, Rome, Jerusalem, Ephesus, et al., are all historically apostolic. In fact, every see is sacramentally apostolic and petrine, because the bishops throughout the whole Church are successors of all the Apostles, which necessarily includes St. Peter.
Resurrexi Posted June 15, 2009 Author Posted June 15, 2009 The decrees of the Holy Roman Church are published in a gazette called the [i]Acta Apostolicae Sedis[/i]. Another name would be used (e.g. Acta Romanae Sedis) if it were thought that the term [i]Apostolica Sedes[/i] did not refer uniquely to Rome. (I am glad that you at least do not try to claim that Constantinople is a see founded by one of the Apostles, by the way!)
Apotheoun Posted June 15, 2009 Posted June 15, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1890770' date='Jun 14 2009, 07:47 PM']The decrees of the Holy Roman Church are published in a gazette called the [i]Acta Apostolicae Sedis[/i]. Another name would be used (e.g. Acta Romanae Sedis) if it were thought that the term [i]Apostolica Sedes[/i] did not refer uniquely to Rome. (I am glad that you at least do not try to claim that Constantinople is a see founded by one of the Apostles, by the way!)[/quote] Rome is but one "apostolic see," but there are dozens, and possibly hundreds of apostolic sees in the Eastern Churches. What Roman Curial authorities decide to call the publications of its patriarchate in the 20th century and in the 21st century is historically irrelevant to the question at hand. Edited June 15, 2009 by Apotheoun
Resurrexi Posted June 15, 2009 Author Posted June 15, 2009 In any case, St. Gregory the Great clearly was not referring to any other see than the Roman See in Epistle 3.30.
Apotheoun Posted June 15, 2009 Posted June 15, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Resurrexi' post='1890787' date='Jun 14 2009, 07:59 PM']In any case, St. Gregory the Great clearly was not referring to any other see than the Roman See in Epistle 3.30.[/quote] He does not have to mention the other two historic petrine sees in every letter, because the fact that he did it in one letter proves your position false. One time by a pope of equating the three historic petrine sees is sufficient evidence to confirm the equality of those sees, and in the final anaylsis of all episcopal sees, for the episcopate is one sacrament, and not many. Edited June 15, 2009 by Apotheoun
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now