Iacobus Posted April 18, 2004 Posted April 18, 2004 I have been to teen Masses before. Always at the retreat center. But I must say I love my more tradional mass. Thankful, this Masses are better than most LT. NO altar gathering, same readings, kneeling, homilies always present, no dances, etc. I only think I do not like is the comerty music. If all my parish had was LT I don't think I would go as often. I like the normal Mass. I conncet more with Christ there than at a LT.
HomeTeamFamily Posted April 18, 2004 Author Posted April 18, 2004 can someone provide a link or a citation to/from the GIRM that adresses the altar gather?
JP2Iloveyou Posted April 18, 2004 Posted April 18, 2004 Here it is. [url="http://www.ewtn.com/vexperts/showresult.asp?RecNum=310233&Forums=8&Experts=8&Days=3000&Author=&Keyword=Lifeteen&pgnu=1&groupnum=0"]http://www.ewtn.com/vexperts/showresult.as...nu=1&groupnum=0[/url]
HomeTeamFamily Posted April 19, 2004 Author Posted April 19, 2004 i posted that on my LTs message board to see what kind of reaction it gets....it definitely makes me think....
ilovechrist Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 [quote name='aznsonny27' date='Apr 18 2004, 01:24 PM'] that may be true. but at my parish we do kneel. and are you saying the teens are not sacred enough to be on the altar. if anything the teens are more sacred than the priests and deacons. [/quote] um.. teens can be on the altar--but as altar servers. how can they be more sacred than priests and deacons, who have received the Sacrament of Holy Orders?? i'm really curious about this one
M.SIGGA Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Apr 18 2004, 03:00 PM'] Liturgical dancing is forbidden in the US unless you are Hawaiian. [/quote] ... and African American parishes. bwt I love Lifeteen because it's a gift to the Church and has yeilded sooo much fruit it's amazing!
Philippe Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Apr 18 2004, 03:00 PM'] I also wonder what will happen when the teens grow up and have to attend a regular Mass like the rest of us. Will they be bored due to lack of entertainment? [/quote] first of all you might be gettin the wrong idea of lifeteen masses... EVERYONE is invited we have 90 year old people there and 9 month old people there i mean its not [b]only[/b] for the teens its just geared more towards teens and that alter gather is interesting ill let my youth leader know about this
hopeful1 Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 (edited) we have a knock off version of lifeteen that we started about a year ago (and have a childrens mass) over at my parish, but it actually appeals to people of all ages. actually, i think we have more ppl there over 50 than we do teens! actually it's basically the same as the traditional mass with the same readings, except the music is a little more upbeat (we usually take stuff from "Spirit and Song" from the OCP if anyone is familiar with it) and use some of Michael W. Smith's stuff (ex. Agnus Dei, Awesome God, Heart of Worship, Forever, ect), but overall it's a nice blend of traditional and "contemporary stuff". We also have a drummer, which i understand is a bit controversial, but i can assure you all that what he plays IS NOT too loud or overdone, but played in a tasteful manner that is both reverent and respectful to the mass. (pk, maybe it's one of those things you need to see, but trust me on this one). None of the readings are omitted. the liturgical dance, is rarely done, if at all (maybe once during lent or advent). we've never done skits. We do have the alter gathering, but we've been doing that at the children's mass for as long as i can remember, so I don't have a problem with it. And when we are up there the priests asks us to bow whenever he kneels to show reverence towards the eucharist. whether or not the kids understand that, i can't judge. I've never been to a LT mass personally, but i enjoy what we have at my parish. I also grew up going to saturday vigils so i can appreciate the traditional stuff as well. From what i heard, i believe Lifeteen and simular programs are a good thing. Obviously not for everyone, but as someone else on here already said it draws in ppl who wouldn't ordinarily go to mass. Edited April 19, 2004 by hopeful1
musturde Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 The Pope doesn't have to neccisarily say something about LifeTeen for it to be acceptable. Somethings can slide if the Bishop is cool with it. I haven't heard a Bishop say anything wrong about LifeTeen in my area so I'm cool with it. True, the Popes said nothing to support it, but has he said anything against it?
musturde Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 Btw I was implying the gathering around the alter and any other objections to Lifeteen.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 Oik is right on the money.!! There is nothing in the GIRM about a Bishop being able to change the Mass, and permit teenagers to gather around the altar. THe United States Conference of Catholic Bishops have NOT given lifeteen permission to do their own thing. There is nothing in the GIRM about African-American parishes having permission to do liturgical dancing either. They are not in Africa. What does it say about obedience if we tell teenagers the rules do not apply to them, that disobedience is acceptable? Lifeteen knows exactly what they are doing - they know they don't have permission from the USCCB - ask them for documentation - it doesn't exist. I have asked. They just figure it brings kids in, so lets do it anyway. They are breaking a cardinal rule of Catholic morality. The end does not justify the means. They are teaching feeling good is more important than obedience, and I do hate this phrase - what would Jesus think?
HomeTeamFamily Posted April 19, 2004 Author Posted April 19, 2004 can i get a quote from teh GIRM that says that the "altar gather" is not allowed???
JP2Iloveyou Posted April 19, 2004 Posted April 19, 2004 [quote name='lankyswimmer' date='Apr 19 2004, 08:06 AM'] can i get a quote from teh GIRM that says that the "altar gather" is not allowed??? [/quote] The short answer is no. They can't write in every single thing that you are NOT supposed to do into the GIRM. It would take forever and be way to long for anyone to read. Instead, they only put in there what IS to be done. In short, if it doesn't specifically say to do it, then it shouldn't be done, but you are correct, there is no line that says, "Do not gather around the altar at Lifeteen Masses." This is often used to justify holding hands during the Our Father. People will say that, well, the GIRM doesn't forbid it, so we must be able to do it. That misses the entire point though. Like I said, the GIRM can't discuss things that are forbidden for the sake of brevity. The GIRM also doesn't forbid smoking of talking on your cell phone during Mass. [quote]The Pope doesn't have to neccisarily say something about LifeTeen for it to be acceptable. Somethings can slide if the Bishop is cool with it. I haven't heard a Bishop say anything wrong about LifeTeen in my area so I'm cool with it. True, the Popes said nothing to support it, but has he said anything against it?[/quote] Actually, this is incorrect. The local bishop has no authority in this regard. For that matter, neither do episcopal councils like the USCCB. All authority to change the liturgy lies in Rome. Canon 838, 1. [b]The supervision of the sacred liturgy depends solely on the authority of the Church which resides in the Apostolic See[/b] and, in accord with the law, the diocesan bishop. The liturgical law does not give the bishop authority to override the general law, which does not allow this practice. In fact, only the ministers are to be in the sanctuary (including laity serving as lectors, servers, etc.), and they may not stand around the altar as if concelebrants. This does give the local ordinary some flexibility on liturgical law, but having people other than the ministers in the sanctuary is not among them.
Yours Truly Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 I myself am 17 years old and have been attending LT at my parish for 3 years now and i strongly disagree with gathering on the alter and have had many arguments with the core team and our priests and i acctually stopped coming up for a few weeks until our DRE convinced me that i should continue if nothing more for unity of practice within lifeteen. So i drudgingly go up everyweek, well i don't feel so bad about it when i'm a eucharistic minister up there, thats about every week but still ... Noone in our parish kneels because we don't have kneelers, this itself infuriates me because people are more worried about their knee's hurting then showing revernce to the holy sacrifie of the alter. Stupid heathens *shakes fist* -Yours Truly
nikkan_hanil Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 i'm not against it, but some lt masses have "liturgical abuse" written all over them.
morostheos Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 On a positive note, the lifeteen website got a green light from Catholic Culture (just trying to lighten up the mood)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now