SevenSorrows Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 [quote name='aznsonny27' date='Apr 19 2004, 05:25 PM'] what is wrong with altar gathering? [/quote] Well first off, Church law is against it, so that should be good enough. But that being said, it is also Church law that we must kneel during the consecration and from what I have seen, lifeteen masses do not do this (yes I know their are exceptions). But the altar is holy, a miracle occurs there, they are witnessing a miracle in which bread and wine are becoming the body and blood of Christ and: 1) they are distracting the rest of the Church who is gathering to observe this miracle. It is very distracting to see 20-50 kids crowding around an altar and fidgiting and moving/talking, laughing. 2) The immodest dress of many girls is offensive, plus it is distracting and causing people to sin, while they are in the presence of God. 3) The youth are learning that if someone wants to change something in the Church without official approval it is ok, as long as a bunch of people like it. 4) It detracts from the reverence and mystery of the act. If the altar is no longer holy and revered, then what is? But I am tired and don't feel like thinking of more. Lastly, I too have tried to contact Lifeteen, but they never like to write back. I did get one response from a Lifeteen priest on their website who tried to belittle me whenever I cited the GIRM, or canon law. Then he goes on to say that they are waiting for approval (a letter has gone to the pope to authorize lifeteen). Of course no letter has been seen and nothing has been approved, but canon law does tell us that when an abuse exists we must stop the abuse immediately until it is resolved. Unlike lifeteen who likes to continue the abuse until they get a letter from the pope (what are the chances of that). So that was a pretty safe call on their part "hey lets send a letter to the pope and if he doesn't write back, then we are ok!!!" Don't get me wrong, I love the youth and want to bring them into the truth, but misuse and abuse is not the way.
JP2Iloveyou Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 I agree SevenSorrows. Make no mistake about it, if and when, God willing, I'm a pastor someday, Lifeteen will be welcome at my parish, but unless they have an indult in their hands from Rome, there will be NO altar gathering going on. [quote]argh will someone just get a final answer?[/quote] I guess I don't know how much clearer it can be made. I've quoted the GIRM and Cannon Law. is there something else you would like to see?
HomeTeamFamily Posted April 20, 2004 Author Posted April 20, 2004 the way i understand it is that the canon law is like the rule....but the GIRM is the implementation of the rule, like the practical application of the rule.....we went through this crisis at our parish right before they put out the new GIRM....and after it was we discussed what it was going to mean.....and there was a part that adressed people "aproaching the altar"...meaning taking something off of it......so as long as one does not "approach the altar"...they are welcome in the sanctuary space also....what about like before mass if someone needs to go put something on the altar or at the podium where the lectors read from?...shouldnt that also be considedred in the same category?
dUSt Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 I think LifeTeen has many very positive things going for it. Overall, I think it has the potential to be an awesome tool for the Church. But, I do not agree with a few things LifeTeen tries to incorporate into the mass. First, the alternate ending is just plain bad theology. "The mass never ends, it must be lived" is simply theologically unsound. Second, there are many reasons why the altar gather is harmful: 1. The GIRM does not allow it 2. Most of the time, the teens do not kneel, which is not good (there's a [b]reason[/b] why we kneel) 3. It separates the teens from the rest of the congregation, which breaks the unity of "one body" 4. It causes a distraction to the rest of the congregation 5. It gives special treatment to one group of people, while leaving out the rest 6. It gives a false impression that the teens are just as important as the priest, blurring the lines of authority and apostolic succession I think if LifeTeen would stop these practices it would be a lot more succesful. 1) because it would be more accepted, and 2) because I think there is a renewal among teens today for a love of Sacred Tradition--for the most part, I think they're beyond the "feel good" movement Anyway. That's my .2 cents. God bless.
Dflanni Posted April 20, 2004 Posted April 20, 2004 I agree with Dust. As a Catholic seminarian and future priest I have my thoughts on this matter. When I was in high school, some from the LifeTeen group from my parish found out that I was discerning a call to the priesthood and asked me to join them a few evenings. I was clearly against the idea, but I went anyways just to see what it was all about. I felt that if I went then I would be able to truly say that I didn't like it because I had gone. My experiences there were some what interesting. I must say that I am quite conservative, I love the tridentine Mass, that's the Latin Mass for those who may not know, and, to be quite frank, get upset when people mess, for lack of a better word, with the liturgy. After going to LifeTeen Masses in the past, many questions have come up. First, how many of the kids here are Catholic? I would imagine that teens invite their friends to come along. Initially this is not a bad thing, as I think it is good to bring others to Christ. But I do wonder if some of those non-Catholics received the Eucharist, clearly knowing as a Catholic that they are not to do such a thing. Second, do the teens understand what is taking place at Mass? I think one can have a general idea of what happens at the Mass, as most of us are familiar with the routine of the Mass. But, do we know what we are taking part in? If teens really did know what they were taking part in then I think there would be much more reverence given, for example by the way they dress and by the way they act in church. So many times have I seen teens just talking and laughing while in the church before Mass and, as others have pointed out, most of the teens look as if they are dressed to go to the movies. We are at the wedding feast of the Lamb! What do we wear to weddings....plain movie-going clothes? Now, I am not saying that we have to get totally dolled up, like for Prom, but a nice dress or skirt for girls, with the appropriate length, sounds good and a dress shirt and nice slacks sounds good for the guys. As a musician, I love to play music. I've played the trumpet for ten years and the drums for about eight years (I play in a band with two other seminarians called the "Priestie Boys", just as a side note). I love music, especially sacred music! Putting myself in the shoes of one who has never been to a Catholic Mass before and going to a LifeTeen Mass, I might feel as if this is how the Mass is for all Catholics around the world. And one may, not to put our Protestant brothers and sisters down necessarily, that they are at a Protestant church based on the music and the other actions that take place during a LifeTeen Mass, for example liturgical dance and the use of LifeTeen bands featuring bass, guitar, drums, etc. Whatever happened to Gregorian Chant or just even more traditional music? I could say more about this particular subject, but I will stop for your sake. Lastly, I wish to point out that LifeTeen, in my eyes, makes the Mass to be a show which draws teens in. Now, I am not saying that there should not be means taken to bring teens in, but I think that many times there can be too much hype. One must remember first that the Mass, in itself, is beautiful and does not need the extra 'stuff' to make it more beautiful. I know it may be hard for teens to see this right off that bat. Also, one must remember that there are teens, like myself and many others, that do not like that which takes place at LifeTeen Masses. What about these people, those who may wish to be included with other teens but do not wish to take part in something that may seem to take away from the beauty of the Mass itself? I would use caution when thinking that to be a teen and go to Mass means being LifeTeen. My last point, which I think is the most important, is the fact that LifeTeen feels the need to change parts of the Mass. I have taken some classes on the Mass in my seminary formation and have reviewed the GIRM and other documents on the Liturgy, especially Sacrosanctum Concilium.....Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy. Things like extending ones arms during the Pater Noster, Our Father, are to be done by the priest alone, not the people. It is a position, I belive adopted by the Romans, and if not it I know it was used by them, when one, usually of authority, was speaking. Also, having teens kneel in the sanctuary during the consecration should not be taking place. On a practical level, it is not needed and can cause much distraction, not to mention the fact that it is an act that seems to separate the community. Plus, some might feel pressured into going up to kneel by the altar. This, along with people trying to hold ones hands during parts of the Mass to pray, I assume the Our Father, causes one to be distracted, pressured, and violated in terms of personal space. Some may say such things help people to feel a sense of community. First off, we are Catholics and not congregationalist, no offense being given to them. Secondly, we have already united ourselves together in the very fact that we have come together and that we have made the sign of the cross together at the beginning of the Mass to start the most important prayer that we can pray. This can act as objection to that which at times takes place after the greeting of the priest when we are told to turn to our neighbor and greet them. In no way do I want to appear as saying that LifeTeen is bad or wrong for what it does, though I have shown some of the areas that I think LifeTeen may want to improve on in order to celebrate the Mass better and to involve all at the Mass. I think it is good that so many teens have come into the Catholic Church by means of LifeTeen and I hope that many more will continue to come. I just wish to show one seminarians thought on the matter. I will leave you all with some questions that I have, which are, "What happens to one after they have advanced in LifeTeen? What I mean here is that there has to be a point where one stops seeing if they are interested in the Catholic Church and the Mass. Does LifeTeen teach teens the Catholic faith, like the Catechism or is simply an act of getting kids at Mass? Also, does anyone know if there has been a study on the number of people who attended LifeTeen that continue to go to Mass, let's say, for instance, after going off to college, getting married, etc?" Just curious. pax Christi! In Christ and Mary, Derrick Flannigan
HomeTeamFamily Posted April 20, 2004 Author Posted April 20, 2004 dust feel free to move this to debate table if ya want
Philippe Posted April 21, 2004 Posted April 21, 2004 dont ferget that there are lots of lifeteens around and like the one at my parish we kneel and stuff but i dunno i do agree with the modesty and the distractions when teens go to the alter for both the rest of the congregation and the teens there becuase you are with all your best friends but also i mean you were talkin about lifeteen kids not goin to masss after and stuff like that well personally i go to lifeteen but i mean i love going to daily mass i see it as the same so i dont want you to stereotype the types of kids that go there and also please dont stereotype the different lifeteen groups around cause some are different then others theres my 2 cents :\
Philippe Posted April 21, 2004 Posted April 21, 2004 alright well heres the deal... it depends on your diocese you can get special permission from the Bishop as long as everyone is in a certain area around the altar the reason this must be true is because the Bishop came and did mass and he invited all the teens to gather around the altar with him so i dunno thats what im thinking
JP2Iloveyou Posted April 21, 2004 Posted April 21, 2004 lifeteener, that's wonderful that you are going to daily Mass. Keep it up! As for your second post about your bishop. He may have had you come up to the altar, but that doesn't make it right. Many other bishops have said that it is against the liturgical law. Clearly, someone in this situation is incorrect. So, we must check what the liturgical law actually says. I think that I have demonstrated it to be quite clear from Canon Law and from the General Instructions, both of which are binding on Catholics. The only group that I know of that has the permission of Rome to gather around the altar at the consecration is the neo-catechumanal way. This permission is only granted by Rome, not by an individual bishop or even by a council of bishops, like the USCCB. It is called an indult. Let me just ask you though, what would be the big deal about remaining in the pews? I've never been in a church before where you can't "see what's going on." Furthermore, at what point do teenagers need to be treated like adults? 18, 19, 20? older? Personally, I kind of like the idea of a Mass geared towards teenagers. I have no problem with P&W music, a homily geared towards that age group, and greater participation from them such as by reading (BTW, NOT lectoring. A lector is a male, usually a seminarian.) God Bless
qfnol31 Posted April 21, 2004 Posted April 21, 2004 I think Lifeteen has some really good ideas (my old youth director used the lessons for us), but has some things wrong with it. (Sorry for those of ya'll in Lifeteen, I think it's great that ya'll have come to know the Church through it). I'm just going to metion the altar gathering real fast. I'm an Extraordinary Minister and so in many ways I have to learn the rules. At the Masses for our school, the EMs are not allowed to go up to the altar until after the priest has received Communion. It was a new rule added by the Pope in the last year or so specifically so people would not gather around the altar. About people standing around the altar, not even the deacon is supposed to stand. He's supposed to kneel (according to the most recent GIRM).
hopeful1 Posted April 21, 2004 Posted April 21, 2004 ok, i used to post on the lifeteen website all the time until i found this place (actually, that is where i found out about THIS PLACE!). while i can't speak for everyone for on that board, i can say that from my experience there the majority of these kids obviously go to the life teen services, and many of them do seem to be sincere about their faith and actually WANT to Learn more about the faith, want to live it out past highschool, and want a better understanding about the mass.In fact these kids used to inspire me. I remember going there all the time and seeing posts asking for advice how to keep the faith in college, how to defend the faith in school or make their catholic school more "catholic" ( all you ppl that have been to catholic schools know what i'm talking about), keeping God in their relationships, advice about confession, the eucharist, rosary, ect. I even remember seeing alot of posts asking ppl to pray for them while they were discerning a vocation! obviously i can't speak for everyone that goes to lifeteen, but i think it's unfair to think that lifeteen doesn't help teens mature in their faith, because when you read the posts you can see that it has. (then again, maybe it's just the devout ones that post ). as far as teaching the faith goes, that's what life night's (the youth group) is for, right? ok, maybe not at every meeting but I'm sure it gets in there, somewhere. as far as the alter gathering goes, i can understand some of your objections to it, and i can see how it can be distracting and perhaps disrespectful. I never really looked at it that way until i read this thread. I'm not sure how it works at most services, and probably besides the point, but at my church no one is forced to be on the alter. It's more of an invitation for those who'd like to participate, and the ones who would be disrespectful anyway usually won't go up. on the other hand, we're not a "full fledged" Lifeteen church yet either.
Philippe Posted April 21, 2004 Posted April 21, 2004 o and i was talkin 2 my mom about it and our Church isnt really a Church i mean the actual definition of a Church "the gather of people" is there but its not the actually Church building... were trying to raise funds to build the building so we dont have pews and my mom was saying how they shouldnt have to kneel cause it hurts their knees and how since they have no pews she thinks it makes them unobligated of kneeling even if they are very capable of doing it... i never saw the alter gather as a bad thing before but i dunno i guess im kinda confused but i dont think that since our Church has no pews that we shouldnt have 2 kneel that just isnt right o and if anyone wants to donate for our church we have about 80,000 or 800,000 now im not sure which but we need like 3 million or so and i think its 80,000 so if anyone wants to donate to our funds drive lemme know and ill c what i can do thanks and God Bless
JP2Iloveyou Posted April 21, 2004 Posted April 21, 2004 GIRM #43 [quote]43 ... [b]In the dioceses of the United States of America, they should kneel beginning after the singing or recitation of the Sanctus until after the Amen of the Eucharistic Prayer, except when prevented on occasion by reasons of health, lack of space, the large number of people present, or some other good reason.[/b] Those who do not kneel ought to make a profound bow when the priest genuflects after the consecration. The faithful kneel after the Agnus Dei unless the Diocesan Bishop determines otherwise[/quote] Basicly, it says unless there is a good reason to not kneel, (the situation you describe might fit the criteria here, I'm not really sure since I'm not at your particular situation) the faithful in the United States should kneel from the Holy, Holy, Holy until the Amen. I have rarely if ever been in a situation where kneeling isn't possible. Even when attending Mass in a gym and sitting on bleachers, it has been my experience that kneeling is possible. Perhaps in your situation it is not. Like I said, I don't know. In any event, here is what the Church actually says and you can interpret it.
HomeTeamFamily Posted April 21, 2004 Author Posted April 21, 2004 do those of you that have problems with the mass also have problems with the lifenight portion of Lifeteen? how bout the retreats and whatnot.....
cmotherofpirl Posted April 21, 2004 Posted April 21, 2004 I have no problems with lifeteen as long as they follow the rules like everybody else. In our diocese years ago, some parishes were put in with carpeting and no kneelers. So now they have to kneel on the floor I attended our diocesean youth rally on Palm Sunday. We did not kneel in the bleachers simply because it was not humanly possible. However, those with floor seating, knelt down.
Oik Posted April 22, 2004 Posted April 22, 2004 I agree with what Dust has said, and actually the majority of others. Bottom line: LifeTeen has awesome potential, but right now it is sending some bad vibes out and that is not cool.
musturde Posted April 26, 2004 Posted April 26, 2004 Wouldn't anyone have mentioned the gathering around the alter?(since lifeteen isn't some small thing) Since so many people do it, why hasn't the USCCB said anything about it? There are orthodox Catholic Priests doing lifeteen masses (and not just tiny group either). I agree it seems disrespectful but isn't receiving Eucharist by hand disrespectful also?
musturde Posted April 26, 2004 Posted April 26, 2004 I personally am on Cmoms side, although I wanna hear something official about it.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 26, 2004 Posted April 26, 2004 If you look in the new document it says parish groups have to conform to all liturgical norms.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now