hope4thenew Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 searched and didn't find this yet...the "news" broke this morning... here is jimmy akin and the national catholic register on it... [url="http://www.ncregister.com/blog/the-pope-said-what-about-condoms/"]The Pope Said WHAT about Condoms??? [/url]
kafka Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 here is Conte's commentary: http://www.catholicplanet.net/forum/showthread.php?t=4563
CatherineM Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 I imagine that it is for married couples only, where one has HIV, as a form of the principal of double effect.
kafka Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 (edited) [quote name='CatherineM' timestamp='1290310750' post='2188293'] I imagine that it is for married couples only, where one has HIV, as a form of the principal of double effect. [/quote] no, the use of condoms in that scenario would be immoral, because the sexual act lacks the procreative meaning, thus making the moral object which is the second font of morality inherently evil and so the overall act immoral. A sexual act must have all three meanings, unitive, marital, procreative to be moral, inherently good. So the Pope would never teach this, not even in an interview, which is where the media distorted what the Pope answered. Double effect is an analysis of the circumstance/consequences of the chosen act, the third font of morality, but use of condoms concerns the moral object of the sexual act which is the second font of morality. The first font of morality is intention/purpose/motive. So for a sexual act to be moral it must have: a good intention. it must be truly unitive, marital, and procreative and the good consequences of the act must outweigh the bad consequences. Edited November 21, 2010 by kafka
Jaime Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 [quote name='CatherineM' timestamp='1290310750' post='2188293'] I imagine that it is for married couples only, where one has HIV, as a form of the principal of double effect. [/quote] You will be a bit surprised at the example actually used
CatherineM Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 [quote name='jaime (the artist formerly known as hot stuff)' timestamp='1290313096' post='2188298'] You will be a bit surprised at the example actually used [/quote] You're right. I was quite surprised. We were discussing this issue in Bioethics last week. This week should be a humdinger.
kafka Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 it is the media distorting the Pope's words and using them to spread a false doctrine. That is the long and short of it. another good blog post analyzing what happened: http://ronconte.wordpress.com/2010/11/20/pope-on-condoms/ The Pope was merely pointing out that a particular intention, to avoid disease transmission, is a good intention. He hopes that such a good intention might lead the person to a better understanding of morality and a turning away from immoral acts. He was not approving of contraception, nor was he approving of the use of condoms by homosexuals (i.e. cases where the condoms are not contraceptive). The Pope’s comments do not imply that the intrinsically evil act of contraception might be moral with a good intention, such as to avoid disease transmission. The Catechism of the Catholic Church: “Legitimate intentions on the part of the spouses do not justify recourse to morally unacceptable means (for example, direct sterilization or contraception).” (CCC, n. 2399). Pope John Paul II: “Consequently, circumstances or intentions can never transform an act, intrinsically evil by virtue of its object, into an act ‘subjectively’ good or defensible as a choice.” (Veritatis Splendor, n. 81.)
Jaime Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 I have not seen any examples of the media distorting what the Holy Father is saying. This is what Time is saying [quote]Benedict's so-called condom concession was not a huge one. He still proscribes the use of condoms as contraception (as he does the birth control pill). His specific example, that of a male prostitute choosing to use a condom in a conscious choice to prevent HIV infection, is couched as "a first step in the direction of moralization, a first assumption of responsibility, on the way toward recovering an awareness that not everything is allowed and that one cannot do whatever one wants." Benedict seems to imply a scale of good and bad intentions — from the indiscriminate use of condoms and other contraceptives to the idea of preventing the spread of AIDS to following the teachings of the Catholic Church. Condoms are not the ultimate solution or the prescribed Catholic way, he reiterates, though Benedict allows that there is little the church can do to prevent anyone from acquiring condoms. Still, he insists that "the sheer fixation on the condom implies a banalization of sexuality... the dangerous source of the attitude of no longer seeing sexuality as the expression of love."[/quote]
cmaD2006 Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 I agree how this pans out in the end should be quite interesting ....
Mark of the Cross Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 [quote name='kafka' timestamp='1290311131' post='2188295'] a good intention. it must be truly unitive, marital, and [b]procreative[/b] and the good consequences of the act must outweigh the bad consequences. [/quote] I have a question! Could someone please explain to me how family planning which is specifically to allow the sex act to occur but not procreation is not considered as contraceptive? And what bad consequences occur out of contraceptives that don't occur out of family planning? Just for my info.
Semper Catholic Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 Wait you mean to tell me the Pope thinks there isn't a black and white answer to one of the most divisive questions in the Catholic faith? Shocking. Only took 100 years.
Skinzo Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 (edited) This thing is being totally distorted. Kafka is right. Janet Smith has an excellent commentary on it: [url="http://www.catholicworldreport.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=220:pope-benedict-on-condoms-in-qlight-of-the-worldq&catid=53:cwr2010&Itemid=70"]http://www.catholicw...r2010&Itemid=70[/url] He was saying only that a person who uses a condom might have a good intention. Read the whole statement especially this part : "Are you saying, then, that the Catholic Church is actually not opposed in principle to the use of condoms? "[b]She of course does not regard it as a real or moral solution[/b]" Then he says" but, in this or that case, there can be nonetheless, in the intention of reducing the risk of infection, a first step in a movement toward a different way, a more human way, of living sexuality." All that means is that the person using the condom may have a good intention, NOT that the Church endorses condom use, which the first part of his statement obviously rejects. S. Edited November 21, 2010 by Skinzo
tinytherese Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 [quote name='Semper Catholic' timestamp='1290334356' post='2188327'] Wait you mean to tell me the Pope thinks there isn't a black and white answer to one of the most divisive questions in the Catholic faith? Shocking. Only took 100 years. [/quote] You must not have read the above article in context. In no way was he promoting contraception. He said that using a condom to protect the infection of disease to another is wrong, but the fact that one is concerned about the wellbeing of another person is the FIRST step on the road to conversion. Eventually, if this mentality is being fully followed through, the person will realise that the act of sex outside of the context of a marriage between a man and a woman that is open to life is in the end, not for the well-being of the other person. So it is a BABY STEP.
Archaeology cat Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 [quote name='Mark of the Cross' timestamp='1290333819' post='2188326'] I have a question! Could someone please explain to me how family planning which is specifically to allow the sex act to occur but not procreation is not considered as contraceptive? And what bad consequences occur out of contraceptives that don't occur out of family planning? Just for my info. [/quote] Quickly: NFP is about knowledge, at its core. It lets the couple know when the woman is potentially fertile or is infertile, and that knowledge can then be used to achieve pregnancy, postpone pregnancy (if there's a just reason), or to help diagnose a medical condition. Nothing is done to thwart the woman's or man's fertility, though. Contraceptives seek to thwart the couple's fertility through barriers or altering the woman's hormones to prevent ovulation, fertilisation and/or implantation of the embryo.
Sternhauser Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 (edited) [quote name='Mark of the Cross' timestamp='1290333819' post='2188326'] I have a question! Could someone please explain to me how family planning which is specifically to allow the sex act to occur but not procreation is not considered as contraceptive? And what bad consequences occur out of contraceptives that don't occur out of family planning? Just for my info. [/quote] Mark, if you really want to understand the natural law aspect connected to Church teaching on this subject, Janet Smith has an excellent CD, called, "Contraception: Why Not?" It thoroughly covers that question, and dozens of others. Short answer: NFP is [i]open[/i] to the possibility of life. It is saying, "If it is your will that we have a child, Lord, we are open to it." A condom says "Buzz off, God. We don't care what you might want. If you want us to have kids, God, you can surely break the condom, in your mightiness. We'll probably kill the kid, anyway, because we've already become so deadened and accustomed to separating the means of sex from the ends of sex." The contraceptive mentality itself is what carries with it the worst consequences. Catholics are not bound to have sex only during the most fertile periods, but the intent to exclude any possibility of the purposes of the sexual act is gravely sinful. The act of wearing a condom to have sex, no matter how people may deny it, is in itself an act that objectifies the other person as merely an object of sexual pleasure, [i]even if the other person wants the other person to wear a condom. [/i] ~Sternhauser Edited November 21, 2010 by Sternhauser
MithLuin Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 Here's the pope's full remarks: [quote]From Chapter 11, "The Journeys of a Shepherd," pages 117-119: On the occasion of your trip to Africa in March 2009, the Vatican’s policy on AIDs once again became the target of media criticism.Twenty-five percent of all AIDs victims around the world today are treated in Catholic facilities. In some countries, such as Lesotho, for example, the statistic is 40 percent. In Africa you stated that the Church’s traditional teaching has proven to be the only sure way to stop the spread of HIV. Critics, including critics from the Church’s own ranks, object that it is madness to forbid a high-risk population to use condoms. The media coverage completely ignored the rest of the trip to Africa on account of a single statement. Someone had asked me why the Catholic Church adopts an unrealistic and ineffective position on AIDs. At that point, I really felt that I was being provoked, because the Church does more than anyone else. And I stand by that claim. Because she is the only institution that assists people up close and concretely, with prevention, education, help, counsel, and accompaniment. And because she is second to none in treating so many AIDs victims, especially children with AIDs. I had the chance to visit one of these wards and to speak with the patients. That was the real answer: The Church does more than anyone else, because she does not speak from the tribunal of the newspapers, but helps her brothers and sisters where they are actually suffering. In my remarks I was not making a general statement about the condom issue, but merely said, and this is what caused such great offense, that we cannot solve the problem by distributing condoms. Much more needs to be done. We must stand close to the people, we must guide and help them; and we must do this both before and after they contract the disease. As a matter of fact, you know, people can get condoms when they want them anyway. But this just goes to show that condoms alone do not resolve the question itself. More needs to happen. Meanwhile, the secular realm itself has developed the so-called ABC Theory: Abstinence-Be Faithful-Condom, where the condom is understood only as a last resort, when the other two points fail to work. This means that the sheer fixation on the condom implies a banalization of sexuality, which, after all, is precisely the dangerous source of the attitude of no longer seeing sexuality as the expression of love, but only a sort of drug that people administer to themselves. This is why the fight against the banalization of sexuality is also a part of the struggle to ensure that sexuality is treated as a positive value and to enable it to have a positive effect on the whole of man’s being. There may be a basis in the case of some individuals, as perhaps when a male prostitute uses a condom, where this can be a first step in the direction of a moralization, a first assumption of responsibility, on the way toward recovering an awareness that not everything is allowed and that one cannot do whatever one wants. But it is not really the way to deal with the evil of HIV infection. That can really lie only in a humanization of sexuality. Are you saying, then, that the Catholic Church is actually not opposed in principle to the use of condoms? She of course does not regard it as a real or moral solution, but, in this or that case, there can be nonetheless, in the intention of reducing the risk of infection, a first step in a movement toward a different way, a more human way, of living sexuality. [url=http://www.catholicworldreport.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=221:pope-benedict-xvi-discusses-condoms-and-the-spread-of-hiv&catid=53:cwr2010&Itemid=70](source)[/url] [/quote] As you can see, he was specifically commenting on the media storm he caused [i]last[/i] time he spoke about AIDs and condoms. Sorta ironic. The message is the same. If people follow the sexual morality preached by the Catholic church, they won't contract sexually transmitted diseases, such as AIDS. Obviously, the use of a condom by a homosexual male couple (prostitute or otherwise) does not have anything to do with contraception, and is primarily intended to avoid the spread of disease. And I think everyone knows by now what the Catholic Church's view on the morality of such an act would be. Here's an article reposted in one of the comments to Jimmy's article: [quote]Last year while in Africa, Pope Benedict XVI issued a statement in regard to HIV and condoms. Does anybody recall the following response that was posted by Fr. Z? http://wdtprs.com/blog/2009/03/harvard-prof-defends-benedict-xvi-on-condoms-and-aids/ Harvard Researcher agrees with Pope on condoms in Africa [Not a CUA prof, a HARVARD prof.] Cambridge, Mass., Mar 21, 2009 / 10:11 am (CNA).- Pope Benedict’s recent brief remark against condoms has caused an uproar in the press, but several prominent scientists dedicated to preventing AIDS are defending the Pope, saying he was correct in his analysis. In an interview with CNA, Dr. Edward Green explained that although condoms should work, in theory, they may be “exacerbating the problem” in Africa. Benedict XVI’s Tuesday comments on condoms were made as part of his explanation of the Church’s two prong approach to fighting AIDS. At one point in his response the Pontiff stressed that AIDS cannot be overcome by advertising slogans and distributing condoms and argued that they “worsen the problem.” The media responded with an avalanche of over 4,000 articles on the subject, calling Benedict a “threat to public health,” and saying that the Catholic Church should “enter the 21st century.” Senior Harvard Research Scientist for AIDS Prevention, Dr. Edward Green, who is the author of five books, including “Rethinking AIDS Prevention: Learning from Successes in Developing Countries” discussed his support for Pope Benedict XVI’s comments with CNA. According to Dr. Green, science is finding that the media is actually on the wrong side of the issue. In fact, Green says that not only do condoms not work, but that they may be “exacerbating the problem” in Africa. “Theoretically, condoms ought to work,” he explained to CNA, “and theoretically, some condom use ought to be better than no condom use, but that’s theoretically.” Condom proponents often cite the lack of condom education as the main culprit for higher AIDS rates in Africa but Green disagrees. After spending 25 years promoting condoms for family planning purposes in Africa, he insists that he’s quite familiar with condom promotion. Yet, he claims that “anyone who worked in family planning knew that if you needed to prevent a pregnancy, say the woman will die, you don’t recommend a condom.” Green recalls that when the AIDS epidemic hit Africa, the “Industry” began using AIDS as a “dual purpose” marketing strategy to get more funding for condom distribution. This, he claims, effectively took “something that was a 2nd or 3rd grade device for avoiding unwanted pregnancies” and turned it into the “best weapon we [had] against AIDS.” The accepted wisdom in the scientific community, explained Green, is that condoms lower the HIV infection rate, but after numerous studies, researchers have found the opposite to be true. “We just cannot find an association between more condom use and lower HIV reduction rates” in Africa. Dr. Green found that part of the elusive reason is a phenomenon known as risk compensation or behavioral disinhibition. “[Risk compensation] is the idea that if somebody is using a certain technology to reduce risk, a phenomenon actually occurs where people are willing to take on greater risk.” The idea can be related to someone that puts on sun block and is willing to stay out in the sun longer because they have added protection. In this case, however, the greater risk is sexual. Because people are willing take on more risk, they may “disproportionally erase” the benefits of condom use, Green said. Another factor that contributes to ineffective condom use in Africa, is the phenomenon where condoms may be effective on an “individual level,” but not on a “population level.” Green’s research found that “condoms have been effective” in HIV concentrated areas where high risk activities are already being conducted, such as brothels in countries like Thailand. Claiming to be a liberal himself, Green asserts that promoting Western “liberal ideology” where, “most Africans are conservative when it comes to sexual behavior,” is quite offensive to them. Citing his new book, “Indigenous Theories and Contagious Disease,” Green described Africans as “very religious by global standards” who are offended by “trucks going around where people are dancing to ‘Rock ‘n’ Roll’, tossing out condoms to teenagers and the children of the village.” Green also noted that there is an ideology called “harm reduction” that is being pushed by many organizations trying to prevent AIDS. The ideology believes that “you can’t change the underlying behavior, that you can’t get people to be faithful, especially Africans,” the HIV specialist explained. One country, Uganda, recognized these issues and said, “Listen, if you have multiple sex partners, you are going to get AIDS.” What worked in Uganda, a country that has seen a decline by as much as 2/3 in AIDS infections, was that officials realized that even aside from religious and cultural reasons, “no one likes condoms.” Instead of waiting for “American and European advisors to arrive,” Ugandan officials reacted and developed a program that fit their culture; their main message being “stick to one partner or love faithfully.” However, in 2004, Uganda’s AIDS infection rates began to increase once again, due to an influx of condoms and Western “advice”, Green recalled. Western donors also came to Uganda and said behavioral change doesn’t work and that, “most infections nowadays are among married people.” Green said these claims are “misleading,” pointing out that “married people always have lower HIV infection rates than single or divorced people of the same age group.” Green’s new book, “AIDS and Ideology,” to be completed in the next few months, will describe the industry in Africa that is “drawing billions of dollars a year promoting condoms, testing, drugs, and treatment of AIDS” and is clearly resistant to the idea that behavioral change is the solution. Yet the two countries that have the highest infection rate of AIDS in the world, Botswana and Swaziland, have recently launched campaigns to promote fidelity and monogamy, the Harvard researcher said. These countries “have learned the hard way” about the failure of condoms in preventing AIDS, he said, noting that “Botswana has probably had more condom promotion” than any other county on a per capita basis. Green said he had no problem “having condoms as a backup to fidelity-based programs.” According to Green, the Catholic Church should continue to “do what it is already doing,” avoid “arguing about the diameter of viruses” and cite scientific evidence in connection with scripture and moral theology. [/quote] [url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/03/27/AR2009032702825.html]Here's[/url] the Washington Post editorial by Green. The point is that if you really want to reduce the transmission of the disease in a far-flung pandemic like this, then, duh, you will have to reduce the risk factors. And that means to reduce the number of people who have multiple partners - fidelity is the way to go, baby!
Jaime Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 What the pope is saying is that condoms are not intrinsically evil, contraception is. [b] WARNING: "I TOLD YOU SO" COMING WARNING: "I TOLD YOU SO" COMING WARNING: "I TOLD YOU SO" COMING WARNING: "I TOLD YOU SO" COMING[/b] I got a lot of grief from a few folk who when I said the same thing in the past, accused me of being liberal and not following Catholic doctrine. But the Holy Father is stating that things (like condoms) cannot hold any intrinsic value. Actions (like contraception) can! So I say NEENER NEENER NEENER NEENER! Now let's return to our regularly scheduled discussion.
CatherineM Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 I just think it is a stroke of genius. He has found a way to compromise without having to compromise. He's right. Condoms aren't contraception when used by two men. I truly never thought of it that way.
holly.o Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 [quote]"...the sheer fixation on the condom implies a banalization of sexuality..."[/quote] This prophetic quote is being realized in how sexually-obsessed and banal the media is being by focusing on this issue. I think he made a very smart, philosophical statement. Also a very merciful one - God does see good intentions even when they aren't in a moral context. I doubt any of us are perfect in our love and actions, and this seems to be what Pope Benedict is saying - that [i]at least[/i] this would be the beginning of a moral conscience in this (very hypothetical) case.
Era Might Posted November 21, 2010 Posted November 21, 2010 (edited) I sometimes wonder whether journalists would be capable of writing a one-page (double spaced) book report on "The Cat in the Hat." Edited November 21, 2010 by Era Might
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now