Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pope B16 & The New Condom Controversy


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I don't understand the controversy.. It makes sense to me, it doesn't seem overwhelmingly controversial.. I dunno, obviously the majority of people Catholic and non-Catholic are buzzing about this. [img]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/public/style_emoticons/default/idontknow.gif[/img]

Edited by Micah
Posted

[quote name='kafka' timestamp='1290311131' post='2188295']
no, the use of condoms in that scenario would be immoral, because the sexual act lacks the procreative meaning, thus making the moral object which is the second font of morality inherently evil and so the overall act immoral. A sexual act must have all three meanings, unitive, marital, procreative to be moral, inherently good. So the Pope would never teach this, not even in an interview, which is where the media distorted what the Pope answered.

Double effect is an analysis of the circumstance/consequences of the chosen act, the third font of morality, but use of condoms concerns the moral object of the sexual act which is the second font of morality. The first font of morality is intention/purpose/motive.

So for a sexual act to be moral it must have:

a good intention.
it must be truly unitive, marital, and procreative
and the good consequences of the act must outweigh the bad consequences.
[/quote]

I would disagree with your assessment here. If the unintended consequence of the use were that procreation is suppressed I don't think this would have to be immoral. Let's say a young couple intends to have a family. The father gets in an accident and gets aides through a blood transfusion. Their every diesire would be to have children but he now has aides and does not want to give his wife this horrible disease. Do you say they must be celibate the rest of their life?

Mark of the Cross
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' timestamp='1290360093' post='2188378']
I just think it is a stroke of genius. He has found a way to compromise without having to compromise. He's right. Condoms aren't contraception when used by two men. I truly never thought of it that way.
[/quote]

And I'm glad that it has been pointed out. Some time ago a priest gave a homily about that. I think many, myself included mistakenly thought he was saying that condoms are OK in general because they prevent things such as diseases and unwanted pregnancies.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='jaime (the artist formerly known as hot stuff) (the artist formerly known as hot stuff)' timestamp='1290316839' post='2188312']
I have not seen any examples of the media distorting what the Holy Father is saying. This is what Time is saying
[/quote]
I meant in the sense that they fabricated a controversy.

[quote name='Skinzo' timestamp='1290334733' post='2188329']
 This thing is being totally distorted. Kafka is right. Janet Smith has an excellent commentary on it:
[/quote]
another quote from Janet Smith's commentary:

"An analogy: If someone was going to rob a bank and was determined to use a gun, it would better for that person to use a gun that had no bullets in it. It would reduce the likelihood of fatal injuries. But it is not the task of the Church to instruct potential bank robbers how to rob banks more safely and certainly not the task of the Church to support programs of providing potential bank robbers with guns that could not use bullets. Nonetheless, the intent of a bank robber to rob a bank in a way that is safer for the employees and customers of the bank may indicate an element of moral responsibility that could be a step towards eventual understanding of the immorality of bank robbing."

[quote name='jaime (the artist formerly known as hot stuff) (the artist formerly known as hot stuff)' timestamp='1290353861' post='2188345']
What the pope is saying is that condoms are not intrinsically evil, contraception is. [b]
[/quote]
I disagree with your assesment of what the Pope said, he was basically saying that the use of a condom in that particular circumstance is one good intention that might lead to a conversion of life.
But yes you are right, it is the use of condoms as a contraception, not the condom itself which is evil.

[quote name='Era Might' timestamp='1290364503' post='2188386']
I sometimes wonder whether journalists would be capable of writing a one-page (double spaced) book report on "The Cat in the Hat."
[/quote]
:lol:

Edited by kafka
Posted (edited)

[quote name='thessalonian' timestamp='1290368543' post='2188392']
I would disagree with your assessment here. If the unintended consequence of the use were that procreation is suppressed I don't think this would have to be immoral. Let's say a young couple intends to have a family. The father gets in an accident and gets aides through a blood transfusion. Their every diesire would be to have children but he now has aides and does not want to give his wife this horrible disease. Do you say they must be celibate the rest of their life?
[/quote]
But procreation one of the three meanings which makes the moral object of the sexual act intrinsically good. Take this away by means of contraception and the moral object is lacking one of the three things which makes the nature of sexual act good. Suppressing procreation is not an unintended consequence, it is a means which makes the nature of the act itself evil. It falls into the second font of morality not the third. The only moral/intrinsically good sexual act is natural sexual relations (unitive), of a married male and female (marital) open to life (procreative).

If one of the spouses has HIV or Aids they would have to abstain, because the bad consequences of having natural sexual relations open to life would outweigh the good consequences, since this would infect the other spouse. So there is nothing they could do but pray and hope in God. An intention or an end cannot change the intrinsic value of a moral object:

Pope John Paul II: “Consequently, circumstances or intentions can never transform an act, intrinsically evil by virtue of its object, into an act ‘subjectively’ good or defensible as a choice.” (Veritatis Splendor, n. 81.)

in your scenario the couple would be using an evil means, contraception, to attain an end which is also lacking in goodness, because the end lacks an openess to life, as well as being unnatural, use of contraception is unnatural and so not truly unitive, as well as not truly marital, because God wills all sexual acts within marriage (or period) to be moral. There would be no truly good reason for them to have sex, because these immoral contracepted acts would not truly strengthen their love or the marriage which is a mystery in God (a Sacrament). All three aspects of moral sexual acts, unitive/marital/procreative are distinct yet have a profound unity to make up the nature of the sexual act. It is a reflection of the Trinity.

Edited by kafka
Posted (edited)

"The only moral/intrinsically good sexual act is natural sexual relations (unitive), of a married male and female (marital) open to life (procreative)."

I don't need a catechism lesson from you regarding marriage. I've been through theology of the body about a dozen times and facilitated it twice. This is not violated in my senario. Sorry. The couple is fully open to life. The intention of the senario that I present is NOT to prevent pregnancy! Therefore it is an unintended consequence. Much like a woman having a medical procedure to have a tumor removed that ends in the loss of her child. You make the latex rather than what goes on in the heart and mind of the men and women the sin, the evil. Granted I don't have much respect for condoms but they are not wherin lies the evil. By the way in my mind the way you are presenting this a man and a woman spacing children through NFP are participating in an intrinsically evil act as well. Otherwise the latex is the sin. Otherwise the latex is the sin.

Edited by thessalonian
EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' timestamp='1290389959' post='2188473']
"The only moral/intrinsically good sexual act is natural sexual relations (unitive), of a married male and female (marital) open to life (procreative)."

I don't need a catechism lesson from you regarding marriage. I've been through theology of the body about a dozen times and facilitated it twice. This is not violated in my senario. Sorry. The couple is fully open to life. The intention of the senario that I present is NOT to prevent pregnancy! Therefore it is an unintended consequence. Much like a woman having a medical procedure to have a tumor removed that ends in the loss of her child. You make the latex rather than what goes on in the heart and mind of the men and women the sin, the evil. Granted I don't have much respect for condoms but they are not wherin lies the evil. By the way in my mind the way you are presenting this a man and a woman spacing children through NFP are participating in an intrinsically evil act as well. Otherwise the latex is the sin. Otherwise the latex is the sin.
[/quote]
I have seen others give this argument in various forms, but it seems proportionalist to me and I've always thought it incompatible with this passage from Humanae Vitae (14):
[quote]Though it is true that sometimes it is lawful to tolerate a lesser moral evil in order to avoid a greater evil or in order to promote a greater good," it is never lawful, even for the gravest reasons, to do evil that good may come of it —in other words, to intend directly something which of its very nature contradicts the moral order, and which must therefore be judged unworthy of man, even though the intention is to protect or promote the welfare of an individual, of a family or of society in general.[/quote]
I'm interested in any thoughts.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='thessalonian' timestamp='1290389959' post='2188473']
"The only moral/intrinsically good sexual act is natural sexual relations (unitive), of a married male and female (marital) open to life (procreative)."

I don't need a catechism lesson from you regarding marriage. I've been through theology of the body about a dozen times and facilitated it twice. This is not violated in my senario. Sorry. The couple is fully open to life. The intention of the senario that I present is NOT to prevent pregnancy! Therefore it is an unintended consequence. Much like a woman having a medical procedure to have a tumor removed that ends in the loss of her child. You make the latex rather than what goes on in the heart and mind of the men and women the sin, the evil. Granted I don't have much respect for condoms but they are not wherin lies the evil. By the way in my mind the way you are presenting this a man and a woman spacing children through NFP are participating in an intrinsically evil act as well. Otherwise the latex is the sin. Otherwise the latex is the sin.
[/quote]
:twitch:

I dont know what to say other than this is seriously not good.

The chosen act of the couple using a contraceptive as a means to an end is not open to life. An intention or a conseqence cannot change the intrinsic value, meaning, or nature of an act. And their intented means is not open to life. You are contradicting your own statements. You are basically saying that an intended and chosen means (an immoral act in this case), bypasses the intrinsic nature of an act, and falls into the consequences because the heart and mind of the couple says so. But what is really happening is they are changing the nature of the sexual act lacking procreation and thereby evil into something good in their own fallen minds. A man or woman cannot change the nature of an act because they intend to. I cannot change the nature of a lie, which is the expression of a falsehood into an expression of truth because I intend to. This is absurd:

{5:20} Woe to you who call evil good, and good evil; who substitute darkness for light, and light for darkness; who exchange bitter for sweet, and sweet for bitter!

It has nothing to do with latex, it has everything to do with the inherent meaning of the act. When a contraceptive is used the procreative meaning is lacking and the intention is to use an immoral means to accomplish what is in the end also immoral because the bad consequences of using an immoral means which is an objective mortal sin by nature would outweigh whatever good ends the sexual act would have which at this point would be mere pleasure, because a truly unitive and marital meaning is damaged and lacking without the procreative meaning as I explained above about their intrinsic unity of the three meanings as a reflection of the Nature of God which is Three Persons in One. You know the end does not justify the means.

The other examples you present are totally irrelevant to this. NFP is natural and open to life. A couple in theory could use NFP as a contraceptive, but using the knowledge of NFP would be an immoral means to accomplish an immoral end just like using a condom or the pill is a means to an end damaging the inherent moral meaning of the sexual act. A woman having her cancer treated is a moral act, and the good consequences would have to outweigh the bad consequences of losing her babies life, for example if she does not get the cancer treated both her life and the life of her baby would be lost. And she must have the good intention of saving her life for the overall act to be moral. But the medical treatment directed at healing the cancer is a moral act by nature. The moral object of the act is to heal the cancer, not to kill the baby.

But the moral object of a sexual act must under God have a unitive/marital/procreative meaning regardless of intention or circumstance/consequences in order to be moral. And in addition the intention and consequences must be good for the overall act to be moral. Three fonts of morality:

[1] the intention, or end, or purpose, or motive, of the person
[2] the moral object, or object, or species, or nature, of the act itself
[3] the circumstances, or consequences, of the intentionally chosen act

all three distinct fonts must be good for the overall act to be good.

(edited out sarcasm. quickly repented of inordinate anger ;) )

Edited by kafka
Posted

[quote name='thedude' timestamp='1290390735' post='2188477']
I have seen others give this argument in various forms, but it seems proportionalist to me and I've always thought it incompatible with this passage from Humanae Vitae (14):

I'm interested in any thoughts.
[/quote]
I agree with you.

Good source quote.

Posted

Whole thing made the first story on our news tonight. It was kind of nice to see the Pope on TV for something other than him apologizing.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' timestamp='1290389959' post='2188473']
"The only moral/intrinsically good sexual act is natural sexual relations (unitive), of a married male and female (marital) open to life (procreative)."

I don't need a catechism lesson from you regarding marriage. I've been through theology of the body about a dozen times and facilitated it twice. This is not violated in my senario. Sorry. The couple is fully open to life. The intention of the senario that I present is NOT to prevent pregnancy! Therefore it is an unintended consequence. Much like a woman having a medical procedure to have a tumor removed that ends in the loss of her child. You make the latex rather than what goes on in the heart and mind of the men and women the sin, the evil. Granted I don't have much respect for condoms but they are not wherin lies the evil. By the way in my mind the way you are presenting this a man and a woman spacing children through NFP are participating in an intrinsically evil act as well. Otherwise the latex is the sin. Otherwise the latex is the sin.
[/quote]


uh, no. definatly no. no according to catholic church teaching.

Posted

[quote name='havok579257' timestamp='1290397350' post='2188508']
uh, no. definatly no. no according to catholic church teaching.
[/quote]
concurred.

Destroyer of Heretics
Posted

[quote name='jaime (the artist formerly known as hot stuff)' timestamp='1290353861' post='2188345']
What the pope is saying is that condoms are not intrinsically evil, contraception is. [b]

WARNING: "I TOLD YOU SO" COMING WARNING: "I TOLD YOU SO" COMING WARNING: "I TOLD YOU SO" COMING WARNING: "I TOLD YOU SO" COMING[/b]

I got a lot of grief from a few folk who when I said the same thing in the past, accused me of being liberal and not following Catholic doctrine. But the Holy Father is stating that things (like condoms) cannot hold any intrinsic value. Actions (like contraception) can! So I say

NEENER NEENER NEENER NEENER!


Now let's return to our regularly scheduled discussion.
[/quote]## [size="3"]And to think there has been all that fuss and bother - why couldn't he have said all that stuff years ago ? Still, not to worry - Father Federico Lombardi is not quite his Alistair Campbell

http://splinteredsunrise.wordpress.com/2010/07/16/press-and-how-not-to-do-it/

[/size]

Posted

[quote name='kafka' timestamp='1290397467' post='2188509']
concurred.
[/quote]

Am I surprised.

Semper Catholic
Posted

[quote name='tinytherese' timestamp='1290335117' post='2188330']
You must not have read the above article in context. In no way was he promoting contraception. He said that using a condom to protect the infection of disease to another is wrong, but the fact that one is concerned about the wellbeing of another person is the FIRST step on the road to conversion. Eventually, if this mentality is being fully followed through, the person will realise that the act of sex outside of the context of a marriage between a man and a woman that is open to life is in the end, not for the well-being of the other person. So it is a BABY STEP.
[/quote]

Nor was I saying that he was. I'm just saying that something like contraception isn't an argument for absolutes.

Posted

It seemed to me that in the example the Pope used, a male prostitute, that the sex and sin was a given judging by the males occupation and his statement that the use of a condom may be the first step in realizing the sin and addressing in this manner may be the start towards the cessation of the act itself, as in the act of recognizing the possible outcome, spread of HIV, may lead to taking personal responsibility a step further negating the sex act completely.

Does it really surprise anyone here that most of the media outlets create the news to fit their purpose? If so I guess you missed the last few election cycles !

ed

Ash Wednesday
Posted

It all kind of reminds me of how I never understood people that got so upset about the Church's contraception ban and accused it of contributing to the spread of AIDS in places like Africa. As if the church somehow approved of people having sex wherever and whenever, and with whoever they wanted...as long as they weren't using a condom. (facepalm) :crazy:

Posted

Here's [url=http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/253679/deflating-nyt-condom-scoop-george-weigel?page=1]George Weigel's response[/url]

The Church's consistent teaching on human sexuality is that you are not to use another person. Concern for someone else's health is the first step towards not being completely selfish about the situation. [i]Not committing adultery[/i] would be a much better and more moral choice than wearing a condom while doing so, though.

Posted

POPE IGNITES DEBATE OVER CONDOMS

Catholic League president Bill Donohue comments on the pope's recent remarks on condoms:

Pope Benedict XVI acknowledges that condoms may make sense in preventing the transmission of disease, and he immediately sets off a firestorm. But he never said condoms are an acceptable means of birth control, nor did he say that they are the answer to HIV/AIDS. Indeed, he said he opposed the widespread use of condoms because that "implies the banalization of sexuality." He also criticized the "fixation" on condoms as a means of combating AIDS.

While what the Holy Father said is newsworthy, it was not revolutionary. Even with regards to the birth control pill, the Catholic Church has allowed for exceptions. In his 1968 encyclical, Humanae Vitae, Pope Paul VI said, "the Church does not consider at all illicit the use of those therapeutic means necessary to cure bodily diseases, even if a foreseeable impediment to procreation should result there from—provided such impediment is not directly intended for any motive whatsoever." Moreover, the Church accepts the use of hormonal contraception to treat endometriosis.

We have been asked by the media what the Catholic League's position is on this issue. This misunderstands our role: we don't have a position on any Church teaching—we simply accept their wisdom and defend the right of the Church to have its voice heard with respect in the public square. We therefore stand proudly behind the pope's comments on condoms.

From Father Z:

First, keep in mind that Papa Ratzinger was talking to a guy who had a microphone. How is that the same as an official act of the Vicar of Christ exercising his magisterium?

Also, he was asked if the Church is opposed in principle to the use of condoms. He responded – and it may be important to read all the words. My emphases:

She of course does not regard it as a real or moral solution, but, in this or that case, there can be nonetheless, in the intention of reducing the risk of infection, a first step in a movement toward a different way, a more human way, of living sexuality.

“Of course” means that the Church’s teaching is pretty clear. Also, just as the Pope clarified in a presser on an airplane on his way to make an apostolic visit, condoms are not a real solution because they fail both to prevent disease and conception. They are not a “real” solution. They are not a “moral” solution because of the motive for their use in most cases. Nevertheless, sin is also wrapped up with “intention” in individual cases. Furthermore, there is a human way to respond to the problems for which some people claim condoms are the answer. Condom use is a more human way in individual cases such as that which the Pope identified in his non-magisterial interview. That doesn’t mean that it is yet a good way. It is simply better than the disastrous way employed before a decision was made to move towards a more human way. Also the word human implies that the acting subject is a person, an image of God.

That is a quick glance at what the Pope said.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='thessalonian' timestamp='1290398061' post='2188513']
Am I surprised.
[/quote]

Are you surprised that he was [i]right[/i]? He was dead-on.

[url="http://www.ewtn.com/vexperts/showresult.asp?RecNum=427467&Forums=0&Experts=0&Days=2005&Author=&Keyword=aids&pgnu=1&groupnum=0&record_bookmark=34&ORDER_BY_TXT=ORDER+BY+ReplyDate+DESC&start_at="]Fr. Stephen Torraco, PhD, on EWTN[/url]

[url="http://www.ncbcenter.org/NetCommunity/Page.aspx?pid=284"]National Catholic Bioethics Center[/url]

I think you owe an apology to both Kafka and Havok. If you don't recognize the reason[i]s[/i] why, that's a problem.

~Sternhauser

Edited by Sternhauser

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...