BG45 Posted July 26, 2011 Author Posted July 26, 2011 Levi (2010) Topic: Tax Evasion and Compliance 1) Tax evasion is usually dealth with as a civil and administrative penalty than a criminal matter, despite the often large sums of money involved. 2) Social and political pressures exist that encourage people to pay their taxes, these pressures in theory exist for corporations as well, but many of them have legal loopholes that allow them to pay no taxes.
BG45 Posted July 26, 2011 Author Posted July 26, 2011 Braithwaite (2010) Topic: Tax Evasion and Compliance 1) Norms and attitudes of a community need to be considered when crafting any policy for tax evasion. 2) Need to differential on the issue of non-compliance; is this an intentional act of evasion or is a bad set of business decisions that went wrong? Is the person just not realizing their offshore account is illicit, or do they think they can get away with it?
BG45 Posted July 26, 2011 Author Posted July 26, 2011 Leighton (2010) Topic: Tax evasion and compliance 1) Anti-tax sentiment leads politicians to discourage tax enforcement 2) In 2008 the General Accounting Office (GAO) identified several strategies to generate large amounts of revenue for minimal expenditure.
BG45 Posted July 29, 2011 Author Posted July 29, 2011 I've been stressing on a practice question today, then a friend asked about legislation named after kids. And I wrote him, when I pasted it into word, about six pages on the issue. Maybe I'm psyching myself out?
BG45 Posted July 29, 2011 Author Posted July 29, 2011 [b][u]Question[/u] 1[/b] [b](33 points)[/b] There has been a good deal of research done on the sentencing phase in the criminal process. Much of this research looks at disparities in sentencing (e.g., gender, race). Recent research has begun to look at the role that employment plays in judges’ decisions to sentence. Some researchers argue that judges will be less likely, for example, to give a man a harsh sentence if he is both gainfully employed and providing financial support to his family. This research is still in its infancy and more studies need to be conducted. One issue that needs to be addressed is the impact that employment has on the “in/out” decision [whether to sentence an individual to a period of incarceration (in) or some type of community based sanction (out)]. Your task is to design a [b][u]quantitative[/u][/b] research project that will assess whether employment influences the in/out decision. You should assume that you have been given access to official court records in Allegheny County, PA (essentially Pittsburgh). This will be your primary data source for this study. You should address the following points in your answer making sure to incorporate into your discussion your understanding of the methodological terms and concepts you are asked to address.[list=1] [*]Which research design (i.e., cross-sectional, longitudinal, experimental, quasi-experimental) is most appropriate for this study? Why? [*]Allegheny County processes approximately 18,500 cases each year. Discuss how you will sample these records in order to garner a sample of 500 cases. Be as specific as possible. [*]How will you operationalize “gainful employment” for this study? [*]What control variables will you include and why? [*]Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of using official records [i]for this study[/i]. [b][u]Answer[/u]:[/b] [/list] The purpose of this study is to address the issue of whether a judge will sentence a person to incarceration or a community based sanction based on the employment of the individual. The area that is to be used for this study is Allegheny County in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania; the largest city and primary source of individuals examined in this study is Pittsburgh. [list=1] [*] The research design for this study will be cross sectional in nature as there is no need to follow a group for a number of years. Furthermore, there is nothing in this proposed study that will need to have any sort of time order analysis, nor does an experiment need to be conducted in any form. Rather, what is needed to fulfill the requirements of the study in a timely and cost effective manner is a simple cross sectional design. This design has several advantages for the study that is at hand as described by Menard (2002) in his comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of longitudinal and cross-sectional research. Longitudinal research is cost prohibitive and time intensive. In order to complete this study in a timely manner, a cross sectional design would be preferable as it offers a snapshot in time. The researcher also wishes to keep the amount of funding necessary at a minimum, in keeping with the realities of the current economic times. [/list] Some limitations to the cross sectional design would include the inability to determine cohort and age effects, as well as an inability to determine temporal ordering and causation (Menard, 2002). However, this study does not look at causation and it is not being argued that gainful employment leads directly to a community sanction, but rather plays a possible role in the determination of sanctions; it is important to remember that not every correlation is causal, while causation always has correlation. 2. According to the information that has been provided, Allegheny County has approximately 18,500 cases per year, of which this study wishes to analyze 500 of that number. The process for determining this selection will be a systematic random sampling approach. A random case will be chosen and then every 37[sup]th[/sup] case from the original starting point will be sampled until the desired number of cases has been reached. The 37[sup]th[/sup] case is not an arbitrary number, but rather is the result of dividing 18,500 cases by the number of cases we wish to use in this study to obtain 37 cases as our sampling interval. For instance, if we were to land on the 5[sup]th[/sup] case randomly as our first case, we would then take the 42nd case as our next case. This would be followed by the 79[sup]th[/sup] case and then by the 116[sup]th[/sup] case and so on and so forth until we reached the 500 cases needed to comprise our sampling frame. 3. Perhaps the most difficult part of this survey is to operationalize the term “gainful employment”. As recent discussions of the nature of the current economic situation have dominated national television media it has been stressed repeatedly on the major networks that a minimum wage job is no longer enough to support a person, let alone a family. The argument behind this study states that a judge might be more lenient on an individual who is gainfully employed and able to financially support a family, something that cannot be done on the current minimum wage rates even at full time employment. Therefore the operational definition of “gainful employment” for this study will be: Gainful employment is an economic state where the individual is employed in a position, or multiple positions, and has the resources from this employment to help sustain and support the individual’s basic human needs in addition to familial financial support. This construct will be measured in the form of the official records that are being used. The court records should provide an employment history of the individual being charged that will show gainful employment under this operationalized definition, or a lack there of. 4. A control variable is a variable that remains constant. In order to properly study if gainful employment has an impact on judicial decisions toward incarceration or community based alternatives, we must control for the extraneous factors that may also influence the sentence, but remain constant throughout. The first variable that should be controlled is that of gender. This variable should be controlled due to the impact that it may have on sentencing; a woman may have gainful employment and be sentenced to a community based alternative while a man receives incarceration, or vice versa. Furthermore, gender studies in regards to sentencing are an entire field that can be debated, and this variable should be controlled so that the data examined in this study is not debated in this context. The second variable to control will be that of race. This, like gender, is a constant that may have an impact on sentencing and has an entire field of debatable issues and sub-topics, especially in regards to incarceration in an urban environment where most of the cases are coming from, where up to 80% of African-American men may be involved with the criminal justice system in their lifetime (Clear, 2011). This variable should be controlled so that the data examined in this study is not debated in this context. The third variable that will need to be controlled is marital status. This should be controlled due to how it may also impact sentencing. An example being, is a boyfriend who helps provide support for the family more likely to be incarcerated than a father who helps provide support for the family? This variable should be controlled so as not to have the data of the study debated within the context of marital relations. Other variables will be addressed as the data is collected and reviewed prior to analysis. 5. There are a number of pros and cons to using official records as a source of information in an academic study. These will be discussed in a concise manner. This is a quantitative study, therefore numbers are important to us. Official data provides numbers for a large amount of variables that will be used. This includes demographics that were previously mentioned as control variables, but also provides us with amount of time employed in a position, the amount of money made at this form of employment, the number and type of previous offenses, number of family members, and so on. This data is vital to providing a full picture for a quantitative study of this nature; however, official records are often filled with holes that will result in missing cases/instances of pieces of data when we enter it into SPSS or another analytical program. These missing cases will negatively impact our analysis, as they will still need to be reported and accounted for in the results, while contributing nothing to the overall findings. Similarly, the use of official data only means that we close off other sources of data for possible use. In determining employment in this case for example, we are limited in that we can’t give the defendants a survey about their employment. Nor, given our reliance on official data only, can we interview anyone else who has been involved in this process: judges, prosecutors, defense attorneys/public defenders, witnesses, police officers, and jurors. The ability to survey all those involved at each step of the process would have allowed us to run more detailed analyses with further variables that may be missing entirely from the official data that we have access to. (wow the board didn't like my formatting.)
BG45 Posted July 31, 2011 Author Posted July 31, 2011 [b]Question 2 (33 points)[/b] As you know, the Pre-Sentence Investigation (or PSI) is a report used by the judge to help determine an appropriate felony sentence. PSIs are developed by probation officers assigned to the court. The PSI summarizes information about the defendant’s criminal and social history that is relevant to the sentencing decision, and typically includes a sentencing recommendation. Sentencing research shows that judges typically follow the sentence recommended in the PSI. One question is whether judges are swayed by probation officers’ recommendations or whether probation officers tailor their recommendations to the particular judge. There is very little research on this process. Design a [b][u]qualitative[/u][/b] research project that will help us understand the process by which probation officers arrive at their sentencing recommendation. Assume that you have full access to the Allegheny County felony court and its personnel. For the sake of this exam, assume further that there are 24 probation officers writing PSIs and 6 felony court judges. In your answer, be sure to include:[list=1] [*]A statement of your preliminary research question(s) to guide your project design. [i](Section A should demonstrate that you know the difference between a qualitative and a quantitative research question.) [/i](5 points) [*]A discussion of the type(s) of [u]interviews[/u] you would use for the project. Include what type of interview, with whom, and your reasoning. (10 points) [*]A discussion of whether or not you would “sit in on” and [u]observe[/u] probation officers while they gather information and produce PSIs. Be sure to state whether you think observation would be useful, and explain your reasoning. (10 points) [/list] (Sections B and C should demonstrate your grasp of the purpose and strength of these two qualitative methods.)[list=1] [*]Discuss[i] the research ethics involved in the study you have sketched out above. [/i](Section D requires that you demonstrate and [u]apply[/u] what you know about research ethics to this specific research project.) (8 points) [/list] [b][u]Answer:[/u][/b] [u]Section A:[/u] Before we can begin a qualitative study, it is important to have the research questions previously laid out. While some qualitative research acknowledges that new questions will continue to arise as the research progresses (Berg, Maxwell) it is important to realize that it is extremely rare for research to begin without a fixed goal in mind (Liebow). In this study there is a goal of determining if judges are swayed by pre-sentence investigation reports, or if probation officers tailor them to judges opinions. Q1. What is the process through which a pre-sentence investigation (PSI) is written? Q2. How much effort does a judge place into the reading of a PSI? Q3. Do writing styles of PSIs vary by probation officer? Q4: Do writing styles of PSIs vary by what judge it is sent to? Q5. What is the impact of a PSI on a judge’s decision? Data collection questions would further break each of these down by asking the who, what, when, where, why, and how’s of each in particular matters. [u]Section B[/u]: While I would like to employee a standardized interview, as it is directly structured with no variations (Berg, 2009) I think that it would be an impediment in this case. The lack of ability to phrase questions in a different manner or order would not be preferable in a situation where you are dealing with individuals of varying levels of education and experience; for instance the researcher knows probation officers in another jurisdiction who have Masters degrees and who have colleagues who have a Bachelors degree. This environment would also not be conducive to a focus group. Judges days are consistently packed with a docket that is often scheduled months in advance. Probation officers often have most of a day scheduled out before it begins as well. Trying to bring together members of either, or both groups, would cause undue harm to the professional services that they render. Instead, I would use a semi-standardized or unstandardized interview type. The semi-standardized interview would allow for the variation of wording and question order to deal with varying experience and education levels, while maintaining a structure. It allows for the advantage of being able to make clarifications if the question is not at first understood, and to further tailor probes between interview subjects as needed. The unstandardized interview is the most difficult for a researcher to adequately conduct because there is a total lack of structure. However, it is the most like a conversation and is the least likely to make an individual feel as though they are being used as some sort of specimen in a scientific endeavor; this may help them open up. In the researcher’s personal experience with probation officers, formality inside of the office setting when it is not required, is an impediment to interaction. A further possible positive of the undstandardized interview is that since there is not set of questions, nor wording to them, the seemingly casual nature of the interview may yield new avenues to explore. These avenues might not have been uncovered in a structured or semi-structured interview situation. [u]Section C:[/u] This section will seek to explain why I feel it would be beneficial to me as the researcher to sit in on a PSI interview and observe how it is conducted. At the same time, I will acknowledge that there are limitations to this effort. Part of qualitative research is realizing your own biases (Martin, lecture). I realize that I am biased in liking to understand how a process works rather than taking a person’s word on it, and I have conducted a Pre-Sentence Investigation in a previous position. Both of these biases must be acknowledged as reasons that contribute to my desire to observe a PSI, but also allow for the researcher to beware of reactivity (Maxwell). It would be beneficial to sit in on a PSI to determine if the probation officer is following his or her own method of conducting it, or is going by the pre-determined checklists that many agencies keep. This would speak to the style that the officer would then use in drafting the PSI and would link directly back to my first Research Question which asked about the process that a probation officer goes through in the writing of a PSI. However, there are negative points to observation. Part of the PSI process, in addition to looking at records, is to interview individuals. Their consent would also presumably be needed for the researcher to sit in on the pre-sentence investigation interview. Furthermore, individuals, professional or otherwise, may alter their normal behavior because they know that they’re being watched. This may be done knowingly, or unknowingly. Another negative aspect is that the probation officers may feel that the researcher is trying to become involved in ways that they may not like. In all research, especially qualitative, it is important to not “burn bridges” with those you would one day like to do further research with, or one of your colleagues might. The probation officers’ opinions should be asked prior to the researcher making the request to sit in; prior to the probation officers themselves, it would be important to go through a gatekeeper first, be it the Chief Probation Officer or a court official. [u]Section D:[/u] The researcher feels that the ethical concerns of this proposed study are limited. However, those ethical concerns that have been identified will now be described. It is important to remember that the researcher is the research instrument. Since this is a study being done with individuals who work in the justice system (judges and probation officers) and cooperation has been assured, there will be no need to use deception in the course of this research. The prior point is included, because prior to doing anything in the study that has been outlined, the ongoing process of informed consent must begin at the outset, despite the assured cooperation; if the probation officers and judges are not kept “in the loop” it may be a breach of ethics. The researcher, if observation permissions are granted, will also have to have an informed consent form signed by any individuals who are being interviewed, so that they may know the researcher’s purpose and to give the ostensible permission that would be needed as a deception model is not being utilized. The researcher has a number of ethical responsibilities to the participants, which makes up the “bulk” of the ethical concerns for the study that has been outlined. First, the researcher will use aliases so that no names will be given in the final research to link back to the individuals who are involved. Efforts will be made to not identify the subjects in any noticeable ways to anyone who may read the research once it is published; this will be especially difficult with the limited number of felony judges (six). The researcher is obligated to avoid harm to the subjects. Probation officers, judges, and any PSI interviewees will not be intentionally harmed in a physical, emotional, or professional manner during the course of this study. This is most likely to become an issue during PSI interview observation, where some questions a probation officer asks may provoke emotional responses in the subject; should the researcher be asked to leave by the interviewee, it will be done with haste. Reciprocity is another issue that must be ethically addressed in this proposed study. The researcher is intruding into the professional lives of these judges and probation officers. The researcher realizes that he is in the debt of these individuals for allowing him the opportunity to share in their experiences and will be happy to do small things around the office if requested, such as making copies and coffee. In addition to such small things, the researcher will allow feedback to be shared by the probation officers and judges on how to better improve the methods to minimize obtrusiveness, and a selection will be made of four probation officers and one judge (the proper ratio when dividing their numbers) to comment on the recorded observations of the researcher. This provides for recognition and is a display of gratitude to the professionals for their participation. Once the research is concluded, it is ethically correct to send a copy of it along with personalized thanks to those involved in the study. This continues the ethical dimension of reciprocity and allows for doors to remain open for possible future research.
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 Have them on January 13th and week after... [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Feminist Theories[/b][/center] [b]Lombroso (1876) [/b]– Females who are more masculine commit more crime [b]Quetelet (1835) [/b]– Of the Development of the Propensity to Crime. Studied in France, the relationship between gender and crime. Men are more likely to commit crime. [b]Gottfredson and Hirschi (1990) – [/b]Differences between males and females are based in child rearing practices. Females have more self control. [b]Adler (1975) - [/b] Women become more masculine as they adopt traditional male roles. [b]Simon (1975) – [/b]As women change roles, they were afforded more opportunities to commit crime. Agreed with Adler on increasing female crime (not empirically supported). [b]Heimer & DeCoster (1999) [/b]– Boys are more violent because they learn the definition more favorably. [b]Cote (2007)[/b] – Conducted longitudinal analysis from the developmental perspective. Little difference in infancy, but during life course the physical aggression gap widens. Females are more into indirect aggression like malicious gossip. Differences are attributed to social relations and different sexual pressures. [b]Giordano & Rockwell (2000)[/b] – Interviewed 127 female inmates. Women were inundated with crime from family and friends. Anecdotal evidence that definitions, both direct and indirect learning of behavior through family and close associates of the family. [b]Hagan et al. (1985)[/b] – Power Control Theory. Parents control girls behavior more closely than boys. In families where both parents work, the genders are treated more equal. Families where father works and mother stays at home, way more restrictive of girls.
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Rational Choice Theories[/b][/center] [b]Clark and Cornish (1985) – [/b]Not all weight the cost/benefit actions the same. [b]Tunnel (1990) – [/b]Offenders don’t think about the risk/their assessment of risk is not realistic. Offenders do not rationally take into account the cost of their activities. They do not feel as though they can be caught and stopped. [b]Cromwell et al. (1991) – [/b]Burglars aren’t rational.
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Integration of Theories[/b][/center] [b]General Notes[/b]: Falsification – if we can’t account for known facts and lack empirical support, it is falsified. Nearly all rhetoric falsified on some level and doesn’t work. Theoretical competition – empirical validity of one theory compared to another. Force development through competition. To integrate is to combine theories. Two main types: Conceptual – merge concepts that are similar. Propositional – linking separate but giving principles side by side – example is life course end to end – 1-2-3 (Eliot et al. 1979) Up and down – example is social control-learning [b]Hirschi (1979)[/b] – Incompatible assumptions. Theories can only be integrated if they argue the same thing. (Against). (This is the view the committee members hold, avoid integration at all costs.) [b]Eliot et al. 1979 – [/b]Most theories only explain 10-20% of the variance. Different theories explain different portions of crime variances, so theory competition is useless. Found support for integrated theory using National Youth Survey data.[center][b]Theory Note Cards: Developmental Theories[/b][/center] [b]Age Crime Debate – [/b]Traditional views hold that average age 20 there is less offending. The career criminal view holds that there is a decline caused by changes in participation, some stop but others continue at a high rate. Because some offenders always participate and others end early, may be one set of factors that determines who participates in crime and another set of factors that effects the frequency and duration. [b]Moffit (1993)[/b] – Life Course Theory. Life course persistent offenders and adolescent limited. LCP offenders start early and end late. LA begin late and have a short career, with some factor causing maturity, such as getting married or having a career. [b]Sampson & Laub (1990, 2005) – [/b]Age graded social control. Re-analyzed the Glueck data. Theory has 3 components. It explains juvenile delinquency, explores behavioral transitions as youth become adults. Explains adult crime. [b]Sampson & Laub (1990) – [/b]Events later in life can change a person. [b]Simons et al. (1994) – [/b]451 2-parent families in four waves, grades 7-10. Most were rural and white. Found support for different avenues to delinquency for early and late starters. Control explains early starters better. [b]Bernard, Snipers, & Gerauld (2010) – [/b]Debate has waned, more view the two sides not as polar opposites. new developmental theories are being developed and tested, the debate is less important. [b]Nagin & Land (1993) – [/b]Found support for both. Developmental theories have adopted the language of the career criminal paradigm. Developmental theories ID factors across people’s lives that account for stability and change in anti-social behavior. [b]Maruna (2001) – [/b]The theory of redemptive scripts. Asked why do people with everything against them stop committing crime. What separates desistors from persistors is differential scripts they use to describe their long term criminality. Persistors – life forces beyond their control. Desistors – redemptive scripts. [b]Gottfredson & Hirschi (1990) – [/b]Criminal propensity position. Some more prone to commit crime than others, but all’s propensity to commit crime is stable over the life course (self control) after age 8. Propensity may manifest in a number of ways, based on circumstance, so that people with same propensity may vary based on opportunity. Actual vary in criminal offending is based on person’s point in the age crime curve. All people follow this curve. Thus agues age crime curve is invariant and doesn’t require explanation, all this is required is to explain why different people have different criminal propensities. [b]Farington (2005) – [/b]Summarized developmental theory conclusions. [b]Alfred et al (1986) – [/b]The panel on research on criminal careers. Get new set of terms to describe criminal behavior. Participation – yes and no. Frequency, the rate of offending of those engaged. Seriousness, onset, desistance. First major new system interpret relate age and crime, set off debate. [b]Wolfgang, Figlio, & Sellin (1972)[/b] – Study in Philadelphia, found 6% of juveniles account for 52% of contact with cops and 70% of all juvenile contact involves felonies. These figures led some to conclude that small group of active criminals accounted for large proportion of crime.
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Deterrence Theories[/b][/center] [b]Beccaria (1764)[/b] – swift, certain, and just severe enough for the crime. Free will, we maximize our pleasure and minimize our pain. Will weigh the costs and benefits of our actions. If the punishment is fitting it shout deter. [b]Kelling (1974) – [/b]Kansas City study, not deter if extra cops placed on the beat. Compared regular police beat with one with more cops added. Tested if increased police presence would increase certainty of punishment, thus lowering crime. No support. [b]Sellin (1959) – [/b]One of the earliest empirical tests. Compared homicide states with and without the death penalty, no difference. [b]Cook (1980) – [/b]Capital punishment not a deterrent. Found higher homicide rates in states with death penalty than those without. [b]Pratt et al. (2006) – [/b]Meta analysis, police size and arrest ratio a weak measure. Found objective (police size, arrest rates) among weakest predictors of crime. Perceptual, such as the deterrent effect perceived of severity was not existent. Deterrent effect of perceived certainty was significant, but weak. [b]Paternoster (1987) – [/b]Many cross sectional studies show support, longitudinal do not. Discuss importance of moral inhibitions and social control. Some people would not commit a crime, even if given the chance. [b]Paternoster (1985) – [/b]Found informal deterrence to be related to crime. When variables of control and learning were included, perceived risk of informal sanctions by family and friends. The relationship between risk of legal penalty and crime is almost non-existent. [b]Hobbes (16-17[sup]th[/sup] century) – [/b]People enter into a social contract with the state to prevent chaos.
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Trait Genetics Theories (Committee hates these, AVOID)[/b][/center] [b]Walsh and Ellis (2007) – [/b]There is a correlation between gene and environment interaction. G-E Correlation means there is a relationship between genotype and the environment. [b]Lombroso (1876) – [/b]Criminals are atavistic throwbacks who have big jaws and thick skulls. [b]Darwin (1859) – [/b]Evidence that traits transfer from parent to offspring. [b]Ellis (2005) – [/b]Evolutionary neuro and cenic theory. ENA integrates evolutionary and neuroscience constructs. Broadly, crime is from evolutionary, neurological, and hormonal factors. [b]Walsh (2002) – [/b]Genes are strands of DNA that code proteins, some produce neuro chemicals and hormones that facilitate feelings and behaviors. Genes create tendencies to respond to environment in certain way. [b]Glueck & Glueck (1950) – [/b]Note need to establish theories with multiple factors. Delinquents have fewer intellectual traits and less school attainment. Delinquent parents are less intelligent and socially adept. [b]Hirschi & Hindelong (1977) – [/b]Relationship between delinquency and IQ scores. IQ predicts delinquency as well as race and social class. IQ effects school performance and ability to adjust to this indirectly effects crime. Official data shows stronger relationship between IQ and crime compared to survey, because people with low IQ are less likely to take the survey and people with high IQ are less likely to get caught. [b]Goddard (1912) – [/b]Examines the two lines of the Kallikaks family. [b]Fishbean (1990) – [/b]Overall, there is evidence that biological conditions have an impact on factors that influence behavior. Biological defects or traits that create a disposition toward crime may be compounded over time by the environment. [b]Christiansen (1977) – [/b]Calculated concordance rates for twins’ criminality. Identical male twins are 2.5x more likely to both be, if one is, compared to fraternal twins. [b]Moffit et al. (2000) – [/b]Longitudinal study. Asked if characteristics are the same between general crime and partner abusers. 500 people sample, personality measured, 18 partner abusers and general crime at age of 21. Both result of negative emotionality. But crime related weak constraints, but had partner abusers. 2 variables not part of the same construct of anti-social behavior. [b]Medneck et al. (1987) – [/b]Genetic factors pass parent to offspring. Adoption study in Denmark. Adopted kids with biological parents as criminals are more likely to commit crime than if adoptive parents and biological parents were not criminals. Most likely to offend if both the biological and adoptive parents were criminals. [b]Caspi et al. (2002) – [/b]Study demonstrates that we need to take both biological and environmental factors into account. MAO maintain balance of several neurotransmitters, and if MAO levels are off, then it is possible to have a problem.
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Conflict Theories[/b][/center] [b]General notes: [/b]Conflict provides an explanation for law formulation and violation. [b]Quinney (1975) – [/b]Laws are enacted to protect the powerful. Laws serve the powerful over the weak, but all are indoctrinated to think that it is our law. [b]Akers and Sellers (2004) – [/b]There are 4 types of empirical studies on conflict. A. Research on the influence of interest groups on legislation, court decisions, etc. (Crime formulation). B) Research on public opinion about what behavior is disapproved of. (Crime formulation). C) Research on relationship between presence of threatening social groups and its impact on crime control efforts within a geographical area (Law violation and enforcement). D) Research on the exercise of discretion in applying the law against the accused law violator (law violation and enforcement). [b]Sumner (1906) – [/b]Consensus view on law formulation. Law developed primarily thru official codification of the prevailing “following mores”, unorganized intuitive principles of right and wrong. [b]Selliu (1938) – [/b]Cultural rules dictate how we act in certain situations. Conflict is primarily between two cultures. Secondly, cultures divide into subcultures. Competing cultural norms for laws. [b]Vold (1958)[/b] – People band in groups to serve their needs. Groups and interest groups struggle with each other, this results in constant conflict in society. Process of law making and crime control reflects conflict of interest groups. [b]Gusfield (1963) – [/b]First type of conflict study (crime formulation). Examine the temperance movement, shows conflict between two groups; the nondrinking rural middle class Protestants and the urban, secular, most immigrants who the first group was losing ground to. 18[sup]th[/sup] Amendment passed. [b]Turk (1969) – [/b]Conflict occurs between authorities and subjects. Theory of criminalization: Criminal status is determined by the authorities.. Thru use of power, criminal status is imposed. Process works so people play by the rules. Conflict when someone refuses existing order. More sophisticated able to achieve goals by means other than crime. [b]Quinney (1970) – [/b]Different societal segments form: high and low standing. Segments of low standing more often law violators, different groups define criminal concepts differently. [b]Jacobs et al. (2008) – [/b]As minority groups increase in size and power, majority exercise more social control on them to keep the status quo. Found that the death sentence for blacks was higher by population after controlling for non-racial variables.
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [quote name='Lisa' timestamp='1324940182' post='2357800'] You're going to dominate this time, BG!!!!!!! [/quote] Thank you so much! I've spent all day typing up my notecards (other than labeling and social learning, left them back in PA I think) to include in my easier to read study guides.*Theory notecards, Policy tomorrow
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Social Disorganization Theories[/b][/center] [b]General Definition: [/b] Inability of a community to realize the shared values of its citizens and maintain social control. Socially organized communities have informal controls: Solidarity – internal consensus on norms Cohesion – Strong bond among neighbors Integration – Regular social interaction External factors can create barriers for social ties which limit informal controls. [b]Park and Burgess (1925) – [/b]Concentric zones. [b]Shaw & McKay (1942) –[/b] expanded on concentric zones [b]Kornhauser (1978) – [/b]criticized theory. [b]Stark (19987) – [/b]5 aspects of high deviance, 30 hypotheses to test. [b]Bursick (1988) – [/b]gave criticisms and ways to continue theory. Stated Shaw and McKay did not say social, societal, and neighborhood conditions directly cause crime, but that social disorganization hinders social control in an area, allowing high crime. The absence or breakdown of social control is key component behind the concept of social disorganization. [b]Sampson and Groves (1989) – [/b]Address criticism of proper testing, looked at intermediate variables. Agreed with Bursick, social disorganization not propose or suggest factors like social class and race are direct causes of crime. Yet, these are types of variables used in the past, so no direct tests of the theory. Provided empirical model to fix this, did not use official data. Included measures of external factors, but also more direct, such as measures of social control (team supervisors and friendship networks). [b]Eliot et al (1995) – [/b]mixed support. Found informal control to be related to delinquency and mediates effects of disadvantaged neighborhoods, but social ties not significant. [b]Sampson, Raudenbush, & Earls (1997) – [/b]Collective efficacy of a community. [b]Sampson & raudenbush (1999) – [/b]Tested their 1997 adaptation and found support for it. [b]Jang & Johnson (2001) – [/b]tried to measure social disorganization directly. Found significant but social control and social learning were stronger. [b]Gottfredson, McNeil, and Gottefredson (1991) – [/b]Did not support, but only examined external variables.
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Self Control Theories[/b][/center] [b]Gottfredson & Hirschi (1990, 1993) – [/b]General Theory of Crime. Low self control is to cause for crime. Set after age 8 and internal to the person. Suggested analogous behavior measure: drinking, job instability, whining as a kid, etc. [b]Hirschi & Gottfredson (1993) – [/b]Why they hate Grasmick: A) less valid because people with low self control are less likely to take the survey and more likely to lie on it. B) Concerned it will imply self control is a personality concept that predisposes people to crime, reminded theory states people are not predisposed but develop self control, don’t want seen as a trait. Said the best identifier of self control are the acts it is used to explain. Acknowledge this may not be acceptable, so attitudinal > behavior, whining as a child, employment instability, etc. [b]Grasmick et al. (1993) – [/b]Developed a 25 item cognitive scale to measure self control. E.G. impulsivity as a sign of low self control. “I often act without thinking”. Self con reps underlying personality threads. Some support for unidimensional trait. [b]Keane et al. (1993) – [/b]Others risky behavior (drugs and drinking) predicts drunk driving. Attempts to explain driving under the influence with measures relating to drinking and driving behavior. People pulled over, breathalyzer and survey given. Questions dealt with risk driving, no seatbelt, drinking. Inferred behaviors to low self control. [b]Sampson & Laub (1993)- [/b]People can change (but that could be due to a pustunny, as a theory suggests). [b]Pratt & Cullen (2000) – [/b]Most studies use attitudinal measures. Meta analysis of self control, both attitudinal and behavioral measures. Showed support for attitudinal. .257 and behavioral .277. Concluded effect size would rank self control as one of the strongest known correlates of crime. [b]Laub & Sampson (2003) – [/b]Changes in behavior due to events [b]Burt et al. (2006) – [/b]Showed measured levels of self control can increase and decrease. [b]Bacon (2003) –[/b]Study of homeless street youth in Canada. Self control and deviant peers and strain variables on crime and drug use. Found low self control predicted deviant peers and values and unemployed status. Strain values not related self control and impacted crime separately. Also, low self control could not explain all of impact of deviant peers and values.
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Just Strain Theories[/b][/center] [b]Durkheim (1897) – [/b]Original concept of anomie developed. A state of normlessness. [b]Cohen (1955) – [/b]Considered the inability of obtaining status as causing crime. Delinquent subcultures in lower class, form due to status frustration. [b]Clowards and Ohlin (1960) – [/b]Differential illegitimate opportunity structures. 3 types of delinquent subcultures: criminal, conflict, retreatist. [b]Hirschi (1969) – [/b]Examine the relationship between education expectations and aspirations. Concluded goal-means gap not a good predictor. Few in sample had aspirations that exceeded expectations. [b]Kornhauser (1978) – [/b]Critical of strain, no goal means no goal-means gap support. [b]Farnsworth and Lieber (1989) – [/b]Suggested measuring strain as economic goals and educational expectations. It was a better predictor than other ways. Best measure was educational aspirations which can support social control theory. [b]Burton & Cullen (1992) – [/b]Reviewed over 50 studies of classic strain and found them largely unsupportive of the theory. However, the majority of unsupportive studies measured strain as a goal-means gap. Of studies that measured strain as blocked opportunities, 50% supported. [b]Burton et al. (1994) – [/b]Tested 3 measures of strain on 477 whites. A) Perceptions of blocked opportunities. B) Gap aspirations and expectations. C) relationship deprivation. found all correlated with crime, however when control and learning variables were included, no strain variables were related. [b]Agnew et al. (1996) – [/b]Added variable of satisfaction with monetary situation because strain is likely to be felt by those with high monetary expectations. With a sample of 400 white adults, found positive correlation with new measure and income generating crime. (Spins off General Strain Theory).
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: Classical Strain Theories[/b][/center] [b]Durkheim (1897) – [/b]Original concept of anomie in suicide, defined as a state of normlessness. Saw as a result of rapid social change and industrial revolution. [b]Merton (1938) – [/b]Adopted to anomie-strain. Macro component: Because legitimate means are not stressed enough, people are more likely to use any means available. Success is stressed to all, but not all have the same means. Creates strains which can lead to crime. Micro responses to strains: Conformity, innovation, ritualism, retreatism, and rebellion. [b]Cohen (1955) – [/b]States frustration, delinquent subculture. [b]Cloward & Ohlin (1960) – [/b]differential illegitimate opportunity structures. [b]Farnsworth and Lieber (1989) – [/b]Suggested measuring strain as economic goals and educational expectations. It was a better predictor than other ways. Best measure was educational aspirations which can support social control theory. [b]Burton & Cullen (1992) – [/b]Reviewed over 50 studies of classic strain and found them largely unsupportive of the theory. However, the majority of unsupportive studies measured strain as a goal-means gap. Of studies that measured strain as blocked opportunities, 50% supported. [b]Burton et al. (1994) – [/b]Tested 3 measures of strain on 477 whites. A) Perceptions of blocked opportunities. B) Gap aspirations and expectations. C) relationship deprivation. found all correlated with crime, however when control and learning variables were included, no strain variables were related. [b]Agnew et al. (1996) – [/b]Added variable of satisfaction with monetary situation because strain is likely to be felt by those with high monetary expectations. With a sample of 400 white adults, found positive correlation with new measure and income generating crime. (Spins off General Strain Theory).
BG45 Posted December 26, 2011 Author Posted December 26, 2011 [center][b]Theory Note Cards: General Strain Theories[/b][/center] [b]Agnew (1985) – [/b]Earliest revision of theory. Youth in Transition survey. Focused on inability to escape negative situations. Included multiple scales to measure. Found aversive environments to have direct and indirect effect on anger. Concluded inability to escape negative situations leads to anger and crime. [b]Agnew (1985, 1992) –[/b] Sources of strain, negative effective states, internal and external. [b]Agnew and White (1992) – [/b]First real test of General Strain. Dependent variable was delinquency and drug use. Found negative life events and hassels to be highly correlated with delinquency. Partia test – no emotions. Also found interaction effect between strain and delinquent peers. [b]Agnew (2001) [/b]– Began to argue certain types of strain more likely to cause crime. A) if viewed as unjust or institutional. B) High in magnitude. C) If caused by low self control. D) If it creates pressures and incentives to rely on illegitimate coping mechanisms. [b]Paternoster & Mazerolle (1994) - [/b] Longitudinal test supports. [b]Mazeroue et al. (2000) – [/b]Theory better explains violent crime, found strain not to lead to anger. [b]Agnew (2001) – [/b]Focused on strain likely to cause crime, also argued that strains should be measured separately, not put into a big variable. [b]Broidy (2001) – [/b]Coping mechanism may blunt the impact of strain on crime. Anger increases involvement in crime. Hypothesize negative effect states may not always lead to crime if there are legitimate coping strategies available. Found anger lead to crime, not other negative emotions. Suggests that anger leads to illegitimate coping mechanisms. [b]Mesner & Rogenfeld (2001) – [/b]institutional anomie. The economy, as an institution, causes strain. [b]Maume & Lee (2003) –[/b] Non-economic institutions act as buffers against delinquency and strain. [b]Baron (2004) – [/b]support, measured types of strain individually. Study of homeless in Vancouver. Found most strain measures related to crime and anger, mediated some of those. Support Agnew’s suggestion to look at types of strain separately. [b]Kubrin, Stucky, and Krohn (2009) –[/b] Not many recent studies provide support for this theory.
MissyP89 Posted December 27, 2011 Posted December 27, 2011 When's your test? Fingers crossed for you.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now