Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I don't think he would but I was just wondering what you think.

Posted

I'm curious as to why you think he wouldn't.

I'm personally not a fan of the whole 'What Would Jesus Do' thing. We are not the Son of God. I prefer thinking of it as "What Would Jesus [i]Want Me To[/i] Do". But that's just me being pernickety.

More on topic, does it matter? is watching The Hunger Games bad or sinful? No. I'll be seeing it next week.
:popcorn:

TeenApologist
Posted

I haven't seen it yet, nor have I read the books. However, I think it would be a good movie based off of Fr. Barron's commentary concerning it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RsFBbS39_z0&feature=g-all-u&context=G27cff10FAAAAAAAAGAA Check it out!

Posted

LOVE Fr. Barron. :)

Posted

i can't wait to see it!

Posted

[quote name='EmilyAnn' timestamp='1332948616' post='2409659']
I'm curious as to why you think he wouldn't.

I'm personally not a fan of the whole 'What Would Jesus Do' thing. We are not the Son of God. I prefer thinking of it as "What Would Jesus [i]Want Me To[/i] Do". But that's just me being pernickety.
[/quote]

I like WWJD - I think it's more about acting in the spirit of Jesus, than imitating his literal actions - but I see your point. The last time I asked myself that question I had just caught sight of a homeless man as I came out of the sandwich shop with my lunch. I had a sudden image of myself multiplying the sandwich and handing out the extras to at least five thousand homeless individuals. :P

Posted

I loved the books personally and can't wait to see the movie. :)

We are told to render unto Caesar what is Caesar's and what is God's unto God. But the people of Panem face a very different situation than Roman taxation of a conquered people, a human tithe of children that are called to fight to the death.

Brother Adam
Posted

I saw the movie and am now reading the book. Reading or watching the Hunger Games is not morally good or bad. As Catholics we can encounter it and find good in it and use that good to evangelize people as to the dignity of human life (which the book upholds), the moral evil of consumerism (which the book condemns), and the possible corruption of human government.

[img]http://a3.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/398973_10150632633252034_19395532033_9395309_2016812462_n.jpg[/img]

[img]http://sphotos.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn1/549080_10150628712312034_19395532033_9376426_950945769_n.jpg[/img]

[img]http://a6.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash3/564240_10150627174082034_19395532033_9370090_34016706_n.jpg[/img]

Posted

Yes, but He would only eat a kosher hot dog whilst at the theater.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1332952754' post='2409691']
Yes, but He would only eat a kosher hot dog whilst at the theater.
[/quote]

mmmm hebrew national

FutureSister2009
Posted

I don't know I mean it's about killing and it's like an annual thing that they put these children through at their town. It is kind of sickening. But I still like the books because of the action.

Posted

Would Jesus not? Ask his mom?

Posted (edited)

Okay, so I was kind of being silly when I made this thread but I said I don't think he would because killing is a mortal sin and the movie is about kids killing each other and so I was thinking along the lines of "why watch people commit mortal sins (even if just reenacted) for entertainment no matter how action packed and razzle dazzle the movie is?" CNS says:[size=3]"[font=Verdana,Arial,Helvetica]Though presumably targeted -- at least in part -- at teens, the dystopian adventure "The Hunger Games" (Lionsgate) involves enough problematic content to give parents pause."[/font][/size]

I really don't care entirely about the hunger games but it does seem to be quite gory. However, I do realize you could also ask the question "does the message out weight the violence?" Just a thought!

Edited by Annie12
IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='FutureSister2009' timestamp='1332953553' post='2409693']
I don't know I mean it's about killing and it's like an annual thing that they put these children through at their town. It is kind of sickening. But I still like the books because of the action.
[/quote]

Yeah, but the whole point is that the killing is wrong.

Posted

Murder is a mortal sin.

mysisterisalittlesister
Posted

I don't think Jesus would even watch "The Passion" He'd be like, "Dude, I'm not watching THAT again."

Posted

For some reason, people keep making the argument that the Hunger Games "is about killing." I never heard this argument until the movie trailer started to get popular, and then when the movie actually came out. However, I have no heard anyone who actually read the books make this argument. I think that for some reason the impression that the books/movie gave off is that they are about killing, but if you read them, you realize that's not at all the theme. In fact, the actual Hunger Games only take up like half of the first book. The rest is setting the stage and making the political commentary on the games very clear in various scenarios in which the main characters decry the outrage of what they are being *forced* to go through. If one of them would have refused, they probably would have been executed and others would have been chosen. There was no way out of it, and the morally good characters did not kill for any reason other than self-preservation, which is morally legit (actually, it's morally obligatory most of the time). So I would just say that to believe that the Hunger Games "is about killing" is too narrow, and that it's really worth reading the books to see what they're actually about. I think most people consider the moral a good one.

Posted

By the way, I don't think it was silly for you to ask that question. Even if there are misperceptions involved (which I don't know if there were), it's good that you're thinking about what is morally right in various situations. One thing I like about PM is that it makes me firmer in my beliefs, because I see both good and bad arguments for various moral issues, and it forces me to think about my stance on things, which makes my conscience more well-formed. :)

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1332961045' post='2409740']
Murder is a mortal sin.
[/quote]

Not to exhaust this ad nauseam, but the main characters did not commit murder; they only killed in self-defense. There are characters who were morally bad in the books/movie who killed out of spite and would definitely be classified as murderers, but that's not the case for many of the characters. The whole point is that those characters were wrong and were influenced by a corrupted government.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...