Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Would Jesus pay $13 for a movie ticket? (Or whatever movie tickets are going for these days...back in my day it was around $7).

Edited by Era Might
homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' timestamp='1332970141' post='2409807']
Would Jesus pay $13 for a movie ticket? (Or whatever movie tickets are going for these days...back in my day it was around $7).
[/quote]

Back in my day, they were $2. (You are too young to have a "back in my day" moment.) Fwiw, They're still around $7 where I live. :|

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' timestamp='1332971341' post='2409814']
Back in my day, they were $2. (You are too young to have a "back in my day" moment.) Fwiw, They're still around $7 where I live. :|
[/quote]

I'm not too young for this moment -- we had $2 movie tickets when I was a kid, too.
They're $8 for matinee and $11 for evenings here :(

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='IcePrincessKRS' timestamp='1332960455' post='2409735']
Yeah, but the whole point is that the killing is wrong.
[/quote]
srsly
I didn't care for the movie, but the point of it wasn't "check out how razzle dazzle it is to watch a bunch of kids fight to the death!"

Posted

It's actually pretty solid morally, I think. It's pro-life, pro-family, anti-war ... the whole thing starts at all because of global famine and nuclear annihilation. The later books are about self-empowerment, courage in the face of opposition and danger, and standing up for what's right.

Sounds a whole lot like the Church's teaching on social issues, if you ask me. :)

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1332949307' post='2409664']
LOVE Fr. Barron. :)
[/quote]
Just wanted to tell you that our Priest knows him personally! They where in the Seminary together and played harmonica together LOL!

Posted

When I was a kid, they were a nickel! And an old man played piano as we watched the moving pictures. Then the infernal talkies came and it all went to hell in a handbasket!!!


Stupid talkies

mysisterisalittlesister
Posted
:|

Srsly dude
Posted

[quote name='mysisterisalittlesister' timestamp='1332988004' post='2409888']
:|

Srsly dude
[/quote]

It looks like you had a vowel movement

Posted

Fr. Starkovich from apriestlife.com made a comment on Katie Prejean's blog post defending HG (katie-prejean.blogspot.com):

I do like the self-sacrifice angle of the story, but I think it is a bit more complex in its moral scope. I will admit that I haven't read the books, and at this point I don't really have the intention to do so. I did see the movie, so I can only comment on the film.

The concept of self-sacrifice in The Hunger Games, I believe, is an expression of a much deeper look at morality. In dystopian works, we usually find a critique of moral and social norms, and I find the same to be true here. The entire premise of the games is built around a supposedly air-tight system of rules and operations that dictates the outcome. The government is attempting to keep the rebellion down and preserve their power by forcing the people of the districts to behave according to the rules that they set. In essence, it's an attempt to stamp out moral creativity.

The human spirit, though, is never content with isolation. And this, I believe, is why Katniss has become a popular character. When faced with a set of rules, she finds a way to accomplish goodness outside of the rules that they set. She accomplishes this through her first act of self-sacrifice, of self-gift when she stands up for her younger sister.

This is a really important concept, because it's a necessary critique of morality. I would argue along the lines of some moral theologians that following the moral manuals and finding a great impetus with Ockham, morality was reduced to casuistry: it is a set of rules to be followed. Even in moral discussions and debates, casuistry generally reigns supreme. We come up with a supposedly air-tight scenario, then we try to judge and create morality based off of the, "What would you do in this situation?" In essence, it becomes situational ethics. (Example: You are in a room with 1 hostage and a terrorist who has a nuclear bomb. If you don't kill the hostage with the pistol on the table, the terrorist will set off the bomb and wipe out a city. What do you do?)

I argue that virtuous thinking (and an authentic Catholic morality at that) rejects casuistry completely. It makes room for the seemingly infinite creativity of the human spirit to find a way to love in the midst of great suffering and difficulty. When put in the situation of A or B, Christian morality sees and opts for option C that includes charity.

I think this is why Katniss is popular in the eye of the audience. In a dystopian world, she rejects casuist moral reasoning and reveals the light of human creativity in the sphere of charity. In the film at least, she does this rather well without actively choosing to kill anyone unless it was self-defense (I really, really regret that she euthanizes the character at the end. Without that instance, she would be a rather bright moral light. It was an action that wasn't necessary whatsoever for the plot of the film. It only hinders her moral goodness). In the face of a world without choice, she inserts the creativity of sacrifice in certain elements, and shows that the human spirit can always be creative. And, her moral, charitable creativity has many ramifications: the relationship with Rue and Peetah, and the resulting rebellion of district 11. They intuited Katniss' actions and thus decided to be creative in their actions. And finally, the ending scene with the agreement to mutual suicide: "They must have their victor." "Do they really?" She creates another option, although a less than moral one.

So--sacrifice yes, but I think the element of self-sacrifice is only the expression of a much deeper moral theme that needs to be explored. Is the work's exploration perfect? Not at all. But it moves us in the general direction and gets people thinking.

To sum it up: love is creative.

Posted

I still have no idea what this book/movie is about.

Posted (edited)

I didn't like the movie. The characters were boring and bland and to be honest the deaths were very tame. There is a japanese movie similiar to this called BATTLE ROYALE. About a future where kids were rotten to the core, uncontrollable and the population was out of control. So the governement would select a group of school kids at random and pit them to a fight to the death till one is standing. There is no reward, there is no glory, it's not even televised. Just a way for the government to show a twisted sense of control. If you have the stomach for it I highly recommend it. Be warned it is over the top and crazy. But it dives into how kids would react to a situation. How they would trust or distrust certain individuals, or how they would use this opportunity to ennact their own personal vendettas. Basic human nature and the most terrible parts of teenage angst.

Edited by blacksheep
Posted

[quote name='blacksheep' timestamp='1333028416' post='2410015']
I didn't like the movie. The characters were boring and bland and to be honest the deaths were very tame. There is a japanese movie similiar to this called BATTLE ROYALE. About a future where kids were rotten to the core, uncontrollable and the population was out of control. So the governement would select a group of school kids at random and pit them to a fight to the death till one is standing. There is no reward, there is no glory, it's not even televised. Just a way for the government to show a twisted sense of control. If you have the stomach for it I highly recommend it. Be warned it is over the top and crazy. But it dives into how kids would react to a situation. How they would trust or distrust certain individuals, or how they would use this opportunity to ennact their own personal vendettas. Basic human nature and the most terrible parts of teenage angst.
[/quote]

I'm not sure I would have enjoyed the movie at all if I hadn't read the book. My husband didn't enjoy the movie and he didn't read the book.

Posted

Jesus sees everything, so He's already watched The Hunger Games, like, billions of times.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' timestamp='1332970141' post='2409807']
Would Jesus pay $13 for a movie ticket? (Or whatever movie tickets are going for these days...back in my day it was around $7).
[/quote]

No, he'd probably give it to the poor and those who needed it.

And no, the perfume pouring story doesn't apply here <_<

Posted

Any movie with Woody Harrelson has to be good.

Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' timestamp='1333042411' post='2410253']
I'm not sure I would have enjoyed the movie at all if I hadn't read the book. My husband didn't enjoy the movie and he didn't read the book.
[/quote]

Yes i never read the books. My sisters did and they enjoyed it. I just thought is was very slow paced and didn't give us enough to really care about these characters. The suits of the city folk we a bit of a weird contrast.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Since Jesus is omnipotent, He already knows the ending, so unlikely He would go see it unless Sts. Peter, John, and James were bored too and didn't wanna go fishing again.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1333043085' post='2410260']
Jesus sees everything, so He's already watched The Hunger Games, like, billions of times.
[/quote]
so, I meant would he willingly sit down in a theater to watch a movie where kids are killing each other, even if it had a good message?????

Because I love Him
Posted

They aren't glorifying killing, in fact their doing the opposite, so since it has a good message and nothing evil is being glorified I think Jesus would see it.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...