Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I think a book that you would be interested in is Peter Kreeft's [i]Catholic Christianity. [/i]It is basically a walk through the Catechism, but Kreeft does an excellent job of saying the same things in a different way. He's also formerly a protestant, so that might help. I recall something about your question in the first couple of chapters. I'll see if I can find it.

Posted

[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1340691064' post='2448975']
An explanation of merit is found in the joint statement on justification: [url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_councils/chrstuni/documents/rc_pc_chrstuni_doc_31101999_cath-luth-joint-declaration_en.html"]http://www.vatican.v...aration_en.html[/url]
but I find it lacking in that it doesn't explain to me where the criticism of "by faith alone, without works" come from by protestants. It would appear to me that both sides do affirm that salvation is by faith alone? Is this a misunderstanding on luther's part at the start of the reformation, or mine in understanding catholic theology? It would appear to be mine because of the above statement on justification from the council of trent.

[/quote]

In my opinion, the joint statement seemed to be more of an ecumenical outreach, than a doctrine defining moment. Having quickly skimmed over the link you provided, I foung more of an affirmation of Grace Alone, and that our salvation is only attained only through Christ. If one wanted to make the arguement of prima fides (faith first), I think one could be made from that document. Though I am unsure of its precedence in catholic theology. (i think Scott Hahn put forth this argument somewhere as well).

I just don't see a repudiating of the catholic doctrine of faith and works beeing necessary for one's salvation.

Posted

And while I go and contemplate what has been presented (in that merit seems to be quite like unto what some Protestants call "Lordship Salvation," though it is indeed telling that google wants to add "heresy" to the end of that.) and come up with more questions on the theology of the Church (and find that book by Kreeft) I do wish to ask the general Catholic population here if protestants have ever tried to convert you xD. I find that those who leave the church and join protestant ones tend to not have a deep understanding of the doctrine which they left (and in that regard, I do find the Catholic church lacking) and protestants don't seek to understand catholic doctrine so I also find that among many protestants there is a belief that Catholics are a false church (which does bother be because it ignores the 1,000 years of church history between Augustine and Luther)

Archaeology cat
Posted

I cannot speak personally about attempts to convert me (I am a convert from Baptist to Catholic, but no one tried to convert me, and I've not been pressured by people to leave the Church), but a former roommate was pressured to leave the Church, and has done so. As you have observed, she didn't seem to be extremely well-grounded in the knowledge of her faith. It is quite sad, really, and you are right to note that catechesis is sorely lacking in some areas, though I think there's a move for that to get better. My pastor has clarsees and short lessons in the bulletin to help with catechesis.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1340734881' post='2449116']
I do wish to ask the general Catholic population here if protestants have ever tried to convert you xD.
[/quote]

My aunt who is a very radical Evangelical/Fundamentalist.

I haven't been on here that long, and I might be forgetting, but I don't think I've ever met a Protestant who is as studied in History and Theology--for lack of a better word--as you are. (The fact that you've actually read from the Council of Trent says a lot, I think.)


There have been a few Protestants who have come on here and have "engaged in conversations" with us though.

[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1340734881' post='2449116']
I find that those who leave the church and join protestant ones tend to not have a deep understanding of the doctrine which they left (and in that regard, I do find the Catholic church lacking)
[/quote]

You observed right. lol.

But as of the past twenty years or so, I think there has been an improvement in catechesis, especially in my generation. I myself am a product of the "New Evangelization", being a fairly parseionate Catholic youth.




[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1340734881' post='2449116']
protestants don't seek to understand catholic doctrine so I also find that among many protestants there is a belief that Catholics are a false church (which does bother be because it ignores the 1,000 years of church history between Augustine and Luther)
[/quote]


You sound more Catholic right now than you realize... hahaha.

Edited by BigJon16
Posted

I don't think, as a Catholic, anyone has tried to convert me. We do have people who stop by here and try to knock down what we believe, and then leave quickly...some do stay a while.

What I notice the most is people try to knock down what they [b]think[/b] the Church believes and teaches; and then refuse (for lack of a better word) to believe what we explain about Catholicism...

Conversations sometimes end up like this...

[b]"you guys worship Mary"[/b]
"actually we don't"
[b]"well you pray to her"[/b]
*dissertation about latria, dulia, and hyper-dulia results* *Etymology of the word 'pray' is presented*
[b]"no, no, no ...you worship to her"[/b]

[b]"because of the Eucharist, you are idolators"[/b]
"no. If we believed it was a piece of bread, then yes we would be. But it is Jesus, so it's not"
[b]"no, no, it's not Jesus, it's a piece of bread and you worship it..you darn idolator."[/b]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='BigJon16' timestamp='1340740776' post='2449149']
I haven't been on here that long, and I might be forgetting, but I don't think I've ever met a Protestant who is as studied in History and Theology--for lack of a better word--as you are. (The fact that you've actually read from the Council of Trent says a lot, I think.)

You sound more Catholic right now than you realize... hahaha.
[/quote]
I honestly think that Protestant understanding of what christianity is, is quite lacking. I do believe that protestants have a better overall grasp of doctrine (half the reason being that services are centred on the sermon, and not the Eucharist) Church history is more lacking in Protestant churches than Catholic churches because of the focus on "the priesthood of the believer" and the capacity for the individual to interpret scripture apart from tradition. It baffles me then, having this then as a central doctrine of exposition of scripture, that protestant groups call each other heretical (though admittedly such accusations are often limited to soteriology). I study church history because I believe it equally important to know where today's faith originates from, and even if I also believe in the priesthood of the believer, many men more learned than I have studied scripture, quite often what protestants describe as "new theology" has president in past theology though many don't bother to look.

I guess i should thank you being in a catholic forum, anywhere else and i guess that would be an insult. There are somethings that are relative, unfortunately.

My next question is on the stability of catholic doctrine. I mean to say, does doctrine change? I do realize that the answer to that is no, but then I offer the example of Tertullian and the change in stance regarding his formulation of the trinity. (Tertullian's Monatism is also interesting in that I find it eerily similar to today's Pentecostal movement, rejecting church history also tends to mean that many doctrines previously labeled heresy do seem to pop up) So things like the council of trent don't really change doctrine, they merely clarify it, but what is the church's stance on the seeming back peddling that occurred as the early church formulated doctrines regarding christology and other such things?

I suppose a related question is, how does the church justify monastic behaviour in that it wasn't advocated in scripture or in the earliest church, rather arising around the 400s in egypt (and then really only after the patriarch of alexandria made that hagiography on that one monk whose name I can't remember).

perhaps i should have put this thread in the transmundane lane xD

Edited by Timothy J. Hutama
Posted

Welcome and thanks for the thought-provoking questions. I used to have a very elementary understanding of the Catholic Church, then I moved to Georgia - the buckle of the Bible Belt. It was the unending questions from ill-informed non-Catholic Christians that made me research what the church really teaches and why. Now I have a middle-school understanding. :D

[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1340734881' post='2449116']I do wish to ask the general Catholic population here if protestants have ever tried to convert you xD.
[/quote]

Yes. Everytime someone invites me to their church, I also invite them to mine. They rarely accept my offer. In my youth I would accept any offer, mostly to avoid offending them, to satisfy some curiosity, and to learn. Now I never accept an offer unless they accept mine. I just don't have that much free time any more.

Posted (edited)

But since i find a majority of catholics don't really know what the church teaches (for even learning must take some effort) can you really say that you only have a "middle school" knowledge of doctrine. I would say that you probably have a "high school" knowledge of doctrine since you did bother to learn something. Of course the gap between high school and university is seminary so i doubt you'd ever be there :P

I should probably pop on with a friend to see what a catholic mass is xD I've seen one from a window above a chapel, but that doesn't really count. I can't take mass though, so idk.

Can I get this thread moved to transmundane *pokes Lil Red*?

Edited by Timothy J. Hutama
Posted

of course. :)

Posted

[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1340834402' post='2449651']
But since i find a majority of [s]catholics[/s] [b]people[/b] don't really know what the church teaches ...
[/quote]

fixed it for you!

(This is my way of letting you know that I like you. I never bother to correct insufferable jerks. Yes, I have a horrible sense of humor. I'm Catholic because they have to forgive me.)

I don't understand your question about monastic behaviour. I thought that monastic behaviour was derived from smaller Jewish sects, like the Essenes, but I haven't studied it.

Posted

[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1340734881' post='2449116']
And while I go and contemplate what has been presented (in that merit seems to be quite like unto what some Protestants call "Lordship Salvation," though it is indeed telling that google wants to add "heresy" to the end of that.) and come up with more questions on the theology of the Church (and find that book by Kreeft) I do wish to ask the general Catholic population here if protestants have ever tried to convert you xD. I find that those who leave the church and join protestant ones tend to not have a deep understanding of the doctrine which they left (and in that regard, I do find [b]the Catholic church lacking[/b]) and protestants don't seek to understand catholic doctrine so I also find that among many protestants there is a belief that Catholics are a false church (which does bother be because it ignores the 1,000 years of church history between Augustine and Luther)
[/quote]

The Church being lacking is not determined by a person's experience at a single parish. I would say that the protestant churches do a better job of fellowship, which is mostly led by the congregation, not the church's office. I am struggling to understand where you are going with the Catholic/Protestant differences.

Posted

Hi TJH!
No protestant has ever tried to convert me. A few atheist/agnostics have though! :P
Ramblings::
From my extremely limited experience with attending a nondenom church, I felt like the messages in the lecture were mainly very similar to what one would hear in an average homily, nothing more complex than what a grade schooler might understand, the music was the same way. That is pretty much where the similarity ended for me. It felt like they were missing out on lots of fun more complex theology and terminology etc etc. I have a friend who is a fallen away Catholic who always complains about all the terminology and complexities as if they were a bad. I think this might be ONE reason Catholics seem to have a harder time teaching/learning about their faith; it is just seems that much more complicated. (I certainly don't pretend to understand it all.) Keep in mind though, this is just based on experience at a single protestant church!

Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1340844211' post='2449713']
The Church being lacking is not determined by a person's experience at a single parish. I would say that the protestant churches do a better job of fellowship, which is mostly led by the congregation, not the church's office. I am struggling to understand where you are going with the Catholic/Protestant differences.
[/quote]

I'm not really going anywhere with them, they're just my perceptions of the Church as an outsider. I find many catholic doctrines beautiful and deep, and far more developed than protestant equivalents (opponents?). And in a world where I see beauty as truth (in many ways) it does call into question what I believe myself and why, hence my presence here. I seek to better understand church history, catholic theology, and my own understanding of what it means to be Christian.

[quote name='sixpence' timestamp='1340846397' post='2449741']
It felt like they were missing out on lots of fun more complex theology and terminology etc etc. I have a friend who is a fallen away Catholic who always complains about all the terminology and complexities as if they were a bad. I think this might be ONE reason Catholics seem to have a harder time teaching/learning about their faith; it is just seems that much more complicated. (I certainly don't pretend to understand it all.) Keep in mind though, this is just based on experience at a single protestant church!
[/quote]

I guess i'm also biased towards my experiences in that I grew up around many fundamentalists (even in the north-east) and they did stress an understanding of scripture more than I find in my current church. Protestant understanding of scripture is wide and varied as the number of denominations that exist (20,000? more? idk). But that's what you get when you have fundamentalists on one hand and people that deny the existence of Jesus on the other, being Christian in name only.

[quote name='Adrestia' timestamp='1340838178' post='2449667']
I don't understand your question about monastic behaviour. I thought that monastic behaviour was derived from smaller Jewish sects, like the Essenes, but I haven't studied it.
[/quote]

My Question was more on Church doctrine. Can it change? This question stems from what I read about the Christological debates of the 5th century. Like is doctrine something that can waver until a council nails it down in church canon?

Posted

[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1340852604' post='2449788']
I'm not really going anywhere with them, they're just my perceptions of the Church as an outsider. I find many catholic doctrines beautiful and deep, and far more developed than protestant equivalents (opponents?). And in a world where I see beauty as truth (in many ways) it does call into question what I believe myself and why, hence my presence here. I seek to better understand church history, catholic theology, and my own understanding of what it means to be Christian.

I guess i'm also biased towards my experiences in that I grew up around many fundamentalists (even in the north-east) and they did stress an understanding of scripture more than I find in my current church. Protestant understanding of scripture is wide and varied as the number of denominations that exist (20,000? more? idk). But that's what you get when you have fundamentalists on one hand and people that deny the existence of Jesus on the other, being Christian in name only.

My Question was more on Church doctrine. Can it change? This question stems from what I read about the Christological debates of the 5th century. Like is doctrine something that can waver until a council nails it down in church canon?
[/quote]

I like your honesty. I think you are doing yourself a disservice by focusing on the difference. When studying the Catholic Church and her teachings to learn, I believe it best to not weigh it against other faiths/beliefs, but process her teachings separate from any preconceptions. I don't know if I am making sense. I have heard too many protestant preachers preach what/why Catholic Church wrong in their sermon. I always thought that is odd and have never understood why that is, perhaps he knows there are ex-catholics in the pews. IDK. I always thought it should be that he preach what/why his church is right.

That said, IMO, the biggest difference is authority. Protestants say Bible is their authority. But I have yet to receive a reasonable answer to how they handle differences in faith[e.g. baptism] when they all are using the same source for their authority. Where do they go? Here's the punchline...the Bible says take it to the Church[Matthew 18:15-20], and that the Church is the pillar and foundation of truth[1 Timothy 3:15]

Posted

Can doctrine change?

depends what you mean by change, i suppose...

If you mean can doctrine develop, as a baby develops into an adult? yes.

If you mean can doctrine contradict itself, as in 1500 year ago we believed "X", but today we are much smarter and "X" is wrong and "Y" is what we believe now? no.

Posted

The Church may present doctrine in a different form or language, but the truth within it would not change.

Posted

[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1340852604' post='2449788']
My Question was more on Church doctrine. Can it change? This question stems from what I read about the Christological debates of the 5th century. Like is doctrine something that can waver until a council nails it down in church canon?
[/quote]

I just did some reading on the Christological debates.
(mostly [url="http://www.nestorian.org/the_christological_controversi.html"]http://www.nestorian...ontroversi.html[/url] & [url="http://www.ritchies.net/p2wk4.htm"]http://www.ritchies.net/p2wk4.htm[/url] among other googled sources)

To me, much of it seemed to be semantics and politics. For the most part, they all seemed to agree that Jesus is God and Man. Some people insisted that teaching two natures meant there were two sons and that it divided the indivisible. Some focused on the divine nature over the human nature of Christ (monophysitism), but minimizing the human nature led to the conclusion that Christ could not save us because he was not [i]really[/i] a man. After a few councils, The [i]Definition of Chalcedon[/i] was written (451):

Therefore, following the holy Fathers, we all with one accord teach men to acknowledge one and the same Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, at once complete in Godhead and complete in manhood, truly God and truly man, consisting also of a reasonable soul and body; of one substance ([i]homoousious[/i]) with the Father as regards his Godhead, and at the same time of one substance with us as regards his manhood; like us in all respects, apart from sin; as regards his Godhead, begotten of the Father before the ages, but yet as regards his manhood begotten, for us men and for our salvation, of Mary the Virgin, the God-bearer ([i]Theotokos[/i]); one and the same Christ, Son, Lord, Only-begotten, recognized in two natures, without confusion, without change, without division, without separation; the distinction of natures being in no way annulled by the union, but rather the characteristics of each nature being preserved and coming together to form one person and subsistence, not as parted or separated into two persons, but one and the same Son and Only-begotten God the Word, Lord Jesus Christ; even as the prophets from earliest times spoke of him, and our Lord Jesus Christ himself taught us, and the creed of the Fathers has handed down to us.

I'm not sure whether the history leading to this definition would be considered doctrinal backpedaling, since the 2nd Council of Ephesus was completely repudiated.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='MIkolbe' timestamp='1340888847' post='2449938']
Can doctrine change?

depends what you mean by change, i suppose...

If you mean can doctrine develop, as a baby develops into an adult? yes.

If you mean can doctrine contradict itself, as in 1500 year ago we believed "X", but today we are much smarter and "X" is wrong and "Y" is what we believe now? no.
[/quote]

Ok here is where the confusion seems to be.

*Dogma is a formally revealed truth found in Scripture and/or Tradition and must be accepted by the faithful.

*Doctrine are those terms and definitions we use to explain the dogma. Over 2000 years we have sharpened and refined and detailed the explanations, as near as you can get to explaining mysteries, and sometimes we change the emphasis, but the Dogmas DON"T change. :) Little doctrines do not grow up to be dogmas . :D.

*Disciplines are the forms we use, they are not infallible and can be changed- such as the way we receive Communion, how we go to Confession and what age we receive Confirmation etc.

*Devotions are things like First Friday devotions, the Rosary, belief in various appariations approved by the Church.

Posted (edited)

Mmm I do wonder, how would you respond to this pastor if you had the opportunity for an open discussion. Is his criticism of catholic theology accurate (being on a catholic forum the answer is no so why xD)
[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ItX-vG06QFk[/media]

I feel the the central division between catholicism and protestantism (and thus my main qualm with catholic/othrodox/coptic theology) is justification, the centre difference of reformed theology.

I feel what he says does line up with what I read in the catechism (and my now obtained copy of Kreeft's book), albeit in a very negative way.

Edited by Timothy J. Hutama

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...