Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

only 3 minutes into it...but..wow..completely wrong...

but a very interesting way he attempt to state it... he gets some of his main points correct, but then explains them incorrectly....

but, speaking for me, I don't 'do' all these things like Mass, confession, and good works, BECAUSE I want grace. That is works salvation. I do them because I love God and wish to bring the love of Jesus to others. Will God infuse grace into me, yes (to the limit of my ability/willingness to receive it)..But I am not motivated by fear. One thing he neglected to mention (granted I only heard 3 minutes) is any sort of relationship with God. A personal relationship with Jesus seemed to be lacking in his expert assessment of Catholic Theology.

One part that I would question would be if Justification is a one time event, how does he explain David, and his justification before and after his murder and adultery? How can it be a one time event if he seemingly was justified twice? Further, why did Paul find himself unworthy of heaven is justification was a one time event? Why did he tell Philipians to work out their salvation with fear and trembling? Why 'work it out', if they were already justified?

Further, would he be able to explain any relationship that simply takes one and only one affirmation, and then that's it? I said yes to my wife 12 years ago....but let me tell you I have messed up that relationship and had to ask for forgiveness from my wife. My relationship, or any relationship, is an on going journey in love, not just a stop at the mini mart.

His pontification about confession, mortal and venial sins psuedo accurate and off the mark.


Here is an article ( a short one) from Mark Shea, in which he used much of the same terminology the good pastor used, in which you can see the pastor's folly:



[quote]

Recently, the Mainstream Media (MSM) got itself all in a tizzy about “the Vatican” supposedly issuing “seven new deadly sins”. As one particularly egregious headline put it “Recycle or go to hell, warns Vatican”.

Given this view of the Faith, discussions in the press then break down into inane prattle about mortal and venial sin. Here, for instance, is Slate explaining it all for you:

What kinds of sins aren't deadly?

The venial ones. The Catholic Church divides sinful behavior into two categories: mortal and venial. (The distinction wasn't widespread until the medieval period.) Mortal sins are those that the sinner knows are serious but nonetheless decides to perform. They include the seven deadly sins as well as countless others, like witchcraft or skipping out on Sunday Mass. Other indiscretions, including any that were carried out by an ignorant or unwilling sinner, fall into the venial category. So do lesser versions of the mortal sins; for example, mild overeating would be a venial sin whereas gluttony is deadly. With both types, you can wipe the slate clean with confession and repentance, but only unrepented mortal sins can condemn you to eternal hell.

What is absent from all this is any concept of life in Christ as relationship. All you get are rules, written on a card and magnetized to the refrigerator. Break rules on Card A and the Divine Administrator puts in the record that you are slated for Hell. Break rules on Card B and the Divine Administrator marks down the infraction and gives you a warning. Earn enough infractions and the Sin Monitor Task Force transfers your name to the “Go to Hell” file. However, if you do the theological equivalent of filling out a waiver by going to Confession, the Divine Administrator will, for inscrutable reasons, round file your sin folder and let you start over.

The goal of the Christian life, in this scenario, is to die with your sin folder empty. Then God has to let you into Heaven, which is this beautiful place that has nothing to do with Him really. It's just a pretty park where your favorite dead people have been standing around waiting for you to arrive. The notion of a life of virtue spent trying to cultivate a relationship with God never enters the picture. It's just a question of keeping and breaking rules. And nobody (in the MSM) really knows why one rule is more important than another. Indeed, some of the rules appear to have nothing whatever do with anything, if you judge by the portrayal of the MSM. A mortal sin to miss Mass? That one must have been stuck in by the Church to try to control people. Hey! Everybody lusts. Downgrade that one to venial. And if we are going to have rule to control people, why not put something in there about banning SUVs? Destroying the earth is more serious than missing Mass you know! Surely God is madder about that (of course, he’s mad about pretty much every infraction so it’s hard to tell.)

In the same way, Hell seems to have nothing to do with relationship in the modern mind. I constantly meet people who think of Hell as an absurdly sadistic overreaction by a touchy God who gets irrationally angry when people don't keep his arbitrary rules. Or else it’s something that falls on the head of innocent people like a safe from a third floor window: “How can you believe in a God who would damn to Hell people who were doing their best, just because they never heard of Jesus?” Prescinding from the fact that the Church believes no such thing, what is striking is that again this notion of Hell has not one thing to do with relationship. There is not the slightest grasp that Hell is the "definitive self-exclusion" of a soul from the society of God. Hell is not some arbitrary punishment that God sticks on us like postage stamps because we got too many infractions in the file or forgot to get a waiver. It is Hitler (or maybe you or me) looking squarely at the offer of relationship with God and man he systematically destroyed and blaming everybody else for his choices. It is the human heart walling itself off finally and utterly from relationship with God and man in idiotic pride. It is any of us, making the final choice to be bricked round in the furnace of ourselves.

In short, people don't seem to grasp that Heaven is simply the fruit of a life that pursues relationship with God on His terms and Hell is simply the fruit of a life that pursues its own course on its own terms. Mortal and venial sins are useful distinctions, to be sure. But if you turn them into another way of trying to be saved by law, you are stone deaf to the most elementary teaching of the gospel: that only Christ, not law, can save us.[/quote]

Posted

This is what I noticed after one pass through that YouTube video.

I do not operate under fear, but I can't speak for others. Our work doesn't get us into heaven. We (Catholics) didn't invent purgatory.

My understanding of salvation (which is still forming) is that it is a life long series of decisions. At every moment we can choose salvation (by cooperating with God) or choose beaver damation (by disobeying God). I could be wrong.

He seems to have a very poor understanding of Catholic teachings on justification; he's just using big words out of context.

Where's Cappie when we need him?

Posted (edited)

Eek. I though I misspelled dam[i]n[/i]ation. stupid fi[i]lt[/i]er.

Also, that dude in the video assumes that Catholics do Catholic things to get grace - like we can earn God's grace by going to church more or praying more "beads" or confessing more. According to my sophomoric understanding, grace is a free gift from God, nothing we do can earn it. All we can do is choose to receive it.

Edited by Adrestia
Posted

[quote name='Adrestia' timestamp='1341283636' post='2451763'] According to my sophomoric understanding, grace is a free gift from God, nothing we do can earn it. All we can do is choose to receive it.[/quote]

and that by praying, receiving the Sacraments, etc, we open ourselves more fully to receive His grace? i dunno...it's late.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1341291642' post='2451834']
and that by praying, receiving the Sacraments, etc, we open ourselves more fully to receive His grace? i dunno...it's late.
[/quote]

I think that's right, as long as those things are what God wants. Daily mass is great, but not if it prevents one from dropping his kids off at school on time or if it takes the place of studying for finals. We have responsibilities. Performing them with great love can also open us to receive God's grace (I think).

Posted

[quote name='Timothy J. Hutama' timestamp='1341117382' post='2451073']
Mmm I do wonder, how would you respond to this pastor if you had the opportunity for an open discussion. Is his criticism of catholic theology accurate (being on a catholic forum the answer is no so why xD)
[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ItX-vG06QFk[/media]

I feel the the central division between catholicism and protestantism (and thus my main qualm with catholic/othrodox/coptic theology) is justification, the centre difference of reformed theology.

I feel what he says does line up with what I read in the catechism (and my now obtained copy of Kreeft's book), albeit in a very negative way.
[/quote]

This is very sad. Why is a pastor of an evangelical church teaching(very poorly) the Catholic theology? Where he learn what he is saying in the video? And who is his target audience?

Posted

Salvation is by grace alone (Ephesians 2:8) and salvation is through Christ alone (Acts 4:12). Look up every occurrence of the word "faith" in the Bible, you will come up with an undeniable fact the only time the phrase "faith alone" is used in the entire Bible is when it is condemned (James 2:24). The epistle of James only mentions it in the negative sense.

The Bible tells us we must have faith in order to be saved (Hebrews 11:6). But is faith nothing more than believing and trusting? Searching the Scriptures, we see faith also involves assent to God's truth (1 Thessalonians 2:13), obedience to Him (Romans 1:5, 16:26), and it must be working in love (Galatians 5:6). These points appeared to be missed by the reformers, yet they are just as crucial as believing and trusting. (1 Corinthians 13:1-3) should be listened to by all and it's certainly an attention grabber.

Paul speaks of faith as a life-long process, never as a one-time experience (Philippians 2:12). He never assumes he has nothing to worry about. If he did, his words in (1 Corinthians 9:24-27) would be nonsense. He reiterates the same point again in his second letter to Corinth (2 Corinthians 13:5). He takes nothing for granted, yet all would agree if anyone was "born again" it certainly was Paul. Our Lord and Savior spoke of the same thing by "remaining in Him" (John 15:1-11).

Paul tells us our faith is living and can go through many stages. It never stays permanently fixed after a single conversion experience no matter how genuine or sincere. Our faith can be shipwrecked (1 Timothy 1:19), departed from (1 Timothy 4:1), disowned (1 Timothy 5:8) wandered from (1 Timothy 6:10), and missed (1 Timothy 6:21). Christians do not have a "waiver" that exempts them from these verses.

Do our works mean anything? According to Jesus they do (Matthew 25:31-46). The people rewarded and punished are done so by their actions. And our thoughts (Matthew 15:18-20) and words (James 3:6-12) are accountable as well. These verses are just as much part of the Bible as Romans 10:8-13 and John 3:3-5.

The Catholic Church has never taught we "earn" our salvation. It is an inheritance (Galatians 5:21), freely given to anyone who becomes a child of God (1 John 3:1), so long as they remain that way (John 15:1-11). You can't earn it but you can lose the free gift given from the Father (James 1:17).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...