fides' Jack Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1341722598' post='2453360'] Traditional, not weird. [/quote] Nah - I'm very much a traditionalist - growing up I memorized 4 different catechisms several times each (I was required to be able to answer verbatim at least half of one before I could receive Holy Communion). I can still recite, verbatim, the 6 "Laws" of the Church as I memorized them as a youngling (which are definitely worded differently than this). I even went to fish eaters, because I thought maybe they would have them closer to your verbage - but even they were closer to mine. Given that, I'm curious as to the source of the verbage as you gave above. Traditional? Maybe, but it would have to be [i]pretty[/i] old to be more traditional than what I know. Specifically, I'm curious as to what you believe the meaning of the word "solemnize" is.
fides' Jack Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1341723023' post='2453373'] These go deeper than the foundational formulas, but would be great to study. Memorizing all the popes would be sweet. Go for it. [/quote] Again - I disagree. I posted that as a joke mainly, but I think all but the last 3 are quite foundational. More so than the 9 ways you can be an accomplice to sin - in my opinion. Anyway, I just think this is a funny topic. I'm certain the most of the peeps here are well ahead of the usual Catholic in memorizing any of these. I definitely agree with you that memorizing things like this is more helpful to one's faith life than most would admit.
Brother Adam Posted July 9, 2012 Author Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1341799498' post='2453711'] Again - I disagree. I posted that as a joke mainly, but I think all but the last 3 are quite foundational. More so than the 9 ways you can be an accomplice to sin - in my opinion. Anyway, I just think this is a funny topic. I'm certain the most of the peeps here are well ahead of the usual Catholic in memorizing any of these. I definitely agree with you that memorizing things like this is more helpful to one's faith life than most would admit. [/quote] Knowing the 265 popes wont get you to heaven, and its not me you are disagreeing with, it is the Church. Knowing the ways you can be an accomplice will help you become holy. It is not meant to be funny. Our ignorance of the faith harms the Church as a whole. That is why personal missals include the basic formulas I listed and they are required for the sacraments in places.
Brother Adam Posted July 9, 2012 Author Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1341799242' post='2453707'] Nah - I'm very much a traditionalist - growing up I memorized 4 different catechisms several times each (I was required to be able to answer verbatim at least half of one before I could receive Holy Communion). I can still recite, verbatim, the 6 "Laws" of the Church as I memorized them as a youngling (which are definitely worded differently than this). I even went to fish eaters, because I thought maybe they would have them closer to your verbage - but even they were closer to mine. Given that, I'm curious as to the source of the verbage as you gave above. Traditional? Maybe, but it would have to be [i]pretty[/i] old to be more traditional than what I know. Specifically, I'm curious as to what you believe the meaning of the word "solemnize" is. [/quote] It is a direct quote from the Roman Catholic Daily Missal published by Angelus.
Gabriela Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1341686386' post='2453160'] Today is Saturday. Go to confession. Do not die an unprepared death. Your eternal soul depends on it. Your catechesis has failed you if you do not know: The 10 Commandments The 6 Precepts The 7 Sacraments The 3 Theological Virtues The 4 Cardinal Virtues The 7 Gifts of the Spirit The 12 Fruits of the Spirit The Spiritual Works of Mercy The Corporal Works of Mercy The 8 Beatitudes The 7 Deadly Sins The 3 Evangelical Counsels The 3 Eminently Good Works The 9 Ways of being an accessory for another's sin. [/quote] Yeah, gosh, it seems like bad list-makers make just awful Catholics. I should think it'd be much more important to LIVE these bullet points than to KNOW them. (But I agree that knowing them can HELP one live them. I just don't think they're absolutely necessary for that...) Edited July 9, 2012 by curiousing
Gabriela Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1341711681' post='2453282'] You also forgot the following: 4 Marks of True Church 3 Pillars of Church Authority 3 things necessary to make a sin mortal 2 things necessary to make a sin venial 20 mysteries of the rosary 73 books of the bible 12 apostles 21 Ecumenical Councils 34 Doctors of the Church 265 Popes [/quote] ...AND A PARTRIDGE IN A PEAR TREE!!!
Lil Red Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='curiousing' timestamp='1341800876' post='2453736'] ...AND A PARTRIDGE IN A PEAR TREE!!! [/quote]
Gabriela Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1341724010' post='2453404'] Learning and meditating on these foundational formulas gives a person an amazing foundation to build on the spiritual life which is why it is included in most missals. I am not advocating anyone is a bad Catholic for not knowing them, just strongly recommending we learn them as a gift from the Church to help us get to heaven. [/quote] Well, alright then! I agree, it'd be awesome to know them. But I think a lot of people have much more important things to work on on their way to heaven (even if, as some say, it wouldn't take long to learn them—for some of us, it would take an incredibly long time). And what about the illiterate? And the terribly undereducated but heroically faithful? And what, really, about the "little children"? I just don't think the purpose of catechesis is list-making. It's about forming a person in relationship to God. I once took a class from a rabbi who told a story about a bunch of yeshiva boys who were dissing a little old Sephardi woman for not knowing as much as the big important yeshiva boys. The rabbi interrupted their arrogant festivities to chide them: "That little old woman has more fear of Heaven in her little finger than you boys have in your whole bodies!" That shut them up.
Lil Red Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 it's not either you have a relationship with Christ or you know that whole list. it's both/and.
Brother Adam Posted July 9, 2012 Author Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='Archaeology cat' timestamp='1341759677' post='2453488'] Wile these things are good to know, I have to say I don't agree with having some kind of test for a child to be given the Sacraments. But that is just my personal opinion. [/quote] I understand where you are coming from, but that is what is eautiful about our faith. In our covenantal faith there are many layers to receiving the Sacraments. Instruction is a basic one. You can get marred without knowing anything about the. THEOLOGYof the body, but the more you know the more beautiful you see the Sacrament is and the less likely you are to fall into sexual sin. Of course a Sacrament isn't going to be withheld from a child who can't memorize. Most parishes have a minimum requirement for education before the Sacraments can be received. Its all about holiness. Btw typing on my phone sorry for errors.
Groo the Wanderer Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 knowing them is just the start. to really live the faith, you also need to understand them. what is good. why and how is gooder.
Lil Red Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [color=#222222][font='Helvetica Neue', Arial, Verdana, sans-serif][size=4][background=rgb(255, 255, 255)] [quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1341801604' post='2453749'] I understand where you are coming from, but that is what is eautiful about our faith. In our covenantal faith there are many layers to receiving the Sacraments. Instruction is a basic one. You can get marred without knowing anything about the. THEOLOGYof the body, but the more you know the more beautiful you see the Sacrament is and the less likely you are to fall into sexual sin. Of course a Sacrament isn't going to be withheld from a child who can't memorize. Most parishes have a minimum requirement for education before the Sacraments can be received.[b] Its all about holiness.[/b] Btw typing on my phone sorry for errors.[/background][/size][/font][/color] [/quote] i definitely understand the education part...but i think it is just as important that a child have a love and holy devotion to the Eucharist that can be nurtured. many times, a child memorizes, goes through first communion/first reconciliation, and then doesn't darken the door of the church until confirmation time (if it doesn't happen with communion/reconciliation). btw i'm drinking, so sorry for any spelling errors.
Brother Adam Posted July 9, 2012 Author Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='curiousing' timestamp='1341801280' post='2453745'] Well, alright then! I agree, it'd be awesome to know them. But I think a lot of people have much more important things to work on on their way to heaven (even if, as some say, it wouldn't take long to learn them—for some of us, it would take an incredibly long time). And what about the illiterate? And the terribly undereducated but heroically faithful? And what, really, about the "little children"? I just don't think the purpose of catechesis is list-making. It's about forming a person in relationship to God. I once took a class from a rabbi who told a story about a bunch of yeshiva boys who were dissing a little old Sephardi woman for not knowing as much as the big important yeshiva boys. The rabbi interrupted their arrogant festivities to chide them: "That little old woman has more fear of Heaven in her little finger than you boys have in your whole bodies!" That shut them up. [/quote] Divine Revelation is pretty much par for the course to getting to heaven. Lists make things easy to memorize, in order to, as I said earlier, internalize them so we may become holy. Head knowledge becomes heart knowledge.
Gabriela Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1341801379' post='2453746'] it's not either you have a relationship with Christ or you know that whole list. it's both/and. [/quote] Yeah, I get it. I just think the reason some people have responded defensively to the statement "your catechesis has failed you" is because that is a really strong statement. I don't think catechesis is ALL about memorizing stuff or making lists. My personal response to this post was that it glorifies intellectualizing faith and diminishes the simple faith of the heart. I understand the two aren't mutually exclusive. I just feel that telling people "your catechesis has failed you" if you have a bad memory or went to a public school or whatever is obviously going to be perceived as "you're a bad Catholic". And that's harsh. (Though, I understand, Brother Adam, it isn't what you said. It just seems clear to me that's how it would be received by those whose faith is more heart-based than head-based.)
Lil Red Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='curiousing' timestamp='1341801952' post='2453757'] Yeah, I get it. I just think the reason some people have responded defensively to the statement "your catechesis has failed you" is because that is a really strong statement. I don't think catechesis is ALL about memorizing stuff or making lists. My personal response to this post was that it glorifies intellectualizing faith and diminishes the simple faith of the heart. I understand the two aren't mutually exclusive. I just feel that telling people "your catechesis has failed you" if you have a bad memory or went to a public school or whatever is obviously going to be perceived as "you're a bad Catholic". And that's harsh. (Though, I understand, Brother Adam, it isn't what you said. It just seems clear to me that's how it would be received by those whose faith is more heart-based than head-based.) [/quote] oh, i hear ya
Gabriela Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1341801806' post='2453752'] btw i'm drinking, so sorry for any spelling errors. [/quote]
Brother Adam Posted July 9, 2012 Author Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1341801806' post='2453752'] [color=#222222][font='Helvetica Neue', Arial, Verdana, sans-serif][size=4][background=rgb(255, 255, 255)] i definitely understand the education part...but i think it is just as important that a child have a love and holy devotion to the Eucharist that can be nurtured. many times, a child memorizes, goes through first communion/first reconciliation, and then doesn't darken the door of the church until confirmation time (if it doesn't happen with communion/reconciliation). btw i'm drinking, so sorry for any spelling errors. [/quote] I agree. The problem of the past 40 years is we threw the content out and the love of the Eucharist went with it. Just ask Pelosi(oops did I say that?)
Lil Red Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 [quote name='curiousing' timestamp='1341802066' post='2453762'] [/quote] tbh, i'm impressed that what i wrote is as coherent as it is!
Groo the Wanderer Posted July 9, 2012 Posted July 9, 2012 pardon my spelling errors, i'm riding a llama
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now