Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Things You Should Know As A Catholic


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1341686386' post='2453160']The 3 Evangelical Counsels[/quote]

i don't understand how knowing that a religious priest (not diocesan) is bound to poverty, chastity, and obedience is as crucial to knowing our faith as knowing the books of the Bible? unless i'm missing something??

Posted

[quote name='Archaeology cat' timestamp='1341759677' post='2453488']
Wile these things are good to know, I have to say I don't agree with having some kind of test for a child to be given the Sacraments. But that is just my personal opinion.
[/quote]

[quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1341858015' post='2453975']
Not saying we shouldn't know stuff, simply that a "test" for the sacraments [b]of initiation [/b]is ludicrous. Marriage prep, masters degree for holy orders, things like that make sense... but those aren't sacraments of initiation.
[/quote]

This is my opinion as well. I went through CCD from 1996-2003, and every single person in my class tuned out and eventually fell away, myself included. It was structured with memorization, recitation by rote, tests, homework and grading. What we walked out with after 8 years was a bunch of prayers we could parrot at will without any understanding of what it meant or why we should care.

I didn't know what transubstantiation was until I was 18, and attended Adoration for the first time as a sophomore in college. I never knew about either of those things until that point.

It took a Protestant ministry to actually teach me about living a relationship with God. So yes, my catechesis did fail me, and that was with knowing much of the list in the OP.

Teaching them the Faith is critical, but if it's not built on getting to know and love Christ and building zeal for His Church, then it's all pointless.

Posted

I will answer my own question: www.fisheaters.com/lists.html

[size=5][b]Also, I made us some flashcards[/b][/size]: http://www.flashcardmachine.com/machine/?read_only=2070688&p=8x2j

Posted

[quote name='sixpence' timestamp='1341860200' post='2454013']
I will answer my own question: www.fisheaters.com/lists.html

[size=5][b]Also, I made us some flashcards[/b][/size]: [url="http://www.flashcardmachine.com/machine/?read_only=2070688&p=8x2j"]http://www.flashcard...=2070688&p=8x2j[/url]
[/quote]

[sharedmedia=core:attachments:3019]

:)

Posted

Still confused on the precepts. Most lists I've seen (including the one in my Missal) list only 5 precepts. Including the Catechism.

Posted

[quote name='Amppax' timestamp='1341864039' post='2454038']
Still confused on the precepts. Most lists I've seen (including the one in my Missal) list only 5 precepts. Including the Catechism.
[/quote] I was confused too, since my Baltimore Catechism has 6 but modern Catechisms have 5. I think they took the 6th one out somewhere in the past century.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hubertus' timestamp='1341864568' post='2454042']
I was confused too, since my Baltimore Catechism has 6 but modern Catechisms have 5. I think they took the 6th one out somewhere in the past century.
[/quote]

[url="http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_are_the_six_precepts_of_the_church"]found this[/url], but don't know how reliable it is:


[quote]
Over the centuries, there have been a number of different ways of numbering the precepts of the Church. [u]The Catechism of the Catholic Church[/u] currently lists only five precepts (the first five below), [u]The St. Joseph Catechism[/u], otherwise known as [u]The Baltimore Catechism[/u], which was used in the United States for over a century lists the first six below, and John Paul II added the seventh below.

[b]Seven Precepts of the Church[/b]
1. To assist at Mass and rest from servile work on all Sundays and holidays of obligation.
2. To fast and abstain on the days appointed by the Church;
3. To go to confession at least once a year;
4. To receive the Blessed Sacrament at least once a year, and that about Easter time;
5. To contribute to the support of our pastors according to our means;
6. Not to marry within certain [u][background=transparent][url="http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_are_the_six_precepts_of_the_church#"]degrees[/url] [/background][/u]of kindred, nor to marry with solemnity at forbidden times.
7. To join in the missionary spirit and apostolate of the Church.

[/quote]

Edited by Lil Red
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1341864841' post='2454045']
[url="http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_are_the_six_precepts_of_the_church"]found this[/url], but don't know how reliable it is:
[/quote] Ah! I just posted about that in the other thread. I wonder why JPII's precept isn't in the catechism now..?

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='MIkolbe' timestamp='1341833623' post='2453846']I think maybe this problem is deeper than "the past 40 years".. As if from 34AD - 1962 catechesis was splendid and without incident...

Pelosi was born in 1940, and was most likely catechised between 1945 and 1956.

Biden was born in 1942, and was most likely catechised between 1947 and 1958.

Blaming everything on "the past 40 years" gets old and when used ad nauseam; really only denotes those who seem to wish to separate the Church into Pre and Post V2. (oops, did I say that?)

Content is 'thrown' out when you have non-engaged catechists, do-little or do-nothing parents, and a culture (which is not confined to a time period) wherein the proper attention is not given from Bishop down to the importance of the tenets of the faith, which were enumerated very well in the very first post; and If they are taught, they are "just the things we memorize, then forget; because the catechist, pastor, parents and parish has not made the 'why' relevant."

Blaming poor catechesis on the past 40 years is a cowardly cop-out, an excuse, a scapegoat on which hedged bets are poised. "We're doing the best we can, but those darned last 40 years..."

Paron my run-on sentences and spelling errors, it's Mondya.
[/quote]
I would give [b]my[/b] daily allotment of props to [b]this[/b] post if I could.

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1341858938' post='2453989']i don't understand how knowing that a religious priest (not diocesan) is bound to poverty, chastity, and obedience is as crucial to knowing our faith as knowing the books of the Bible? unless i'm missing something??
[/quote]
I don't know how any child raised in the church misses out on that one. (As the CFRs teach: no money, no honey and a boss.) Choose a better example. ;)

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1341863855' post='2454035']
[file removed]
:)
[/quote]
You're the best. Thanks! :love:

OnlySunshine
Posted (edited)

I already knew my catechesis was not strong enough. There is still much I don't know. I had to re-teach myself the basic regulations for Catholic life. I grew up not knowing that it was a requirement to attend Mass on Holy Days of Obligation because my parents were always too tired from work to go. My mom has apologized to me more than once for not being such a great teacher. I never prayed the Rosary or knew anything about devotions. Thank God for books like:

[i]Did Adam and Eve Have Belly Buttons?[/i]
[i]Catholic Questions and Catholic Answers[/i]
[i]Surprised by Truth[/i]
Catechism of the Catholic Church (most importantly)

They answered all my questions when I came back to the faith in 2007. ;)

Edited by MaterMisericordiae
fides' Jack
Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' timestamp='1341858781' post='2453988']
I don't think that using the sacraments as a reward is a good idea, though, and that's how it comes across if you have to pass a test before receiving a sacrament --like you "earned" the sacrament. I definitely agree that if there are no expectations of people knowing this stuff, no one will bother. But I think we have enough problems with people seeing confirmation as "Catholic Graduation" and we don't need to turn First Holy Communion into some sort of reward, as well.
[/quote]

I would agree - but I didn't see it as a reward growing up - ever. If catechesis stops after Holy Communion or Confirmation, then there's a problem. For us, though, we were not only quizzed on our memorization, but on our understanding of the memorized material, as well as memorized prayers. And when we were old enough that memorization no longer cut it, we started studying theology.

But it all starts with memorization.

fides' Jack
Posted

[quote name='MIkolbe' timestamp='1341833623' post='2453846']
I think maybe this problem is deeper than "the past 40 years".. As if from 34AD - 1962 catechesis was splendid and without incident...

Pelosi was born in 1940, and was most likely catechised between 1945 and 1956.

Biden was born in 1942, and was most likely catechised between 1947 and 1958.

Blaming everything on "the past 40 years" gets old and when used ad nauseam; really only denotes those who seem to wish to separate the Church into Pre and Post V2. (oops, did I say that?)

Content is 'thrown' out when you have non-engaged catechists, do-little or do-nothing parents, and a culture (which is not confined to a time period) wherein the proper attention is not given from Bishop down to the importance of the tenets of the faith, which were enumerated very well in the very first post; and If they are taught, they are "just the things we memorize, then forget; because the catechist, pastor, parents and parish has not made the 'why' relevant."

Blaming poor catechesis on the past 40 years is a cowardly cop-out, an excuse, a scapegoat on which hedged bets are poised. "We're doing the best we can, but those darned last 40 years..."

Paron my run-on sentences and spelling errors, it's Mondya.
[/quote]

I won't blame poor catechesis on the past 40 years. I'll blame poor catechesis for part of the major problem in the world today. I don't know when it started, but VII [i]did[/i] certainly seem to be the hinging point at which problems (perhaps existing) suddenly became immediately visible to anyone who cared enough to watch or listen.

But, really? Do I need to draw attention to your ad hominem attacks here? Just because Pelosi and Biden went through catechesis during a time which you seem to imply also had poor catechesis (or are you saying that catechetical instruction is as good now as it has ever been?), doesn't mean that they didn't live through the period immediately following VII when even people with solid theological training were turned completely around (by instructors of the faith), and taught heresy.

But again, I agree. It is the "why" that is relevant, much more than the "what". Uninstructed people can still get to heaven if they understand the "why".

Okay - backing off again...

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1341867271' post='2454075']
I would agree - but I didn't see it as a reward growing up - ever. If catechesis stops after Holy Communion or Confirmation, then there's a problem. For us, though, we were not only quizzed on our memorization, but on our understanding of the memorized material, as well as memorized prayers. And when we were old enough that memorization no longer cut it, we started studying theology.

But it all starts with memorization.
[/quote]
If the testing is happening all the way through, without regard to sacramental prep (by that I mean, you don't have a test in religious ed the year you get a sacrament, but not in other years) then it makes more sense. I was thinking you meant more along the lines of, "okay, now we have this test, before you're allowed to make your First Communion, and then this test will happen before Confirmation, and if you don't know XYZ, you have to wait." If the testing is not connected to reception of the sacraments, then I think it could at least serve as a good bench mark of where the kids are at and what else needs to be taught/emphasized in religious ed.

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' timestamp='1341868005' post='2454080']
If the testing is happening all the way through, without regard to sacramental prep (by that I mean, you don't have a test in religious ed the year you get a sacrament, but not in other years) then it makes more sense. I was thinking you meant more along the lines of, "okay, now we have this test, before you're allowed to make your First Communion, and then this test will happen before Confirmation, and if you don't know XYZ, you have to wait." If the testing is not connected to reception of the sacraments, then I think it could at least serve as a good bench mark of where the kids are at and what else needs to be taught/emphasized in religious ed.
[/quote]
We had testing all the way through, but we also had to pass certain benchmark tests in order to receive our Sacraments. I'm not sure if anyone ever FAILED a test, though I know some did come close.

fides' Jack
Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' timestamp='1341868005' post='2454080']
If the testing is happening all the way through, without regard to sacramental prep (by that I mean, you don't have a test in religious ed the year you get a sacrament, but not in other years) then it makes more sense. I was thinking you meant more along the lines of, "okay, now we have this test, before you're allowed to make your First Communion, and then this test will happen before Confirmation, and if you don't know XYZ, you have to wait." If the testing is not connected to reception of the sacraments, then I think it could at least serve as a good bench mark of where the kids are at and what else needs to be taught/emphasized in religious ed.
[/quote]

Well, I guess for us it was both. They had testing every year - and you could pass or fail every year. Before the sacraments, the tests would be more difficult, and if you couldn't pass, then you couldn't receive the sacraments. But I don't remember anyone actually failing a sacrament test (as opposed to the other ones, which were failed a few times). Maybe they just made the effort to spend extra time with the kiddos who didn't know their stuff before receiving Holy Communion and Confirmation... don't know.

Posted

[quote name='MIkolbe' timestamp='1341833623' post='2453846']
I think maybe this problem is deeper than "the past 40 years".. As if from 34AD - 1962 catechesis was splendid and without incident...

Pelosi was born in 1940, and was most likely catechised between 1945 and 1956.

Biden was born in 1942, and was most likely catechised between 1947 and 1958.

Blaming everything on "the past 40 years" gets old and when used ad nauseam; really only denotes those who seem to wish to separate the Church into Pre and Post V2. (oops, did I say that?)

Content is 'thrown' out when you have non-engaged catechists, do-little or do-nothing parents, and a culture (which is not confined to a time period) wherein the proper attention is not given from Bishop down to the importance of the tenets of the faith, which were enumerated very well in the very first post; and If they are taught, they are "just the things we memorize, then forget; because the catechist, pastor, parents and parish has not made the 'why' relevant."

Blaming poor catechesis on the past 40 years is a cowardly cop-out, an excuse, a scapegoat on which hedged bets are poised. "We're doing the best we can, but those darned last 40 years..."

Paron my run-on sentences and spelling errors, it's Mondya.
[/quote]
Poor catechism in recent decades is indeed a serious part of the problem, though hardly the whole problem. When people in many places aren't being taught the truth from their pastors and religious education, it's hard to expect them to be orthodox.

No need to accuse those who mention this of cowardice.

Posted

[quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1341867957' post='2454079']
I won't blame poor catechesis on the past 40 years. I'll blame poor catechesis for part of the major problem in the world today. I don't know when it started, but VII [i]did[/i] certainly seem to be the hinging point at which problems (perhaps existing) suddenly became immediately visible to anyone who cared enough to watch or listen.
[/quote]

One of my former spiritual directors made this hyperbole (and I am paraphrasing, my memory isn't perfect): Vatican II revealed that the pretty wrapping covered an empty box.

By empty, he did not mean completely void of substance or meaning, just that the church was not where we thought it was. Another analogy would be a young adult who moves away from home for the first time and realizes that he is not as prepared for the real world as he thought he was.

It's possible that Vatican II exposed some underlying problems. (I'm not old enough to remember before Vat II.)

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

the problems were there before Vat II. I still run into people that prayed the rosary during Mass. They were supposed to be praying the Mass along WITH the priest - the missals had the translations. Even then, not everyone 'got it'.

Posted

[quote name='brianthephysicist' timestamp='1341845854' post='2453895']
This makes me think of the quote from Emerson:

Watch your thoughts, they become words. Watch your words, they become deeds. Watch your deeds, they become habits. Watch your habits, they become character. Character is everything.
[/quote]

Ohhh... I just have to say this: Emerson ripped it off from the Talmud. The Talmud was written way before Emerson was ever born. Just FYI.

Posted

Speaking of "testing": Does anyone test that the kids are actually [i]living[/i] the precepts and doing good works, etc., before admitting them to Communion? I still think that's much more important than memorizing the lists. (Though I repeat: I see the good in learning the lists. I just don't think it's the [i]most[/i] important thing in Catechesis.) If no one's doing that, I really don't see the point in testing them on the lists before admitting them to Communion.

Though, I have heard a lot of my elders say that they memorized a bunch of stuff in school (like Shakespeare and other literature) and never understood what any of it meant as kids, but as they got older, and still remembered it, the meaning began to dawn on them, and they discovered the purpose of the memorization. Still, those weren't things that one memorized in order to influence the way they lived. If we're going to test those much-more-important things, we ought to test that the message is getting through by testing the living as well, no?

Of course, this is tantamount to testing how much people sin/fail to do good works before admitting them to Communion. Which is absurd.

In which case, I conclude that hinging admittance to Communion on any kind of testing is just absurd!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...