Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Can Melinda Gates Be Excommunicated - Please


Recommended Posts

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

I am sure the title I chose will be controversial. Oh well. I didn't know she was Catholic until a couple weeks ago.

[url="http://www.cnn.com/2012/07/09/opinion/gates-contraception-families/index.html?hpt=hp_c1&is_LR=1"]http://www.cnn.com/2...t=hp_c1&is_LR=1[/url]



Man I don't know. People are so ignorant and their views so twisted. Children are a blessing. Those who criticize the CC for publically expressing it's opinion about ABC do the very same thing they decry when trying to pass it out to everyone. They make judgements on what size people's families should be. If the issue is well some people can't really afford 5 kids then why the h-e-double toothpicks did Melinda Gates limit the size of her family? THis stuff going on is demonic. It separates women from their role as givers of life, the greatest gift and makes the working world the superior play for a woman. Sad. Truly sad.

Edited by thessalonian
ThePenciledOne
Posted

Don't really think it's our call.

Maybe we should pray instead?

The world isn't gunna get better if we gnash our teeth at every person that seems to fight against the Lord's Will. And it does little for our cause if we get mad and get bent outta shape. We have to practicing what we are preaching and reading, which is Love.


Otherwise, I'm surprised that anyone is still surprised when these things come out.

OnlySunshine
Posted

The world has become the [i]Culture of Death[/i]. To be honest, I am still disgusted but no longer surprised when I hear of people talking about birth control as if it's some kind of blessing. They are misguided about proper alternatives. I still don't understand why people see abstinence as a huge thorn in their paw. Why take something that could cause infertility (even when you stop taking it) when there is something free and much safer?

Our Lady of Guadalupe, protector of the unborn, pray for us!

Posted

Can she? Guess that's up to her Bishop.

Should she? Guess that's up to her Bishop.

thessalonian
Posted

1) I am not gnashing my teath. Not sure where you got that from my post. I am direct.
2) I am not surprized
3) I know it is up to her bishop
4) I am all for prayer and certainly undedrstand these things need prayer.
5) I am not mad and outta shape. Not sure where you got that from my post. I am direct.

Just seems to me that sooner or later for the Church to let Catholics know it means business and that we need to pick the Church or the world, something drastic needs to happen to wake people up. For the good of these people and the Church.

Posted

Melinda's views are completely one-sided. She does not even understand the church's teachings on this issue. Excuse me if I am wrong, but a person cannot be excommunicated for just disagreeing in this case, but for insisting that their views be made official right?

Posted

[quote name='savvy' timestamp='1341870307' post='2454089']
Melinda's views are completely one-sided. She does not even understand the church's teachings on this issue. Excuse me if I am wrong, but a person cannot be excommunicated for just disagreeing in this case, but for insisting that their views be made official right?
[/quote]

Actually she has excommuniated herself ("put herself out of the community")

OnlySunshine
Posted

[quote name='savvy' timestamp='1341870307' post='2454089']
Melinda's views are completely one-sided. She does not even understand the church's teachings on this issue. Excuse me if I am wrong, but a person cannot be excommunicated for just disagreeing in this case, but for insisting that their views be made official right?
[/quote]
[quote name='Tifoso' timestamp='1341872347' post='2454096']
Actually she has excommuniated herself ("put herself out of the community")
[/quote]

Excommunication can be either [i]latae sententiae[/i] (automatic, incurred at the moment of committing the offense for which canon law imposes that penalty) or [i]ferendae sententiae[/i] (incurred only when imposed by a legitimate superior or declared as the sentence of an ecclesiastical court).

Of course, every element must be met for it to be a mortal sin -- full knowledge, grave matter, and deliberate consent. We don't know if all of these have been met. Only God knows. :)

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='savvy' timestamp='1341870307' post='2454089']
Melinda's views are completely one-sided. She does not even understand the church's teachings on this issue. Excuse me if I am wrong, but a person cannot be excommunicated for just disagreeing in this case, but for insisting that their views be made official right?
[/quote]

I don't know whether she understands the Churches teachings and rejects them culpably or not. That is certainly why bishops are left with the decision. I would hope that he will have her in to explain the Churches teaching as bishops have done with the likes of pelosi and sebellus. She most certainly, from her interviews knows what the Churches teaching is. Further if she is "ignorant" of them it seems to be a chosen ignorance on some level if she does not understand them because she does not to my knowledge articulate the reasons behind them and then say I disagree. She is an adult and it seems to me that a responsible thing for a Catholic to do is to at least do some research and see why the Church teaches what it does. There seems to be some culpability if one does not. An arrogance.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='MaterMisericordiae' timestamp='1341872871' post='2454099']
Excommunication can be either [i]latae sententiae[/i] (automatic, incurred at the moment of committing the offense for which canon law imposes that penalty) or [i]ferendae sententiae[/i] (incurred only when imposed by a legitimate superior or declared as the sentence of an ecclesiastical court).

Of course, every element must be met for it to be a mortal sin -- full knowledge, grave matter, and deliberate consent. We don't know if all of these have been met. Only God knows. :)
[/quote]

Understood. Though at times it is the Bishops job to make judgements on such matters. I do like the new translation of the mass (I think it is called the confetor or something like that) where it says "through my fault, through my fault, through my most grievious fault" however. I think we have been too lax on the three conditions for mortal sin.

On a side note seems to me that there might be something lacking with regard to the "full knowledge" part of this. Seems like as I implied above there would be some culpability if one has access to the knowledge but has not taken the time or is too arogant to look in to it? We have some responsibility to educate ourselves it seems.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' timestamp='1341874428' post='2454102']
Seems like as I implied above there would be some culpability if one has access to the knowledge but has not taken the time or is too arogant to look in to it? We have some responsibility to educate ourselves it seems.
[/quote]

you are correct. Invincible ignorance cannot be claimed in the case of a Catholic who has by his or her own fault failed to educate himself on the matter. If a Catholic has taken due effort according to his state in life to inform his conscience andmake himself knowledgeable about Church teachings and [b]through no fault of his own [/b]is ignorant of something, then invincible ignorance can be claimed. In other words it would be super duper hard for a Catholic to claim invincibile ignorance on "big ticket" things like contraception and abortion which are well advertised.

Ignorance alone [b]may [/b]lessen culpability ("wow didn't realize it was THAT serious!" type thing) but does not remove culpability. Invincible ignorance removes culpability.

ThePenciledOne
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' timestamp='1341869123' post='2454087']
1) I am not gnashing my teath. Not sure where you got that from my post. I am direct.
2) I am not surprized
3) I know it is up to her bishop
4) I am all for prayer and certainly undedrstand these things need prayer.
5) I am not mad and outta shape. Not sure where you got that from my post. I am direct.

Just seems to me that sooner or later for the Church to let Catholics know it means business and that we need to pick the Church or the world, something drastic needs to happen to wake people up. For the good of these people and the Church.
[/quote]

Well, directness or not you kinda went off every which way demanding repercussions etc. so yeah....anyways...

The Church has been the Church for a lot longer than any of us and more than likely I think the Holy Spirit knows where to channel His Grace. So, I mean I think it the long run it doesn't matter and in the mean time we should be persevering through prayer and listening to what the Lord's Will is directing ourselves.

KnightofChrist
Posted

She, and thousands of liberal Catholics who give pretense to be in good standing, whilst openly supporting the Abortion Holocaust, must learn to be obedient to Mother Church.

Your concerns are valid, thessalonian. Because she and the many others like her cause public and serious scandal when they advocate such demonic things as murdering babies for whatever reason.

Pray with me she learns obedience and that Catholics who support the Abortion Holocaust will be strictly disciplined for their very public disobedience and scandal.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

burn her at the stake then force the remains to sit in the comfy chair!

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' timestamp='1341888617' post='2454235']
burn her at the stake then force the remains to sit in the comfy chair!
[/quote]

No.

Posted

Ok, having read all the posts and especially the love references, again I ask what would St. John the Baptist have done. I am sure the "Holy Spirit knew how to channel his grace" even back then, seemed it was channeled right through St John the baptist. I still say that the love the sinner, hate the sin thing is a modern invention that does more harm than good. Think of all the saints who stood up to sinners and abuses in both the laity and the church hiearchy throughout the years, did they hate the sinner, or did they see a need that had to be addressed, we change nothing by being wishy washy in our actions. perhaps when we recognise the sin that is the Holy Spirit prompting us to action, but then we think gotta love that sinner so we do nothing, we ignore the call. If we point out a sin or an abuse we may not change it immediatley but its at least been brought into the light of truth where it may garner enough attention to affect a change at some point. Although its easier to just love the sinner and allow them to continue down their path, its not our souls that are being affected, or is it?

ed

Posted (edited)

Gee, abstinence and NFP don't require a long drive to a fully-stocked clinic. Plus, it's more environmentally friendly (if you've seen the opening to the pilot episode of "Torchwood" or follow the recent studies of the high levels of pahrmaceuticals in the water supply), which should be something that the left-of-center crowd should appreciate.

Edited by Norseman82
IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

My first thought was whether we want more Bill Gates's in this world.

PLEASE don't take this post as a serious statement on this issue.

ThePenciledOne
Posted

[quote name='Ed Normile' timestamp='1341897144' post='2454263']
Ok, having read all the posts and especially the love references, again I ask what would St. John the Baptist have done. I am sure the "Holy Spirit knew how to channel his grace" even back then, seemed it was channeled right through St John the baptist. I still say that the love the sinner, hate the sin thing is a modern invention that does more harm than good. Think of all the saints who stood up to sinners and abuses in both the laity and the church hierarchy throughout the years, did they hate the sinner, or did they see a need that had to be addressed, we change nothing by being wishy washy in our actions. perhaps when we recognize the sin that is the Holy Spirit prompting us to action, but then we think gotta love that sinner so we do nothing, we ignore the call. If we point out a sin or an abuse we may not change it immediately but its at least been brought into the light of truth where it may garner enough attention to affect a change at some point. Although its easier to just love the sinner and allow them to continue down their path, its not our souls that are being affected, or is it?

ed
[/quote]

Ok, well I like how we are all assuming how it went back in St. John's day, which I will admit I did as well earlier in this thread. Concerning the 'modern invention' of loving the sinner, hating the sin, the fact is to notice the nuance. It is to love the person, but recognize the behavior that is sinful, which can be addressed in a more honest form by recognizing the other as a human person. The idea that it is 'wishy washy' is total poppypickle, because it doesn't seem to match up to whatever the idea of orthodoxy you may have.
The role of a Catholic is to defend the Church, yes to a point, but more importantly it is to evangelize others and bring them into a more fulfilled, and loving relationship with the Lord. I think, that's the more important one. God can take care of the Church, as He has since the beginning of time. I think it's easier to love a thing, (yes I am calling the Church a thing), rather than engaging and trying to love people despite their flaws and errors. Things don't let us down. Things don't change. Yet, what makes humanity beautiful is that people can prove us wrong, people can change and people can fall.
As to your last question, I would say yes maybe to a point, but more so no. If our eyes and wills are placed upon God then I think we will be ok in the end.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

tie her to the comfy chair and make her use windows me for everything. no reboots allowed. for eternity

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...