MithLuin Posted July 10, 2012 Posted July 10, 2012 Can one be excommunicated for ideas? I mean...actions, yes. I realize that if you commit certain sins, usually publicly, and do not repent, there are some consequences. But if one is preaching heresy, isn't the Church's usual response to declare the person a heretic/anathema, [i]not[/i] to excommunicate them? Anyway, I agree it's up to her bishop to decide something like that, and up to her confessor to work on the state of her soul. I'm not going to pass such judgements based on a newsreport, knowing how easy it is for such things to be distorted by the media. Doesn't mean I think she's right, of course, and if I ever meet her, I might even say something about it.
MithLuin Posted July 10, 2012 Posted July 10, 2012 Also...there is a real problem that needs to be addressed in the Third World, and it has everything to do with the treatment and abuse of women. There are way too many men in the world who don't think that marriage means what the Church says it means. (Not saying women are angels, either, but one problem at a time.) Is contraception (and abortion) the answer? No, of course not! But if a woman lives in a little hut in a garbage dump and has a husband who doesn't respect 'not right now'...how are we surprised if she thinks contraception will be a good way to help her raise the children she has already? In other words...I don't think Melinda Gates misdiagnosed the problem (entirely). I think she's offering a solution that is quick, easy...and wrong. There's a much better solution out there, but it involves changing society and making human beings take responsibility for their actions. It's free - but never popular.
Amory Posted July 10, 2012 Posted July 10, 2012 [quote name='MithLuin' timestamp='1341946201' post='2454400'] Can one be excommunicated for ideas? I mean...actions, yes. I realize that if you commit certain sins, usually publicly, and do not repent, there are some consequences. But if one is preaching heresy, isn't the Church's usual response to declare the person a heretic/anathema, [i]not[/i] to excommunicate them? [/quote] Catholics who commit heresy are [i]ipso facto[/i] excommunicated according to the current code. Heresy has to be externally manifested (i.e., heretical thoughts alone will only get one excommunicated when accompanied by heretical words). However, since it's a [i]latae sententiae[/i] penalty no declaration from a hierarch (such as the pope or a bishop) is necessary.
Slappo Posted July 10, 2012 Posted July 10, 2012 [quote name='MithLuin' timestamp='1341946201' post='2454400'] But if one is preaching heresy,[b] isn't the Church's usual response to declare the person a heretic/anathema, [i]not[/i] to excommunicate them? [/b] [/quote] Anathema is the [b]worst [/b]type of excommunication. [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01455e.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01455e.htm[/url] [quote][b]Anathema remains a major [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05678a.htm"]excommunication[/url][/b] which is to be [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12454b.htm"]promulgated[/url] with great solemnity. A formula for this [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03538b.htm"]ceremony[/url] was drawn up by Pope Zachary(741-52) in the chapter[i]Debent duodecim sacerdotes,[/i] Causexi, quest. iii. The Roman Pontifical reproduces it in the chapter [i]Ordo excommunicandi et absolvendi,[/i] distinguishing three sorts of [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05678a.htm"]excommunication[/url]: minor [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05678a.htm"]excommunication[/url], formerly incurred by a [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11726a.htm"]person[/url] holding communication with anyone under the ban of [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05678a.htm"]excommunication[/url]; major [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05678a.htm"]excommunication[/url], pronounced by the Pope in reading a sentence; and [b]anathema, or the penalty incurred by crimes of the gravest order, and solemnly [/b][url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12454b.htm"][b]promulgated[/b][/url][b] by the [/b][url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12260a.htm"][b]Pope[/b][/url][b].[/b] In passing this sentence, the pontiffis vested in [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/01428c.htm"]amice[/url], stole, and a violet cope, wearing his [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10404a.htm"]mitre[/url], and assisted by twelve [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12406a.htm"]priests[/url] clad in their [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14343d.htm"]surplices[/url] and holding lighted candles. He takes his seat in front of the altar or in some other suitable place, amid pronounces the formula of anathema which ends with these words: "Wherefore in the name of [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06608a.htm"]God[/url] the All-powerful, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, of the Blessed Peter, Prince of the Apostles, and of all the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04171a.htm"]saints[/url], in virtue of the power which has been given us of binding and loosing in [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07170a.htm"]Heaven[/url] and on earth, [b]we deprive N-- himself and all his accomplices and all his abettors of the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07402a.htm"]Communion of the Body and Blood of Our Lord[/url], we separate him from the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14074a.htm"]society[/url] of all [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03712a.htm"]Christians[/url], we exclude him from the bosom of our Holy Mother the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03744a.htm"]Church[/url] in [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07170a.htm"]Heaven[/url] and on earth, we declare him [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05678a.htm"]excommunicated[/url] and anathematized and we judge him condemned to [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07207a.htm"]eternal fire[/url] with [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04764a.htm"]Satan[/url] and his [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04710a.htm"]angels[/url] and all the reprobate, so long as he will not burst the fetters of the demon, do penance and satisfy the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03744a.htm"]Church[/url]; we deliver him to [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04764a.htm"]Satan[/url] to mortify his body, that his [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14153a.htm"]soul[/url] may be saved on the day of judgment[/b]." Whereupon all the assistants respond: "Fiat, fiat, fiat." The pontiff and the twelve [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12406a.htm"]priests[/url] then cast to the ground the lighted candles they have been carrying, and notice is sent in writing to the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12406a.htm"]priests[/url] and neighbouring [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02581b.htm"]bishops[/url] of the name of the one who has been [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05678a.htm"]excommunicated[/url] and the cause of his [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05678a.htm"]excommunication[/url], in order that they may have no communication with him. Although he is delivered to [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04764a.htm"]Satan[/url] and his [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04710a.htm"]angels[/url], he can still, and is even bound to repent. The Pontifical gives the form for absolving him and reconciling him with the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03744a.htm"]Church[/url]. [b]The [/b][url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12454b.htm"][b]promulgation[/b][/url][b] of the anathema with such solemnity is well calculated to strike terror to the criminal and bring him to a state of repentance [/b], especially if the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03744a.htm"]Church[/url] adds to it the [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03538b.htm"]ceremony[/url] of the Maranatha.[/quote]
Slappo Posted July 10, 2012 Posted July 10, 2012 All the council's contain "anathema sit" (Let him be anathema) sentances when proclaiming dogma.
thessalonian Posted July 10, 2012 Author Posted July 10, 2012 "I'm not going to pass such judgements based on a newsreport, knowing how easy it is for such things to be distorted by the media." The videos are available online. You can hear it straight from the horses mouth.
fides' Jack Posted July 10, 2012 Posted July 10, 2012 [quote name='Groo the Wanderer' timestamp='1341943836' post='2454382'] tie her to the comfy chair and make her use windows me for everything. no reboots allowed. for eternity [/quote] I think wishing her to go to hell is too much, Groo.
Ed Normile Posted July 11, 2012 Posted July 11, 2012 [quote name='ThePenciledOne' timestamp='1341936225' post='2454338'] Ok, well I like how we are all assuming how it went back in St. John's day, which I will admit I did as well earlier in this thread. Concerning the 'modern invention' of loving the sinner, hating the sin, the fact is to notice the nuance. It is to love the person, but recognize the behavior that is sinful, which can be addressed in a more honest form by recognizing the other as a human person. The idea that it is 'wishy washy' is total poppypickle, because it doesn't seem to match up to whatever the idea of orthodoxy you may have. The role of a Catholic is to defend the Church, yes to a point, but more importantly it is to evangelize others and bring them into a more fulfilled, and loving relationship with the Lord. I think, that's the more important one. God can take care of the Church, as He has since the beginning of time. I think it's easier to love a thing, (yes I am calling the Church a thing), rather than engaging and trying to love people despite their flaws and errors. Things don't let us down. Things don't change. Yet, what makes humanity beautiful is that people can prove us wrong, people can change and people can fall. As to your last question, I would say yes maybe to a point, but more so no. If our eyes and wills are placed upon God then I think we will be ok in the end. [/quote] TPO, I beleive I was the only one assuming how it was back in St Johns day, I base that assumption on teh fact He baptized Jesus and was a very holy man. He also recognized a human, the human was a sinner and he showed his love for this human sinner by calling him out on his sin and demanding he repented. What more love of a man could another show than to love his very being, his soul, that gift from God that sets him above the animals and truly makes him almost god-like, at least in the sense of being created in God's image with a soul, but to love him enough as a human and a sinner to try to help him on his way to salvation instead of just saying, I love him but I hate the sin he is engaging in. If I see my child breaking the law, of God or man, and just allow it by not rebuking him am I showing love, or am I pretending to love him by coddling him in his error? As to your last statement, that sounds very protestant to me, you know the whole, Jesus died for me so I am already saved, I do not need to confess or work toward my salvation all I have to do is be reborn. Would God expect us to just cast a blind eye to the sin of another, Jesus rebuked sinners and commanded them to sin no more, he also told his disciples when those of a town would not accept their teaching to shake the dirt of their sandals as they left that town. Do you feel his command to go forth and forgive men their sins meant they were then open to return to their sinful life with no consequences. that would be a tad more wishy-washy than I think the Son of Man could accept. ed
4588686 Posted July 11, 2012 Posted July 11, 2012 [quote name='MaterMisericordiae' timestamp='1341866000' post='2454065'] I still don't understand why people see abstinence as a huge thorn in their paw. [/quote] Because people really, really like to floopy.
Amppax Posted July 11, 2012 Posted July 11, 2012 (edited) I have absolutely nothing to contribute to this. Edited July 11, 2012 by Amppax
ThePenciledOne Posted July 11, 2012 Posted July 11, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Ed Normile' timestamp='1341970127' post='2454540'] TPO, I beleive I was the only one assuming how it was back in St Johns day, I base that assumption on teh fact He baptized Jesus and was a very holy man. He also recognized a human, the human was a sinner and he showed his love for this human sinner by calling him out on his sin and demanding he repented. What more love of a man could another show than to love his very being, his soul, that gift from God that sets him above the animals and truly makes him almost god-like, at least in the sense of being created in God's image with a soul, but to love him enough as a human and a sinner to try to help him on his way to salvation instead of just saying, I love him but I hate the sin he is engaging in. If I see my child breaking the law, of God or man, and just allow it by not rebuking him am I showing love, or am I pretending to love him by coddling him in his error? As to your last statement, that sounds very protestant to me, you know the whole, Jesus died for me so I am already saved, I do not need to confess or work toward my salvation all I have to do is be reborn. Would God expect us to just cast a blind eye to the sin of another, Jesus rebuked sinners and commanded them to sin no more, he also told his disciples when those of a town would not accept their teaching to shake the dirt of their sandals as they left that town. Do you feel his command to go forth and forgive men their sins meant they were then open to return to their sinful life with no consequences. that would be a tad more wishy-washy than I think the Son of Man could accept. ed [/quote] Most persons living in sin are not going to care about God's Love, nor are they going to understand why you are pointing out the deficiencies in their behavior. This would mean that in order to evangelize we have to choose a more subtle tactic. As to my last statement, I think you're reading a bit much into it, but whatever. Obviously, we have different ways of going about loving people and evangelizing, as long as it's doing God's Will, it doesn't matter to me. If my philosophy seems wishy-washy or Protestant then I'm sorry, but I am only doing what I have learned in my walk with Christ and growth in the spiritual life. And most of it is centered around the personhood of each individual, as it would have helped me years ago, because a lot of people are hurting and wounded and want help and an ear to listen to them. Edited July 11, 2012 by ThePenciledOne
KnightofChrist Posted July 11, 2012 Posted July 11, 2012 [quote name='ThePenciledOne' timestamp='1342028871' post='2454695'] Most persons living in sin are not going to care about God's Love, nor are they going to understand why you are pointing out the deficiencies in their behavior. This would mean that in order to evangelize we have to choose a more subtle tactic. [/quote] Subtle tactics have there place, but such tactics aren't the only option. Clear, bold, direct, straight and to the point tactics also are effective, if not more so. Sure using such tactics can increase hostility against the evangelist, even lead to his martyrdom, but that too can be a tool to evangelize and help bring sinners to repentance. Subtle tactics can work but eventually there will be a need to be clear, bold and direct. Both have a place in the conversion of souls to Mother Church.
ThePenciledOne Posted July 12, 2012 Posted July 12, 2012 [quote name='KnightofChrist' timestamp='1342031531' post='2454705'] Both have a place in the conversion of souls to Mother Church. [/quote] Glad we agree!
Skinzo Posted July 30, 2012 Posted July 30, 2012 The Gates of Microsoft will not prevail: [i]"L’Osservatore Romano[/i], the Holy See’s official daily newspaper, has taken up arms against Bill Gates and Nestlé. The Pope’s newspaper has launched a tough and clear attack against the two on the front page of this afternoon’s issue: an editorial by Giulia Galeotti on “birth control and disinformation†entitled “The risks of philanthropyâ€, defines Bill Gates’ wife as being “slightly off the mark and confused†as well as “misinformedâ€. Melinda Gates announced to the CNN that over the next eight months she wants to spend 450 million Euros on research into on research into new birth control methods, improved information on contraception and providing access in the planet’s poorest countries, primarily Africa, to such services and instruments. Speaking to the CNN, Mrs. Gates confided the difficulty she faced as a believer, aware that her initiative challenges the leaders of the Catholic Church." [url="http://vaticaninsider.lastampa.it/en/homepage/the-vatican/detail/articolo/benedetto-xvi-benedict-xvi-benedicto-xvi-17154/"]http://vaticaninsider.lastampa.it/en/homepage/the-vatican/detail/articolo/benedetto-xvi-benedict-xvi-benedicto-xvi-17154/[/url] S.
Winchester Posted July 30, 2012 Posted July 30, 2012 (edited) The Kennedy's, Pelosi, Sebelius... Our Bishops don't seem to have the guts to excommunicate, anymore. Edited July 30, 2012 by Winchester
PhuturePriest Posted July 30, 2012 Posted July 30, 2012 (edited) Preaching error should be dealt with. She should be told the truth. When someone of authority in the Church tells her the truth and she still is resistant and doesn't care, then the excommunication process may begin. But she unfortunately is a product of 95% of the Catholic population [b]or more[/b]. We can't judge her off terrible catechesis and inadequate Bishops ([url="http://www.knightsofdivinemercy.com/2012/07/04/cardinal-dolan-says-church-failed-to-teach-against-contraception/"]http://www.knightsof...-contraception/[/url] ). We are feeling the fruit of the labor that many Bishops sowed throughout the years. Had it not been for the terrible response time, the easy-going attitude about teaching it, or even at times total rejection of the Pope's infallibility on this by the Bishops, this wouldn't be a problem. Heresy running rampant is all that can be expected with such atrocities. Now it is our job to clean up the mess, and if we do not do so than it will be up to the next generation to clean up an even bigger mess. Much of the weight is on the shoulders of the Bishops, clergy and religious, and we should definitely pray for them that they preach the truth fearlessly and that they finally put forth their power of authority given to them by our Lord (Acts 20:28 "Take heed to yourselves, and to the whole flock, wherein the Holy Ghost hath placed you [b]bishops, to rule the Church of God...[/b]" The word "rule" is very powerful under this context. The Bishops need to start exercising such power). Our consolation is Christ's promise that the gates of Hell would never prevail against the Holy Mother Church. Am I the only one who read that in Michael Voris' voice? I'm so proud of myself... Edited July 30, 2012 by FuturePriest387
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now