BigJon16 Posted November 13, 2012 Posted November 13, 2012 He goes to the Latin Mass, stating that he doesn't agree with Vatican II. He is my dentist. The subject came up when I asked him to fill out the dental report on my seminary application. It was a very awkward dental appointment. Although, he did earn some more respect from me: In order for him to disagree with Vatican II, means that he has more knowledge about our faith then the average cafeteria Catholic, even if the knowledge is wrong. I had expected him to be just another cafe Catholic.
PhuturePriest Posted November 13, 2012 Posted November 13, 2012 [quote name='BigJon16' timestamp='1352812449' post='2509141'] He goes to the Latin Mass, stating that he doesn't agree with Vatican II. He is my dentist. The subject came up when I asked him to fill out the dental report on my seminary application. It was a very awkward dental appointment. Although, he did earn some more respect from me: In order for him to disagree with Vatican II, means that he has more knowledge about our faith then the average cafeteria Catholic, even if the knowledge is wrong. I had expected him to be just another cafe Catholic. [/quote] Both Catholics are damaging to the faith. I can't really see why either is preferable.
qfnol31 Posted November 13, 2012 Posted November 13, 2012 True "Old Catholics" also reject Vatican 1.
KnightofChrist Posted November 13, 2012 Posted November 13, 2012 [quote name='BigJon16' timestamp='1352812449' post='2509141'] He goes to the Latin Mass, stating that he doesn't agree with Vatican II. He is my dentist. The subject came up when I asked him to fill out the dental report on my seminary application. It was a very awkward dental appointment. Although, he did earn some more respect from me: In order for him to disagree with Vatican II, means that he has more knowledge about our faith then the average cafeteria Catholic, even if the knowledge is wrong. I had expected him to be just another cafe Catholic. [/quote] While I most certainly do not share his pov I do have some respect for it. For 50 years traditional minded Catholics and nontraditional minded Catholics have been taught, by left leaning bishops, that VII approve of all kinds of things that were actually abuses. Then when you read the VII documents that are used to justify the abuses the writing is not very clear. The false spirit of VII is very much still alive. Left leaning bishops are still trying to hijack VII and thus spread confusion to those like your dentist. I wish the Pope would get rid of the ambiguity of VII and replace it with clearer teachings as well as formally condemn very clear all the elements of the false spirit of VII.
BigJon16 Posted November 13, 2012 Author Posted November 13, 2012 [quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1352822090' post='2509182'] Both Catholics are damaging to the faith. I can't really see why either is preferable. [/quote] I'm not saying that he is 'preferable', just that I have a bit of respect for him because he likely knows more about our faith then a cafe Catholic. Even if what he knows and thinks is misguided. It was better to hear him say that then to say "I went to church once" or refuse to fill out the forms because he hates Catholicism period. I shall be praying for him though.
eagle_eye222001 Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 [quote name='BigJon16' timestamp='1352836035' post='2509301'] I'm not saying that he is 'preferable', just that I have a bit of respect for him because he likely knows more about our faith then a cafe Catholic. Even if what he knows and thinks is misguided. It was better to hear him say that then to say "I went to church once" or refuse to fill out the forms because he hates Catholicism period. I shall be praying for him though. [/quote] True. It's at least a refreshing change of scenery.
Anastasia13 Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 (edited) I thought about visiting a local Old Catholic church. I was disappointed at the moral laxity demonstrated on the website's info about it. I don't know if this is common or not. WEEP, Catholics! I could have been one. Edited November 14, 2012 by Light and Truth
Basilisa Marie Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 It seems to me that a lot of "Old Catholics" tend to have problems accepting Vatican II not really because of what the documents actually say, but because of what other people have done - taking a handful of ideas from them and running away with them. Like, inculturation - SC talks about how incorporating local culture can be a good thing, and a tool to help people come to a deeper understanding of what's going on in the liturgy. But inculturation is balanced with paragraphs on how simplicity is great, how chant should be preserved as the primary music, and nothing's said about turning the altar around or using felt banners or holding hands during the Our Father or whatever crazy things people have come up with. It's my hope that with Pope Benedict's efforts to promote the availability of the Tridentine liturgy, the new translation of the missal, and a general increase in the quality of catechesis we can reach out to more "Old Catholics" and help them come back to the Church.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1352867446' post='2509673'] It's my hope that with Pope Benedict's efforts to promote the availability of the Tridentine liturgy, the new translation of the missal, and a general increase in the quality of catechesis we can reach out to more "Old Catholics" and help them come back to the Church. [/quote] Honestly, I think it is going to take more than just catechesis and the liturgy for them. Since they are in formal schism, as opposed to the SSPX, and since they actually formally reject both Vatican I and II, the road to unity with them is nearly as difficult as it would be with the church of England. I might be exaggerating a little bit there, but perhaps not as much as we would like. Actually I have read that the Old Catholics are formally in communion with the Anglican Communion by means of the Union of Utrecht. So that is rather a barrier to reconciliation with the Catholic Church. Besides that, their catechesis is at a far worse state even than ours is. From the [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Union_of_Utrecht_(Old_Catholic)"]Wiki article[/url] on them: [indent=1]Old Catholics hold an open view to most issues, including the role of women in the Church, the role of married people within ordained ministry, the morality of same sex relationships, the use of one's conscience when deciding to use artificial contraception, and liturgical reforms such as open communion (because no human can presume to exclude any Christian from communion). Its liturgy has not significantly departed from the Tridentine Mass, as is shown in the English translation of the German Altarbook (missal). In 1994 the German bishops decided to ordain women as priests and put this into practice on 27 May 1996; similar decisions and practices followed in Austria, Switzerland and the Netherlands. The Utrecht Union allows those who are divorced to have a new religious marriage, and it has no particular teaching on abortion, leaving such decisions to the married couple.[/indent] Realistically, I think they are more likely to lose valid orders than they are to come back into communion with the Church. I would like to be wrong on that, of course. It would be a very critical misunderstanding to treat these guys as schismatic rad trads. They seem to be theologically extremely liberal, so the keys to reconciliation with traditionalists, i.e. catechesis, liturgy, and orthodox theology, are not the same as the keys to reconciliation with theological modernists. Edited November 14, 2012 by Nihil Obstat
Rosaries Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 Very cool! I wish I could meet more like this. I know very few Catholics and most are ChristmasandEaster types. Sad.
BigJon16 Posted November 14, 2012 Author Posted November 14, 2012 He is a good dentist, though. That I am sure of.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 [quote name='Rosaries' timestamp='1352875256' post='2509766'] Very cool! I wish I could meet more like this. I know very few Catholics and most are ChristmasandEaster types. Sad. [/quote] Old Catholics will not help you in that respect.
dominicansoul Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 [quote name='KnightofChrist' timestamp='1352830490' post='2509261'] I wish the Pope would get rid of the ambiguity of VII and replace it with clearer teachings as well as formally condemn very clear all the elements of the false spirit of VII. [/quote] He spoke a lot about this while Cardinal. I think many of his actions reflect a move toward this direction. By far, he is my favorite Pope ever!!!!!!!!
Papist Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 (edited) The validity and legitimacy of VII does not rely on peoples' use or misuse of it. The "spirit of Vatican II" was invented in order to disagree/reject with Humanae Vitae. Because one can't read the documents of VII and Humanae Vitae, and then accept one and reject the other. Edited November 14, 2012 by Papist
Papist Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 Does anyone recall when Humanae Vitae came out? Many Catholic "theologians" bought a full page in the New York Times just to advertise/announce they reject the Pope's encyclical. The thing is that they could have not have read it prior to taking the ad in the paper. All they were going on was leaks and rumors. Everyone was anticipating the Pope changing Church teaching contraception.
Basilisa Marie Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1352905287' post='2509833'] Does anyone recall when Humanae Vitae came out? Many Catholic "theologians" bought a full page in the New York Times just to advertise/announce they reject the Pope's encyclical. The thing is that they could have not have read it prior to taking the ad in the paper. All they were going on was leaks and rumors. Everyone was anticipating the Pope changing Church teaching contraception. [/quote] I can see why some people would think it was a fairly reasonable assumption to make, as oral contraceptives were a new thing and there was no physical "barrier" involved, and seeing as his advisory council on it decided in favor of some form of contraception for married couples. It came out on July 25, 1968. Here's the timeline from Wikipedia: [quote][color=#000000][font=sans-serif][size=3]With the appearance of the [/size][/font][/color][url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined_oral_contraceptive_pill"]first oral contraceptives[/url][color=#000000][font=sans-serif][size=3] in 1960, dissenters in the Church argued for a reconsideration of the Church positions. In 1963 [/size][/font][/color][url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_John_XXIII"]Pope John XXIII[/url][color=#000000][font=sans-serif][size=3] established a commission of six European non-theologians to study questions of birth control and population.[/size][/font][/color][sup][url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humanae_Vitae#cite_note-shannon-19"][19][/url][/sup][sup][url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humanae_Vitae#cite_note-mcclory-20"][20][/url][/sup][color=#000000][font=sans-serif][size=3] The commission that Pope John XXIII formed to study population problems as well as acceptable methods of birth control met once in 1963 and twice in 1964. As Vatican Council II was concluding, Pope Paul VI enlarged it to fifty-eight members, including married couples, laywomen, as well as theologians and bishops. The last document issued by the council (Gaudium et spes) contained a very important section titled "Fostering the Nobility of Marriage" (1965, nos. 47-52), which discusses marriage from the personalist point of view. The "duty of responsible parenthood" was affirmed, but the determination of licit and illicit forms of regulating birth was reserved to Pope Paul VI. After the close of the council a fifth and final meeting of the commission was held, again enlarged to include sixteen bishops as an executive committee, in Rome in the spring of 1966. The commission was only consultative but did make a report to Paul VI approved by a majority of members, proposing that he might use his authority to approve at least some form of contraception for married couples. A minority number of members opposed this report and issued a parallel report to the Pope. After two more years of study and consultation, the pope issued [/size][/font][/color][i]Humanae Vitae[/i][color=#000000][font=sans-serif][size=3], which removed any doubt that hormonal anti-ovulants are contraceptive. [/size][/font][/color][/quote]
Papist Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 [quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1352908591' post='2509847'] I can see why some people would think it was a fairly reasonable assumption to make, as oral contraceptives were a new thing and there was no physical "barrier" involved, and seeing as his advisory council on it decided in favor of some form of contraception for married couples. It came out on July 25, 1968. Here's the timeline from Wikipedia: [/quote] Also, the media did not help matters.
Aloysius Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 (edited) There seems to be some confusion of terms. "Old Catholics" split after Vatican I. They are all over the place in terms of their beliefs these days, I think they're even the ones responsible for "ordaining" Sinead O'Connor. Traditionalists are the ones that have problems with Vatican II; they accept the authority of the papacy, though some of them (sedevacantists) don't believe the seat of the Papacy is currently occupied. But SSPX types do accept that Pope Benedict XVI is the pope (at least the priests of the society have to recognize this or they get kicked out, the laity will vary as it does anywhere), and they vary as to their degree of problems with Vatican II. I kind of suspect the OP met someone more like this, some type of sedevacantist or SSPXer, not an "Old Catholic", just based on the description. Old Catholics are not generally very traditional, they are outright heretics (whereas Traditionalists vary and even the ones that oppose Vatican II cannot be easily painted with the term "heretic") in denying doctrine explicitly. Edited November 14, 2012 by Aloysius
Papist Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 Maybe the dentist is 92 years old and we are jumping to conclusions.
Era Might Posted November 14, 2012 Posted November 14, 2012 A lot of old catholics attend the 4PM Mass on Saturday. I think maybe they go out for coffee afterwards.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now