Not The Philosopher Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 Distributism is something which I've heard bandied about a bit, and have a vague understanding of - it being a "third way" between socialism and capitalism and all. But there has to be more to it than just being another flavor of social democracy, I'm guessing. So I was wondering if someone more in the know here could give me some helpful links and whatnot to help me out.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 The Church and the Market by Thomas E. Woods, Jr.
Amppax Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 (edited) [url="http://distributistreview.com/mag/test-2/"]http://distributistr...com/mag/test-2/[/url] This site is a great resource on distributism. Nihil, isn't Tom Woods pretty opposed to distributism? Edited November 27, 2012 by Amppax
Nihil Obstat Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Amppax' timestamp='1353995028' post='2517520'] Nihil, isn't Tom Woods pretty opposed to Distributism? [/quote] [img]http://www.gagful.com/uploads/2012_1/1327196940_FOILED_AGAIN_DARN_gag.jpg[/img] Yeah, there is a chapter in that book in which he lays out several objections to distributism.
Amppax Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 I'm not a distributist, although the basic premise as its been explained to me appeals to me. Something I need to study more.
Aloysius Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 (edited) [b]The Outline of Sanity[/b] by GK Chesterton Here's a good review: [url="http://distributistreview.com/mag/2010/12/the-outline-of-sanity-2/"]http://distributistr...ne-of-sanity-2/[/url] Most of The Distributist Review is quite good: [url="http://www.distributistreview.com"]http://www.distributistreview.com[/url] Here's their recommended reading list: [url="http://distributistreview.com/mag/test-2/recommended-reading/"]http://distributistr...mended-reading/[/url] A few things on that reading list can be read online (the links are included there) but not all of them. Heinrich Pesch is a good one from that list ([b]Ethics and the National Economy[/b]) (here's a good review of him: [url="http://www.newoxfordreview.org/reviews.jsp?did=0205-storck"]http://www.newoxford...did=0205-storck[/url] that's the economic school that much of Catholic Social Teaching has looked to)... and also maybe [b]Economics as if God Mattered[/b] by Dr. Rupert Ederer as a pretty good primer on the Catholic Social Teaching that is ignored by the Catholic proponents of Liberal Capitalism (like Tom Woods). There's a lot out there, but really to be deep in Catholic Social Teaching is to cease to become a Liberal Capitalist, and to become some degree of Distributist. Edited November 27, 2012 by Aloysius
Nihil Obstat Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1354000642' post='2517571'] There's a lot out there, but really to be deep in Catholic Social Teaching is to cease to become a Liberal Capitalist, and to become some degree of Distributist. [/quote]
Aloysius Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 Well, it is true man . Maybe replace the word "distributist" with "solidarist" or something, which is why I said "varying degrees".
Nihil Obstat Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='the171' timestamp='1354000775' post='2517573'] [s]Capitalism[/s] Corporatism and socialism are so mainstream. [/quote] FTFY
4588686 Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1354000642' post='2517571'] There's a lot out there, but really to be deep in Catholic Social Teaching is to cease to become a Liberal Capitalist, and to become some degree of Distributist. [/quote] You misspelled socialism. BAZINGA! In all seriousness, I don't see how it's really other than a basically democratic socialist movement put into Catholic language. But my reading of it was pretty quick.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1354000855' post='2517574'] Well, it is true man . Maybe replace the word "distributist" with "solidarist" or something, which is why I said "varying degrees". [/quote] I am willing to accept that distributism is at least acceptable for a Catholic, but you will not even afford me the same latitude. Makes me want to flip tables in frustration. (┛◉Д◉)┛彡┻â”â”» Well when I establish my neo-feudal paleolibertarian utopia, I promise not to have you exiled. Even though I know I cannot expect the same courtesy from you.
the171 Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 Distributism is Capitalism with a heart. ahhahahahhaa
4588686 Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1354000876' post='2517575'] FTFY [/quote] Why not just describe yourself as an extreme libertarian rather than trying to morph the traditional meaning of 'anarchism' and 'capitalism'? That's not intended to be a sleight. I'm also not convinced that in the socio-economic system you and Winchester adhere too that monopoly would be prevented from developing as I think Nozick has argued pretty well. But I guess that's for another thread.
Aloysius Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1354001058' post='2517577'] I am willing to accept that distributism is at least acceptable for a Catholic, but you will not even afford me the same latitude. Makes me want to flip tables in frustration. (┛◉Д◉)┛彡┻â”â”» Well when I establish my neo-feudal paleolibertarian utopia, I promise not to have you exiled. Even though I know I cannot expect the same courtesy from you. [/quote] I won't exile you mate, but I also won't let you become a tycoon. sorry bro, u mad? [quote name='the171' timestamp='1354001121' post='2517578'] Distributism is Capitalism with a heart. ahhahahahhaa [/quote] I am relatively okay with this characterization, as Chesterton said, the problem of Capitalism is not too many capitalists, but too few. it's certainly a bit more than that, but it would all depend on your definition of capitalism. [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1354001053' post='2517576'] You misspelled socialism. BAZINGA! In all seriousness, I don't see how it's really other than a basically democratic socialist movement put into Catholic language. But my reading of it was pretty quick. [/quote] It is altogether much more radical than that, but also much more opposed to socialism it's hard to pin down for those who are too used to the usual binaries. there are of course overlaps in everything, but I don't think it's quite fair to characterize it as being any kind of socialism, is is very much opposed to socialism actually.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1354001247' post='2517581'] Why not just describe yourself as an extreme libertarian rather than trying to morph the traditional meaning of 'anarchism' and 'capitalism'? That's not intended to be a sleight. I'm also not convinced that in the socio-economic system you and Winchester adhere too that monopoly would be prevented from developing as I think Nozick has argued pretty well. But I guess that's for another thread. [/quote] I have not described myself as an anarcho-capitalist for some time now. I have indicated on a couple occasions that it is "close enough", but I generally also say that I do not personally use the label. I am currently avoiding using the anarchist label for myself until I have had a chance to study the foundations of philosophical anarchism so that I can piece together a coherent argument one way or the other. ETA: Are we not Facebook friends again? You could have known all that just by looking at my profile. [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1354001635' post='2517584'] I won't exile you mate, but I also won't let you become a tycoon. sorry bro, u mad? [/quote] So mad. You should let me enjoy the fruits of my moral labour. [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1354001635' post='2517584'] I am relatively okay with this characterization, as Chesterton said, the problem of Capitalism is not too many capitalists, but too few. it's certainly a bit more than that, but it would all depend on your definition of capitalism. [/quote] If that truly defines the distributist position, then I am fine with it too. Edited November 27, 2012 by Nihil Obstat
4588686 Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1354001635' post='2517584'] It is altogether much more radical than that, but also much more opposed to socialism it's hard to pin down for those who are too used to the usual binaries. there are of course overlaps in everything, but I don't think it's quite fair to characterize it as being any kind of socialism, is is very much opposed to socialism actually. [/quote] I know it says to be opposed to socialism. And it seems to be certainly divorced from the 'scientific socialism' of the time and the social elements of the Utopian programs but in terms of piratical policy programs it seems more or less exactly what you'd expect from a 19th century Dem Soc party. I agree that it is very much an anti-socialist party in terms of theory and vision of a normative political arrangement but practically I don't see any real difference other than, I would assume, some social positions
4588686 Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1354001837' post='2517585'] I have not described myself as an anarcho-capitalist for some time now. I have indicated on a couple occasions that it is "close enough", but I generally also say that I do not personally use the label. I am currently avoiding using the anarchist label for myself until I have had a chance to study the foundations of philosophical anarchism so that I can piece together a coherent argument one way or the other. ETA: Are we not Facebook friends again? You could have known all that just by looking at my profile. [/quote] You keep trying to get people to look at your facebook page. I suspect some sort of trap.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1354002183' post='2517589'] You keep trying to get people to look at your facebook page. I suspect some sort of trap. [/quote] [img]http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-0xToZLlI3Eo/Tgx1Bj9m9sI/AAAAAAAAI78/AyEFs0OkJkw/s1600/chris_hansen.gif[/img] Why don't you take a seat right over there?
Aloysius Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 (edited) He's actually Chris Hansen from Dateline NBC. o snap Nihil beat me to the punch. Edited November 27, 2012 by Aloysius
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now