Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1354051005' post='2517853']


St. Anselm actually had two arguments. Kant unarguably destroyed the first but some people believe that the second may be logically consistent. Kurt Godel attempted to reproduce a proof of the ontological argument and you can read his notes. His argument is consistent but his axioms were considered shaky

I'd recommend you look at some of Plantinga's and Norman Malcolm's stuff.
[/quote]

I don't really buy the ontological argument. Aquinas's Summa Contra Gentiles goes basically showed me all I need about it. I think the argument from contingency has a lot of merits (though it really is not definitive), because the alternative is an infinite set of contingent entities giving rise to each other, and as as Duns pointed out, even an infinite set would need some kind of explaination outside itself. But in the end, as I have said, one might posit natural law (though not the universe itself, which is obviously contingent in its parts) as a non-contingent entity. So there is room for doubt.

I have read Norman Malcom's stuff on Wittgenstein - I was unaware he was a Christian. I have not read Plantigina, though this is in part because I am a little embarressed about his connections to the Discovery Institute, which even if its goals had some merit, set out to do them in an underhanded, sneaky way that I don't like.

@Mark

I appreciate your position, but I really really really don't want this to turn into an Christianity vs Atheism thread. I have trod that road too long. I do think, at the very least, Agnosticism, and I mean genuine Agnosticism not just saying you can't know as a cop out, has some merits. And while I do recognize idea that, even if its not true, Christianity can give one a sense of well being and purpose, but I don't think that alone is enough reason to believe in it.

But like I said, I am feeling better about the issue now that I have taken a moment to discuss it a bit.

Posted (edited)

@Hasan

Now that I read it, I think what you were saying about what is permitted being arbitrary with or without God, because if goodness is just whatever God says, it may as well be arbitrary. But I don't think that's right. I don't really know how to explain it, but I think Aquinas says, for God, unlike for man, his existence and his essence are one and the same. So it is not that whatever arbitrary thing God decrees is right, because those decrees are based on his essence, which is Love. I am probably explaining it wrong though, and maybe you could poke a lot of holes into this, but that I just my thought. I wasn't even really talking about doing good or bad in the first place, but the idea that, without God, there is no ultimate meaning behind our actions, good, bad, or indifferent. Or at least that is my thought.

One other thing is, I really don't want to worry about philosophy any more (even though I contradict that in this very post). I have read so much of it on the issue it makes my brain hurt. Really, if people who read this prayed for me, I think that is the most I could ask for.

Edited by Kevin
Posted

One (very strange) man's statement. Take it for what it's worth. Ignore the last couple of sentences.

Leonard Cohen reciting "God Is Alive, Magic Is Afoot"

[url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3enVT53yDLM&feature=related"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3enVT53yDLM&feature=related[/url]

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Hi Kevin, thanks for sharing. I'd like to reply to a few things, starting with the fundamental question in your last paragraph:

[quote name='Kevin' timestamp='1354026539' post='2517665']

I just want to know, how can I deal with this doubt without just turning away from God?
[/quote]

I think your doubts stem from the fact that you know there is something deeper in both faith and science that would answer your questions, and you're not satisfied with the answers you have found so far. Maybe start by considering it more like a grace from God instead of a doubt within yourself? It would make sense that what you consider a doubt is actually a grace if it returned when you started going to Mass again.

From there, I think most of the specific issues you state would start coming into focus if you look at Creationism through a different lens. Have you read Dei Verbum or some good books about Scripture and how the Church interprets it? (I don't know any offhand, but I'm sure people have suggestions)

 

Below is my take on the specific issues you mentioned, taking into account what I know through both the Church and science. The basic theme is science answers the How? questions and the Church answers the Why? questions.

 

The fossil record and evolution? Scripture reveals who is our Creator and our purpose for living. Science reveals how we were created. I believe God created us in His image, male and female, to love Him and love one another, and that evolution (Big Bang, dinosaurs, fossils, monkeys, etc.) were the method through which God eventually made Adam and Eve and implanted a human soul within them. You see, science can say we evolved from a monkey, and Scripture never contradicts that. Rather, it teaches that we have a soul and a dignity given by God, which gives us a purpose and resposibilty over all of Creation.

Thus, the Bible doesn't give any indication of evolution because science is outside it's scope. Genesis serves a more philosophical purpose. The events are true, but it isn't a science or history textbook, and obviously doesn't make sense when we read it that way. But it does make sense when we read it to learn who we are and why we exist.

Regarding other religions, Catholicism does not consider them man-made inventions to be tossed out like an atheist would. The Church recognizes that behind every faith and religion is a search for God and Truth. So there is something good in every belief (even atheism, in its acknowledgement that only one Truth exists). The full Truth is found in the Catholic Church. Believing this frees us to recognize parts of the Truth found elsewhere, and to believe that God's Love is indeed available to all through whatever is good, true, and beautiful in their life.

"Why did all humanity save the Jews forget where they had come from?" The Jews forgot countless times too. The only one who remembered was God, who revealed Himself to the Jews and promised to send a Savior through them (even in spite of themselves). Of course, God sent a Savior for all people - Jews and Gentiles.

And in the afterlife, there is no time, so "trillions and trillions of years" is really a misnomer. We will simply "be" with God. I've always imagined it like an immense castle with countless rooms, intricate passages, towers, and caverns... surrounded by a city stretching as far as the eye can see... all to explore and enjoy like any of those brief moments in our lives that we wished could last forever -- and that wish comes true. If you haven't been in love, read some good love poetry. Even those who know they will die someday dare to speak of loving each other forever. That's a foretaste of heaven.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Hi, I've struggled with doubt about the existence of God too. It sort of went away later on as I prayed and got to know Him more. But sometimes temptations and doubts stay, maybe sometimes it's a trial... you can increase your faith through this by believing in God despite the doubts you feel :) One thing that I heard that I found very useful, is that with temptations against faith or purity, never battle them directly, that would tend to increase them.. it's just how it works for some reason. Instead, try to run from them. Don't dwell on them... maybe you've been dwelling on them a lot. I know you maybe want to, just to figure things out. But when we have all this doubt, it's like something pressing down on us, there is *no* clarity. How can we figure anything out without finding clarity first? For this we need to find God... make sure you don't consent to the doubts, confess all your sins, receive the Sacraments (without consenting to the doubts: that is important), pray... the more we pray, the better it would get, eventually. Maybe not at first, but keep praying. Pray the Rosary... go to Eucharistic Adoration, or just visit the church when it's open and pray by the Tabernacle, if your church doesn't have Adoration... use Sacramentals, holy water... the Miraculous Medal :) it was just the feast of the Miraculous Medal. Read the Bible, books by the Saints, things to help you. Don't dwell on these arguments until you find clarity first, in your mind. This clarity would come from God. Try to pray because it's really hard without prayer.

 

To address some of your concerns...I'm not sure if my reply would be helpful, but I recommend praying for grace so that God could help you with your doubts.

 

God knows how He created the world. The scientists have been trying to figure it out for centuries. Maybe leave this to God, because He knows. Remember science is constantly evolving... pun intended :) we don't know everything. Science is based on what we can observe.. but what are the methods we use to observe? what are we observing? is everything observable? has everything that could help lead us to the right understanding been found? I mean - we know God exists because He revealed this to us... and it is something reasonable to believe, not unreasonable. But science can't disprove the existence of God because it deals with creation that we can see, and God is above this, by the very reason that He is the Creator.

 

Leaving things to God is not filling in things in the gaps in the way the atheists say... it's being humble to acknowledge that we dont' in fact know everything.

 

As for other religions, it's complicated... I mean, some (the idea that there is God,for example) is true... some is not... we know that Christianity has been revealed and is fully true. The reason other religions didn't get it fully is because we need God to reveal it to us, we cant just know it by ourselves... that's my understanding... and clearly with our ignorance, limitations, and also original sin, and lack of knowledge about the divine, things do get skewed without God intervening somehow. So, He intervened. Remember that since the fall, people don't automatically live in union with God: so there is much to overcome for us, to know the truth, because to find it we need to find God... since He is Truth. All truth comes from Him. Since we are away from Him, He has brought Himself and Truth to us, in His Son. He who knows the Son, knows the Father.

 

Regarding Heaven being frightening because it lasts forever... the Saints who experienced even a bit of God's love, were so overcome by it, they wanted it to last forever. I think once we experience God, we would never want to leave His presence :) and we'll have no sin, so we wouldn't have anything blocking us from Him or experiencing His Presence in the truest way. Here on earth, we have the Eucharist, and  we need to receive Him with trust and in a state of grace... Feelings regarding our faith: that is a gift... it's not something we can make in ourselves. God asks of our good will :) remember faith is a choice.

 

Regarding Heaven and the experience of time, that is not something I know about, but I'm sure whatever it is, it would be great because it would be a place of great joy :) once a soul gets there, I don't think this issue is something to worry about. Jesus said, He goes to prepare a place for us... so the gift from God to be with Him, is something that He thought of knowing how He created us... we have nothing to fear with God :) the only thing to fear is offending Him, out of love. Not His plan for us. I don't think we should fear His plans for our eternity because they are good, and God is good.

 

I hope it doesn't seem like I'm trying to brush away your problems or minimize them. Not at all... I know what it's like to struggle with terrible doubts, and thoughts that dont seem to leave. It's painful and very confusing... I know how painful it must be because I've gone through similar things too. But - I think the answer is found not in trying to figure it out while in this state of confusion... it is trying to pray and learning to trust God, so He can give you clarity and fill your mind with light. You need God's light... dont' rely simply on your reason, because right now you are going through confusion... resist the idea to leave God or to give up. DON'T focus or dwell on these thoughts, but run from them, until you find more clarity and then ask God to help you with them. This is what I find helpful. It might take time to figure it out, and it might take time to feel like you've 'found' God, but He is right there now... He is not far away. Try to think of it like that... God is right NOW there with you, wherever you are... He also knows everything that you are going through... when we doubt, we close ourselves to God so it's really hard to feel any help from Him. When we trust, we open ourselves up and receive more graces. Try to trust, simply in your will, - to start to come closer to Him. If you can't make yourself will this, try as much as you can, without giving up, and then ask God to take you the rest of the way, and then just surrender to Him. Again it might take a bit of time to figure out how to do this, - we are always learning :) but focus on your will, and try to trust not starting in your feelings, but starting in your decision to at least try to trust. Then make the very best attempt you can, and then ask God to help you with the rest, then keep intending to trust Him, and wait. I'm not trying to figure out a technique, lol, but just a way to escape focusing on your doubts for a time. Try focusing on your will instead, while asking God to help you reach out to Him, or even to want to reach out to Him, if that is difficult. If it's hard to think of God being there with you, try to maybe imagine this first, perhaps... but eventually, it would not be imagining anymore, you might see when it would just become obvious. It would be like something you 'know', not even just believe intellectually. But it's very important to not dwell on doubts. I know someone might say, - not here but let's say an atheist  in a hypothetical scenario - if you keep on putting away thoughts that contradict your faith, of course you would just keep on believing... but the reality is that aren't these thoughts very intrusive? don't they feel heavy, in a way, like something is weighing on your mind, and just adding confusion? If you keep dwelling on them, you'll just become more entangled in them. It's really a lot like being entangled in a web, and the more you struggle with them directly, the more tangled you'll get. Rather, run from them, ignore them, and eventually with prayer you can have more clarity to return to the intellectual questions that are bothering you, but without all the confusion weighing down on you :) so see you are not trying to escape difficult questions, you are trying to find clarity in your mind first before thinking about them. It's like trying to wake up fully before thinking about a difficult subject, like calculus. It's hard to do calculus half asleep ;) hope my analogy makes sense.

 

God bless you :)

 

 






 

 

 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

You might also be interested in reading about St Therese, because she had a great trial where she lost all feeling of faith, and it became only a blind sort of choice to her... she persevered though and is now a Saint :) she also had tuberculosis during the time so it must have been so difficult... have you read her book "Story of a Soul"? :)

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

 

 

And in the afterlife, there is no time, so "trillions and trillions of years" is really a misnomer. We will simply "be" with God. I've always imagined it like an immense castle with countless rooms, intricate passages, towers, and caverns... surrounded by a city stretching as far as the eye can see... all to explore and enjoy like any of those brief moments in our lives that we wished could last forever -- and that wish comes true. If you haven't been in love, read some good love poetry. Even those who know they will die someday dare to speak of loving each other forever. That's a foretaste of heaven

 

 

 

Thank you for you responses. I would like to say that I found your answers totally compelling, but in a way, I it seems hard to take the Bible in only a metaphorical sense. God might have set the world into motion knowing life would evolve, but the Fall has to be something literal, as does the Covenant. But like I said, these are not really "questions" I have - I already know what the response is, I just worry that response might be wrong.

 

Also, I have actually read so much love poetry, and in a way, I've sickened of it. All I feel is, "I wonder how it would be to feel a positive emotion so intensely, because I sure don't."

 

And yes, I already was aware that it wasn't "trillions and trillions of years", as I said in the post, because that would be absurd. The "just being with God" is frightening to me. An absolute state of being without time, it seems to me very similar to the idea of not existing at all, just reversed, and it is the absoluteness that scares me.

 

@Mary

 

Thank you for your response. The problem is, if I knew how to not think about it, I wouldn't be here in the first place. Also, while I want to believe what you say, all religions would say "we know that our religion has been revealed and is fully true." I think Christianity is the right one if any are right, but the sometimes I am not sure if any actually are right.

Edited by Kevin
MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Just a comment about the fall... it's doctrine actually that Adam and Eve were real people and really fell, and that we all descend from them. My understanding is that we should not take this metaphorically. As for how this fits into science, I think scientists are trying to construct a theory based on what they saw, - it does not account for all they saw, much less for all that can be seen, and some things cannot be seen or found. Also remember that nature was affected by the fall so it's hard to talk about science and the Garden of Eden I think since - science deals with what can be observed and understood today.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

"Thank you for your response. The problem is, if I knew how to not think about it, I wouldn't be here in the first place."

 

Well I think its all about what you choose...right when you get the thoughts, just direct your mind to something else like the Rosary, force your mind away from it. Much like we do with other things like temptations to anger, impure thoughts, jealousy, ETC.

 

"Also, while I want to believe what you say, all religions would say "we know that our religion has been revealed and is fully true." I think Christianity is the right one if any are right, but the sometimes I am not sure if any actually are right."

 

The difference with Christianity I think is that our religion has specific historical events to back it up... I mean, it's clear that Jesus Christ is a real person, He lived on earth, and then many of the disciples left Him during the Crucifixion but then somehow became more devoted to Him after His death... if He had not risen, why did they? The Bible says that many saw Him after He rose from the dead. While the Bible was written, these many were probably still alive and would have said something if it were not true. Also, some secular people complain about using the Bible in a way that gives is authority, but it's actually MORE reliable than other documents from the time. One reason is that it's from God, but since unbelievers would not agree, - there's something to maybe help them be more open to it: the Bible was written only a bit after Jesus' Resurrection and we have many early manuscripts. Other books during the time were written much later, sometimes hundreds of years after their events, and have much fewer manuscripts, yet they are completely accepted by the secular world. Why is that? If we assume the miraculous can't be true no matter what, we won't be open to evidence for it. The fact that the Bible deals with the miraculous does not disqualify it from being a true book, because there's nothing to suggest that miracles don't take place. It's only an assumption that people might have if they don't believe. So if we look at it without assumptions that it "cant' be true", we see it's actually more reliable than other documents :) as for the differences in the Gospels, etc, that shows different sides of the event, also on a more basic non theological level it shows the Apostles didn't just copy from each other.

 

Also, there are so many miracles that have happened during these 2000 years and still happen today. It's best to believe without need for evidence, but this can help if someone is struggling. For example, http://www.miraclerosarymission.org/lanciano.html  http://www.therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/lanciano.html

 

But I think the best way to gain more faith is probably through prayer :) it's something that comes from God... we need to be made stronger through prayer first, then think about all these things carefully, with Him, prayerfully. This is just my understanding, but maybe you can see if it might work for you, or if not, I hope that you find something that does :)

 

God bless :)

Posted

Mary, regardless of some of the things I disagree with you about, I agree that what I need to do is pray, and I am trying to do that more. Thank you for your kind response.

theculturewarrior
Posted

Evolution has actually deepened my faith and my relationship with God.  I am a Christian Darwinist.

 

My thoughts on the matter are as such:  Man's relationship with God is learned through his understanding of himself and through observations of his environment.  The most astute and accurate observations of our environment and our cognition and behavior come from science.  When I came to this conclusion, I realized that every scientific fact has a theological significance.  It is a very profound turning point in my faith.

 

Wrestling with doubt is not a sin.  Feelings are not sins.  I hope that you do not feel guilty for having doubts.  Maybe it is just an instinctive part of your psychology that is telling you that you need to dig deeper to strengthen your faith.  There are two things in life that are never blind.  They are faith and love.

theculturewarrior
Posted

I want to add one last thing.  I started off in life as an atheist.  The Church has an answer.  I would not be Catholic today if this were not so.

Posted

Kevin, have you read "Come Be My Light" by Bl. Teresa of Calcutta?

Posted

 There are two things in life that are never blind.  They are faith and love.

 

I would tend to disagree.  Those are two things that require complete commitment, which enables you dismiss or not consider questions and doubts.  Very interesting commentary from John Henry Newman.  http://www.newmanreader.org/works/discourses/discourse11.html

Posted (edited)

Kevin, have you read "Come Be My Light" by Bl. Teresa of Calcutta?

 

I have not not.

 

Truth be told, I am thinking of picking up The Moviegoer by Walker Percy (a great Catholic novelist) since I think that book's main character and I share some similar traits.

 

@theculturewarrior

 

Rationally, I know I shouldn't feel guilty. But on a subconscious level, I think that yes, I do feel a bit so.

Edited by Kevin
Posted

I have not not.

 

Truth be told, I am thinking of picking up The Moviegoer by Walker Percy (a great Catholic novelist) since I think that book's main character and I share some similar traits.

 

The thing that really touched me about that book was in being able to understand Mother Teresa's struggle with faith. For most of her life, she felt almost nothing. She went from personal, mystical experience with God, to feeling that He had abandoned her. But she knew that faith was more than feeling, so even though she did not feel God, she still had faith. How does that happen? How does one have faith, even when there is such an abyss in their soul that they can hardly even pray?

The reason is that faith does not come from us, and it is not something that we 'do'. It is a gift which we can simply respond to, however we are able. So even when you do not feel it, you can still live it. 

Even that darkness is a gift, because we can use it to understand that we love God not for how it comforts us, but simply as the only possible response to such an incomprehensible, radical love for us.

theculturewarrior
Posted (edited)

I would tend to disagree.  Those are two things that require complete commitment, which enables you dismiss or not consider questions and doubts.  Very interesting commentary from John Henry Newman.  http://www.newmanreader.org/works/discourses/discourse11.html

 

It requires complete commitment, agreed, but it does not require the Christian to suspend belief.  It does not require you to dismiss questions about God, although everyone, Christians, atheists, etc. are able to do that.  God gave us freedom so that we can choose to love him.  He gave us faith and reason so that we can know him.  I love my wife very much, but that is because I know who she is.  I trust her fidelity, because I see the world in the light of reason and faith.  It is the same in my relationship with God, although hidden behind the mystery of faith.  I have never stopped looking for answers, and the Church has always provided them.

Edited by theculturewarrior
theculturewarrior
Posted (edited)

One more thing:

 

I drifted between atheism and agnosticism when I was younger.  I think that if reason is your only instrument, true agnosticism is the only logical outcome.  I encourage everyone to take a good look at the history of philosophy, from Descartes to present.  The deeper is delved into those philosophies, the more I realized that reason alone is ineffective.  It is difficult and dizzying to know any basic thing just by testing it with reason.  I take all arguments for and against the existence of God with a grain of salt for that reason.  This is where I am at today:  The truth is many things, but it is not reductive.  It is not formulaic.  Western thought has been damaged by the search for a simple reductive formula.  Instead of that, I will use everything I have to know God, to enjoy my life, to create satisfying social bonds, and to marvel at the Universe.  Logic is just a small part of that, but truth is my foundation.

Edited by theculturewarrior
Posted

One more thing:

 

I drifted between atheism and agnosticism when I was younger.  I think that if reason is your only instrument, true agnosticism is the only logical outcome.  I encourage everyone to take a good look at the history of philosophy, from Descartes to present.  The deeper is delved into those philosophies, the more I realized that reason alone is ineffective.  It is difficult and dizzying to know any basic thing just by testing it with reason.  I take all arguments for and against the existence of God with a grain of salt for that reason.  This is where I am at today:  The truth is many things, but it is not reductive.  It is not formulaic.  Western thought has been damaged by the search for a simple reductive formula.  Instead of that, I will use everything I have to know God, to enjoy my life, to create satisfying social bonds, and to marvel at the Universe.  Logic is just a small part of that, but truth is my foundation.

 

I agree about Agnosticism being the end result. I think the end result of most analytical philosophy is just that. But I am trying to have some faith.

 

@Nihil Obsat

 

I appreciate that. I just, er, tend to prefer literary considerations of these themes to straightforward religious writing. In fact, I probably would have lost my faith back in college if not for the works of Flannery O'Connor.

Posted


 

@Nihil Obsat

 

I appreciate that. I just, er, tend to prefer literary considerations of these themes to straightforward religious writing. In fact, I probably would have lost my faith back in college if not for the works of Flannery O'Connor.

 

Usually I am the same way. Come Be My Light is one of the very few religious books I have truly enjoyed that was not straight up theology. There is only a very small handful of books that fall into that category for me.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...