Era Might Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 (edited) If you aren't afraid of the fact that all the grandness and beauty in the world is going to one day be utterly snatched away from you, along with your identity, your mind, and everything else, I can only say I don't understand your way of thinking. I didn't say I wasn't afraid of it, only that if that is indeed that case, then it does not follow that one cannot have peace or meaning in life. The world went on without me for a long time before I was ever born, and if it were to go on without me after I die, there are any number of ways one could find meaning in that. "I sadly smiling remember that the flower fades to make fruit, the fruit rots to make earth. Out of the mother; and through the spring exultances, ripeness and decadence; and home to the mother. You making haste haste on decay: not blameworthy; life is good, be it stubbornly long or suddenly A mortal splendor: meteors are not needed less than mountains:" --Robinson Jeffers, "Shine Perishing Republic" Edited December 1, 2012 by Era Might
Era Might Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 I don't mean to sound harsh, but this kind of argument for secularism or agnosticism is not one of the things that bothers me about the faith. Also, even if there is no god, one can still appreciate belief in the concept of god as a personification of ideas and values, and religion as communal attempts to create meaning.
Kevin Posted December 1, 2012 Author Posted December 1, 2012 I didn't say I wasn't afraid of it, only that if that is indeed that case, then it does not follow that one cannot have peace or meaning in life. The world went on without me for a long time before I was ever born, and if it were to go on without me after I die, there are any number of ways one could find meaning in that. "I sadly smiling remember that the flower fades to make fruit, the fruit rots to make earth. Out of the mother; and through the spring exultances, ripeness and decadence; and home to the mother. You making haste haste on decay: not blameworthy; life is good, be it stubbornly long or suddenly A mortal splendor: meteors are not needed less than mountains:" --Robinson Jeffers, "Shine Perishing Republic" If you think that is "meaning" then we simply have irreconcilable worldviews. The idea of meaning without an ultimate referent seems to me a mere case of self-deception, as Sartre says here. There is no room in such a world for peace or meaning. I would also point out how that poem (which as a poetry MFA I'm pretty familiar with) ends: But for my children, I would have them keep their distance from the thickening center; corruption Never has been compulsory, when the cities lie at the monster’s feet there are left the mountains. And boys, be in nothing so moderate as in love of man, a clever servant, insufferable master. There is the trap that catches noblest spirits, that caught—they say—God, when he walked on earth.
Era Might Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 (edited) If you think that is "meaning" then we simply have irreconcilable worldviews. The idea of meaning without an ultimate referent seems to me a mere case of self-deception, as Sartre says here. There is no room in such a world for peace or meaning. Not sure what you mean by "ultimate referent" but reality is an "ultimate referent." Accepting the way things are is a referent, even if one does not know why or what. The buddha's nirvana is an "ultimate referent." I wasn't trying to reconcile any worldviews, simply challenging the assertion that without the existence of your conception of a personal god, one cannot find meaning in life. I would also point out how that poem (which as a poetry MFA I'm pretty familiar with) ends: But for my children, I would have them keep their distance from the thickening center; corruption Never has been compulsory, when the cities lie at the monster’s feet there are left the mountains. And boys, be in nothing so moderate as in love of man, a clever servant, insufferable master. There is the trap that catches noblest spirits, that caught—they say—God, when he walked on earth. Ok? Jeffers mentions the word god, though I'm not sure how that changes the point I was making (and, by the by, I find it interesting how he slips in that "they say"). I guess I'm not sure exactly what you are struggling with or doubting. You seem to believe pretty firmly that reality requires an "ultimate referent" which you identify with a personal god who judges and and makes everything right at the end of time. If you accept that there is meaning in life, and you define meaning in a personal god, then it seems that your conception of reality makes the existence of god pretty much a given? Or am I missing something? Edited December 1, 2012 by Era Might
Kevin Posted December 1, 2012 Author Posted December 1, 2012 (edited) Not sure what you mean by "ultimate referent" but reality is an "ultimate referent." Accepting the way things are is a referent, even if one does not know why or what. The buddha's nirvana is an "ultimate referent." I wasn't trying to reconcile any worldviews, simply challenging the assertion that without the existence of your conception of a personal god, one cannot find meaning in life. Ok? Jeffers mentions the word god, though I'm not sure how that changes the point I was making (and, by the by, I find it interesting how he slips in that "they say"). I guess I'm not sure exactly what you are struggling with or doubting. You seem to believe pretty firmly that reality requires an "ultimate referent" which you identify with a personal god who judges and and makes everything right at the end of time. If you accept that there is meaning in life, and you define meaning in a personal god, then it seems that your conception of reality makes the existence of god pretty much a given? Or am I missing something? You say, "accepting the way things are" but that's the problem - you nor I don't know with any certainty the way things are. What we call "reality" is just an illusion based on our perceptions in a world without an ultimate metaphysical reality, and a world without God is a world without the possibility of a such a metaphysical reality. Jeffers belief system is anti-humanist. He doesn't believe we can just live in the same comfortable way as before if the traditional idea of God. Or to use Sartre again: And when we speak of “abandonment†– a favorite word of Heidegger – we only mean to say that God does not exist, and that it is necessary to draw the consequences of his absence right to the end. The existentialist is strongly opposed to a certain type of secular moralism which seeks to suppress God at the least possible expense. Towards 1880, when the French professors endeavoured to formulate a secular morality, they said something like this: God is a useless and costly hypothesis, so we will do without it. However, if we are to have morality, a society and a law-abiding world, it is essential that certain values should be taken seriously; they must have an a priori existence ascribed to them. It must be considered obligatory a priori to be honest, not to lie, not to beat one’s wife, to bring up children and so forth; so we are going to do a little work on this subject, which will enable us to show that these values exist all the same, inscribed in an intelligible heaven although, of course, there is no God. In other words – and this is, I believe, the purport of all that we in France call radicalism – nothing will be changed if God does not exist; we shall rediscover the same norms of honesty, progress and humanity, and we shall have disposed of God as an out-of-date hypothesis which will die away quietly of itself. The existentialist, on the contrary, finds it extremely embarrassing that God does not exist, for there disappears with Him all possibility of finding values in an intelligible heaven. There can no longer be any good a priori, since there is no infinite and perfect consciousness to think it. It is nowhere written that “the good†exists, that one must be honest or must not lie, since we are now upon the plane where there are only men. Dostoevsky once wrote: “If God did not exist, everything would be permittedâ€; and that, for existentialism, is the starting point. Everything is indeed permitted if God does not exist, and man is in consequence forlorn, for he cannot find anything to depend upon either within or outside himself. He discovers forthwith, that he is without excuse. For if indeed existence precedes essence, one will never be able to explain one’s action by reference to a given and specific human nature; in other words, there is no determinism – man is free, man is freedom. Nor, on the other hand, if God does not exist, are we provided with any values or commands that could legitimise our behaviour. Thus we have neither behind us, nor before us in a luminous realm of values, any means of justification or excuse. – We are left alone, without excuse. That is what I mean when I say that man is condemned to be free. Condemned, because he did not create himself, yet is nevertheless at liberty, and from the moment that he is thrown into this world he is responsible for everything he does. The existentialist does not believe in the power of passion. He will never regard a grand passion as a destructive torrent upon which a man is swept into certain actions as by fate, and which, therefore, is an excuse for them. He thinks that man is responsible for his passion. Neither will an existentialist think that a man can find help through some sign being vouchsafed upon earth for his orientation: for he thinks that the man himself interprets the sign as he chooses. He thinks that every man, without any support or help whatever, is condemned at every instant to invent man. As Ponge has written in a very fine article, “Man is the future of man.†That is exactly true. Only, if one took this to mean that the future is laid up in Heaven, that God knows what it is, it would be false, for then it would no longer even be a future. If, however, it means that, whatever man may now appear to be, there is a future to be fashioned, a virgin future that awaits him – then it is a true saying. But in the present one is forsaken. Just to qualify - Sartre seems to imply Divine Command theory (that the arbitrary will of God is in the old sense goodness) but in the old model the God of Abraham and the God of Plato and Aristotle are the same, so God's will is not arbitrary but the manifestation of Love. I think that, under your model, there is no possibility of metaphysical truth, and that is what I mean when I say you cannot construct "meaning" because to me meaning is synonymous with telos in the Aristotelian sense. The problem with Sartre is doesn't really go far enough - though he is right in his essentials, he still in the end tries to reconstruct an excuse for life to go on at all just like those he criticizes. What I doubt are simply matters of fact, i.e. the Resurrection, the Fall, etc. I don't feel I know enough to even make a probabilistic evaluation of the veracity of these things, so I can only go with what seems best to me without knowing if I am right. Also, while I appreciate your taking the time to respond, I came to this site to get away from the discourses of secularism and agnosticism and engage with people who share the faith I feel is weak in me. So I would rather not continue this debate. If you what you believe makes you feel good, all the more power to you, but it will not work for me. Edited December 1, 2012 by Kevin
Lilllabettt Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 Faith is something that requires doubt. Uncertainty and Faith will both wash away on the shores of eternity ... until then, those who would have the one must contend with the other. You have gotten some interesting replies. But one thing I didn't see mentioned ... it's possible that you are meant to use this experience to develop your "negative capability" - your capacity to just live and be with uncertainty and doubt, without thrashing about desperately for "answers" or "proof." Many, many important people have gone through this experience. Abraham Lincoln, Shakespeare come to mind. They are truth seekers, they look and look, they learn, they grow in knowledge, and then they hit a wall. They struggle for awhile, and then they "surrender" and learn to be patient with not knowing, with ... waiting. It's inside this space that some of the most brilliant streaks of creativity and innovation happen. Some people say that well developed negative capability is what gives Barack Obama his creativity as a politician. If you are a person who would always rather take the "red pill" (Matrix reference!!!) this can be such a painful experience, and the reality is, you may or may not get "over" it over the course of your life ... but if this is what it is happening to you, maybe it will be helpful to recognize it and see that it has its purpose ...
Era Might Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 (edited) Just to qualify - Sartre seems to imply Divine Command theory (that the arbitrary will of God is in the old sense goodness) but in the old model the God of Abraham and the God of Plato and Aristotle are the same, so God's will is not arbitrary but the manifestation of Love. I think that, under your model, there is no possibility of metaphysical truth, and that is what I mean when I say you cannot construct "meaning" because to me meaning is synonymous with telos in the Aristotelian sense. Yes, I have something of the post-modernist in me, in the sense that I believe meaning is usually constructed, though I am not anti-religion, and still consider myself a Christian of the agnostic sort. I had my own thread in the debate table about a month ago called "the non-existence of God"...you might find some more answers from others that are helpful. Here's the link: http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/124369-the-non-existence-of-god/ Edited December 1, 2012 by Era Might
Era Might Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 (edited) Oh, Kevin, if you like Sartre you have to read Simone Weil. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simone_Weil Edited December 1, 2012 by Era Might
Kevin Posted December 1, 2012 Author Posted December 1, 2012 (edited) Yes, I have something of the post-modernist in me, in the sense that I believe meaning is usually constructed, though I am not anti-religion, and still consider myself a Christian of the agnostic sort. I had my own thread in the debate table about a month ago called "the non-existence of God"...you might find some more answers from others that are helpful. Here's the link: http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/124369-the-non-existence-of-god/ Yes, reading your thread, I would say that you are just the sort of person I am trying to get away from (not in a personal way I mean, because you seem like a very nice person) by coming here because I am surrounded by people like you in my real life. I don't think I can agree with almost anything you say at all, so I think we will just have to agree to disagree. Thank you for the recommendation, but I feel I need to get through Kierkegaard before I move to other existentialists. Edited December 1, 2012 by Kevin
Freedom Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 I meant that as in all humanity. It was not meant as an insult, and I don't know how you interpreted it as such. I am sorry if I have offended you unintentionally though. But I feel like you are being really unfair to me. I want to believe and in mostly I do, I just have some doubts, and also a history of depression and anxiety. I'm sorry you feel that I was being unfair to you. I stated facts about the Shroud of Turin. When I said that quote about believers and unbelievers, I said this because I can't help you, to pass it off to other Phatmassers who can. Please do not address me on this thread of "Doubt" again.
Maggyie Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 I'm sorry you feel that I was being unfair to you. I stated facts about the Shroud of Turin. When I said that quote about believers and unbelievers, I said this because I can't help you, to pass it off to other Phatmassers who can. Please do not address me on this thread of "Doubt" again. Personally I think the Shroud of Turin is a fake. It is still a pious and holy object but it's not Jesus' face, I don't think. God's existence does not depend on the miraculous - to me the proof that God exists is the evidence His grace in my life.
Freedom Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 Personally I think the Shroud of Turin is a fake. It is still a pious and holy object but it's not Jesus' face, I don't think. The Shroud of Turin is not fake.
Freedom Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 Scientists link the Shroud's images to a resurrection event. Ray Rogers: "The only way that such an idea can be understood within the known laws of nature is as matter converting to energy. This is expressed by Einstein's celebrated e=mc2 equation of equivalence. And understood that way, conversion of the matter in a human body to energy (what else) would produce energy equivalent to a nuclear explosion several thousand times as great as the bomb dropped on Hiroshima." !!!! Read more, click below.. http://www.shroudstory.com/faq-miracle.htm Front and back
Freedom Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 That was a bad link... In a stunning announcement, scientists say the Shroud of Turin, the alleged burial robe of Jesus Christ, is most likely authentic. Why it would be 'impossible' to fake
Maggyie Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 Scientists link the Shroud's images to a resurrection event. This is off topic but there are many eminent historians who argue on the contrary. I believe the shroud was carbon dated to the 1200s. Regardless, it is certainly an amazing piece of art. And regardless it's authenticity doesn't affect whether Jesus actually rose from the dead.
4588686 Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 You say, "accepting the way things are" but that's the problem - you nor I don't know with any certainty the way things are. What we call "reality" is just an illusion based on our perceptions in a world without an ultimate metaphysical reality, and a world without God is a world without the possibility of a such a metaphysical reality. Jeffers belief system is anti-humanist. He doesn't believe we can just live in the same comfortable way as before if the traditional idea of God. Or to use Sartre again: And when we speak of “abandonment†– a favorite word of Heidegger – we only mean to say that God does not exist, and that it is necessary to draw the consequences of his absence right to the end. The existentialist is strongly opposed to a certain type of secular moralism which seeks to suppress God at the least possible expense. Towards 1880, when the French professors endeavoured to formulate a secular morality, they said something like this: God is a useless and costly hypothesis, so we will do without it. However, if we are to have morality, a society and a law-abiding world, it is essential that certain values should be taken seriously; they must have an a priori existence ascribed to them. It must be considered obligatory a priori to be honest, not to lie, not to beat one’s wife, to bring up children and so forth; so we are going to do a little work on this subject, which will enable us to show that these values exist all the same, inscribed in an intelligible heaven although, of course, there is no God. In other words – and this is, I believe, the purport of all that we in France call radicalism – nothing will be changed if God does not exist; we shall rediscover the same norms of honesty, progress and humanity, and we shall have disposed of God as an out-of-date hypothesis which will die away quietly of itself. The existentialist, on the contrary, finds it extremely embarrassing that God does not exist, for there disappears with Him all possibility of finding values in an intelligible heaven. There can no longer be any good a priori, since there is no infinite and perfect consciousness to think it. It is nowhere written that “the good†exists, that one must be honest or must not lie, since we are now upon the plane where there are only men. Dostoevsky once wrote: “If God did not exist, everything would be permittedâ€; and that, for existentialism, is the starting point. Everything is indeed permitted if God does not exist, and man is in consequence forlorn, for he cannot find anything to depend upon either within or outside himself. He discovers forthwith, that he is without excuse. For if indeed existence precedes essence, one will never be able to explain one’s action by reference to a given and specific human nature; in other words, there is no determinism – man is free, man is freedom. Nor, on the other hand, if God does not exist, are we provided with any values or commands that could legitimise our behaviour. Thus we have neither behind us, nor before us in a luminous realm of values, any means of justification or excuse. – We are left alone, without excuse. That is what I mean when I say that man is condemned to be free. Condemned, because he did not create himself, yet is nevertheless at liberty, and from the moment that he is thrown into this world he is responsible for everything he does. The existentialist does not believe in the power of passion. He will never regard a grand passion as a destructive torrent upon which a man is swept into certain actions as by fate, and which, therefore, is an excuse for them. He thinks that man is responsible for his passion. Neither will an existentialist think that a man can find help through some sign being vouchsafed upon earth for his orientation: for he thinks that the man himself interprets the sign as he chooses. He thinks that every man, without any support or help whatever, is condemned at every instant to invent man. As Ponge has written in a very fine article, “Man is the future of man.†That is exactly true. Only, if one took this to mean that the future is laid up in Heaven, that God knows what it is, it would be false, for then it would no longer even be a future. If, however, it means that, whatever man may now appear to be, there is a future to be fashioned, a virgin future that awaits him – then it is a true saying. But in the present one is forsaken. Just to qualify - Sartre seems to imply Divine Command theory (that the arbitrary will of God is in the old sense goodness) but in the old model the God of Abraham and the God of Plato and Aristotle are the same, so God's will is not arbitrary but the manifestation of Love. I think that, under your model, there is no possibility of metaphysical truth, and that is what I mean when I say you cannot construct "meaning" because to me meaning is synonymous with telos in the Aristotelian sense. The problem with Sartre is doesn't really go far enough - though he is right in his essentials, he still in the end tries to reconstruct an excuse for life to go on at all just like those he criticizes. What I doubt are simply matters of fact, i.e. the Resurrection, the Fall, etc. I don't feel I know enough to even make a probabilistic evaluation of the veracity of these things, so I can only go with what seems best to me without knowing if I am right. Also, while I appreciate your taking the time to respond, I came to this site to get away from the discourses of secularism and agnosticism and engage with people who share the faith I feel is weak in me. So I would rather not continue this debate. If you what you believe makes you feel good, all the more power to you, but it will not work for me. Near the end of his life Hitchens made the interesting point that, no, Trotsky could not have saved the USSR and turned it into a genuinely humane system. The best he could hope to implement had he won the politburo power struggles was a more benign form of Stalinism. That is because, external realities being what they were, there was no way the revolution could be saved from the White Generals and Imperialist powers without things like some form of collectivism and disciplining of labor. The Soviet Union saved it's political reality but lost any distinctively socialistic (the absence of private property is not unique to socialism) features and became an authoritarian state like any other. Hitchens concluded by noting that the last chance that Trotsky had to save any moral legitimacy in the revolution was in 1905. Before WWI. History doesn't have any determined direction (sorry, Marxists) and teleology is just a very comforting myth. There isn't any meaning in a fixed sense with a God or without. If things are good because God wills them to be good then they are arbitrary and rape could be positively moral tomorrow, if God were to will it. If morality is determined by God's essence, his essence and will being the same, then it still pretty flimsy. God can't be any other way and therefore goodness is constant but that still seems pretty meaningless since sin and goodness to others is really only important because of it's relation to God, ultimately.
Freedom Posted December 1, 2012 Posted December 1, 2012 This is off topic but there are many eminent historians who argue on the contrary. I believe the shroud was carbon dated to the 1200s. Regardless, it is certainly an amazing piece of art. And regardless it's authenticity doesn't affect whether Jesus actually rose from the dead. An amazing piece of art work? Puulease! You are a misinformed person and unwilling to be informed. The Shroud has been examined for decades by the highest ranking scientists and was proclaimed authentic by all of them and the majority of them were atheists.
Kevin Posted December 1, 2012 Author Posted December 1, 2012 (edited) If morality is determined by God's essence, his essence and will being the same, then it still pretty flimsy. God can't be any other way and therefore goodness is constant but that still seems pretty meaningless since sin and goodness to others is really only important because of it's relation to God, ultimately. I'm not sure how it is flimsy. First, the idea that God "can't be any other way" puts God within the context of time - but God exists absolutely. Secondly, sin and goodness to others are not only important because of their relation to God, or at least to revelation. Goodness can be arrived at with the light of human reason, as seen in Plato and Aristotle. There is no "relation" in the first place because, again, God's goodness (essence) and his existence (being God) are the same thing. If you have determined teleology is wrong and that purpose is a myth, then I pity you your conclusion. At the very least, I feel if I drew such a conclusion at this point, it would be for the wrong reasons, so I will not do it. However, I really did not come here to debate theology. If you are trying to convince me of the incoherence of the idea of God's existence, you will not do it. Actually, I think I have gotten all I can out of this thread, so I will just leave it alone for awhile. Thank you to everyone who prayed for me. I will try to get in touch with a councilor, spiritual or otherwise. Edited December 2, 2012 by Kevin
Gabriela Posted December 2, 2012 Posted December 2, 2012 I haven't been through all the posts on this, so pardon me if someone else has already said this, but the only way to get faith is to ask God to give it to you. I learned the hard way (your way). I spent 31 years trying to rationalize my way to faith. It was quite tortuous. No matter how much I read, studied, argued, researched, and thought, I couldn't convince myself. I eventually got so desperate that I just went to church one day and begged God to give me faith. I told Him I'd harass Him for it until I die. That I'm not giving up this time. That I will not go away. I did that every day for several months, and then, suddenly, I realized I believed. Just a little. ;-) But it keeps growing (and I keep asking!). :-) What I learned from that experience is that faith is not generated out of reason. It exists just beyond reason. I imagine it like a ladder, on which the fourth rung, say, is reason, and the fifth rung is faith. I have to actually step off of the fourth rung in order to stand on the fifth one. So, you know, ask. (And be shameless about it, cuz otherwise He might not take you seriously!)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now