Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

so its mental illness why he did this ? so I should feel sorry for him ? Surely satan has mental illness. So I should feel sorry for him too. Heck if I look at it how you do mabey God will forgive satan too in the end and this suffering this earth has seen will all be 4 nothing.

Edited by Guest
Posted

Who said he was mentally ill? That sounds like speculation to me.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

if God is merciful to this guy in judgement I want nothing to do with that god...

 

You don't really mean that.  We believe in the possibility of salvation for everyone, through Christ's sacrifice. 

 

That being said, it's probably not the most tactful thing to talk about God having mercy for the perpetrator around people who are trying to grapple with this senseless tragedy.  

 

We all deal with these things differently, and we all have to keep this in mind.  I hope the last thing we want to do is fight over this particular tragedy.  

Posted

1. Nations are not charitable.

 

http://www.american.com/archive/2008/march-april-magazine-contents/a-nation-of-givers

[quote]Q. Are Americans more or less charitable than citizens of other countries?
A. No developed country approaches American giving. For example, in 1995 (the most recent year for which data are available), Americans gave, per capita, three and a half times as much to causes and charities as the French, seven times as much as the Germans, and 14 times as much as the Italians. Similarly, in 1998, Americans were 15 percent more likely to volunteer their time than the Dutch, 21 percent more likely than the Swiss, and 32 percent more likely than the Germans. These differences are not attributable to demographic characteristics such as education, income, age, sex, or marital status. On the contrary, if we look at two people who are identical in all these ways except that one is European and the other American, the probability is still far lower that the European will volunteer than the American[/quote]

 

[quote]2. I don't know who "us" is, and I don't necessarily want "us" to do anything differently at all, I just want to understand why people don't seem care that, this very day, a group of children 50 times as vast died in Africa from a single disease as in this particular event in Massachusetts.[/quote]

 

The point is we [i]do[/i] care.  Just because the media isn't interested in broadcasting the same story every day doesn't mean we don't care.  What else are we supposed to do about children in Africa dying of malaria except Doctors Without Borders, and giving money? 

Posted (edited)

In a case like this, people want to assume it was mental illness. Me too. It is a pretty common reaction. The reason for that, I believe, is that we do not want to accept that we are capable of such evil actions.

But if you can think of it, you are capable of it. And that is terrifying. It should be terrifying.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
PhuturePriest
Posted

I'm sure the parents of all those kindergarders are really grateful for your God's mercy right now.

 

A father whose daughter died by being shot to death in a school tragedy in 1999 said the best thing he and his wife decided to do was not to be bitter about the killer, to forgive him, and to celebrate their daughter's life. Forgiving heals, hate destroys. Forgiving does not mean excusing. It means forgiving. Forgiving this guy does not mean if he were still alive we wouldn't throw him in jail. It means we forgive him.

Posted

A father whose daughter died by being shot to death in a school tragedy in 1999 said the best thing he and his wife decided to do was not to be bitter about the killer, to forgive him, and to celebrate their daughter's life. Forgiving heals, hate destroys. Forgiving does not mean excusing. It means forgiving. Forgiving this guy does not mean if he were still alive we wouldn't throw him in jail. It means we forgive him.

 

 

Well good for he and his wife. Something tells me they are in the vast minority in being so perfect and balanced in their grief.

Posted

You don't really mean that. We believe in the possibility of salvation for everyone, through Christ's sacrifice.

That being said, it's probably not the most tactful thing to talk about God having mercy for the perpetrator around people who are trying to grapple with this senseless tragedy.

We all deal with these things differently, and we all have to keep this in mind. I hope the last thing we want to do is fight over this particular tragedy.

I thought one had to repent. How could of this guy repented ? I know God and I know he's just. I just find it amazing when people want to make him out to be a victim. Give me a break. If hell is real and people go there then this guy better be there. Along with hitler and evil men like him. I want to take the catholic faith serious but I find it odd when its seemed as if people like these have a good shot at mercy but the church wants to threaten me with hell if I miss mass or masturbate. Seems really odd.
Posted

And for the record I don't blame God for this. I love Him and know He's good.

Posted

I thought one had to repent. How could of this guy repented ? I know God and I know he's just. I just find it amazing when people want to make him out to be a victim. Give me a break. If hell is real and people go there then this guy better be there. Along with hitler and evil men like him. I want to take the catholic faith serious but I find it odd when its seemed as if people like these have a good shot at mercy but the church wants to threaten me with hell if I miss mass or masturbate. Seems really odd.

 

Mass murderers don't kill people.  Masturbation and missing church on Sunday do, silly. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Well good for he and his wife. Something tells me they are in the vast minority in being so perfect and balanced in their grief.

 

His exact words were "You never get over it." He said after the first two or three years the sting lessens, but it never leaves. He will always be in pain about it. But if people would stop being bitter and hateful, they would be happier. Being bitter and hateful leads to more violence. Hate can only breed hate.

theculturewarrior
Posted (edited)

I have nothing more to say about this.  There is nothing wrong with feeling angry and outraged.  I get that.  If you hate Adam Lanza and you want him to burn in hell, I understand that and I do not question it.  I am not asking anyone to join me in praying the Office of the Dead for him.  I am going to grieve for the loss of one of my own.  My disability has made very easy for me to look at anyone and say there but for the grace of God go I.  I do understand how all of you feel and how upsetting it must to hear me say this.  I am going to grieve for him, and to pray for him.  To me that seems the Christian thing to do.

Edited by theculturewarrior
Posted (edited)

With that said though I know how important it is to go to mass...So that's not my goal to attack that....But give me a break with feeling sorry for this bastard who shot murdered children at a school...Really screw this bastard...The church has said over and over how many people will pry end up in hell...and were told we can go to hell for simply masturbating or missing mass and not making confession before we die...I mean if that's how it is cool...I'm alright with that and i'll fear God and go to mass and confession...but save me the pity partys for bastards like this and bastards like hitler and act as if God wmight forgive them...because if that's the case then the sending people to hell for missing mass or masturbating doesn't add up...you nolonger have a just and fair god...

Edited by Guest
Posted

if you can think of it, you are capable of it. And that is terrifying. It should be terrifying.

 

This.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

I thought one had to repent. How could of this guy repented ? I know God and I know he's just. I just find it amazing when people want to make him out to be a victim. Give me a break. If hell is real and people go there then this guy better be there. Along with hitler and evil men like him. I want to take the catholic faith serious but I find it odd when its seemed as if people like these have a good shot at mercy but the church wants to threaten me with hell if I miss mass or masturbate. Seems really odd.

 

There's nothing wrong with feeling anger and outrage at the guy who did this.  But we can't ever know for sure if anyone is in Hell, nor should we encourage others to hope that someone is in Hell.  Even Hitler.  We don't know what is going on in a person's mind right before they die (which is why the Church no longer condemns victims of suicide, for example).  Instead, we can hope that God's justice be done, whatever that may be.  And we can pray for the victims of terrible things like what happened today.  

 

I think I like to point out that even these people have "a shot at mercy" like you said because the instinct is to want to condemn them to Hell.  The Church emphasizes the seriousness of other sins because we usually belittle them (It's not really about missing mass, it's about putting God first in your life, etc).  

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

I thought one had to repent. How could of this guy repented ? I know God and I know he's just. I just find it amazing when people want to make him out to be a victim. Give me a break. If hell is real and people go there then this guy better be there. Along with hitler and evil men like him. I want to take the catholic faith serious but I find it odd when its seemed as if people like these have a good shot at mercy but the church wants to threaten me with hell if I miss mass or masturbate. Seems really odd.

 

How could he have had full culpability in order to commit a mortal sin? In order for a mortal sin three things are necessary: Full consent, full knowledge, and it must be grave matter. We have grave matter down most certainly, but the other two are pending. This guy wasn't thinking right. He is suspected to have a plethora of mental problems, such as autism, being a sociopath, and having asperger syndrome. With these in mind, he didn't have full consent of what he was doing, and he didn't have full knowledge. He didn't have empathy, and that isn't his fault. I'm not excusing what he did by any means. What he did was wrong and it has to be one of the most evil acts I have ever heard of. But he can still be forgiven by God, especially if he didn't meet the criteria for Mortal sin. In fact, according to the Church even if he didn't have these things and knew exactly what he was doing, he still could have been forgiven. In those last moments, he could have sincerely told God he was sorry and felt remorse for what he did. We can't think of sin in black and white situations. We don't know his mind at the time, and therefore cannot make a judgement. That's why we cannot make a judgement about anybody. That is God's job, for only he knows everything about the situation.

 

And I'm with Basilisa Marie. It is okay and in fact good to feel outrage and anger. There is such a thing as just anger, and this is certainly one of those cases where it is used. Emotions are running high, so it's really not the time to make statements. Talking about our feelings is good, but when it is something as sensitive as this and we know others will disagree and be greatly offended, it is best to not say anything until people start coping with the situation.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Basilisa Marie
Posted

In a case like this, people want to assume it was mental illness. Me too. It is a pretty common reaction. The reason for that, I believe, is that we do not want to accept that we are capable of such evil actions.

But if you can think of it, you are capable of it. And that is terrifying. It should be terrifying.

 

Agreed.

Posted

Alright I'm not gonna argue...I see what you are saying...I love everyone at phatmass....goodnight....what a sad day...Godbless

Posted (edited)

It does seem though more and more now a days I hear from catholics that there is this possibilty that all may be saved...I'm not even against that really...I don't wish for any1 to suffer in hell for eternity...its just hard to wrap my mind around though...because it just makes me wonder why Jesus had to die...why didnt God just forgive everyone 1 and destroy the devil a long time ago...why drag this mess out...I mean if people like hitler end up in heaven in the end then this all really starts to seem like one really sick game.....at any rate God is good in my mind and heart...I really believe that....I love Him and all you guys too....Godbless and goodnight...

Edited by Guest
Posted

why didnt God just forgive everyone 1 and destroy the devil a long time ago...

 

Everyone is forgiven. All that is required is an acceptance of that forgiveness. Pretty minimal requirement, really. And Satan's power was broken on Cavalry. He has already lost.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...