PhuturePriest Posted January 30, 2013 Posted January 30, 2013 I went on MonkRock (Because I know the guys personally and see them every year at the Midwest Catholic Family Conference) and I found an awesome Crusader Cross Scapular. I and my family were formally enrolled in the brown scapular when I was very young, and I feel bad for not having one, so I'm going to get it. I knew my brother didn't have one, so I showed it to him and asked if he wanted one. Here is how this conversation ten minutes ago went down (His words are in bold): "Would you like one?" "What is it?" "It's a brown scapular, but it's awesome because it has the Crusader Cross on it!" "Why would I wear it?" "Because you're supposed to. We were enrolled in it years ago." *Starts yelling* "I didn't want to! Mom and dad made me!" "And? You're still supposed to wear it." "I'm not going to wear it!" *Slams door* "...." *Comes back* "I'll wear it! But I'm not going to wear it twenty four-freakin'-seven!" *Slams door and stomps in a crazy rage* I don't understand what quite happened. I didn't say anything in what could be interpreted as a condescending way (I made sure of that), and all I did was ask if he wanted one and he started yelling. Any thoughts? And just because I love the guys at MonkRock, here is the scapular and a link to their website: http://www.monkrock.com/index.cfm?load=page&page=36&group=13
IcePrincessKRS Posted January 30, 2013 Posted January 30, 2013 I think maybe instead of telling him things like "You're supposed to" (because you already know that this can be a sensitive area) you could say something like "We were enrolled in it and I think it's spiritually beneficial... plus it's the coolest scapular I've seen." Don't make it so much of a "you're not doing what you're supposed to" thing as a "this could be really helpful if you want to do it" thing. Because, yes, the scapular is a great devotion, but there is no doctrine or anything that I'm aware of stating that we HAVE to wear one. Obviously I don't know your brother and I could be totally wrong on this, but I think he's the sort of person that maybe more subtle suggestions would work better when you're talking to him about religion. Plant the seed, don't clobber with the hammer.
PhuturePriest Posted January 30, 2013 Author Posted January 30, 2013 I think maybe instead of telling him things like "You're supposed to" (because you already know that this can be a sensitive area) you could say something like "We were enrolled in it and I think it's spiritually beneficial... plus it's the coolest scapular I've seen." Don't make it so much of a "you're not doing what you're supposed to" thing as a "this could be really helpful if you want to do it" thing. Because, yes, the scapular is a great devotion, but there is no doctrine or anything that I'm aware of stating that we HAVE to wear one. Obviously I don't know your brother and I could be totally wrong on this, but I think he's the sort of person that maybe more subtle suggestions would work better when you're talking to him about religion. Plant the seed, don't clobber with the hammer. Thanks! I'll try this! I think his responses could be slightly better (I don't see how going into a rage over it is in any way sane), but I'll try. He doesn't have to, but since we were enrolled we are technically supposed to wear it. We're also supposed to say the Rosary daily because of that as well, but I think I should work on just wearing it first.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 30, 2013 Posted January 30, 2013 That is a nice one. I will have to be replacing mine soon, so I should save that link.
PhuturePriest Posted January 30, 2013 Author Posted January 30, 2013 That is a nice one. I will have to be replacing mine soon, so I should save that link. I like the explanation for it in particular: The Crusader Brown Scapular, in particular serves as a constant reminder of the Cross of the Crusaders that all Christians - the "Church Militant" - are called to bear and the spiritual armor they are to wear in their fight against the Enemy (the flesh, the world and the devil) for the salvation of souls
PhuturePriest Posted January 30, 2013 Author Posted January 30, 2013 little brothers....so annoying Actually, he's older than I am. I'm the youngest of all the children.
sixpence Posted January 30, 2013 Posted January 30, 2013 Actually, he's older than I am. I'm the youngest of all the children. was not referring to him....... :smile3:
MissyP89 Posted January 30, 2013 Posted January 30, 2013 I feel like you could have been a little gentler with him, esp. given that you've said your brother isn't as religious as the rest of you. "Because you should/are supposed to," is never a good response to any question. I'd give him a few days to cool off. If I were your brother and not very open to faith, having it brought up constantly would irritate me.
PhuturePriest Posted January 30, 2013 Author Posted January 30, 2013 was not referring to him....... :smile3: I figured so. :P I feel like you could have been a little gentler with him, esp. given that you've said your brother isn't as religious as the rest of you. "Because you should/are supposed to," is never a good response to any question. I'd give him a few days to cool off. If I were your brother and not very open to faith, having it brought up constantly would irritate me. Probably, but I wasn't planning on that reaction. Usually he just says something like "Okay, whatever." and goes on. This time he got angry and wanted to know why he had to get it. I would have planned something different had I known wearing a Scapular was going to be like asking him to light himself on fire and then try to douse it with gasoline. But I don't bring it up constantly. This is the first religious thing I have mentioned in months.
IcePrincessKRS Posted January 30, 2013 Posted January 30, 2013 Thanks! I'll try this! I think his responses could be slightly better (I don't see how going into a rage over it is in any way sane), but I'll try. He doesn't have to, but since we were enrolled we are technically supposed to wear it. We're also supposed to say the Rosary daily because of that as well, but I think I should work on just wearing it first. Obviously his response could be better, but you also have to think about your approach. You might need to change tactics to get the response you would prefer, or at the very least a less volatile reaction. "Hey, I think this is really cool. What do you think? I think I am going to get one, would you like one, too?" If he says no then, "Ok, well let me know if you change your mind." Smile, shrug, leave it at that. You put the offer out there, encouraged the devotion without making him feel like he's doing something wrong. I was enrolled in the brown scapular as a kid. I'm not the best at following those rules. And to be fair, (speaking from my own experience) having been enrolled as a kid chances are he didn't really know what all that entailed any more than I did, it was just something he was reluctantly going along with because your parents wanted him to. I didn't do it reluctantly, but I had no idea what it was about. I didn't find out until I was an adult.
PhuturePriest Posted January 30, 2013 Author Posted January 30, 2013 Obviously his response could be better, but you also have to think about your approach. You might need to change tactics to get the response you would prefer, or at the very least a less volatile reaction. "Hey, I think this is really cool. What do you think? I think I am going to get one, would you like one, too?" If he says no then, "Ok, well let me know if you change your mind." Smile, shrug, leave it at that. You put the offer out there, encouraged the devotion without making him feel like he's doing something wrong. I was enrolled in the brown scapular as a kid. I'm not the best at following those rules. And to be fair, (speaking from my own experience) having been enrolled as a kid chances are he didn't really know what all that entailed any more than I did, it was just something he was reluctantly going along with because your parents wanted him to. I didn't do it reluctantly, but I had no idea what it was about. I didn't find out until I was an adult. I'll try that! I think a lot of it comes down to the fact that I'm not comfortable around my family (Except for my sister, of course), so when I speak to them it can kind of be awkward and things don't come out the way I intend them to. And yeah, I had no clue what it meant either (I was about five when we did it), but I'm a person where if you tell me to do something (Like pray the Rosary every day and wear the Scapular) I will do it. I will want to know why because I'm not a doormat, but I won't refuse if you don't give an explanation right away. He's definitely not one of those people. If I ask him to drive me to the store I have to explain why and what's in it for him. He won't be content just going "Okay" and drive me there.
IcePrincessKRS Posted January 30, 2013 Posted January 30, 2013 I'll try that! I think a lot of it comes down to the fact that I'm not comfortable around my family (Except for my sister, of course), so when I speak to them it can kind of be awkward and things don't come out the way I intend them to. And yeah, I had no clue what it meant either (I was about five when we did it), but I'm a person where if you tell me to do something (Like pray the Rosary every day and wear the Scapular) I will do it. I will want to know why because I'm not a doormat, but I won't refuse if you don't give an explanation right away. He's definitely not one of those people. If I ask him to drive me to the store I have to explain why and what's in it for him. He won't be content just going "Okay" and drive me there. It can be hard when you aren't that comfortable with people. Sometimes there are touchy subjects with my siblings that I really tiptoe around and try hard to get my message across without sounding like an uppity witch. I am close with all of them, but some don't exactly operate on the same moral ground as me so it can be hard to phrase things in a way that they might be receptive to. And sometimes I just try to lead by example and don't bother saying anything because I know it won't make a difference at that point in time. I was definitely more like you as a kid. My mom said "do it" and I did. lol
PhuturePriest Posted January 31, 2013 Author Posted January 31, 2013 It can be hard when you aren't that comfortable with people. Sometimes there are touchy subjects with my siblings that I really tiptoe around and try hard to get my message across without sounding like an uppity witch. I am close with all of them, but some don't exactly operate on the same moral ground as me so it can be hard to phrase things in a way that they might be receptive to. And sometimes I just try to lead by example and don't bother saying anything because I know it won't make a difference at that point in time. I was definitely more like you as a kid. My mom said "do it" and I did. lol Yeah, it definitely is. I've been trying to figure out when it is best to say something or lead by example, and if I should say something how I should say it. It's definitely not too easy, especially since my brother has always had anger issues that have formed into major anger issues now that he is nineteen. Haha. Yeah, I'm kind of easy to boss around. :P
cartermia Posted January 31, 2013 Posted January 31, 2013 Haha. Yeah, I'm kind of easy to boss around. :P ...hmmm... that is good to know! :whistle:
Mary+Immaculate<3 Posted January 31, 2013 Posted January 31, 2013 Here are some videos giving basic, but helpful insight into the devotion to Our Lady, the promises, etc. done by the great gabiafterhours (Gabriel) and famous (now) sister sheiscatholic (Leah): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8lN0MrjRow0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38hMoGfh10U I really hope your brother is just going through a phase. The devil doesn't want people to wear the brown scapular because he won't triumph if they are both outwardly and inwardly devoted to the Blessed Mother. Having two older brothers at home, I know they can be a hassle, but I think that the others on here are right. Instead of saying "this is something you're supposed to do," try to make it more of a "this is a cool thing to do because it grants you protection and graces." Of course, it is always harder to offer the long explanation, but he does have to right to know what he is getting himself (back) into if he chooses to wear it again.
PhuturePriest Posted January 31, 2013 Author Posted January 31, 2013 Here are some videos giving basic, but helpful insight into the devotion to Our Lady, the promises, etc. done by the great gabiafterhours (Gabriel) and famous (now) sister sheiscatholic (Leah):http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8lN0MrjRow0http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38hMoGfh10U I really hope your brother is just going through a phase. The devil doesn't want people to wear the brown scapular because he won't triumph if they are both outwardly and inwardly devoted to the Blessed Mother. Having two older brothers at home, I know they can be a hassle, but I think that the others on here are right. Instead of saying "this is something you're supposed to do," try to make it more of a "this is a cool thing to do because it grants you protection and graces." Of course, it is always harder to offer the long explanation, but he does have to right to know what he is getting himself (back) into if he chooses to wear it again. Thanks for the videos! And yeah, I totally agree. When I realized I should have mentioned the promises with it and everything, he was kind of already storming out the door and there wasn't much I could do.
Basilisa Marie Posted January 31, 2013 Posted January 31, 2013 I have a sister who sounds similar to your brother. I'm older than her by almost 3 years, and I can't tell her to do anything (part of it probably stems from living in my obnoxious over-achieving in school shadow for a decade). She's not as religious as I am, and frankly it's hard to even get her to go to mass (she's going through a phase of only wanting to do things she wants to do). Maybe one way you can approach your brother is ask him to do something "religious" WITH you. Frame it as a brotherly activity. Like praying the rosary, or a decade of the rosary, or going to adoration for a bit, or something. If he says no, be cool with it and shrug it off, but keep offering every so often. The scapular to me seems kinda like a big commitment for someone who isn't ready for it, and frankly there's not a whole lot of point to wearing it if you aren't going to do the devotions. :) Maybe start smaller.
Papist Posted January 31, 2013 Posted January 31, 2013 Tell him he does not have to wear it 24 friggin 7. Tell him he just needs to make sure he is wearing it at the moment he his death. When he asks why, there's your open door.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now