Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Well, This Was Interesting... Any Help?


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted

Tell him he does not have to wear it 24 friggin 7. Tell him he just needs to make sure he is wearing it at the moment he his death. When he asks why, there's your open door.

 


This would work with most normal people. However, he has an insane fear of death and hell in general. Just mentioning either makes him freaked out and he won't continue the conversation. Even though the Scapular is so you won't go to hell, he will still be mad because I said the two forbidden words in his vocabulary.

Posted


This would work with most normal people. However, he has an insane fear of death and hell in general. Just mentioning either makes him freaked out and he won't continue the conversation. Even though the Scapular is so you won't go to hell, he will still be mad because I said the two forbidden words in his vocabulary.

 

Yeah...thats difficult, I imagine that the real issue is some sort of neurosis or scrupulosity   You may have triggered something in him.

 

I think for some people the fear of hell is so great they stay away from religious stuff because it gets too overwhelming.  If you know a priest who has a psychology background you may want to share this with him in order to facilliate a better conversation with your brother.  I think this is the reason that many people are attracted to the lighter religions... because their fear of hell is paralyzing.  Now, some take it too far and ignore hell altogether, which is just as bad, but I would see if you can work within your limitations.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Yeah...thats difficult, I imagine that the real issue is some sort of neurosis or scrupulosity   You may have triggered something in him.

 

I think for some people the fear of hell is so great they stay away from religious stuff because it gets too overwhelming.  If you know a priest who has a psychology background you may want to share this with him in order to facilliate a better conversation with your brother.  I think this is the reason that many people are attracted to the lighter religions... because their fear of hell is paralyzing.  Now, some take it too far and ignore hell altogether, which is just as bad, but I would see if you can work within your limitations.

 

I'll see if I can find a Priest with said degree. My brother does have ADD, which I hear can cause these sorts of things.

Posted

Yeah...that's difficult, I imagine that the real issue is some sort of neurosis or scrupulosity 

 

or maybe he just needs to take a nap.  his reaction to your suggestion seems quite normal, it certainly is not neurotic behavior

Posted

I'll see if I can find a Priest with said degree. My brother does have ADD, which I hear can cause these sorts of things.

 

I understand, I come from a family that is deeply ADHD and ADD...so there's loads of things that we are just really careful about.  Still, for a grown adult to be petrified of hell to such a degree that they shut down would indicate that their is something else going on.  Most people who reach the age of reason will fear hell but not loose it if they speak about Hell.  His reaction sounds more like what a 4-5yo would do...the "I don't hear you" phase.

missionseeker
Posted


This would work with most normal people. However, he has an insane fear of death and hell in general. Just mentioning either makes him freaked out and he won't continue the conversation. Even though the Scapular is so you won't go to hell, he will still be mad because I said the two forbidden words in his vocabulary.

perhaps he an inkling of what a scapular is and the mention of it freaked him out because of that ? 

PhuturePriest
Posted

or maybe he just needs to take a nap.  his reaction to your suggestion seems quite normal, it certainly is not neurotic behavior

 

If he behaves that way because he needs a nap, he needs a nap every day. He really does have a bad temper.

Posted

Everyone does, some just hide it better that others

PhuturePriest
Posted

Everyone does, some just hide it better that others

 

I strongly disagree.

Posted

you dont need to get snippy about it. 

PhuturePriest
Posted

you dont need to get snippy about it. 

 

I wasn't being snippy.

Posted

I wasn't being snippy.

 


chill man :cold:

just joking

PhuturePriest
Posted


chill man :cold:

just joking

 

I was chill. I don't know why you think I'm not being chill. :anyone:

Posted

SO ANYWAY YOU GUYS.

 

 

 

Here are some videos giving basic, but helpful insight into the devotion to Our Lady, the promises, etc. done by the great gabiafterhours (Gabriel) and famous (now) sister sheiscatholic (Leah):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8lN0MrjRow0

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38hMoGfh10U

I really hope your brother is just going through a phase. The devil doesn't want people to wear the brown scapular because he won't triumph if they are both outwardly and inwardly devoted to the Blessed Mother. Having two older brothers at home, I know they can be a hassle, but I think that the others on here are right. Instead of saying "this is something you're supposed to do," try to make it more of a "this is a cool thing to do because it grants you protection and graces." Of course, it is always harder to offer the long explanation, but he does have to right to know what he is getting himself (back) into if he chooses to wear it again.

 

Thanks so much for posting those videos! This is the first I've heard of him and he's amazing. I can't wait to dig in. :bounce:

Posted (edited)

I agree with the others that saying "you're supposed to" was probably the trigger. I don't know how old your brother is, but if he's over 16 and still living at home, he may be undergoing an internal struggle to separate himself from his family, find out who he is independently of others, become his own man, etc. If he's at that age, then most of the people in his life are still telling him what to do, what he should do, what he's "supposed to" do, all the while his internal urge is to free himself, decide for himself, do for himself. In that case, he's probably actually being quite patient and calm by walking away whenever someone mentions something to him that he knows they think he ought to do. And this time, he may have just heard it all day long, and you were the straw that broke the camel's back.

 

Possibly.

Edited by curiousing
PhuturePriest
Posted

I agree with the others that saying "you're supposed to" was probably the trigger. I don't know how old your brother is, but if he's over 16 and still living at home, he may be undergoing an internal struggle to separate himself from his family, find out who he is independently of others, become his own man, etc. If he's at that age, then most of the people in his life are still telling him what to do, what he should do, what he's "supposed to" do, all the while his internal urge is to free himself. In that case, he's probably actually being quite patient and calm by walking away whenever someone mentions something to him that he knows they think he ought to do. And this time, he may have just heard it all day long, and you were the straw that broke the camel's back.

 

Possibly.

 

He's nineteen, but he spends 99% of his day in his room. He doesn't ever come out except to eat.

Posted

He's nineteen, but he spends 99% of his day in his room. He doesn't ever come out except to eat.

 

I was that way at 15, and boys develop more slowly than girls. If I were in your position, I'd wait till he cools down, then go apologize and gently ask if there's anything he wants to talk about. You may not have that kind of relationship, but you never will, either, unless you tell him that you're willing to—even when he's not. It's a gesture that welcomes intimacy and friendship, even if that intimacy doesn't come now.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...